Hi all, this is as much an attempt to get my thoughts down on (virtual) paper, as it is to ask you all out there for advice and perspective. (Sorry that this is going to be over-written, that's just how I tend to process all the options). For a brief overview for those who don't want to read everything:
Sword and board option, using a rapier
- Also a list of questions relating to the build
- Board and board option, using shillelagh
- Sword and sword option
- Ending with considerations of other bonus actions available, that might be preferable for Build 1 over GWM: Hew
I'm now planning a new character for a campaign that'll go to 20. As I've recently played a character with a two handed weapon I'll avoid considering that as an option. From the RP side of things think Peter from Deadpool 2, so I'm going straight down the line as much as possible: human, sword and board, Champion.
Note, a lot of this discussion will be centring around play in Tiers 3 and 4, despite not having even started playing yet. This is because I think I've a decent handle on the lower tiers, and because we'd be playing by semi-AL rules, where I'd be able to respec to one of the alternate options based on opportunities that come up during play. So while I don't need to make any decisions for quite a while, I like thinking through build options, and to have some idea on what to aim for.
Damage isn't my priority (as tempting as that is to focus on, as raw numbers can be easier to quantify), but despite my best efforts I'll probably give it more weight than I want to throughout. Instead I intend for protection and support options to have a bit more of a focus. With all that, here's what I've landed on (to aim at, by level 20):
1. Sword and Board build
STR: 20, DEX 14, CON 18, INT 8, WIS 13, CHA 8
Fighting styles: Protection and Duelling
Weapon: Rapier. Mastery = Vex (or Push, Sap, or Slow)
Without magic items, AC = 20
Party: TBC, but looking to be paladin, ranger, and cleric
No multiclassing (self restriction this time round for RP purposes). Official materials only, no homebrew.
Feats:
Now I'm aware there's a lot that isn't optimal, or even has anti-synergy. But despite this, I feel that it offers good coverage on the following:
Party support:
- Reaction to give a party member within 5' disadvantage to be attacked
- STR 19 save once per turn to make enemy prone
- Enemy: Concentration Breaker (disadvantage spell concentration save)
- On a crit: hand out Heroic Inspiration to ally
- On initiative: spend Heroic Inspiration to give party advantage on the roll (slight waste for self, as I already have advantage on initiative)
Defence:
- Reaction: take no damage from a DEX save (if successful, on a save for half effect)
- Reaction: +6 AC against melee attacks
- Once per rest: turn a failed mental save into a success
- Indomitable x3: on a fail can reroll a save +20
- Boosted DEX saves, to better succeed on Interpose Shield (good for party fireball, or enemy dragon breath, etc)
- While bloodied, resistant to all but Force damage
- While bloodied, gain 9HP at start of each turn
- Bonus action: Second Wind
Damage:
- +2 damage to each attack
- Crits on 18-20 roll
- Good ol' Action Surge
- On a crit or on killing an enemy: can use a bonus action to make an extra attack
- Once per turn: Can reroll one damage die
- On a crit: add an extra damage die
- 1x advantage against enemy within 5', if they target ally
- Between Vex and hopefully making an enemy prone, lots of chances for advantage on attack rolls. After level 10, get Heroic Inspiration each turn, and level 13, on a miss get advantage on next attack, should be getting advantage and hitting most of the time
Disadvantages: +1 DEX from Defensive Duellist isn't terrible, but not ideal for a Strength build. Lack of Bonus Actions in general, and taking GWM purely for Hew is a poor option to try and correct that lack
And I'm aware this is an awful method to calculate damage but bear with it, this is just for a rough estimate:
If all attacks hit: 4x 1d8+7, plus ~2 (for piercer reroll) = 48
With a crit: 4x 1d8+7, +2, +bonus action attack and crit damage (1d8+7+2d8) = 68.5
Questions:
- Am I overrating having a dedicated bonus action for this build, even going so far as to pick up GWM just for Hew?
- Similarly, Defensive Duellist is probably higher on my list than it should be. Shield (spell) is just so good, that even a more limited version seems hard to pass on, but is it really worth it?
- Or for that matter, Shield + Duelling + Shield Master + Protection FS. They all work quite nicely together, that it seems like I'd be giving up an awful lot when I consider 2 weapon fighting. What circumstances would tip the scales to favour Dual Wielding over sword and board?
- Zhentarim Ruffian vs Purple Dragon Initiate: I've gone for the former, despite already having advantage on initiative (level 3: Remarkable Athlete). PDI gives out more Heroic Inspiration, but Lord's Alliance Agent partially covers that. Better party initiatives feels like the more impactful option - but is there a better origin feat I should consider picking up?
Piercing (+ vex, Piercer) vs Bludgeoning (+ topple, Crusher) or Slashing (+ sap, Slasher), is there a good reason to favour one of the latter over the former, with this particular build? (Might not be as much of a team player as I originally intended, but I feel if I'm likely to crit more often then Piercer will have more of an effect.
- Between Heroic Inspiration, Vex, SM bash, Studied Attacks, Protection, and Lord's Alliance: Reassert Honour, there's enough advantage and enemy disadvantage being given out, that there's no great need to double down on it, so then slightly more damage might be the better play).
- Resilient: DEX, Piercer, Defensive Duellist, and even Mage Slayer could all be done away with. Anything you'd pick instead of them for this build?
2. Board and Board (Shillelagh) build
With the above, that's all built with using only a rapier in mind (or dagger or shortsword I guess). I've no idea what magical items the campaign could bring, but sticking to just one weapon type would reduce flexibility to accept treasure as we come across it. So switching gears a little, tweaks could be made to freely switch to any other single handed weapon (Longsword, Battleaxe, etc).
Let's spec for what I'm considering as the best case scenario, Shillelagh + getting a magical staff. (And I'm aware that Shillelagh can be problematic with casting with a shield, will leave that to work out with DM, or on getting a Ruby of the War Mage as well). And by best case, I'm meaning an option that'll give a dedicated bonus action, better damage overall, and possibly "better" weapon mastery.
Will be giving up the feats: Zhentarim Ruffian (origin), Defensive Duellist, Great Weapon Master, Piercer.
Will be gaining:
Advantages of this build: Reliable bonus action attack; Limited spell casting (1 druid spell, plus assuming magic staff comes with spells); increased damage die; more damage overall; extra flexibility with feats or extra ASI; extra reaction options/crowd control; Crusher is usually my favoured of Slasher/Piercer/Crusher; optional: increase INT instead of WIS with MI:Druid, as no one in the party looks to be covering that stat, and then can pick up relevant skills to match
Disadvantages of this build: Shillelagh shenanigans: no guarantee of DM buy in (eg always have it cast, or of being able to use it with a shield without RotWM); less defence options in melee; multiple sources of making an enemy prone/advantage to hit; maybe slightly less sources of advantage until enemy goes prone (no vex); no advantage on initiative for party; maybe too many reaction options
Damage, if all attacks hit: 4x 2d6+7, + 1d4+7 = 65.5
Damage with one crit: 4x 2d6+7, +2d6, + 1d4+7 = 72.5 and all in the party have advantage on attacks against that enemy
3. Sword and Sword (Two weapon fighting) build
This is the one I'm least suited to assess. I feel like I'm missing something fundamental, I'm just not seeing what makes it attractive. (Will make edits if I have anything grievously wrong)
Will be giving up the feats/FS: Duelling, Protection, GWM, Shield Master, Resilient: DEX, Piercer (I'm assuming Scimitar now becomes the weapon/s of choice)
Will be gaining:
- Two Weapon Fighting FS (not necessary, but why not)
- Defence (or Blind Sight) FS
- STR -> DEX build (so better initiative, etc)
- Optional: Stagger and Sway (a new feat from the WoW book. Defer damage, and purge some of this on a bonus action)
- Two weapon fighting to me says to lean into damage, so let's pick up Fey Touched for a little more mobility (Misty Step) and 1x Hunter's Mark
- Then lastly flexibility to pick up: ASI = 2x WIS (for Stagger and Sway), Slasher, or Dual Wielder (BA competes with St&Sw, might be best to choose one over the other), Resilient: WIS
Assuming I've gone with St&Sw version, stats now look like:
STR: 8, DEX 20, CON 18, INT 8, WIS 18, CHA 8
Advantages: More attacks. More flexibility in feats, and stats, and maybe weapons. Dedicated Bonus Action with either DW or St&Sw. Get to use a new feat (always fun), for a damage reduction of 5 per hit (even without purging damage will be ahead, but if boosting WIS can purge 4d6 of incoming damage from the pool as a BA). Increased mobility with Misty Step.
Disadvantages: I must be doing something wrong, this looks to be less damage overall, except on rounds when Hunter's Mark is being used. This might change if weapons have damage riders (Vicious etc), or adding in a weapon with a 1d8 hit die for some of the attacks (DW). AC goes down to 19 (without even factoring in that Magic Shields are relatively easy to come by). No Protection, or pseudo Evasion (SM). Much less sources of advantage (no prone with topple weapon, no vex, no shield master prone)
Damage, if all attacks hit, with Nick: 5x 1d6+5 = 42.5
Or if going Nick + Dual Wielder: 6x 1d6+5 = 51
Damage with a crit, if all attacks hit, with Nick: 5x 1d6+5 + 1d6 = 46 + enemy has disadvantage on all attack rolls
Or if going Nick + BA from Dual Wielder: 6x 1d6+5 +1d6 = 54.5 + enemy has disadvantage on all attack rolls
Then with the once per day Hunter's Mark, damage increases by 17.5, or DW: 21, or on rounds with 1 crit, 21 or 24.5, for totals of 60, 72, 63.5, and 75.5 respectively.
I haven't factored in Action Surge for any of the above, but using it with Hunter's Mark would probably be the case for Dual Wielding pulling significantly ahead in damage.
Possibility: With a paladin and a ranger in the party, if a spell storing item came up, Hunter's Mark and Divine Favour might then be more readily available. Would that shift the balance enough to consider a dual wield build? Similarly, if a weapon becomes available with a damage rider, at what point (1d6? 2d6?) do the scales tip to make a 2 weapon build the better option?
Appendix 1: Bonus Action
In much of the above, especially with the first build, I've been looking for a good, reliable, bonus action. As nothing really stood out I've fallen back on GWM. (I'll have enough attacks, advantage, and crits on 18+, but still not enough to make it a strong choice). Huge thanks to this post for listing every BA now available.
Other options considered are:
- Weapon juggling (while still using a shield) for the BA attack: I don't like the visuals, and DM doesn't either - but I could push for it if I really wanted it
- Fey Touched feat: for once per day Misty Step and Hunter's Mark/Hex
- Durable feat: I should be durable enough already, extra healing seems like overkill
- Observant feat: study action each turn could be intriguing, but I just can't see it being all that worth it
- Potion guzzling: Needs no feat/stat/action investment, so with plenty of gold, why not? Potion miscibility is also nothing I've encountered before, let's go gambling!
- Polearm Master feat: as mentioned in Shillelagh build
- Telekinetic feat: shove is nice to have.