r/anime • myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jul 03 '22

Meta Meta Thread - Month of July 03, 2022

A monthly thread to talk about meta topics, i.e. /r/anime itself and its rules and moderation. Keep it friendly and relevant to the subreddit.

Posts here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.

Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.


Previous meta threads: June 2022 | May 2022 | April 2022 | March 2022 | February 2022 | January 2022 | December 2021 | Find All

Next meta thread: August 2022 | Find All

86 Upvotes

303 comments sorted by

•

u/reddadz x3https://anilist.co/user/MysticEyes Jul 03 '22

I haven’t done this in ages but I come bearing gifts bringing some rule changes, mostly in regards to how we want to handle Official Media going forward. It ended up being a pretty stacked month on our end.

June Mod Report

  • We trialed the Crowd Control feature provided by the admins (on the Lenient setting), which lasted a week. After discovering that 90% of the 518 auto-removed comments were eventually approved by the mods (as well as 56% of the 153 posts), we decided that the benefits weren’t worth the hassle and so we discontinued its use.

  • Voted to restrict[ Official Media] purely to material directly tied to the anime production, and to create a new flair for artwork associated with the anime but unrelated to the production. [vote failed]
  • Voted to allow countdown artwork to be posted as [Official Media]. [vote passed]
  • Voted to limit countdown artwork such that it may only be posted as an album and only when one day remains on the countdown. [vote passed]
  • Voted to allow an exception so that "Day Of" artwork may be individually posted after the "final day" album has already been posted. [vote passed]
  • Voted to allow celebratory, commemorative, or "thank you" artwork to be posted as [Official Media]. [vote failed]
  • Voted to allow celebratory, commemorative, or "thank you" artwork to be posted using the [Misc.] flair. [vote failed]
  • Voted to allow official birthday artwork to be posted as [Official Media]. [vote passed]
  • Voted to allow anniversary videos or artwork to be posted as [Official Media]. [vote passed]
  • Voted to allow non-informational teasers or "announcements of future announcements" to be posted as [News]. [vote failed]
  • Voted to allow non-informational teasers or "announcements of future announcements" to be posted as [Official Media]. [vote failed]
  • Voted to allow non-informational teasers or "announcements of future announcements" to be posted using the [Misc.] flair. [vote failed]
  • Voted to require that all [Official Media] posts of a specific anime have the anime name in the title of the post? (Similar to our current rules on fanart, clips, edits, and videos) [vote passed]

To summarize:

  • Countdown artwork may only be posted as an album when one day remains before the broadcast. In the event that a production has a "Day Of" artwork, those may be individual posts if the album has already been posted.
  • Celebratory, commemorative, and "thank you" artwork is prohibited as an individual post.
  • Non-informational teasers or "announcements of future announcements" are prohibited.
  • All [Official Media] posts need the name of the anime in the title of the post..

  • Voted to make the daily question/recommendation/discussion thread a permanent feature of the subreddit following the trial period. [vote passed] Data from the trial period
  • Voted to discontinue the Merch Mondays, Recommendation Tuesdays, and Miscellaneous Anime Questions weekly threads. [vote passed]
  • Voted to launch another round of mod applications this month. [vote passed]
  • Voted for open applications (pinned on the front page) as opposed to closed applications (in Meta or Daily thread). [vote passed]
  • Started internal discussion on the anime-specific rule regarding personal views from fandoms on anime, as well as possibly allowing discussion about fandoms in general. [currently in progress]
  • Started internal discussion on the possibility of introducing ‘retired topics’, which would prohibit the agreed-upon topics as posts while allowing them in the Daily Thread or Casual Discussion Fridays. [currently in progress]

June by the Numbers

  • Removed posts: 2294 by moderators, 4742 by bots, 6632 distinct
  • Removed comments: 1488 by moderators, 2091 by bots, 2995 distinct
  • Approved posts: 741
  • Approved comments: 1978
  • Distinguished comments: 2219
  • Users banned: 135 (76 permanent)
  • Users unbanned: 2
  • Admin/Anti-Evil Operations: removed posts: 3, removed comments: 6.
→ More replies (10)

2

u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Aug 09 '22

This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.

23

u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Jul 03 '22

Any talk of changing the rules for when a show releases more than one episode? This is obviously being sparked by the recent Kaguya threads, and I don't think the mods were in the wrong in how they handled the threads, you guys followed the precedent well and I'm sorry you had to deal with that shitshow, but it did have me thinking about how useful doing separate threads actually is.

If we look at Netflix shows, I think it could be good to have two threads. One for Episode 1, and one for the Full Season. People can post initial impressions in Episode 1, useful for anybody unsure if they wanna pick it up so they can pop in and see what people's first thoughts are, and then Full Season where people can go fully in-depth in their thoughts. Is anyone really dropping into an Episode 4 thread to leave a comment? I looked at JoJo Part 6 and saw 540 comments on Episode 1, 184 comments on Episode 12, then double digit comments for 4 and 7, the random ones I decided to check. 7 had less than 20 even.

So when a show like Kaguya or Lupin airs two episodes back to back, I think it might be beneficial to do one thread for both going forward.

26

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 03 '22

Yeah the Kaguya situation was interesting. Practically it makes most sense for their to just be the one thread for both, since at the time most people are going to comment having seen both (though really, for that case most people were commenting having seen neither, with comments written up well in advance, but hey that's Kaguya for you). Inevitably part of the problem is that titles can't be edited, and the threads are posted by a bot, which makes things kind of rigid for non-batch releases.

It was hilarious though, because while I think that the majority want it, and it's probably a good thing, holy shit do people get to the right answer with the wrong justification. The vast majority of the comments being about the karma was disappointing to say the least, but I guess I shouldn't be too surprised given how r/anime is with popularity contests.

7

u/Egavans https://anidb.net/user/Egavans99 Jul 03 '22

Inevitably part of the problem is that titles can't be edited, and the threads are posted by a bot, which makes things kind of rigid for non-batch releases.

Wouldn't the more straightforward choice for Kaguya have been to delete/lock the episode 13 thread and simply flair the episode 12 thread as "episode 13 also"?

7

u/LG03 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bronadian Jul 03 '22

They were 2 separate episodes. Someone who watches episode 12 a week later might not want to see 13 discussion because they haven't watched it yet.

Personally I don't have an issue with how it was handled on the mod side, users should have jumped to the episode 13 thread if they wanted to talk about both episodes at the time. Instead now there's an episode 12 thread 'archived' with loads of ep13 spoilers.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Jul 03 '22

since at the time most people are going to comment having seen both (though really, for that case most people were commenting having seen neither, with comments written up well in advance, but hey that's Kaguya for you).

That's really any highly anticipated manga adaptation, to be fair. I've done it for JoJo myself. I was actually in an interesting position where I only had access to episode 12 for most of Friday, but then I couldn't even go into the thread because it was full of spoilers for episode 13 as well, and the mods even said there were too many for them to bother trying to remove things. Actual lawlessness in there.

The vast majority of the comments being about the karma was disappointing to say the least, but I guess I shouldn't be too surprised given how r/anime is with popularity contests.

The argument about karma literally makes no sense either. Not like one thread was gonna have the combined total of the two separate threads (pretty sure we've talked about this), and I wouldn't be surprised to see Kaguya at the top 2 spots in the next karma poll. Bonus points if the comments are largely "the mods tried to keep us down but we prevailed."

16

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jul 03 '22

Bonus points if the comments are largely "the mods tried to keep us down but we prevailed."

Can already see them lol

20

u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Jul 03 '22

"the mods wanted Spy X Family to win"

6

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 03 '22

Bonus points if the comments are largely "the mods tried to keep us down but we prevailed."

Maybe not literally these words, but there were some already in the last karma thread (which as you know didn't even contain said episodes).

5

u/cppn02 Jul 03 '22

oly shit do people get to the right answer with the wrong justification. The vast majority of the comments being about the karma was disappointing to say the least, but I guess I shouldn't be too surprised given how r/anime is with popularity contests.

Yeah. Even as someone quite invested in the karma rankings it was weird how this was many people's main takeaway especially with Kaguya still crushing the ranking anyway.

People seemed way less bothered about the fact that the two threads turned out basically useless as discussion posts for their respective episode.

9

u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Jul 03 '22

I agree. When something is released as a batch, I might check out the first episode thread, but I lose interest when I see a bunch of them. A batch release thread would be better.

I think an arguement for split threads is future reference, but even then they're not very helpful for the future visitors, because:

  1. Most of them usually don't get much interaction.
  2. When they do, they contain spoilers for later episodes.

16

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 05 '22 edited Jul 05 '22

Blame /u/Gaporigo for the new banner attempt (on old reddit).

Edit: for those that haven't been following it the girls are from today's matchup of the Best Girl Contest, we figured we'd give it a try for a bit.

10

u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Jul 05 '22

Tell me it sucks so I don't have to make other 3 ty.

But really, any feedback is welcome.

11

u/punching_spaghetti https://myanimelist.net/profile/punch_spaghetti Jul 05 '22

It definitely looks better.

could use better girls though

6

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '22

It's much nicer.

5

u/Zeralyos https://myanimelist.net/profile/xNJF_Ellie Jul 05 '22

I really like it.

4

u/Tarhalindur x2 Jul 05 '22

Much improved, thank you!

4

u/chilidirigible Jul 05 '22

Current version is much less obtrusive, though with RES on classic reddit there is some overlap between my username and the rightmost character, so those eliminations better start happening soon.

4

u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Jul 05 '22

4

u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Jul 05 '22

> cuts Wiz's head
> "It just works"

7

u/Maccaz15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maccaz Jul 05 '22

I hate it and instantly blocked it with ublock.

2

u/SnuggleMuffin42 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Animemes_chan Jul 05 '22

I actually thought it was fine and I don't get why people are getting pissy. Mostly probably because they're being conservative (hate any change)

→ More replies (3)

10

u/isthatsoudane https://myanimelist.net/profile/ojoulover Jul 03 '22

it feels like consistently the worst/lowest effort threads are suggestion threads. even ones that wouldn't count as "low effort" don't seem to really add much...would the mods consider banning suggestion threads and redirecting them either to the daily thread and/or r/animesuggest? esp given the latter is pretty active...doesn't have 4M users, but these threads always seem like the worst here.

2

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Aug 03 '22

To actually address this since it got lost in the shuffle earlier: no we aren't currently planning on doing anything about recommendation/What to Watch? threads.

For a bit of historical context: they used to be banned years ago when the now-retired Recommendation Tuesdays megathread was introduced but that was reversed less than a year later to allow them again.

We did recently increase the minimum length for most text threads including What to Watch?, which should help reduce the zero-effort threads to some extent. Still, recommendation threads are the first point of contact on /r/anime with many people new to Reddit, the subreddit, or even anime in general and we're aiming to be available and helpful to some degree without solely redirecting people elsewhere.

As of writing this on /new there are currently about 165 (non-removed) threads from the past 24 hours, of those 29 are flaired with What to Watch?; 17.5% isn't insignificant, but it's also not overwhelming everything else and we believe they're easy enough to ignore if you don't feel like they're providing enough information to work with.

Personally, I keep a list written up in a document that's easy to copy and paste if they don't give any preferences or what they've seen before.

2

u/isthatsoudane https://myanimelist.net/profile/ojoulover Aug 04 '22

Fair enough, seems reasonable. As always, I appreciate the thoughtful response!

1

u/Militant_Worm Aug 03 '22

At least a requirement to have a link to a AL / MAL etc list so people aren't wasting they time recommending stuff the OP has already seen.

10

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 04 '22

Banner is kind of neat, but honestly doesn't look great.

13

u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Jul 04 '22 edited Jul 04 '22

You should have seen what we were gonna go with before Durin learnt CCS less than 24 hours ago.

3

u/chilidirigible Jul 04 '22

Recently I tweaked the banners on /r/Macross and having to do New Reddit and the mobile browser interface was a pain in the ass.

6

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 04 '22

Come back and fix it yourself then.

Is your issue with the banner itself or its interaction with the other elements? The redesign look is cleaner because the banner's by itself but I'm not eager to start messing with the entire header layout.

6

u/chilidirigible Jul 04 '22

It's both cleaner in New Reddit and worse in New Reddit, since New Reddit has so much white space.

I don't like the UI having to overlap it in Old Reddit, though.

Having messed with banners on several occasions, I do appreciate that it is a lot of work to do this across different interfaces, but this is still... ehhhhhhhh.

5

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 04 '22

The space on the edges for New Reddit had been intentional, got rid of that now.

Would be great if we had a designer on the mod team to actually do this well but no, you all get a backend developer hacking around instead.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 04 '22

I don't like the UI having to overlap it in Old Reddit, though.

Yup, I probably won't really mind any choice of what's on the banner (tho I kinda preferred no banner), but this is a big no-no.

18

u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Jul 04 '22

A banner of waifus makes this place look like a boys club. Strong dislike.

9

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 04 '22

This is specifically matching the best girl contest and isn't going to be permanent, it won't even look the same tomorrow with the change in groups.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/baquea Jul 04 '22

I don't mind the general design, but the edges look really bad (although it might just be my screen/settings - this is how it displays for me).

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Tarhalindur x2 Jul 04 '22

I would like to add my voice to the list of people disliking the new banner, at least in its present form. (It makes it a little too hard to visually distinguish from certain less SFW subreddits, among other things.)

17

u/dorkmax_executives Jul 03 '22

Might as well bring back something I said a year ago. Why are visual posts (key visual, teaser visual, etc.) allowed to be posted as link posts? Literally defeats the purpose of the content, as it does not fully show the image on Reddit if it's posted as a link. There's also less engagement if it's a link post. I believe visuals should ALWAYS be image posts.

9

u/Lovro26 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lovro26 Jul 03 '22

Agree with this, there is no reason to allow visual images to be posted like this only thing you get from posting like this is that your post will be first as it's faster to post like that (I have seen people post like this just so they can post it first and then wait for the mods to remove the normal one so they can delete their post and then post it normally to get the higher engagement on the post).

17

u/SnuggleMuffin42 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Animemes_chan Jul 03 '22

I posted this right as the old thread got expired so I'll repost it here. Pinging /u/fetchfrosh as well who commented:

The prediction tournament post is completely broken. It's reddit fault - they REALLY want to push this feature, so every vote counts as an upvote on the thread.

But because it's daily, the result is that the Best Girl Prediction Tournament is virtually pinned to the top of the sub and will be for a whole month. That seems.. excessive. It pushes away other content off the front page, and honestly it's pretty meaningless and shouldn't be that emphasized.

Maybe limit the prediction thread to just once a week, and no more?

8

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 04 '22

It's reddit fault - they REALLY want to push this feature

Not disagreeing here.

so every vote counts as an upvote on the thread.

I just want to correct you on this part, it doesn't work that way any more (make a new account and vote if you don't believe me). Yes the the thread has loads of upvotes but that is because it is the real-true-same-thread getting posted again and again. The post naturally rises and falls like any other post does, it just gets re-created daily and the cycle goes again. It isn't quite the same as being pinned - that karma number the post has is misleading.

But yes, that does mean there is effectively two best-girl related threads on the frontpage each day for as long as a new prediction is added each day.

7

u/SnuggleMuffin42 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Animemes_chan Jul 04 '22

I guess it doesn't really matter what mechanism Reddit used to break their own site - The bottom line is that the predictions post starts the day with 25k upvotes and since r/anime doesn't have a lot of 30k upvote threads to begin with, essentially stays right on top as #1 every day, for the entire day.

It's absurd. And in a way actually harms the contest because the prediction thread has a far higher visibility.

8

u/8andahalfby11 myanimelist.net/profile/thereIwasnt Jul 03 '22

Are there any rules established yet to prevent recommendation posts that are just titled "AAAAAHHHHH!!!", "HEEEEEEEEEEELLLLLPPP!!!!!", or any similar-sounding variant that sounds like OP needs an ambulance rather than a show suggestion?

9

u/reddadz x3https://anilist.co/user/MysticEyes Jul 03 '22

We already consider posts with non-descriptive titles as low-effort content, so the rule already exists.

8

u/baquea Jul 05 '22

I'm guessing comparisons between a remake and an original have to go in the 'source material corner', right? Asking for Tokyo Mew Mew New, where I expect such comparisons are going to make up most of the discussion.

7

u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Jul 05 '22

We just did a trial of the Reddit Talks feature. We chose to do it on the new upcoming anime of the summer season.

We did it very informally and mostly just wanted to see how it worked. Here's a couple of our thoughts about the feature.

  • Chat UI is somewhat rough. I couldn't get it to work correctly so we had to use reddit stream for a lot of it. The feature might work but will need more testing. If it was working as intended than it is in a awful state.
  • Audience participation is really important and will need to be used more effectively. Giving a platform for potential trolls however is a scary proposition. There are ways around this however.
  • Have a mod that is not actively hosting. Both for moderating chat but also to catch new viewers up on what is being discussed. Many new viewers will come in and ask repeat questions and some of them aren't up to date on the community.
  • From what we can tell Reddit Talks are shown to everyone on reddit and not just /r/anime.
  • Chat fills up pretty quickly. We did this at a random time on the 4th of July (not everyone is American we know) with no heads up and got 300 users instantly. This isn't a lot in terms of the scope of the subreddit but is easily enough for a lot of conversation. The post got 464 comments in a 2 hour time span. That is also with us not being the best at accommodating community discussion.
  • The talk is recorded and saved.

To be clear we aren't 100% sure if this will be a recurring event. It can be mod heavy and might not fit the subreddit. It really depends on what the community thinks.

Questions for you guys!

  1. Is there any content that you would be interested in having a reddit talk hosted about?
  2. Are any of you interested in speaking verbally or even being a host of a Reddit Talk?
  3. If anyone tuned in what did you think? /u/The_Loli_Otaku had some constructive feedback in the original talk.
  4. Would you like more casual talks or formal? Casual would be like the current talk, recommendation talks, general discussion about anime. Formal could be AMA's, Q&A's, or sub focused events.

6

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jul 05 '22

Are any of you interested in speaking verbally or even being a host of a Reddit Talk?

I don't have a problem speaking publicly so I'd like to tentatively throw my hat in the ring but I'm also very busy at the moment. Please just keep me in considerations as you move forward with your plans.

5

u/The_Loli_Otaku Jul 05 '22

Seasonal talks are alright, but I noticed that a lot of the shows the hosts just weren't really interested in discussing or shilling at all. Totally fair, I understand, but if we were to do another discussion based on chatting about which shows are airing I feel that if we're not able to discuss a show fairly we should really just skip it. Skip it or try to fairly critique it to fill in the audience on what exactly each type of show is and who it'd be suited for. Ideally we could possibly get some regulars tuning in for seasonal anime discussions to find some recommendations for what to watch.

I'd be up for joining in on these discussions but I'll admit that my knowledge of currently airing shows is a bit dire, I tend not to watch anything less than two years old, there's a reason I'm more part of the rewatch crowd. Still, when it comes to shilling or discussing sequels or any subject I'm knowledgeable on I would be eager to help.

The show was a bit iffy but it certainly has potential and is a good opportunity to get the community together. I think it would be very important to improve chat functionality, or at least. I did notice yourself and Durandal trying to interact with chat quite often but half the chat interaction was calling out spam comments, which are an easy remove and ban. With better viewer integration and a slightly cleaner format we could have a pretty good regular podcast on our hands. Speaking of, will this be uploaded to the likes of Audible or Soundcloud?

Imma be real, probably keep it casual. Our community isn't really preppy enough to where its suited towards AMA's or question panels outside of special circumstances.

3

u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Jul 05 '22

if we were to do another discussion based on chatting about which shows are airing I feel that if we're not able to discuss a show fairly we should really just skip it. Skip it or try to fairly critique it to fill in the audience on what exactly each type of show is and who it'd be suited for. Ideally we could possibly get some regulars tuning in for seasonal anime discussions to find some recommendations for what to watch.

If we were actually trying to do this properly I would try and make sure we have people in the chat who I know are invested in shows and series that the main hosts just aren't knowledge about. Its the main benefit of the reddit talk system and is a great use case for it.

I'd be up for joining in on these discussions but I'll admit that my knowledge of currently airing shows is a bit dire, I tend not to watch anything less than two years old, there's a reason I'm more part of the rewatch crowd. Still, when it comes to shilling or discussing sequels or any subject I'm knowledgeable on I would be eager to help.

Will keep that noted! I'm actually interested in maybe doing more specialized but casual recommendation streams. I really like the idea of showing off shows that just don't see the light of day anymore. Maybe something like "You have 2 minutes, SHILL YOUR SHOW!!!.

Speaking of, will this be uploaded to the likes of Audible or Soundcloud?

I don't think reddit has a built in download feature but we could probably download it on our end (assuming that isn't against TOS). Looking at the built in reddit player it is absolutely barebones. It doesn't show who is talking, you can't adjust individual peoples audio, no built in download feature.

Imma be real, probably keep it casual. Our community isn't really preppy enough to where its suited towards AMA's or question panels outside of special circumstances.

I agree with this. I'm sure there is a time and place for something a bit more complicated but its a bit out of the scope of normal plans. Especially if we want this to run with any consistency.

How was the discoverability of it on your end? How did you end up finding the Talk? We didn't actually pin it or even distinguish the post (mostly because I forgot).

4

u/The_Loli_Otaku Jul 05 '22

The talk was actually sent to me via the app. I thought it hooked everyone on for the event. I wasn't looking for it or anything, I just got an app notification that we had a seasonal anime discussion stream going on and I clicked out of curiosity. A lot of other people will have done the same thing judging by how much the view count was going up and down. I'd heard nothing about it beforehand.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 05 '22

How was the discoverability of it on your end? How did you end up finding the Talk? We didn't actually pin it or even distinguish the post (mostly because I forgot).

I wouldn't have had any idea this had been happening were it not mentioned here. Never saw the slightest mention of it.

7

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 05 '22

11

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 05 '22

Mod answer: we're voting on it now.

Personal opinion (unrelated to how the mod vote is going): not a fan and I'll probably be looking for a way to block them across Reddit in my browser.

6

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 05 '22

They can get pretty spammable. If there was a way to approve or block gifs as a mod on a subreddit basis this could be repository of comment faces. But that's probably not possible.

10

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 05 '22 edited Jul 06 '22

I'd love to have some incarnation of comment faces that works on all platforms, but an unregulated (on our end) repository is not it. Reddit Powerups have custom emoji which would almost work but aren't quite flexible enough (or have enough slots).

Edit: speaking of Powerups, parts of that are going away. Last time I tested the custom emoji on a different subreddit they didn't work on old reddit so I'm not in a rush to go ask for them, but it's something to consider.

7

u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos Jul 06 '22

Impressiv how reddit keep trying to add new features that are worse than what was already possible 10years ago with some CSS and R.E.S...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Verzwei Jul 12 '22

Yeah that's the main thing. If we could designate which .gifs are allowed and which aren't, thus allowing us to narrow it down to a set of approved, anime-related .gifs, then I'd be all for it. But it seems like we can't do that. It's either "Let literally everything in" or don't allow them at all.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jul 05 '22

My immediate gut instinct is eww no no no please now ... but I am quite curmudgeonly by nature.

It does seem like the sort of thing that could fit okay for posts that are intended to be full of emotional, "reaction-based" comments and replies. But for posts that are intended/aspiring to be more discussion-oriented I fear a feature like this will just distract or steer away from meaningful discussion.

6

u/animepig https://myanimelist.net/profile/ChickenDan Jul 03 '22 edited Jul 03 '22

What are the current rules about YouTube videos cause I feel like /new gets moderately flooded with crappy YouTube videos from the poster’s channel, so self advertising basically

6

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 03 '22

Self promotion used to require a 10:1 ratio of non-promotion to promotion. The mod team removed that requirement like 2 years ago.

2

u/Sandtalon https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sandtalon Jul 03 '22

You can read the rules right here, but clips and edits are limited to two per month, other videos are limited to two per week.

6

u/jfads89a Jul 05 '22

Anime Questions, Recommendations, and Discussion

I must express my dissatisfaction with the lack of uniform pluralization in the daily sticky threads' titles, especially given the regularity of multiple discussions occurring in parallel.

4

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 05 '22

I had been thinking about it more collectively—the entire thread is one big discussion about anime—but you're not wrong now that you've pointed it out.

5

u/jfads89a Jul 05 '22

I have planted the seed. May enough OCD nourish it and make it bear fruit.

6

u/Verzwei Jul 09 '22

Hey all, looking for some targeted feedback. Disclaimer: There is currently no pending nor planned vote for this, and it's very possible that discussion here may result in no changes at all.

With that being said, how do folks feel about our "OC" tagging/flairing system for fanart?

Per our rules, we use OC to essentially mean Original Creator, and the line explaining it reads as such:

OC fanart refers to content that you have drawn, built or otherwise created yourself.

The potential issue is that, while "OC" can mean Original Creator or Original Content, it unfortunately overlaps with a different definition of "OC" that is very common in (fan)art and fanfiction circles, where it means Original Character. Even the phrase "Original Content/Creation" can have multiple meanings, since some can see it as "This (new) character I drew is an original creation by me."

These mixed definitions, and the fact that we do not allow Original Character artwork, often lead to a lot of confusion with first-time users of the subreddit. With relative frequency, I or another mod might have to explain "Well when our flair says OC, we mean this OC and not that OC."

So, with the preamble out of the way, two questions:

1: Do you feel that our current usage of the OC tag is intuitive and serves its purpose sufficiently?

2: If we were to change the tag from "OC" to something else, do you have any suggestions?

For #2, please keep in mind that this is a tag that would potentially go into our rules and onto our flairs so it needs to be succinct but also self-explanatory enough so that people understand the usage at a glance. It needs to be something that conveys "I made this representation of something from an anime" but also needs to cover a wide variety of mediums, from drawings to paintings to cake decorations.

5

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 09 '22

I haven't personally seen any issue with it being tagged as OC despite also being part of fanfiction circles, but...

If we were to change the tag from "OC" to something else, do you have any suggestions?

Is "Original Fanart" too long for a flair? I feel like if it's not, that would be a simple enough change. Original = I made this, Fanart = it's based on an existing thing and isn't an original character.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 12 '22

OC has different meanings, but in the context of the sub it should be pretty clear, especially if one takes a minute to read the rules before posting.

3

u/Verzwei Jul 12 '22

especially if one takes a minute to read the rules before posting.

2

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 12 '22

yeah, but in that case they have no grounds to complain and the change is really up to saving the mods the time to remove stuff

2

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Aug 05 '22

"OC"

I think it took me over a year to figure out what this meant.

6

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 12 '22

I'mma drop a hot take real quick, hot take threads can be a fun time (even if they can get a bit toxic). And so I want to talk briefly about this thread. It was removed as, "a short discussion thread. This is a form of restricted content that isn't allowed as a full post on the sub." It mentioned that this was a form of "restricted content" but the restricted content list on the rules page makes no references to any content in that sort of space.

Now, as of some time that I'm honestly not sure of, posts with a few common phrases were banned including "does anyone else" and "unpopular opinion". The former is definitely broadly lame because the answer is always yes (and really its just another way of saying, "upvote if you..."), but the latter does somewhat bother me because unpopular opinion threads can at least produce some novel content and make for a decent place to genuinely criticize some anime that will normally just get you dogpiled.

So swinging back to the hot take thread, it seems like it was removed less as "this is low effort" and more as "this is another way of saying 'unpopular opinion' and we don't do that". The basic post itself is a broad, open ended prompt, and if that counts as low effort than so do a lot of such prompts. Recent popular threads like, "what anime are you still mad about," "what do newer anime fans say that hurts as an older long-time fan," and "what anime do you think was wasted potential" are all examples from the past month of threads with a similar type of open ended question that are structurally the same as the removed post. All three of them also come with the same potential for toxicity (the first and last for variations of "X anime bad" and the middle for potential to be attacking other fans). I don't see a dramatic difference between the threads, and so I'm just putting it out there that I think it, and threads like it, should be fine.

8

u/crobat3 https://myanimelist.net/profile/crobat3 Jul 12 '22

That thread was considered to be "low-effort" because it contained only a prompt with no further explanation or elaboration, and that is what sets it apart from the three examples provided - the first one gave possible reasons for someone to get mad about an anime, and in the other two threads the OPs gave their own opinions about the topic. Hence, if the OP had shared their own personal hot takes, for instance, the thread would likely have been approved.

Regarding the use of the phrase "unpopular opinion" - while it does open some room for discussion, in my experience that specific phrasing almost always results in users dogpiling on the OP, or the OP insulting every other user in the thread for presenting a different view. The threads were almost universally toxic to the point that it wasn't worth it to keep them around.

5

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 12 '22

That thread was considered to be "low-effort" because it contained only a prompt with no further explanation or elaboration, and that is what sets it apart from the three examples

That makes sense. I can't see what the original post said now since it was removed, but I can buy that.

and in the other two threads the OPs gave their own opinions about the topic. Hence, if the OP had shared their own personal hot takes, for instance, the thread would likely have been approved.

This is a personal take on thread structure, but having the OP response in the body of the post instead of as a comment usually is for the worst. This was something that was explicitly banned in askreddit (though there it's in the title, since there's no body text over there) because it awkwardly skews discussion around one opinion. Basically you get a bunch of top level comments responding to that, and a lot of the other discussion gets pushed down as a result of a bunch of similar comments.

Regarding the use of the phrase "unpopular opinion" - while it does open some room for discussion, in my experience that specific phrasing almost always results in users dogpiling on the OP, or the OP insulting every other user in the thread for presenting a different view. The threads were almost universally toxic to the point that it wasn't worth it to keep them around.

So there's like two different types of "unpopular opinion" threads. First is the specific "Unpopular opinion, but X is actually a terrible anime" and the second is the open ended "What's your unpopular opinion about this season". The former tends to suck but the latter is usually more or less fine.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 13 '22

Hence, if the OP had shared their own personal hot takes, for instance, the thread would likely have been approved.

Can we, like, not do that? I always appreciate when the OP puts their own take on the prompt as a comment instead of the post itself. Putting it in the post gives that particular take special treatment over the others, and often skews the discussion accordingly. Putting their takes in additional comments avoids that and is thus much preferable in general, and OP did in fact give several takes of their own in the comments (you can argue whether they were hot takes but that's besides the point).

3

u/crobat3 https://myanimelist.net/profile/crobat3 Jul 13 '22

They could - that was just an example of how OP could have fleshed out their thread. Instead of sharing their own take they could have provided other prompts or examples for other users to expand on.

As long as there's sufficient elaboration and it's not just a simple one-liner statement, it would be fine.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 24 '22

Hey Comment-face lovers.

The next season's seasonal comment face submission thread will go up Wednesday (midnight) and run for one week.

Additionally I have collected some data about comment-face usage.

  • This is the number of comments that contained each comment-face. So multiple uses of a single face in one comment would be counted as one use.
  • Does not count posts, only comments.
  • Excludes mod-distinguished comments (So no bot-moderator removal messages)

Below are two comments with different date ranges.

4

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 25 '22

Excellent! I have at least one thing to submit since I've actually been watching not one but two seasonals this time.

3

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 24 '22 edited Jul 24 '22

2021-06-01 - > 2022-07-19 (Since 2021, seasonal commentfaces excluded)

FaceCount
mugiwait34980
ero12132
therethere10305
azusalaugh10094
hardthink9269
awe8593
laughter6172
sadholo5976
yuishrug5612
konhug5521
toradorasalute5329
panic5185
faito5182
rengehype4702
sakurathink4502
holdme4284
schemingsaten4271
concealedexcitement4158
curious4059
anko3937
feelingloved3864
utahapraises3808
cosy3801
salute3755
slowgrin3735
drool3610
woo3570
loliwave3504
rengethink3447
maxshock3437
punch3373
neat3116
kannathumbs3041
ama2993
terror2964
hikariactually2662
dekuhype2536
justright2515
makicry2421
SPORTS2319
happyclap2267
lewd2230
harukathink2219
mugistronk2169
nico-heart2152
saesmile2139
pointandlaugh2099
cantbehelped2007
taigasigh1988
umucool1905
k-on-hug1899
doggo1799
everythingisfine1760
angrypout1750
garlock1750
uwaa1724
binoculars1718
howcouldyou1671
fingertwirl1649
protest1645
wow1614
lolifightsback1589
mechablush1587
mugipout1562
yuitears1543
delighted1521
crazedlaugh1513
chinosmirk1501
animatedthink1492
watashiworried1485
flyingbunsofdoom1460
kotohoops1460
fistbump1456
frustration1408
spinning1403
kukuku1361
whisperwhisper1347
shatteredsaten1328
nichijouthumbs1326
rinkek1300
helmetbro1296
urarahype1267
morethanonewaifu1251
teehee1251
dighole1248
pout1236
firstthinginthemorning1235
morecomfy1224
gununu1199
thoughtful1190
ptsd1171
nobully1168
blankblink1156
elsieqq1113
bruh1092
badtaste1080
excitedyui1068
lewdgyaru1058
thinkingtoohard1051
megadeathparty1037
dead1020
mug91016
kotourashock1008
csikon1008
longday1005
eh996
towel981
akkotears964
modabuse964
foldedarms944
saberawe924
godisdead923
niatilt916
notlewd911
mug8909
kaguyashaking898
mangaka887
goblet1884
salutegeo871
scaredmio871
mentioned867
spooked840
ilovethiskindofshit833
akyuusqueel833
vacationcup812
evilgrin807
popcorn2803
mug7800
emiliaohdear795
scrumptiouslymoe791
harukathonk791
grandhype782
slapbet777
eheheh771
whippersnappers767
squee762
breakingnews750
facepalm747
gabdisgust744
shakeit732
headrub730
nyanpasu722
peasants722
congratulations718
floweryhug714
kyonfacepalm713
katoupls709
teekyuuhype701
cokemasterrace698
oilup690
drunkhisone666
sleepingcutie666
feelsgoodman658
hajimepout656
takasakiapproves653
mug3649
norice646
indexsmugshrug637
healthypasstimes633
imdone629
shock615
elsiesigh614
hypeeyes605
smugpoint601
mindmelt589
lifeishard585
hyoukawink580
urbansmile575
funky567
hugbear566
bigshock560
modsalute559
hypeoverload557
volibearQ553
deletethis549
eyythisguy548
saehug548
frustrated546
takaradasalute543
papithumbsup540
sideeyes533
kms526
kumikouninterested525
whatdidijustread524
deadlystare521
moeshitarcher518
flustered515
mischievous515
suddenshock514
smugtouru513
serialkillerlaugh506
comfortfood506
piracy504
shades502
mashiroglare495
assman495
comfy489
whatamireading489
kinirohug487
soon487
worshipme487
happydera485
kaguyasigh483
disbelief469
gendo-pls467
slightoverreaction464
finethen462
fish459
rum456
brofist454
forgotkeys451
cup7449
nocomment448
dontgetit439
trynottocry438
bacchiri435
wallpunch434
vashheadscratch425
chiochanvictory424
fujostare423
kotori415
cup4409
tch407
emptyinside406
sassyimouto406
stare406
tiredfate398
elves390
sulking388
biiru387
heavydrinker386
ringomusume383
shirayukiappeased381
shinjimug373
yuruyuriapprove369
shirouthumbsup366
nosenpai366
shutupandtakemymoney365
sweating363
ohfuck362
yousaidsomethingdumb359
girlslastdab359
killitwithfire353
hnng351
shirayukieavesdrop351
mug1351
giveuponlife350
kukuku2343
forbiddenlove338
katoupout334
dejected331
tablesleep329
surprisedpikachu328
hisocuck327
surefam327
unsure326
jibrilaww324
shitposting323
sagiri323
konosubawot323
flattered321
delicious321
glasses-push318
kurisudisappointed314
cateyes314
smugrose314
lesbians311
facepalm2309
lost307
smugboard302
wallbang300
holdback300
miyamoriunimpressed300
gintamathispleasesme299
smugobi298
meguminthumbsup298
whowouldathunkit298
fuukothumbsup297
haruhiisnotamused295
lolismile293
cup6292
kaorusmile289
hahahawhat286
nanami-hug286
not-raining279
aliens274
scaredillya273
why268
salt265
nuidideverythingright265
banjo259
fightme251
bitchplease251
spacetears250
dancewithit250
getout249
crumblingdespair248
fedup247
shh244
grouphug243
hackadollthumbsup243
torrentialdownpour242
etotamadunno242
merch241
romance240
mug2240
elsienopesout238
threatening238
fuckyou232
sobright229
overwhelmed227
megushock221
kobeniblush219
cheekychika219
ok212
gasp211
nosebleed205
waah204
jibrilfetish203
ginapproves202
smugshinobu202
holdup201
backfired199
idoruwinkdesu195
barakamonnotcool193
gunfire192
angryfeline192
toradorable192
nicoisdone190
yui-crying190
juice1189
thebutton188
lwahorror187
mywaifumadeyouasandwich186
restrainedanger183
smugasuna181
isthisameme180
cackle179
KUSOTTARE178
lolipolice177
saltymug177
riddhethink175
terminate174
hanasakueurgh173
cultured171
poltears171
exasperated170
kumikolook167
wipetears166
loli_ok165
watashihasdeclined165
chitosesmug164
shirayukifuckinreally163
headpat162
watchadoin161
criticism160
yorokobe158
takeoutthetrash157
tomato157
konodioda157
jawdrop156
jashinsip155
psh-mongrels155
cheekygahara154
justno153
peace153
banhammer152
saikikek151
bakabakashii150
manly-tears147
igiveup146
drink2142
upvote140
thumbs-up139
headshake132
luckytehe132
satisfyingbev127
unko127
sickness122
head-tilt122
deflate121
lalahmm121
illyastare121
datass119
selfcontrol119
chitogheh118
mmph114
mindblank114
dame113
nononono111
micdrop107
hellopolice107
shittaste106
rerorero106
TOMODA106
disagree105
laststraw105
badday104
excitedmao104
calmdown104
ok_hand103
smughaikyuu103
mayushii102
budgetsmile101
annoyedkiki101
bookburning99
toohighforthis99
wow-really98
lyingawake97
panickedgakuto94
tanakalove94
kanyehidouyo94
konosubawot294
ookii93
thatsmyfetish93
outofplace91
whathaveidone90
cup390
konosubawot389
missedthepoint88
hideintoilet88
mmmmyrgh88
womanlytears86
nottodisushittoagen86
spilledtea85
lovenectar83
shockedsotoka82
haaaaaaah81
heart-thumbs-up81
throwsalt80
araara79
lifedrained79
shhbabe79
annoyedkirito79
shirayukidrunk78
loveisatrap74
smugkaguya74
misakiteehee72
araragi-171
sowwy70
comehere69
trollnui67
smoke66
happyhug65
tooexcitedforsleep65
hearteyes63
atthewindow62
elderlylove60
nonnonbino59
theydidwhat57
wtfdidijustwatch57
angryheadgrab54
regretdecisions54
promise50
kawaii48
konosubawot448
done47
plebgetawayfromme47
nooo45
cooresto45
peacepeace45
smugkillua39
f537
scarredforlife36
badnews35
schwing35
grandmawhy34
WRYYY33
yoihug28
whyhime25
triggeredkillua19

3

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 25 '22

Why am I not surprised absolutely dominates both of these tables.

2

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 24 '22

2022-05-06 - > 2022-07-19 (Since seasonal comment-faces announced)

FaceCount
mugiwait4959
azusalaugh1772
awe1458
therethere1221
hardthink986
laughter870
ero844
sadholo776
toradorasalute735
seasonallisten705
utahapraises661
yuishrug625
faito612
rengehype601
panic583
neat557
schemingsaten552
curious526
rengethink514
seasonalthink504
anko482
drool476
feelingloved457
SPORTS451
terror432
hikariactually431
slowgrin426
sakurathink417
concealedexcitement409
ama408
seasonalhype391
cosy374
salute374
konhug366
maxshock349
holdme349
kannathumbs343
dekuhype333
woo331
makicry330
mugistronk327
everythingisfine318
justright316
pointandlaugh312
harukathink305
loliwave292
umucool291
fingertwirl285
binoculars278
fistbump277
happyclap276
nico-heart275
megadeathparty274
watashiworried273
uwaa269
mechablush268
thoughtful260
cantbehelped258
doggo257
wow250
seasonalshock240
towel239
spinning237
crazedlaugh230
lewd222
seasonalapproval222
punch214
yuitears210
taigasigh206
frustration206
kotohoops203
rinkek203
seasonaldepression203
garlock202
protest193
delighted192
saberawe190
teehee190
saesmile185
morethanonewaifu184
seasonalpout181
morecomfy176
howcouldyou169
csikon168
grandhype167
shatteredsaten163
kyonfacepalm160
seasonaltired159
dighole156
squee156
helmetbro156
scaredmio154
ptsd150
akyuusqueel149
akkotears148
blankblink148
kotourashock148
foldedarms146
harukathonk146
flyingbunsofdoom145
scrumptiouslymoe143
seasonalconfused143
animatedthink142
thinkingtoohard137
lolifightsback135
modabuse134
whippersnappers134
kukuku133
excitedyui132
angrypout131
mugipout128
pout128
vacationcup126
nichijouthumbs126
elsieqq126
oilup125
eh124
shakeit123
healthypasstimes120
gununu120
goblet1117
badtaste116
nobully115
cokemasterrace114
bruh114
hypeeyes114
fujostare114
forgotkeys113
kaguyashaking112
seasonallove112
emiliaohdear111
mangaka111
congratulations110
ilovethiskindofshit109
nyanpasu104
assman102
godisdead100
firstthinginthemorning100
shock99
popcorn298
evilgrin97
elves97
urbansmile94
suddenshock94
k-on-hug92
hypeoverload91
mindmelt90
whisperwhisper90
forbiddenlove90
smugpoint90
nocomment90
rum89
spooked89
norice89
notlewd86
lewdgyaru86
comfortfood85
eheheh85
urarahype85
brofist84
mug384
shades82
teekyuuhype82
volibearQ81
lesbians80
sagiri79
sideeyes79
katoupls79
eyythisguy78
bigshock77
seasonalcool77
mentioned76
imdone76
fish76
longday75
smugtouru75
mug775
kumikouninterested75
gabdisgust74
stare74
feelsgoodman73
vashheadscratch73
dead72
soon72
mug872
seasonallaugh72
mug171
niatilt71
hyoukawink69
surprisedpikachu69
modsalute69
takasakiapproves69
seasonaldisapproval69
kaguyasigh68
trynottocry67
finethen67
disbelief66
facepalm66
peasants65
drunkhisone65
gendo-pls65
dontgetit64
frustrated63
heavydrinker63
whatdidijustread63
shirayukiappeased62
indexsmugshrug62
salutegeo61
lost61
piracy61
waah61
killitwithfire60
emptyinside59
bacchiri59
hugbear58
whatamireading58
happydera58
hajimepout57
mischievous57
worshipme57
shirayukieavesdrop57
elsiesigh56
wallpunch54
merch54
comfy54
lifeishard54
seasonaldisdain54
tch53
sweating52
saehug52
takaradasalute52
floweryhug51
mashiroglare51
slapbet51
serialkillerlaugh50
moeshitarcher50
chiochanvictory50
deletethis50
papithumbsup50
ohfuck49
flattered48
delicious48
headrub47
tiredfate47
biiru46
kurisudisappointed45
sobright45
konosubawot45
slightoverreaction44
kms44
tomato44
ginapproves44
yuruyuriapprove44
flustered43
hnng43
hahahawhat43
cheekychika43
ringomusume43
aliens42
cateyes42
nosenpai42
smugrose42
meguminthumbsup42
criticism41
overwhelmed41
breakingnews40
holdback40
surefam40
katoupout40
nosebleed39
shutupandtakemymoney39
kinirohug38
unsure38
yousaidsomethingdumb38
smugobi38
facepalm237
gasp37
chinosmirk37
glasses-push37
grouphug36
banjo36
wallbang35
girlslastdab35
romance35
not-raining35
cup434
shitposting33
kobeniblush33
angryfeline33
kaorusmile33
peace33
nuidideverythingright32
torrentialdownpour32
etotamadunno32
nicoisdone32
crumblingdespair32
funky31
holdup31
smugboard31
cup731
fuckyou31
sleepingcutie30
shinjimug30
ok30
justno29
fightme29
getout29
dejected29
gintamathispleasesme29
jibrilaww29
lolipolice28
hisocuck28
sassyimouto28
threatening28
why28
hanasakueurgh28
deadlystare27
wipetears27
mug927
miyamoriunimpressed27
nanami-hug27
shirouthumbsup26
chitosesmug26
tablesleep26
shh26
megushock26
backfired25
saikikek25
banhammer25
shirayukifuckinreally25
mug225
jibrilfetish25
smugshinobu25
yui-crying25
elsienopesout24
lolismile24
loveisatrap24
scaredillya24
terminate24
thebutton24
mindblank24
hackadollthumbsup24
haruhiisnotamused24
giveuponlife23
jawdrop23
riddhethink23
kumikolook23
dancewithit22
lwahorror22
salt22
exasperated22
isthisameme22
hellopolice22
whowouldathunkit22
idoruwinkdesu21
comehere21
KUSOTTARE21
cheekygahara21
kukuku221
mywaifumadeyouasandwich20
outofplace20
mmmmyrgh20
bitchplease20
barakamonnotcool20
gunfire19
takeoutthetrash19
sulking19
calmdown19
kotori19
fuukothumbsup18
restrainedanger18
micdrop17
fedup17
dame17
illyastare17
selfcontrol17
cup617
igiveup17
juice117
konodioda17
TOMODA17
psh-mongrels17
laststraw16
spacetears16
cackle16
ok_hand16
nottodisushittoagen16
datass16
smughaikyuu16
watashihasdeclined16
head-tilt16
shittaste15
watchadoin15
drink215
saltymug15
toradorable15
badday14
deflate14
nononono14
yorokobe14
budgetsmile14
luckytehe14
smugkaguya14
thatsmyfetish14
konosubawot414
poltears14
shirayukidrunk14
missedthepoint13
sickness13
unko13
loli_ok13
manly-tears13
thumbs-up13
disagree12
panickedgakuto12
spilledtea12
toohighforthis12
cultured11
lalahmm11
nooo11
scarredforlife11
shhbabe11
kanyehidouyo11
headpat10
bookburning10
womanlytears10
peacepeace10
konosubawot210
upvote9
elderlylove9
jashinsip9
mayushii9
konosubawot39
heart-thumbs-up9
headshake8
rerorero8
araara8
bakabakashii8
lyingawake8
satisfyingbev8
shockedsotoka8
theydidwhat8
trollnui8
throwsalt7
done7
lifedrained7
regretdecisions7
whathaveidone7
annoyedkiki7
smugasuna7
annoyedkirito7
misakiteehee7
chitogheh7
araragi-17
angryheadgrab6
badnews6
excitedmao6
haaaaaaah6
hideintoilet6
nonnonbino6
tanakalove6
lovenectar6
cooresto5
schwing5
smoke4
smugkillua4
wtfdidijustwatch4
f53
happyhug3
mmph3
ookii3
promise3
whyhime3
cup33
wow-really3
yoihug2
WRYYY2
atthewindow1
hearteyes1
tooexcitedforsleep1
sowwy1
plebgetawayfromme1
triggeredkillua1
grandmawhy0
kawaii0

2

u/chilidirigible Jul 26 '22

Huh, where's [](#airfist)? I know I've used it a few times, though I maybe the only one who does so.

2

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Jul 27 '22

Huh, [ are all missing. The other Bot-chan faces as well, but I can't remember if I've used them recently. Wonder why that is.

2

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Jul 27 '22

Just saw the other thread, I'm curious about the selection process (forgot if this was mentioned in the previous one); Is the mod team voting on them or something?

2

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 29 '22

Yes. At this point in time, the selection will be made by the mod team.

6

u/Mazen141 Aug 05 '22 edited Aug 05 '22

So my account got caught by Reddit's spam filter by mistake and I ended up getting shadowbanned and had all my posts removed for spam, now I was able send an appeal which was then accepted and my account has been unbanned, problem is that most of the posts I've made on Reddit (which are mostly on this subreddit) haven't seemed to be reapproved, take this one for an example, I was wondering if there was any way for my posts to be reapproved?

7

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Aug 06 '22

Oof, that's unfortunate. All your submissions should be reapproved now, will write a script (probably in the next day or two at this point) to approve your comments. If there are any other specific comments you'd prefer immediately reapproved let us know here or via modmail.

4

u/Mazen141 Aug 06 '22

Thanks so much! I don't believe I have any comment important enough to require to be immediately approved by the mods when they're going to be approved in a couple of days, I'm honestly just curious as to how my account got caught by the Reddit spam filter, I typically post every couple of days and my posts don't really seem like typical spam stuff, only guess I have is that reddit wasn't a fan that most of the posts I've been making lately have been link posts for the most part

Again thanks for helping me out, I didn't really expect to receive a reply or to even have my posts reapproved on this subreddit let alone comments,

4

u/Custom_sKing_SKARNER Aug 07 '22

I just got a notification about 2 replies of you months ago xd

Congrats on recovering your account.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/cppn02 Aug 06 '22 edited Aug 07 '22

Lol seems like your posts getting reapproved is causing people getting notifications on your old comments.

I just got notified on two replies from you that are over a year old and I reckon this thread is why.

edit: And a third one.

edit 2: Four and counting.

edit 3: Eight now.

edit 4: Ten!

edit 5: Eight more while I was asleep so 18 in total.

4

u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Aug 06 '22

Took me a while to find the comment I got notified about because I kept going to "all" messages instead of "unread" and obviously years old comment won't be there in "all"

4

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Aug 06 '22

Oh that's why I got a notification on a 9 months old comment in a locked thread lol

→ More replies (3)

5

u/baquea Jul 06 '22

Can #angrypout get added to the 'Sulking, Pouting' section on the comment face categories page on the wiki?

5

u/Verzwei Jul 29 '22

Minor rule update

Previously, our rules regarding Clips, Video Edits, and Videos read as follows:

Any clip, edit, or video within the top 75 posts of all time are never allowed to be reposted.

Recent discussion questioned the value or usefulness of this rule when the "top 75 of all time" contains a large quantity of content that already cannot be reposted due to our other rules. Posts including, but not limited to, News, Official Media trailers and visuals, and episode discussions already cannot be reposted at all, regardless of whether or not they are in the top 75 of all time. Such posts directly reduce the amount of situations in which the above-quoted rule can be applied to cut down on reposted content.

We have amended the rule to the following:

Any clip, edit, or video within the top 75 posts of all time for each flair are never allowed to be reposted.

Intended effect: This will increase the quantity of video content posts that are ineligible for reposting due to their popularity and previous success on the subreddit. Currently, there are approximately 10 [Video] posts and 15 [Clip] posts in the top 75 of all time when not splitting it by flair, and that quantity changes as new posts make it to the top 75 of all time. This change makes it so that the top 75 Clips, the top 75 Edits, and the top 75 Videos are all ineligible for reposting.

The rules page has been updated, and each subcategory includes a filtered and sorted link to the top posts for each flair. Redesign/"New" Reddit makes tracking the top 75 a little obtuse due to infinite scrolling, but it's the first 3 pages of results on Old Reddit.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jul 30 '22 edited Jul 30 '22

I'm not too clear on the exact details of this bug but after some quick testing it appears that the spoiler tags do not function properly if you insert a hyperlink inside them. This seems to be a specific problem for only Android phones with the Reddit app since the spoiler tags are working as intended for the Bacon Reader app on Android, the iOS app, and multiple web browsers.

Here is an example: [Is Kasukasu adorable?] Yes.

Would anyone happen to know of a work-around to this problem other than outright removing the links? And if not, then is the answer simply a policy change of not allowing hyperlinks into spoiler tags?

2

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 30 '22

spoiler tags are working as intended for the Bacon Reader app on Android

Bacon Reader (android) has problems with native spoilers, but hyperlinks inside are not one.

But as for the default reddit app (android), I don't see an issue with your example (before/after click).

2

u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jul 30 '22

For some reason, they aren't working on my friend's Android (even for the parent comment) and also for this particular user.

Now I'm even more confused...

→ More replies (2)

8

u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin Jul 29 '22

This is probably a bit “politically incorrect” and some will think this might be “downplaying”, but I would suggest given latest spreading dynamics (in Japan) we need an “Anime VA and staff catching COVID Mega thread” and direct all similar discussions to this thread.

Case in point: lots of VAs reporting +ve today alone. In addition to Aoi Yuuki as reported some hours ago I count Akari Kitou, Lynn (getting the notice midway in a Engage Kiss broadcasting session no less, whoops), Daki Yamashita, Miho Okzsaki, Aina Aiba alone for VAs with a bit of notability here, with more lesser known ones too. I can see our sub-Reddit being flooded with similar posts very fast given:

a) Japan’s 1st Omicron wave in January - February seems smaller than many other countries after all;

b) they didn’t had an “early” spring “BA.2” wave;

c) this makes this current “BA.2.x” wave quite a bit bigger in proportion than most parts of the world right now, with peak still not reached (though at least it’s decelerating for ~2 weeks);

d) VAs (especially) and anime staff probably have more contact with everyone else than you and me;

e) Experts have all noted that it’s only a matter of time, maybe within 2022 or even already did, that there’s more who had COVID experience than those who haven’t. It’s almost certainly only a matter of time before most of us here do, I haven’t but I expect I will within this year.

Given the changing dynamics since Omicron appeared late last year, I just think that such news are of quite a bit less worrying than, say, even last summer. I am not going to say that it’s “individually equivalent to the nastier end of seasonal influenza”, but the changing situation means that a central thread for such news seems to be better than having one every few hours for the next weeks and then having everyone saying the same Best Wishes or arguing about COVID.

Mods, what do you think?

4

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 04 '22

With all the banner talk, one possible way would be to take inspiration from the /r/OnePiece sub. I don't frequent it a lot but their banners have always been great.

The way they do it is they hold a banner contest from time to time - Announcement, Submissions, Voting and Results. I could see this work very well for /r/anime as well, featuring multiple shows in a quality banner while also having some community involvement.

Of course I don't know if that would actually work as well in this sub. Both seem similar in terms of activity (judging from the active users count), so that seems alright. On the other hand there's already a lot of botting going on in other votings on the sub, which could be an issue.

There'd also be the question of how often the banner is supposed to be changed. Once per season could work but might also be too much for this procedure. A yearly banner might work better in that regard, though it loses the seasonal connection. If one goes seasonal there'd also be the question of when exactly - I can't imagine doing the banner as the season start would work all that well, but that'd be necessary if one wants the banner to connect to the current season. It might work better to do it mid or even after the season.

Just an idea.

13

u/Verzwei Jul 05 '22

No thanks, I don't want permanent AOT and/or Kaguya banners.

I feel like getting a wide variety of show representation would be difficult, given that a handful of the most-popular series tend to generate a disproportionate amount of hype on the subreddit.

At least with a series-specific sub, having a content focus makes total sense.

Not saying the idea is completely without merit, but I think it would take a lot of iterating on. Our current experiment is tying the banner to an event that we actively have ongoing right now (the best girl contest) so these banners would likely be quite impermanent and subject to change.

2

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 05 '22

Yeah, that's what I was worrying about as well.

For what it's worth I kinda like the discount-banner we have for now.

4

u/michhoffman :Ij::Ik::Il:https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman Jul 05 '22

Is there a reason why the Made in Abyss Discussion Thread just went up? I double-checked HiDive, and they aren't releasing it until tomorrow at 2:30 PM UTC.

4

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 05 '22

Early season quirks with the bot, taking care of it.

2

u/michhoffman :Ij::Ik::Il:https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman Jul 05 '22

Awesome! Thank you

4

u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Jul 05 '22

Quick question on seasonal comment faces -

here its noted that

Series must be currently airing as part of this season, the image can be from a previous season if the show is a sequel. Movies/OVAs that have become accessible between seasonal nominations will be allowed.

When you say previous season, are there limitations here? If we are on season 5 of bookworm, can a comment face be nominated from season 1? What about with something like Baki where the new ONAs from 2018 are a sequel to the 2001 show, could something from a different production be used? What about remakes - Spriggan/Bastard had aired in between seasons so they would be eligible, but would stuff from the old movies/OVAs be eligible?

My thought is that it doesnt need to be formalized and as long as its funny go for it - even if its less preferred

on that last note, i will need to screen cap every neco arc in existence for submission

2

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 06 '22

doesnt need to be formalized and as long as its funny go for it - even if its less preferred

That is pretty much the spirit of it.

Stuff from previous seasons are fine. If you have a dope face from the original Baki (which was like 2001) that fits the requirement and you an nominate it. It will at least make it onto our spreadsheet - although it may end up less preferred for one of the limited spots.

I want to be lenient to movies/OVA's as they don't align with traditional season timings, especially when you factor wide English releases/availability. So any OVA/movie that came out since the previous nomination thread would be fine to nominate.

4

u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jul 30 '22

Lycoris Recoil thread please and thank you!!!

3

u/cppn02 Jul 30 '22

Secondend. Sent a mod message half an hour ago and no reaction so far.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 30 '22 edited Jul 30 '22

LycoReco thread is missing, should've been up more than half an hour ago based on past weeks

edit: is up now

11

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jul 04 '22

Argh a banner, I hate it.

Nothing against it specifically I just don't like because I'm grumpy and hate change

6

u/cppn02 Jul 11 '22

Another week another RWBY episode discussion dominated by source material discussion. What is the point of the source corner if people are allowed to discuss this openly down in the comments?

6

u/Verzwei Jul 12 '22

I'm unsure if anyone on the mod team is personally following this show on day-of-simulcast. I do know that we have at least one moderator who is familiar with the original, but hardly anyone is reporting anything — We're receiving virtually no reports/modqueue activity for this show. So the source commentary is tending to linger a bit longer until one of us can manually comb the thread.

2

u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jul 11 '22

It was bad for the first few hours but the thread has now been cleaned up a LOT. Good mods :)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Oppaipaisen Jul 03 '22

Q1: Is there a reason why comment faces have an inconsistent size?

Q2: Am I the only one that thinks that this look like "Why yes, I will grope some boobs"?

3

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jul 03 '22
  1. Well, they were added over a five+ year period. Also some were cropped for content puposes.
  2. I can't see it on mobile but I know exactly which one you mean.

2

u/chilidirigible Jul 03 '22

That's why I like to
put text here

1

u/Nebresto Jul 03 '22

2: Username checks out

1

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Aug 03 '22

Is there a reason why comment faces have an inconsistent size?

A lot of them are cropped from larger shots and won't necessarily fit the same aspect ratio when doing so. Also to reduce file sizes since Reddit only gives us so much to work with.

3

u/Panda_Generals https://myanimelist.net/profile/Panda_In_Space Jul 03 '22

Can we get a single post for the whole season for Netflix animes since they get almost all the episodes at the same time so someone who binges it can discuss there but someone can also go to the the normal episode discussion if they want

3

u/cppn02 Jul 04 '22 edited Jul 05 '22

Just wanted to ask if the complete lack of moderation regarding source-related discussions on the RWBY episode post can be expected for the rest of the season so I know if there is still a point in joining these threads.

edit: No answer is also an answer I guess.

3

u/8andahalfby11 myanimelist.net/profile/thereIwasnt Jul 06 '22

On desktop at the top of the sub there's the banner with all the anime girls. Homura and Madoka are not next to each other. She'd never put up with that in the anime! Please fix!

9

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 06 '22

The order is because of the matches in the current round of the Best Girl 9 contest, with each next to their opponent. If Madoka and Homura keep winning they might end up next to each other.

3

u/baquea Jul 13 '22

Is there any way to reveal spoilers that only contain a comment face? I see them occasionally, but clicking or highlighting them doesn't seem to do anything, unlike for a text spoiler, so I can't figure out how to view them. I'm using desktop old Reddit BTW.

[Example] How do I view this?

6

u/Verzwei Jul 13 '22

What browser? Are there any other extensions that could be interfering with it?

I ask because I pretty much only use this subreddit on desktop Chrome, with old.reddit, and I was able to click on the spoiler bar and then see the comment face without any issue.

2

u/baquea Jul 13 '22

Firefox. Just tried on Chrome, and it looks like it does work on there for me too.

Playing around with it though, I actually managed to figure out how to view it on Firefox - you just have to click within the bottom two rows of pixels of the spoiler box to display it.

2

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 13 '22

More generally without any extensions... I'm not sure.

Off the top of my head I can't think of any sub-wide CSS that would do that in a limited way, and it would also be bad if people weren't aware of that exception and put something there that should actually need the spoiler tag, e.g. in the text of the comment face itself.

That said if you have an extension like RES or something else that allows custom CSS on your end, you could make the new spoiler tags function like the old ones and reveal on hover which does work for that specific issue.

3

u/baquea Jul 17 '22

On the laughter section of the comment faces categorized wiki page, #laughter, #azusalaugh and #pointandlaugh are all missing the † to indicate they're animated.

3

u/Sandtalon https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sandtalon Jul 17 '22

Thanks, fixed.

3

u/Nebresto Jul 18 '22

Not sure if there's plans for this already: After the final round of the contest is done I suggest having all winners in the banner for maybe a week or so. Then we can go back to normal or what ever

3

u/LordTrinity https://myanimelist.net/profile/LordTrinity Jul 25 '22

Is there any place or thread which I can collect and/or see data about r/anime ? I am interested in seeing data about flairs, particularly how many of the users here use MyAnimelist in comparison with other sites

3

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 25 '22

This is the right place to ask, as far as I'm aware we don't have current stats on user flair (/u/badspler would have a better idea if that's tracked) but when we moved to the new flair system about a year ago this is what the migration ended up with:

SiteFlair CountPercentage
MyAnimeList3401988.4%
AniList28367.4%
Kitsu10812.8%
Anime-Planet5171.3%
AniDB280.1%
38481

2

u/LordTrinity https://myanimelist.net/profile/LordTrinity Jul 25 '22

I see. Thank you for the answer!

3

u/molave_ https://myanimelist.net/profile/mo_lave Jul 27 '22

What are your thoughts in holding "Day Zero" rewatches for shows that use the binge release model?

As an example, I fully expect that the discussion threads for part two of Stone Ocean would be devoid of replies because they all get posted at the same time.

I'm thinking that if someone posts one "rewatch" post a week per episode, we can simulate the weekly release model and the conversations that arise from it.

3

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 27 '22

I don't think we're going to do that in an official mod/episode bot capacity any time soon but we also aren't planning to stop anyone that wants to do it themselves.

I know for Stone Ocean specifically there was talk of doing that last month.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '22

Can we have a tag for self-promotion posts ? Like I entered here: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/wa1mci/my_starter_anime_list_under_60_episodes_and/ and expected a list. Instead there is a link to article.

If not tag then maybe bot could add a some kind of warning when he detects a link in post ?

3

u/Oppaipaisen Aug 03 '22

Since I don't see a thread for August, and this one is sticky.

Rename

To something more sensible as tableflip. Volibearq is stupid.

2

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Aug 03 '22

Can't really do that without breaking all its uses so far. Blame League for constantly redesigning its champions.

3

u/Oppaipaisen Aug 04 '22

It would be the same as a removed commentface. So I don't see the problem.

3

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Aug 04 '22

Yeah, and there haven't been any new comment faces for years precisely because that'd require removing old ones, aside from the seasonal set that was designed around that issue.

2

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Aug 05 '22

I KNOW there are comment faces with two names (please don't make me go looking for them)

7

u/DutchPeasant https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotJames Jul 04 '22

Also not fond of the banner, I'm not interested in getting disappointed with a contest once again.

5

u/punching_spaghetti https://myanimelist.net/profile/punch_spaghetti Jul 04 '22

Yeah; it would be one thing if it was connected to the writing club or WT!, but something that already has plenty of attention? Maybe not.

5

u/collapsedblock6 myanimelist.net/profile/collapsedblock Jul 04 '22

Those already have space in the sidebar. It would be odd to try to give another connection to those in the banner, which is meant to be more permanent usually.

5

u/punching_spaghetti https://myanimelist.net/profile/punch_spaghetti Jul 04 '22

It shouldn't be specifically those, but using the space to highlight something that doesn't get as many eyeballs would seem more useful to me.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/chilidirigible Jul 04 '22

If I were to lodge an objection to the banner beyond its aesthetics, it would be this one.

4

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jul 04 '22

I didn't even know it was the contest...

9

u/DutchPeasant https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotJames Jul 04 '22

If half of the top characters are from the last 5 years you best believe it's a contest.

12

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jul 04 '22

Having near irrelevant side characters from a popular show should have also been a giveaway.

5

u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jul 04 '22

Not to mention three of them from the same (recent) show

5

u/Ralon17 https://anilist.co/user/Ralon17 Jul 07 '22

Curious what you guys think about videos that are just filmed reactions to episodes or things along those lines. I believe according to the rules they're perfectly fine, but personally I feel like they're incredibly lazy content. Not saying it has to fall under low-effort since it does require actually recording yourself and uploading a video, which is multiple times slower than reposting a meme, but is there's much value to these? Is there anyone who really enjoys watching those (serious question, not rhetorical)?

7

u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Jul 07 '22

We actually talked about that a bit recently, I believe at the end we didn't consider they were such a big problem at the moment to ban them all.

Personally I do enjoy some reaction videos, I watch most of this girl's videos, I don't know, I just like seeing how other people react to shows or scenes I like.

3

u/bubudog1 Jul 09 '22

Reaction videos can be done well. I've watched this guy's Arcane series and he actually goes quite in-depth into his thoughts and analysis of the story.

6

u/10xkaioken Jul 03 '22

I really don't like manga readers already spoilering anime threads as soon as possible. Like someones topcomment is about a 4 seconds scene which has absolutely no sign, except you know what happens in 10 episodes later 🙄

4

u/Humg12 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Humg12 Jul 07 '22

Any chance you could ban complaints about Netflix in discussion threads? Any show released by netflix will have at least 2 of its top 5 comments on every thread just be complaining about Netflix jail and how that will affect the show's standing on the seasonal chart. The discussion has been done to death already, at this point it's just annoying.

2

u/WeeziMonkey https://myanimelist.net/profile/WeeziMonkey Jul 04 '22

There's no discussion thread for Tensei Kenja

→ More replies (2)

2

u/DocWatson42 Jul 06 '22

Greetings and felicitations. I noticed that r/animevhs is not on the wiki's list of related subreddits and would like to have it added, please.

2

u/GamingImperial501 Jul 13 '22

Why are Clip posts limited to 5 minutes at best? Why isn't it allowed to post longer clips?

16

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 13 '22

A couple years ago someone posted a K-On clip that was more than half an episode. The sub doesn't allow piracy (even though unofficial clips are still piracy) so a cap was put in place to prevent full episodes from getting posted.

2

u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Jul 16 '22

Neito's Sailor Moon rewatch had to be pushed back to next Friday the 22nd at the last minute. There was a scheduling conflict that happened. Hope to see you guys there! We probably will put out a reminder a couple days before!

2

u/blockyboi13 https://myanimelist.net/profile/AF_43 Jul 22 '22 edited Jul 22 '22

How do I get my flair up on this account. I went to the link, but it’s trying to put the flair on a different account of mine. So how do I fix this?

Edit: so now it’s recognizing the proper Reddit account but it won’t let me copy and paste the URL to my MAL profile. What do I do?

2

u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jul 24 '22

LL Superstar S2 ep thread

2

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 27 '22

Nothing for a while and then suddenly a bunch of things happening all at once.

2

u/feidothelemoneido Jul 29 '22

Where’s the new Casual Discussion thread?

2

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 29 '22

It lost its sticky position but it is alive and well here: https://redd.it/wapgjm

2

u/feidothelemoneido Jul 29 '22

Thank you so much!

3

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 29 '22

Also it's always linked in the sidebar on the right in the Megathreads section and under the Megathreads menu at the top of the subreddit.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Zictor42 Jul 04 '22

Should we have a more explicit rule of "not criticising people for liking show X"? It's really annoying to see people trying to skirt the civility rules with insinuations.

1

u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Jul 04 '22

If this is about Mushoku Tensei, I'm going to propose we just ban discussions of it entirely, because this subreddit loses its mind over it and it's exhausting.

6

u/Zictor42 Jul 04 '22

Well, it also happened recently with Bastard.

If you are talking about banning all the discussions about one anime because some haters cannot control themselves, you're actually giving them power. They'll be able to shadow ban any series by crowding the discussions. You also have the option of avoiding any posts about Mushoku Tensei.

I had several Mushoku Tensei posts that went perfectly fine. Just check my post history.

3

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 12 '22

Half-serious petition to ban discussion and mention of the actual title of Kaguya-sama movie as it is a spoiler.

3

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Aug 06 '22 edited Aug 06 '22

I just want to point out the objective fact that #fish was 174 out of 455 comment face usages in the last 3 months, which puts it in the upper 40% percentile, and it should have a graphical image to go with it.

and not any image, you know the one I mean

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '22

Do the seasonal comment face categories have to remain static with each new set?

8

u/Verzwei Jul 03 '22

I think part of the reasoning (or at least the desire) to keep them relatively static is so that they'll always work in the future. As long as the tags stay the same, then someone vising threads 3+ months old can still see some semi-related comment face, even if it's not the specific one the original user intended when the comment was made. Categories could theoretically be added as long as we have space (which, to my understanding, we kind of do not) but retiring a category would then break all the faces attached to it in old posts.

3

u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Jul 03 '22 edited Jul 03 '22

We have one animated one.

But yeah, due to limited space it pretty much just has to be static, this Shamiko one is an exception because it is just 2 images and badspler decided to just put the two suggested images together.

Edit: Wait, you mean the categories, I can read, you can always suggest some new ones, maybe we'll change them.

2

u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jul 03 '22

Are the mods going to put the Anime Questions, Recommendations, and Discussion thread underneath the Megathread? Or since it's going to be a daily thing, are you not going to bother? Which, would make sense. Since it's going to be a daily thing and therefore constantly pinned.

I was just curious/wondering about that.

3

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 22 '22

Update: it's done! Took longer than I wanted to for various reasons but the daily thread's there with the other megathreads now and should be updated not long after the new thread goes up every day (~15 minutes afterward because of how Reddit works with our current automation for it).

(Tagging /u/ZaphodBeebblebrox since you also asked about this before.)

3

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Jul 22 '22

2

u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jul 22 '22

2

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Jul 03 '22

2

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 04 '22

It's not impossible, I've just been unfortunately busy with other things and that's not currently a high priority because it is always stickied and relatively easy to access compared to other megathreads. Looking to maybe do it later this week.

(Tagging /u/NotSoSnarky for an updated answer.)

3

u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jul 04 '22

That's perfectly fine, I was just curious. Thanks for the answer.

2

u/RobotiSC https://anilist.co/user/Lonebot Jul 03 '22

I have to mention something that has been bugging me, especially considering the Mushoku Tensei situation that’s happening now.

Why are Crunchyroll trailers allowed in the sub? Most of them if not all are mostly English subbed versions of the original, they usually get released a few days or even weeks after the original, which can confuse people who might think it’s a new trailer, and worst of all, it’s region locked, so some users can’t even watch it. Most of the time Japan-locked trailers are never posted on the sub because no one can watch it outside Japan, so what’s the difference here other than a couple more people can watch it and that it’s subbed?

Thank you.

9

u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Jul 04 '22

Why wouldn't we allow subbed trailers to be posted here?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SnuggleMuffin42 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Animemes_chan Jul 05 '22

sub? Most of them if not all are mostly English subbed versions of the original, they usually get released a few days or even weeks after the original, which can confuse people who might think it’s a new trailer, and worst of all, it’s region locked, so some users can’t even watch

Region locking sucks, but other subs figured out a way around it - a bot that automatically creates a gify (or some other site) mirror of the post. Maybe for trailers you can set it up..

1

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 03 '22

Hey so I fixed it immediately, but I accidentally posted a broken spoiler tag in my comment on the not currently airing thread that didn't get automatically removed by Automod like anything with broken spoiler tags are supposed to be? Figured I'd mention it here so whoever's in charge of Automod could make sure it doesn't happen again.

Specifically, I forgot the first ! in the spoiler code, but I had everything else required for it.

2

u/Tarhalindur x2 Jul 04 '22

I think I remember having that exact same issue (down to the issue being the missing first "!") in either one of the Higurashi threads or one of the Gear threads, for the record.

1

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jul 05 '22

Oddly, I posted a comment with a broken spoiler tag today (the initial bracket was backwards) that I expected to see removed, and it wasn't.

Meanwhile, I tried to explain to somebody about a common failure mode for spoiler tags, leaving out the [] and the closing bracket, having just those two remaining characters and nothing else, and automod nuked it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Jul 15 '22

Did this episode discussion get posted by accident? It's a Fall 2021 show or is it bc the fansubs are coming out right now?

1

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jul 15 '22

Slow fansubs, yes.

1

u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Aug 02 '22

Does this thread count as news or rumour?

3

u/crobat3 https://myanimelist.net/profile/crobat3 Aug 02 '22

That's a tweet coming from a verified account of an ANN journalist, so it's reputable enough to be considered news.

1

u/BorrisChow Aug 06 '22

Does anyone know why I get the message "your reddit account does not meet the minimum requirement to vote" at the youpoll link when I try to rate episodes in the weekly discussion posts? I was able to vote fine until recently. I think someone said it was about minimum karma requirements, but I have ~3k, so I'm not sure if that is the case.

1

u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Aug 07 '22

The karma requirement is for comment karma, the karma you have is post karma, I don't think there is a way to make it so it is both.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Turbostrider27 Jul 03 '22 edited Jul 04 '22

A mod removed four threads I made today because apparently, the trailers and visuals were all in one article.

However, I've seen many times before where trailers and visuals were posted seperately as individual threads. This was never been a rule here before (excluding the recent changes about countdown, celebration visuals, etc)

The most recent example is from the Oshi no Ko topic where one thread was made a minute before the other and both contained the same info. Both threads were allowed to stay. Why is second thread not a duplicate?

Examples:

reddit.com/r/anime/comments/v8ipob/oshi_no_ko_anime_announced/ (first thread)

reddit.com/r/anime/comments/v8iqjt/oshi_no_ko_anime_teaser_visual/ (posted second, almost full minute later).

I legit don't understand why my topics are removed this way. The ones I'm referencing to are the Tomo-chan Is a Girl! and Solo Leveling.

Edit: it appears even if this was discussed before, the rule for this haven't been made to the sub rules thread.

By this logic of 'content restriction', it means that only ONE thread of an anime related news can only be posted because a Japanese or English news site would contain all those info (ex. visual, preview, cast, etc all within one article). There can be no second thread that exists based on how my topics were removed today.

Edit 2: I got a response back and it's the same reply about within an article and that 'rarely' happens. This is not true because Japanese articles are usually posted the same time when official site contents go up. Latest example is Mashle where it contains the PV and Key Visual within a single article.

5

u/notathrowaway75 https://myanimelist.net/profile/notathrowaway75 Jul 03 '22 edited Jul 04 '22

I would agree there shouldn't be multiple threads for the same show i.e. one for the key visual and one for the PV.

But different threads for multiple shows? Of course that should be allowed.

4

u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Jul 03 '22

I would be totally against restricting visuals because they are part of an article, there's even a discussion below about Key visuals as image posts only

Someone worked really hard on them, not the best idea being hidden in some post that people only read the title

→ More replies (8)

1

u/Lovro26 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lovro26 Jul 03 '22

I had a couple of post in the past removed for the same reason it usually only happens with CR article stuff and nothing else from what I have seen

→ More replies (7)

1

u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 03 '22

I guess it's because it was part of the initial discussion so that could've caused some confusion but I agree that it doesn't seem to have made it into the rule changes. Just speculation on my part though.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)