r/AncestryDNA • u/dilfybro • 6h ago
Results - DNA Origins Heart just breaking, from having to inform a 2nd cousin that she is not her documented father's biological daughter
I recently led an online family discussion about a family patriarch/matriarch history (both born 150 years ago); attendance was high - close to 25-30 people came. It felt great to share the family history information I'd accumulated.
Near the end, I asked for anyone who was in contact with certain 2nd generation family members who already had AncestryDNA profiles, to please contact me afterwards; I'd love to be able to use their results, with my own, for further research.
Soon after, I heard from one of the daughters of such, my 2nd cousin. She is in mid-life, and in her first email, she sent me "Viewer" access to her own AncestryDNA profile. Which, I hadn't asked for, but it was kind. She said she hoped this was useful, until she was able to get ahold of her father's AncestryDNA profile for me. I had already matched with her father, so I was stoked. She mentioned in her email that the health of her elderly father was in rapid decline.
I looked at her matches, and my mouth dropped. Her father was not on her list. She had made no indication that she knew this - let alone what it meant - even though she knew that I was seeking her father's AncestryDNA profile. I studied it; indeed, none of the ~20 of our common family with AncestryDNA profiles (which I see on my own match list) appear on her match list.
Her father, was not her biological father. And she apparently did not know this.
How did this happen? I checked her family history. Her documented father and mother had married, and 2 years later filed for divorce. More than one year after that - so more than a year after the divorce filing - she was born. And a year after that, the divorce was filed.
How could it be, that she sends me her AncestryDNA match list, if she knows that she is not her father's biological daughter? It would obviously be of no use to me, since we would have no common matches. It must be, that even though she has her match list, she has no idea that she is not her father's biological daughter.
She told me, when we got on video chat, that her parents had a tumultuous, on and off relationship. And, in fact, at the court hearing, her father insisted on full custody of her. The judge insisted that full custody would be granted to only one party, and the other party would have no visitation rights, through to her adulthood. Her paternal grandparents testified, "No way will we consent to not seeing our granddaughter until she's 18." Her father was granted full custody; and she was raised, first primarily by her paternal grandparents, and then by her father, and his second (and then third) wives. She has seen her mother only a few times during her life, and doesn't now know if her mother is still living.
So I made sure she was alone in the room, and I gently tried to break it to her. "You father, he appears on my match list. But I don't see him on your match list." Silence. "Oh? Well, that's weird." "Yes, and none of our other relatives who are on my match list appear on your match list." "Huh. Yeah, I hadn't really noticed that." "Look, I think the implication might be that [your documented father] is not your biological father."
She hardly missed a beat "Well, okay. Though what matters is who raised you." She was so upbeat about it.
In fact, I had already run the Leeds analysis on her match list, and identified the family her biological father came from; made up a list of all the candidates - documented men in a very wide age bracket. I knew that of the candidates, all of them lived thousands of miles away from her mother; except one, who was in the military, and was documented to be near where her mother lived at the time.
She said, moments later, "I don't think my dad needs to know about this. He won't be with us much longer, he's not well." I assured her that I regard this information as hers, her own deeply personal property, and that I would not be sharing it with anyone else.