I know I am very very late to the party on this one, but I had been meaning to watch it all year.
I thoroughly enjoyed it but the final scene in the diner is making me lose my mind a little bit. I was reading discussions on here and didnāt see anyone talking about what Iām seeing. I might be way off and overthinking on this, or maybe this was plainly obvious and I missed it somewhere (iām also slightly stoned) but I would love to get it out and poke your brains even if it gets torn to shreds.
First of all, I donāt buy the whole āits all in their headsā read of the movie. I think thats a boring cop out and the movie is exploring a much more intricate and complex themes (how we look at peopleās own dirty laundry and shameful actions, compare them to our own, radical empathy)
The movie does however have plenty of moments where we are darting quickly between the reactions that the characters are hoping for when it comes to their āworst thingsā being addressed or discussed vs the more repulsed and judgemental responses that the movie often stays in.
So while acknowledging that there is that aspect, I think that when Emma walks into the diner, they are implying or at the very least heavily leaning into Charlieās inner monologue that she might have a gun.
When she walks into the diner, the song that starts playing (The Wind by Nolan Strong and the Diablos) goes like this:
I know she has gone but my love lingers on
In a dream that the wind brings to me
This might be a stretch, but I watched it back and the song almost sounds āI know she has a gunā.
As she walks up to the counter, she seems to quickly order, taking her hand out of her left pocket and mumbling quickly, grabbing her order number and the glass of water. after playing it back it almost sounds like she is saying āIāve got a gun.ā
As she sits down at the table, you see her left pocket and it seems like she may have SOMETHING in there. It doesnāt really necessarily resemble a gun but I could see it.
Obviously Charlie is shaken and crying but it reads much more like fear in the build up.
I do think he fell deeper in love with her after learning about her secret, and his manic actions (the SA, the weird interaction with Rachelās cousin) are a reaction to him struggling with the judgement that may come with continuing to love Emma while knowing that he may never actually know if she has really changed from her high school days. That doubt will never fully go away.
I like to think that they still end up together and love each other forever happily ever after lalala. the final scene made me really sad, but it was beautiful. I donāt want to think that she kills him after the credits roll, but the director did a great job of letting that doubt stick with you.
TL;DR she might have had a gun, he might have just been making it up, I might just be making it up. Please discuss this movie with me, not just the ending