r/Debris • u/sanctuary_moon • May 11 '21
Debris - S01E11 Asalah - Episode Discussion
| Episode | Title | Directed by | Written by | Airdate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.11 | Asalah | Eagle Egilsson | J.H. Wyman & Ryan Wagner | May 10th, 2021 10/9c |
Episode synopsis: When a woman who has been affected by the Debris is found with knowledge of Bryan's past, he is forced to confront his trauma.
Past Episode Discussions
- 1.01 Pilot
- 1.02 You Are Not Alone
- 1.03 Solar Winds
- 1.04 In Universe
- 1.05 Earthshine
- 1.06 Supernova
- 1.07 You Can Call Her Caroline
- 1.08 Spaceman
- 1.09 Do You Know Icarus
- 1.10 I Am Icarus
Reminders
No piracy. Link requests and links to unauthorized distribution such as torrents/streaming sites will be removed.
Use spoiler mark up for any unique information about unaired episodes: >!Between these "brackets" resides a spoiler!< results in Between these "brackets" resides a spoiler
24
Upvotes
33
u/kyflyboy May 11 '21
That beard...right out of Costumes-R-Us. Whew.
20
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21 edited May 11 '21
wait hold up doesn't this mean that all of George's thoughts are in the debris's neural network? HOLD UP IS THIS WHY ANSON WAS CONNECTED TO FINOLA???? IS THIS ALSO WHY BRYAN AND FINOLA HAD A CONNECTION EVEN IN ALTERNATE REALITIES TOO?
18
u/usagizero May 11 '21
Not going to lie, i was both hoping and expecting them to explain the injections. Was a good back story episode for Bryan, and wtf that was at the end.
17
u/CupcakeCardinal May 11 '21
End credits audio:
Man: We have found Beneventi. Over. Repeat. We've found Agent Beneventi.
Woman: He's in a state of confusion. There's a laceration on his chin and a wound on his upper chest.
Man: What the hell happened to these men?
16
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21
ngl I felt a little bit disappointed with this episode because I felt like it wasn't revealing enough, but the more I think about it the more I realize that we actually got a ton of info. Damn, I really like this show!
16
u/SG14ever May 11 '21
"Brian Veneventi Brian Veneventi" - sounds like a starbucks order?
Next scene - spilt fofo coffee :-)
13
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21
HOLD UP was that a time line change with the files?
13
u/[deleted] May 11 '21
Not sure i like the idea of upping his injections.. Really hope we find out what he needs those injections for
12
u/mtm4440 May 11 '21
Why not shock her? Like shutting off the power to the house.
11
u/satanclauz May 11 '21
That's some Team America World Police level beard going on.
Maybe cut back on the music royalties next time.
11
u/usagizero May 11 '21
That seems why he looks up to Finola, she seems to have hope.
10
u/usagizero May 11 '21
Narrator: "He failed her." ;)
9
u/evirustheslaye May 11 '21
Those hazmat visors look like store bought clear storage containers cut in half
9
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21
Hooooooly shit Bryan looked so fucked up there lol
9
u/mtm4440 May 11 '21 edited May 11 '21
Getting like Inception up in here. Give him the kick! Play the music.
9
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21
weird. the new is bleeding into the old
9
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21
oh shit is this an alternate reality?
9
u/NorthernSparrow May 11 '21
Clearly this episode is not gonna be explained instantly. They’re setting something up. I bet it’ll lead to whatever this season’s finale is
9
u/gatemansgc May 11 '21
i wonder what the colored metals in directions are going to, if we're gonna know this season or have to pray the series gets a season 2.
8
u/gatemansgc May 11 '21
"once the conflict is over" rip
8
u/gatemansgc May 11 '21
the color of your phone only really matters if you're dumb enough to not keep it in a case
8
u/2_Fingers_of_Whiskey May 12 '21
This episode seemed like filler. It was obvious that the girl was going to die because Bryan was carrying around her picture, and she was talking about going to America and learning to play piano, etc. Anytime a show introduces a minor character and they start making happy future plans, you know they’re toast. We didn’t learn anything more about what George is doing, what Maddox knows, what the injections are, etc.
I was trying to be patient with this show but it’s getting more difficult...
8
u/ladygold9 May 12 '21
That fake beard though!
8
u/bkniceley May 13 '21
Didn’t see this mentioned but sure seems like the shock therapy wasn’t what got Bryan out. Looked like Maddox killed Muriel to disrupt their connection
7
u/evirustheslaye May 11 '21
Partners clearly unaware of America’s shit roads
7
u/NorthernSparrow May 11 '21
I can’t get over the director’s name: Eagle Egilsson!
7
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21
Benny???
7
u/gatemansgc May 11 '21
food for soul
7
u/gatemansgc May 11 '21
was not expecting elton john this episode. or at all
7
u/usagizero May 11 '21
Wonder how much this music cost them. lol
7
u/usagizero May 11 '21
That can't be good.
7
u/gatemansgc May 11 '21
reboot his brain O_O
7
u/usagizero May 11 '21
That sounded ominous.
6
u/daphydoods May 11 '21
Ugh I’m streaming and the sound is delayed so I’m hearing some girl from the voice singing
6
u/mtm4440 May 11 '21
This woman is going to recite conversations of his from the other universes?
6
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21
ooooh nice mirroring shot
11
u/ProfitPakistan May 11 '21
A show acknowledging that the US considers terrorist assets so it can further its war-profiteering agenda? Bold move. The powers that be won't let this get a 2nd season.
5
u/gatemansgc May 11 '21
here we go!
no flipping today either, it's an off day for the phillies!
5
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21
I forsee them
5
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21
could somebody turn the fucking music down please?
5
u/NorthernSparrow May 11 '21
ooo nice beard
5
u/gatemansgc May 11 '21
dafuq is going on
5
u/usagizero May 11 '21
Do we know if this is before or after the debris started to fall?
5
u/WilsonTree2112 May 11 '21
OMG, ERICA STRANGE!
5
u/KellyKeybored May 11 '21
Something that's been bothering me. Does Maddox know that Finola's father George is alive?
But Finola and Bryan went rogue, Bryan actually had to kill some of Maddox's team to save George. They took George to Garcia's garage in Oregon to hide. (But they didn't really show Finola or Bryan reporting back to their respective bosses, they just traveled to the next "case," the house by the ocean with the alternate realities.)
I think what confused me was the different alternate realities shown (in the previous two episodes), where George is alive in one timeline (and even working with Maddox I believe), but dead in another.
Maybe this is a subtle indication that we're not dealing with the proper (original) reality?
Bryan previously told Finola that Maddox "saved" his life, it certainly does seem that way. Whatever is in those injections seems to be keeping him alive (I wonder if Bryan died (much like George) and the debris resurrected him?).
5
u/SG14ever May 12 '21
It struck me as odd that when she first encounters Brian and team, she doesn't speak in english...
18
u/JakeFromSkateFarm May 11 '21
The use of a Native American to set up some sort of mystic / mythic / prehistory aspect is both a bit problematic in its own right (spiritual native / native spirituality as a prop for non-indigenous narratives and characters), and a bit too on the nose regarding The X-Files’ famous use of it.
Also a bit disappointing that the show used the deaths of two innocent women as props for the main male lead’s character development.
4
u/usagizero May 11 '21
Oh hey, that woman in the preview is Erin Karpluk, from Being Erica, which was a pretty fun Quantum Leap sort of show.
4
u/usagizero May 11 '21
Were all those debris pieces??
4
u/NorthernSparrow May 11 '21 edited May 11 '21
Bryan is rocking a Jensen Ackles’ Soldier-Boy-worthy beard
(link)
4
u/gatemansgc May 11 '21
he's not gonna end up safe ):
4
u/BigDingus04 May 11 '21 edited May 11 '21
I'm just watching it now, only half way through, but it seems apparent with how many times Asalah brings up needing her grandfather to be safe that he's going to die (and Brian is going to feel guilty about it).
I hope I'm wrong, but most shows that focus in on one thing so much are all but telling you what's going to happen :(
Edit: Well, guess I was off, but not in a better direction lol
4
u/OddSite0 May 12 '21 edited May 12 '21
I did some searching for native creation myths and I think I may have found something (This is a copy paste of I comment I made down below).
I think that the end scene may be inspired by the Jicarilla Apache creation myth and a creator figure named "Black Hactcin" (perhaps this is "Blackwater Grandfather". In these myths the cardinal directions and their colors are important symbols: east, black; south, blue; west, yellow; north, white (also described as verigated or glittering). I found a few of these myths mentioning Black Hactcin either planting seeds, or sending out rays of light, or building different colored ladders (In these creation myths humanity and all life lives in the dark below the earth). It looks like this show is using metal in place of this.
In one of the stories Black Hactcin caused an eclipse because the shamans thought they could control the newly created Sun. There might be something credible here?
here is the book that I read some of this from https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/text-idx?c=genpub;idno=AGY7794.0001.001
7
u/OddSite0 May 11 '21
Did he shoot Asalah or did she die in the crossfire?
6
u/SignalHorizonTracy1 May 11 '21
The Anasazi and Bryan’s past
3
u/OddSite0 May 14 '21
Actual footage of Bryan Beneventi investigating a new Debris location https://youtu.be/EHh5YhnfMEg
5
u/gatemansgc May 11 '21
okay, now to read u/SignalHorizonTracy1's review, see if she has any idea on what we learned from that episode.
2
u/OgOggilby May 12 '21
I missed what those injections are about. And what's going on with that guy with the weird eyes a few episodes back
2
u/DarkChen May 12 '21
The more i watch the more i feel like they are trying to recreate the lost/fringe feeling but are forgetting some crucial details or have no idea what made those shows great...
For one this generation is used to binge whatching which doesnt favor this mystery type narrative, only makes the plot look thin and shallow.
Also, both those shows, lost specially, used args(alternative, or augmented even, reality game) to supplement lore and increase interest in mysteries. It would fit like a glove here with the end of episodes transmissions and hidden messages and easter eggs, but probably because it has a somewhat costly price args ended up falling out of use.
Debris also doesnt appears to have a slimmer of hope in it. Not only it seems like there is always this gloom and doom feeling following the protagonists, solving a debri doesnt appear to give any answers, only more questions. With fringe, most of the time, you appeared to find a piece to help solve the bigger puzzle. Here, im not even sure we know what the bigger puzzle is... Is it the orbital's goals or is it what the aliens want or why the ship was destroyed?
Honestly, i hope the season doesnt end in a cliffhanger because i dont think it has much chance at renewal at all
2
u/_Wingless_Pegasus May 12 '21
Can someone explain the ending involving Arizona! I like this show but I am so confused!!
2
u/OddSite0 May 12 '21
This review brings forth some interesting implications that Bryan's trip down memory lane may not be all that it seemed.
https://www.tvfanatic.com/2021/05/debris-season-1-episode-11-review-asalah/
3
u/SG14ever May 11 '21 edited May 11 '21
For me, this was the most emotionally charged / gripping episode so far...
(and 3 episodes (s01e08_spaceman) ago was IMHO best overall so far)
2
u/releazethebeez May 11 '21
So the debris is just a Giant cloud? i-debris if you will
2
u/WouldChangeLater May 12 '21
Honestly, at first I was impressed that they found a way to fit a flashback into the narrative framework of the debris.
But dang it. It was frustrating and ended with me liking Bryan even less. After the arc with jumping to different realities, I was actually kind of excited. That ground the plot to a halt, but it was cool and mysterious. This was just not fun.
1
u/OddSite0 May 13 '21
I was looking at the IMBd page for this show because I was rewatching Spaceman and I wanted to see if Agent Sha (The dude Bryan shot in the face) was in any of the episodes. I found something really weird reguarding the cast list for episode 13, Celestial Body: Tucker and Steele aren't credited in it???? The fuck?!? Is this weird or am I just looking at incomplete data? Let me know what you guys think.
Edit: Also please remember to mark for potential spoilers even if it is just speculation!
-2
u/[deleted] May 13 '21
How very lame that the writers just went for stereotyped war vet for the whole Bryan backstory. And seriously how hard is it to find a glue-on beard that doesn't make Bryan look like a Yeti? But you know what really bothered me about this episode? Having Muriel sit on an office chair placed on a box
– is this is kid’s theater-? And then leaving her there for whole episode! Wow – Did no one think this through? Shouldn’t that spooky Debris infected person be the perfect time for big visual drama and effects? What the viewers get is a random woman seated on an office chair mumbling. Gee somehow that visual isn’t grabbing me.
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] May 11 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '21
[removed] — view removed comment