r/Akane • u/Key_Photograph_7529 • 4h ago
Is Akane actually falling down the wrong path, or are the readers (and the other characters) simply overthinking things?
This will be my last post about this development (since we’ll know more in this week’s chapter), but I’ve been looking at readers’ reactions, both in Japan and internationally, and I’ve noticed that the majority of people (ESPECIALLY in Japan) seem to think that Akane is losing her way, that she needs to be corrected by her friends and ani-sans, and that she’s being influenced by the big bad, Issho. They believe that her friends and older brothers need to bring her back to the right path. That is, until I came across a comment from a Japanese reader that said something like this:
As for Akane - Banashi, to be honest, I don’t really get the idea that she’s “putting too much pressure on herself” right now, and since I don’t get it, I don’t understand what’s wrong with her “putting too much pressure on herself” in her current situation. Isn’t that fine? She’s just throwing herself into the art she’s aiming for.
And even if she were to part ways with the Shiguma faction for a while, that’s fine in its own way (though, to be honest, that aspect hasn’t really been explored in depth anyway).
That was the moment I started wondering whether Akane is actually going through her supposed dark arc, or whether we're just reading too much into everything.
Suenaga-sensei has always been incredibly good at subverting readers' expectations and introducing plot developments that nobody sees coming (but which, in retrospect, have actually been very carefully foreshadowed). Just look at the whole Shinta expulsion incident or Issho's challenge to Akane to perform without making the audience laugh in a comedy competition.
Akane Banashi has always been told through Akane's subjective first-person perspective. Her inner thoughts are made explicitly clear to readers, and every arc begins from her POV. However, in this arc, the narrative has shifted to a third-person perspective, opening with other characters' POVs as they talk about her, while Akane's inner thoughts are completely concealed from us. In other words, we're seeing Akane's situation through the subjective perspectives of other characters, while her actual intentions behind distancing herself from everyone and deciding not to return to the Shiguma school remain entirely hidden from the readers.
I can't help feeling that readers' opinions are being influenced by how the other characters perceive Akane. Most readers seem to believe that Akane is becoming corrupted under Issho's influence and needs to be brought back to her senses, or even rescued by her anisans and friends. And that's largely because the characters themselves seem to view Akane as this sunshine, happy-go-lucky tanuki, the typical shounen protagonist who's always cheerful and a little dorky. She simply can't be acting like this. She must have lost her way and gone too far. Her anisans need to come and save her, set her straight, and bring her back to the path she was originally supposed to follow. She's fallen into Issho's hands! She doesn't know what she's doing! Blah, blah, blah...
It's not that I think Akane isn't allowed to be vulnerable or that she shouldn't need help from her friends. But I feel that, despite their good intentions, the other characters are seriously underestimating her resilience and determination. She understands perfectly well what pursuing her art entails and what sacrifices it demands. According to the actual storyline, Akane has simply been extremely busy with work for twenty days and hasn't had the time to contact her friends. Yet everyone is acting as though she's deliberately cut herself off from the entire world.
Besides, Akane has already been through much worse. She spent THREE YEARS in France without her friends or family around, and somehow still managed to perform rakugo for audiences who didn't even speak Japanese, despite rakugo being such a niche art form even in Japan. Nobody reached out to her, nobody was there to help her, and yet she managed to make it work. Compare that to the current situation, where she's simply overwhelmed with work for twenty , and everyone is acting as though she's completely abandoned all her relationships.
Honestly, Akane has grown so much. She's already an adult woman and a futatsume, yet people are still treating like when she was a zenza
As for the idea she is consumed by rakugo and should learn the same lesson her father did — "It's just rakugo" — I don't entirely agree with that interpretation either. Akane and her father have fundamentally different personalities. Her father loves rakugo, but ultimately sees it as a job. Akane, on the other hand, loves rakugo and is completely devoted to it. To me, her relationship with rakugo is more like that of an artist who is deeply passionate, almost obsessively so, about their craft. Rakugo is the only thing that truly fulfils her. And honestly, she's always been a little crazy in that regard.
That's precisely why her parents never tried to stop her from pursuing rakugo, even though they weren't entirely comfortable with her decision. They respected her choice, and they knew that trying to stop her would ultimately be futile. Akane has always been someone who puts her art above almost everything else.
So when people say she's becoming corrupted or turning into Issho, I can't help thinking that, if anything, Akane is still herself. And even if she fails, I think it would be much better for her to learn from that failure and pick herself back up on her own, rather than having the elders make decision for her.
And here's another unpopular opinion: I really don't like the way Karashi and Hikaru have been behaving in this arc. I've never been particularly invested in either of them, but this arc has only reinforced my existing dislike.
Karashi took it upon himself to inform Taison about Akane so that Guriko could approach her, even though Akane had explicitly asked him to leave her alone beforehand. She had even thanked him for it. Sure, he might have had good intentions, but he still chose to disregard her wishes.
As for Hikaru, I really don't like how she keeps spamming Akane's phone with an endless stream of messages. Akane might not be responding to her, but that doesn't mean she has to keep doing that. I honestly don't find it cute at all. I've never been a fan of Hikaru's clingy antics in the first place.
The dynamic between the two of them and Akane has always given me the impression of a parasocial relationship between fans (Hikaru and Karashi) and their idol (Akane). They behave like her personal hype squad, constantly acting as though they're incredibly close to her and understand her so well, when Akane herself doesn't seem particularly invested in either of them.
Calling them Akane's friends doesn't really feel accurate to me, considering the three of them have only had a handful of actual conversations, and Akane spent three years in France without keeping in touch with either of them. Calling them her rivals would be even more inaccurate, since they've never really been on the same level as her.





