Hi everyone!
The new (and pretty great) FSRS post by u/ClarityInMadness got me thinking of something: can there be underlying differences in the way people remember different "kinds" of knowleage (ie. language vs. medical knowleadge for example) that are not accounted for and lead to systematic underperformance in scheduling systems?
The parameters of the scheduler change depending on your desidered retention, grading, etc. and I'm by no means am I an expert on the mathematics and statistics behind it. Certainly, the difficulty, stability and retention (and other) parameters in FSRS can help to tailor reviews to the desired retention. However, are these parameters enough to blindly infer the necessary info for scheduling, without needing to "know" the kind of information in a card?
In med decks like anking we have very different kinds of memory tests (Paired association, Causal knowledge, Procedural knowledge, Clinical reasoning) than in a language vocabulary deck. Yet, the same parameters apply. The systems we have today have historically been developed for language learning (a bit use of anki when it was launched), yet today we have a very heterodox learning enviroment. I wonder how much the data used to empiracaly develop schduling algos based on language learning is applicable to medical cards, for example.
Still, I'm open to discussion and this really is just more of a shower thought I've been having as I read more about FSRS. I have found an interesting article that examined this question (Sense et. al, 2016) and the authors found rates of forgetting were different in different areas of study, even though they were constant through time. This part of the discussion really encapsulates my question fairly well:
"Most models that assume memories are encoded as traces assume that all traces are treated equally when it comes to learning and forgetting. The models propose certain rules under which traces are encoded, retrieved, and maintained, but those rules usually apply regardless of the type of declarative fact material or the context."
Would love to hear your thoughts!