r/ATT • u/bobbyrayidk • 20h ago
Billing Switched to AT&T after being promised a lower bill. Now I'm paying significantly more and feel trapped by their trade-in promotion. What are my options?
About a month ago, I switched three lines from T-Mobile to AT&T, and I'm wondering if anyone has experienced something similar or has advice on how to handle this.
I was previously paying $120/month total for three unlimited lines with T-Mobile. I was also wanting to upgrade to the iPhone 18 Pro Max, which T-Mobile was offering me for an additional $18/month with my trade-in. So my total would have been approximately $138/month.
I went into an AT&T store because I was having some service issues with T-Mobile at my house anyways and figured if I can get some better service at home and pay less money it was worth the hassle of switching. I explained my situation to the salesperson and made it VERY clear that I would only consider switching if AT&T could beat the $138/month I would have been paying with T-Mobile, including the new phone.
The salesperson sat down with me and with the current promotions discounts, etc, I believe the figure quoted was around $134/month. I agreed to switch all three lines and traded in my iPhone 14 Pro Max for a promotional credit of approximately $1,200 toward the new phone, spread over 36 months. I paid the taxes on the phone right then and there and left the store.
Fast forward to my first bill yesterday and it's $406.94.
I understand that first bills can be higher due to prorated charges, but what really surprised me was the over $100 in activation fees that were never disclosed to me during the sales process.
After reviewing the bill and accounting for the expected $1,200 trade-in promotion, and other discounts my recurring monthly bill appeared to still be way too high. So I went into the store and they told me my actual total is around $175 a month. They’re claiming the price they gave me didn’t include taxes and fees and that’s the reason for the discrepancy. The manager told me they don’t include that in the price because they can’t predict how much they’ll be but T Mobile had no issues giving me the price of $120 including taxes and fees and I made it clear I needed to be cheaper so clearly the sales rep intentionally lead me to believe that $134 price was the ALL IN price.
The manager basically told me there was nothing he could do he won’t lower my bill or reverse the transaction. He also tells me I owe them $1250 for the phone if i leave my plan with them even though they took my iPhone 14 Pro Max and said I can’t have that back either.
Essentially, I feel like I was convinced to switch based on pricing that wasn't accurate, surrendered my old phone as part of that agreement, and am now financially stuck with a substantially more expensive plan and have come out of pocket way more money over this first month than I would have had I just stayed put.
What is my recourse? I saw to report to AG of my state, the fcc, and to fill out the ATT notice of dispute, but I’m just not sure how much that will really help.
I genuinely feel like I was stolen from.
