11/12/26 EDIT UPDATE: Well it looks like Abby quietly removed the AI art for sale on her website that was listed as “handmade”. This is a good start, and I am guessing she has seen this post, but still hasn’t commented on it. There is still clothing listed that has AI generated prints, but they are no longer listed in her drawing/paintings section. The AI art that was listed is still on her instagram page.
10/28/26 EDIT UPDATE: More than 20 people have come forward in this thread with many complaints about orders made with Abby. These complaints range from 15+ years ago, to very recently.
They include:
-Outright nondelivery
-Not giving refunds for orders never received.
-Ghosting people asking about their order
-Responding to inquiries about orders disrespectfully and unprofessionally
-Dishonesty about the status of the order
-Delays lasting years
-Items being delivered with major issues or not as described
These reports are detailed in the comments and I encourage you to look through them before commenting about us "not having a life" or "virtue signaling." Taking advantage of dozens of fans supporting your work is NOT something we should brush off or ignore. This is a clear pattern of dishonesty.
Throwaway account for privacy.
I just want to start by saying I know this is a very hotly debated topic amongst fans. All I ask is everyone take a step back and look at the evidence below without bias.
Yes, I am aware that Abby has denied using AI for visuals for the Feels shows. I and several other fans do not think this is the case. I also believe her use of AI goes far beyond these visuals and is often deceptive. If you click through the LA visuals post, you will see what other fans have figured out.
Lets start with the Feels shows. The visuals for "Must Be Treeman" I think most people could clearly identify as being AI generated. When the photo is run through SynthID, (which looks for invisible watermarks created to help people identify AI generated content) it identifies it as AI generated. images of those here. So let's say she used a few AI assets here and there for the visuals. Maybe they were provided to her by someone else? Or maybe she forgot? I do not think so.
I noticed she used AI generated posters for workshops on her page, so I started downloading some of her recent animated videos on instagram. They struck me as a little off, and not matching the imperfect, handcrafted style im used to seeing from her, and had some inconsistencies with shapes. shadows, borders, etc. I also ran them through SynthID, and every single one came back as AI generated. images of those are here Definitely not a good look to be selling courses on animation, stop motion, etc, and then use AI to create it for you while implying that you made it by hand.
I became pretty concerned and started checking out her website. If you look at the artwork she has for sale, especially all of the recent collages, they all appear to be AI generated- just look at the guitars, the tuners, the strings, some of the details- there are tons of AI artifacts throughout. Some of these can be seen here. All of the ones I ran through SynthID also came back as AI generated. To double check, I also ran through some of her older artwork listed on her website, and those did not come back as AI generated.
The worst part? She is selling clearly AI generated artwork for $160-$200, and claiming they are made by hand...
Many have (likely AI generated) descriptions claiming it to be hand crafted, like: "This 12x12 artwork is meticulously crafted from cut-out paper, all handmade and signed by me." and "Perfect for collectors and fans of unique, handmade illustrations that bring a festive edge to your art collection." and "12x12 cut-out paper and felt made by hand" I also believe this is why she no longer sells on Etsy, because they actively crack down on people selling AI generated artwork.
This is not okay. It is one thing to use AI in your work. It's another to be dishonest about it.
And it's a WHOLE other thing to sell something as handmade or crafted when it very clearly is generated using AI.
Unfortunately, if you do a little searching on the subreddit, you will also find posts of people complaining about how Abby goes about selling her artwork. These posts range from months ago to years ago, so it seems to be a pretty consistent pattern of ghosting paying customers without delivering them the art they paid for. Here is one example from a few months ago, and another example from 4 years ago. I know this alone is fairly common for small artists selling through instagram, but when looked at in the context of all of this, it seems like further evidence of deceptive practices when selling artwork to fans.
I have been a huge fan of Abby's work for many years, and have always admired and identified with the hand-made crafty aesthetic she is known for. While I was initially disappointed by her use of AI in the visuals, and her being dishonest about it, I was willing to let it go and definitely would not have posted about it. Unfortunately it seems to extend to AI artwork she is selling as handmade, or hand crafted for $160-$200 when it clearly is not. This is wrong on so many levels, and we should not be okay with being taken advantage of or lied to.