https://www.woroni.com.au/news/regulator-says-anu-council-was-not-competent/
19.11.2026 by Kuba Meikle
A few weeks ago, the Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency (TEQSA) tabled a detailed Statement of Reasons in relation to the conditions imposed upon ANU in early September, which revealed damning findings against the culture and processes of ANU Council, the University’s governing body.
TEQSA found an alarming “lack of debate and discussion around the decisions made by the ANU Council”. The regulatory found that Council was not appropriately informed about, nor did it sufficiently question, matters including oversight of the Nous Group consultants employed to design Renew ANU, the then Vice-Chancellor Genevieve Bell’s employment with Intel, the composition and decisions of the Council’s Nominations Committee, or decisions to reduce ANU’s overall student headcount between 2018 and 2023. In particular, TEQSA found that Council approved the $250 million cost-cutting target of Renew ANU without discussing “the basis upon which that figure had been reached, or consideration given to how that target would impact the university's staff, students, or overall operations”.
The regulator highlighted that Council Standing Orders were purposefully used to curtail discussion. For example, the Chancellor enforced rules that limited the number of times a Council member could speak to a matter, which stifled back-and-forth discussions and effective scrutiny. TEQSA also found that minutes did not capture “dissenting views or the substance of the discussion” as it either did not happen or was purposefully omitted from the record. Finally, the reasons lambast the Council’s failure to adopt an organisation-wide strategy between June 2024 and July 2026. According to TEQSA, this lack of long-term strategic vision prevented Council from making well-reasoned and informed decisions. Ultimately, the lack of due diligence exercised by ANU Council led TEQSA to find that the ANU Council was dysfunctional and failed to exercise “competent governance oversight”.
The regulator also took aim at the knowledge and background of Council members. TEQSA found that few Council members, especially elected representatives, attend optional training provided by the Australian Institute of Company Directors. This led to “a poor understanding amongst ANU Council members as to their role and responsibilities on the Council” which may have contributed to flawed decision-making. TEQSA also questioned the backgrounds of appointed Council members, finding that the vast majority had finance and banking, rather than higher education or public service backgrounds. The regulator expressed concerns that this homogeneity may have led to “group think”, warning that ANU should increase the diversity of its Council appointments.
Finally, TEQSA criticised Geneveive Bell’s Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). These were set by then Chancellor Julie Bishop as: “Successful onboarding to the VC role”, "Rationalise the OVC and its work practices", "Undertake Exec Renewal", "Complete ‘learning journey’ for the VC", and "Identify key challenges, and measurable relative change state metrics by EOY". The regulator questioned how the Indicators were linked to ANU’s strategic objectives and how unmeasurable targets like a “learning journey” were meant to be assessed. TEQSA also found KPI completion was evaluated through a self-assessment completed by Bell which was then signed off by the Remuneration Committee. Furthermore, the KPIs and their evaluation were not presented to or considered by ANU Council, preventing the body from effectively scrutinising Bell’s performance.
To some extent, the report confirms a lot of what people already knew or suspected. However, the final and most devastating blow to the university comes in the statement’s conclusion. The regulator says it does not believe ANU’s claim that the failures were because of a temporary lapse of judgment or the particular individuals on ANU Council at the time – rather, the issues are “serious, systemic failures” which were enabled by ANU's institutional governance practices.
TEQSA says that while it recognises ANU is already voluntarily addressing some deficiencies, this has only occurred after extensive and concerted public scrutiny and regulatory intervention. TEQSA also finds that the university's voluntary actions have not gone far enough and that without the imposition of the conditions, it fears that ANU would engage in similar behaviour in the future.