r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • May 01 '22
Meta Meta Thread - Month of May 01, 2022
A monthly thread to talk about meta topics, i.e. /r/anime itself and its rules and moderation. Keep it friendly and relevant to the subreddit.
Posts here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: April 2022 | March 2022 | February 2022 | January 2022 | December 2021 | November 2021 | Find All
•
u/Verzwei May 01 '22
April Mod Report
Note: The above votes did not fundamentally change how we currently handle OP/ED sequences, and all other Official Media, Clip, and repost rules still apply. We debated internally whether we wanted to only allow OP/ED sequences when they satisfy Official Media rules, or to potentially categorize all OP/ED sequences as Clips even if they fit the Official Media format. We ultimately voted to continue allowing them under either flair depending on the manner in which they are posted.
April By The Numbers
42
u/michhoffman :Ij::Ik::Il:https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman May 01 '22
I wanted to bring up that there is some clear botting going on in the episode discussion thread polls in the form of a much larger than expected number of "Excellent" votes being added across the board for episodes about 40 hours in. The 40 hour mark is significant because our Karma and Poll Ratings count through 48 hours so whoever is botting is likely targeting it for that reason. I've noticed this happening for around 3 months now as smaller shows have been getting way more votes than ever before, but I only just saw the most blatant form of it this past week on the latest One Piece Episode.
39 hours into its 48 hour voting period, the discussion thread had around 3100 Karma with 274 Excellent Votes. 9 hours later it had 3150 Karma with 760 Excellent Votes (500 Excellent Votes added corresponding with just 50 Karma added), and it currently has 834 Excellent Votes 5 days later. That's a clearly unnatural rate of growth in votes during that 9 hour period.
22
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal May 01 '22
I was predicting August for this after the last milestone but nope, going faster than I expected. Welcome to exponential growth: the anime (subreddit)!
At this rate we're definitely reaching 5 million before the end of the year. Too fast!
17
u/LG03 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bronadian May 01 '22
Some people have been noticing lately that some high upvoted comments have been getting copied from discussion threads and pasted onto disqus boards wherever those are utilized.
This is a spambot technique and a fairly common one. Bots/spammers are ripping these comments for the purpose of getting their posts highly rated and organically engaged with on disqus (or similar boards). The purpose of this is to make their comment look legitimate for the inevitable edit, where they come in a while later and swap the comment out for a link to a malicious site.
Often it'll look something like this after the edit, 'This show was great but if you want something really amazing, watch this show instead.'
Naturally it should go without saying not to click strange links but personally I wanted to try to spread the word on this to try to raise some awareness.
15
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal May 01 '22
[Madoka Magica spoilers] The image posted here from when my group joined the mod team just gets funnier and more prophetic with time.
14
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead May 04 '22
I know you can't ban people from PM'ing folks, but are you aware of several (most likely automated) accounts PM'ing people after they've used certain keywords, wanting to talk about harem/romcom/action anime after you have used this word in an anime subreddit? The goal is to make people use some app, apparently. Maybe you can escalate this to the admins and tell people to report those accounts- they are generally 6 to 12 months old and their only activity is a handful of comments a few months ago to get around minimum karma requirements.
12
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal May 19 '22
Hi y'all, this is an update on the daily discussion megathread that I proposed last month.
The vote's currently ongoing and if it passes the thread will start being posted on May 27th at 10:00 UTC (rather than midnight UTC as for our weekly threads). It'll run for two weeks and during that time the Merch Mondays, Recommendation Tuesdays, and Miscellaneous Anime Questions threads will not be posted.
I wanted to get another round of feedback on the post body after taking into account some changes people proposed last time. Here's the current revision:
Notably the "Other Threads" section at the bottom will be like the sidebar/menu and link directly to the weekly threads rather than searches, so those will be updated regularly.
10
u/[deleted] May 01 '22
Definitely hope we get those daily discussion threads
9
u/WHM-6R May 07 '22
I understand it might not always be possible due to moderator work load, but informing users when one of their comments is deleted might be beneficial to prevent future rule breaking. At the very least, I can say that receiving a pm today after my first two comments on a subject were deleted would have prevented me from making my three subsequent comments on the same issue.
16
u/Turbostrider27 May 01 '22
What is the status regarding posts related to "countdown art" for seasonal anime?
This was bought up in the previous Meta Thread several times.
7
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val May 01 '22
I noticed a particular uptick last month in people using the [Watch This!] flair for standard non-actual-WT! recommendation/reaction posts
I understand how the flair naming might be confusing for non-regulars unaware of the WT! project but it’s still really frustrating
Do mods have the ability to change flairs on posts? I always assumed so but either way I think something should be done to make sure posts that aren’t proper WT!’s don’t linger on the front page with the WT! flair
7
u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod May 11 '22
This isn't really important, but some of the boarders of the new commentfaces seem to be off by one. A few examples are and .
Though now that I look at it in more detail, it may be whatever method you used to compress the commentfaces to fit within reddit's restriction causing some bleed.
7
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22
If anyone's curious about traffic numbers I dumped our May 2022 stats over in today's /r/reddit thread.
Reposting the table here:
6
u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel May 01 '22
How are the discussions for the daily thread? Any progress that you can share?
6
u/[deleted] May 11 '22
a little feedback on new seasonal comment faces
this is not what "disdain" means and this image does not portray disdain
6
u/ha_ck_rm_rk https://anilist.co/user/Bubaruba May 11 '22
For the seasonal commentfaces, would it be possible to remove the capitalization? For example, #seasonalhype instead of #SeasonalHype. Almost every other commentface is all lowercase (the only exception I can think of is #volibearQ). Having to capitalize these new commentfaces is a bit disorienting and not in-line with the regular commentfaces.
1
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jun 06 '22
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
5
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ May 06 '22
[](#fish)
That is all.
I've never even seen Symphogear,, nor will I ever.
5
u/TheRiyria myanimelist.net/profile/TheRiyria May 20 '22
I might just be missing them, but the new Seasonal Comment Faces don't seem to be listed in the Comment Face Wiki.
Would it be possible to add them there?
5
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover May 31 '22
I know we will be getting rid of the seasonal comment faces, but can we vote on keeping some?
For instance: is such a niche comment face, that it would be incredibly useful to have past the seasonal anime.
9
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover May 01 '22
Thoughts on my taste type of "discussions" or posts, don't usually generate that much actual discussion, and should be considered for low effort if they aren't already. These are something that people should put in CDF or miscellaneous questions or something like that.
4
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary May 03 '22
A very minor thing I noticed: would it be possible to use old.reddit links in the megathreads section of the sidebar, assuming that doesn't berak anything of course? At a glance I think every other link is old.reddit, while those are all redd.it links that shorten new.reddit links.
4
u/The_Loli_Otaku May 06 '22
Say, I was wondering what context might have been alright to post the rain song sequence? I had my upload removed since it's classified as a special ed apparently but I was wondering the specifics for this kind of thing. I couldn't quite understand what type of music clips would be allowed aside from amvs whilst looking at the rules.
4
u/chilidirigible May 07 '22
I've sent both a modmail and a separate DM to /u/Gaporigo with updates to a Watch Order Wiki entry and haven't seen changes to the entry yet, but even a reply acknowledging receipt would be appreciated.
4
u/b0bba_Fett myanimelist.net/profile/B0bba_Cheezed3 May 13 '22
Sorry to ping you again /u/Chariotwheel, but Gapo fixing the Seasonal Commentfaces has once again broken them in the extension
4
u/[deleted] May 14 '22
Not sure if this is the right thread for this, but why is my MAL username showing up in my flair on desktop but not on mobile?
4
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: May 14 '22
re: mod rewatch series, are there gonna be 24 hour reminder pings like a normal rewatch? (no is fine, I'll just have to punch in some dates to my calendar)
Ponyo soon. Gonna just watch it at home tho.
4
u/Vindex101 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vindex101 May 22 '22
Komi-san latest episode got a bunch of good subs already out, just posting here cause the episode thread for it still isn't out.
4
u/loomnoo https://anilist.co/user/loomnoo May 29 '22
I was very excited about the daily thread, but I guess they exist in sort of an awkward middle between /new and CDF for me. It's kinda like a miniature /new hybridized with a CDF where the ice isn't broken yet so discussion is a bit muted. And, it's my understanding that we don't want too much of a social aspect lest it become another CDF. Still in the early stages so I do hope that we collectively carve out a good role for it as time goes on.
I do enjoy the lack of mean-spirited, cynical, unhelpful dunking that you tend to get in /new though. I feel like the rec and misc threads had a culture of helpfulness that carries over somewhat.
4
u/Soupkitten https://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jun 03 '22
Another late Dance Dance Danseur episode thread btw
10
u/MyNeighbour127 May 03 '22
So its apparently forbidden to reply to a comment praising an unexpected and good action scene in an anime to reply saying that the book has really good action scenes.
The extreme extent of the anti-source rules are just awful, no discussion here, fuck off.
7
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian May 04 '22
I know it's 100% not actually possible but I just want it on record because it's been around so much lately...
Can we have automod remove comments that use "Mid"? That's got to be one of the worst trending words on this subreddit.
6
u/Royal_Heritage May 23 '22
Given the allegedly low score in MAL forums of "The executioner and her way of life", there has been a proliferation of calling "incel" anyone on MAL who doesn't like the show or gives it a low score. Primarily these kinds of talks happen in both the weekly karma thread & the anime corner and similar ranking posts here on this sub.
Are these kind of comments reportable? I recall the unwriten rule of not namecalling or harassing fanbases, wich quite frankly seem like a similar groundbase.
3
u/Mazen141 May 03 '22
Hi! I wanted to ask about the "album" posts rule, to be more specific it's regarding the subreddit's stance regarding posting production materials for shows here.
A little over a week ago I made a post compiling some of Kaguya-Sama's love is war production material, the post got removed because it included images from the currently airing S3 which was fully my mistake, I then asked the mod who removed the post wether if I could remove the season 3 content and make it just for the first two seasons only. I was told that I shouldn't since it's not relevant and that they don't want the sub to be flooded with past shows' production materials, I'll be honest and admit that I wasn't a big fan of that response.
For the relevancy point, I'm willing to argue that past seasons of a currently airing show would be considered at least to be somewhat relevant, no? and even in the case of the show not being currently relevant then there should still be room to post and discuss for it right? this sub doesn't limit discussion to only new anime afterall.
For the other point, I really don't think posts showcasing production materials for anime are made nowhere near enough on this subreddit for them to be considered to be flooding it, especially when we have had posts like the countdown arts posted daily near the start of the season and ranking posts made on weekly basis.
So I wanted to know the subreddit's stance regarding these types of posts, since I was interested in making posts showcasing production material for shows that have aired more than 3 months ago.
Thanks, in advance!
3
u/b0bba_Fett myanimelist.net/profile/B0bba_Cheezed3 May 11 '22
Seasonal Commentfaces don't seem to be working on /u/chariotwheel's Commentface extension, confirmation that this isn't just me?
3
u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo May 12 '22
Seasonal comment faces update.
3
u/engalleons https://myanimelist.net/profile/engalleons May 15 '22
I've recently seen a new (to me) "Frequently Asked Anime Question" mod removal reason directing them to the "watch order" and "where to watch" areas of that page.
Are there any other types of questions that have been/will be explicitly pointed to FAAQ?
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '22
Was curious about unpopular opinion threads. I saw that there's a mod filter for them in the title?
How long has this been a thing for?!
3
u/baquea Jun 02 '22
Can the daily thread be added to the megathreads tab in the top-bar?
2
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky May 03 '22
The sidebar Monthly Meta Thread link still links to last month's meta thread instead of this one.
2
u/fraggers_ May 03 '22
Hello, I came here from the /r/anime discord server with a query.
I was thinking when was the last time we had a mascot visual update or mascot update in general as far as I recall it was something like 5-6 years ago and I was thinking it's time for an update to the subreddit and discord server mascots.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '22
Per the seasonal comment face thread, there is not space for additional permanent faces.
Is it possible to acquire more space?
2
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler May 11 '22 edited May 11 '22
Seasonal Comment Faces (context) are now live.
Enjoy.
Wiki link on how to use them.
Oh, if you were one of the 10 people that found the hover text poll in the original thread, well done.
2
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary May 21 '22
In the sidebar, how do you decide what to put in "other discussions"? Asking because I feel like Vampire in the Garden should be there as batch release.
2
u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer May 25 '22
Believe there should be a "batch release" for SAC_2045 S2.
Sent a mod mail but I forgot to mention that the bot struggled in case that was being accounted for
2
u/sabdeyazdan https://myanimelist.net/profile/ParodySama May 27 '22
I'm not sure if mentioning it here is the proper way to make it notified, but Dance Dance Danseur episode 8's discussion thread is not up, about 2 hours after the subs are released.
2
u/EruditePolymath May 29 '22
Hey, I keep trying to upload my review of Scissor Seven. I flair it as a video edit since it contains clips from the anime but it keeps getting removed by mods. Do I need to tag it as a spoiler since it contains clips from the anime? I've seen similar videos uploaded here without a spoiler tag.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WAsLcHhLPqQ
2
u/InternationalTank7 May 30 '22
Not sure if no one reported it or if it just otherwise got missed, but this clip somehow slipped by long enough to get 250 comments and 2500 upvotes. It's from the most recent episode, which aired just 3 days ago.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '22
Again the Komi-san episode thread is delayed. Also, the archive list has fallen a couple of episodes behind.
2
u/Cryten0 Jun 01 '22
Personal Opinion. While the daily thread is nice for every day communications and questions it tends to drown out serious questions. Making it unwieldly for people after specifics.
2
u/feidothelemoneido Jun 01 '22 edited Jun 02 '22
Question for posting fanart: Do you have to warn for spoilers in the title, or can you do it in the post body?
Edit: Thanks so much!
2
u/feidothelemoneido Jun 02 '22
Another question: Why are fanfics forbidden? Not against it, just curious.
3
u/Feisty-Site-6261 May 04 '22
A lot of people post clips with spoilers in them, but don't mark them as spoilers until either a mod has to do it or a user tells them too. Is there a way for posts with the clip flair to automatically be tagged as a spoiler when posting?
1
u/tankeryy May 30 '22
please add Bakuon!! on the watch order wiki please!!
1
u/edgefigaro May 31 '22
What is the reasoning behind the lack of a banner at the top of this subreddit? It feels like a natural subreddit to have one, and the community is likely large enough to be happy to provide new ones seasonally.