First, they tell you that you aren’t up to the task; then, they take away the very conditions that would have enabled you to succeed; finally, they turn around and say, "See? You really aren't up to it."
This playbook has been used on women, on the poor, and on colonized peoples. Now, it’s the children’s turn.
In the 19th century, European intellectuals claimed that a woman’s uterus controlled her brain—rendering her irrational and unfit to vote or engage in various other activities. They eventually admitted they were wrong; the uterus does not control the brain.
And today? The narrative has shifted, but the underlying logic remains the same: an underdeveloped brain supposedly controls a child, making them irrational. Consequently, children are deemed incapable of deciding whether to get a pet, choosing between school and work, or engaging with the realities of life.
Do you see the pattern? First, they define you as someone who lacks the capacity for independent thought; then, they strip away the conditions that would allow you to form such thoughts; finally, they point back to your state as "proof" that you truly lack the capacity to think for yourself.
This is exactly what was done to women: by asking, "You’re just a woman—what could you possibly think?" they pressured women into suppressing their own ideas. Then, "scientists" would chime in: "See? They have no ideas of their own; they can’t survive without men."
The same thing is happening to children today. Parents say, "Just get into university first," and schools insist, "Your future is all about getting into university." Children stop daring to have their own ideas—and then adults conclude, "Look, children are just irrational."
This isn’t science; it’s circular reasoning. Science can tell us that "developmental differences exist," but it cannot dictate that "therefore, your right to choose should be stripped away." Jumping from "there are differences" to "you aren't fit to make your own decisions" is a political choice, not a scientific conclusion.
At 14, I started a company. I needed a bank account to receive payments, and a credit card to build a credit history. I learned English to understand letters from the IRS, and I studied mathematics to manage my accounting ledgers.
No one forced me; the needs were thrust upon me, and I had to learn.
Learning isn't about attending classes before you start living; it’s about learning what you need, when you need it. The fundamental flaw of the school system is that it decouples learning from application—and then blames the students for lacking motivation.
One final point:
I am not advocating for children to do whatever they please. My philosophy is this: pave the way, ensure a safety net is in place, and then return the power of choice to the child. Don’t use "you’re being irrational" as a shield—open the door and let them go out and bump into things.
And so, I ask those intellectuals: if you truly wish to protect children, please stop projecting your own perverse desire for control onto them. please.