r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

AskALiberal Biweekly General Chat

1 Upvotes

This Tuesday weekly thread is for general chat, whether you want to talk politics or not, anything goes. Also feel free to ask the mods questions below. As usual, please follow the rules.


r/AskALiberal • • 5d ago

Megathread: Senate Leadership Challenge

55 Upvotes

Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Maryland) said Thursday that he is challenging Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-New York) to be majority leader in the next Congress.

All discussions of the Democratic Senate Leadership should be held here.

https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/sen-chris-van-hollen-says-will-challenge-sen-chuck-schumer-majority-le-rcna609100


r/AskALiberal • • 15h ago

Liberals have impressively dominated the main artistic/creative cultural media domains in the 21st century: Books, Films, TV, etc with the exception of one: Podcasts - why do you think liberals took such a beating in this space?

14 Upvotes

It seems bizarre in retrospect that this occurred - if you transported me back to the early noughties I would have been absolutely convinced liberals would dominate it with so many intelligent and articulate public intellectuals etc.

Yet instead the podcast space is dominated by the likes of Joe Rogan, Steven Bartlett and Tucker Carlson all being in the top 10 most listened to podcasts - how did this happen? It's obviously more complex than MAGA/cancel culture etc - how did liberal figureheads fail to become the juggernauts of the podcasting space?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Would you support David Lisnard over Le Pen and Melenchon?

9 Upvotes

David Lisnard is a center-right politician described as “the French Milei” for his libertarian/neoliberal stance on economics, including advocating for austerity. Betting markets currently place him second in the election, behind only Le Pen. On foreign policy, he is pro-EU, pro-NATO, and supports Ukraine.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

How Should Democrats Address the Educational Challenges Facing Boys and Men (e.g., academic underachievement, declining male college enrollment, and the underrepresentation of men in teaching)?

7 Upvotes

I do not really think expanding the amount of financial aid would be sufficient to address the specific educational challenges that boys and men face. Honestly, I think the problems starts way earlier.

By K-12, you already have boys falling behind in stuff like reading, grades, graduation rates, etc. For example, you have the U.S. Department of Education saying that boys constantly underperform when it comes to reading and young men being more likely to leave high school without finishing. So by the time you already have them applying to college, these issues are already sort of baked in.

You can blame it on parenting, but that is not really solving the problem at all. You would essentially be throwing your hands up and saying whatever (unless your proposal is to take these boys away from their parents and have some sort of military school raise them or that Democrats can somehow magically force parents to raise their boys differently). It would also be confirming the assertions of young men and others on the right that Democrats do not really care about helping men and boys.

I'm more interested in what Democrats could do to address the underlying causes. For example, should there be greater investment in early academic intervention, efforts to recruit more male teachers and mentors, or reforms to how schools engage boys academically?

And in general, how do you make education and academia something that boys and men feel motivated to want to do well in?

I am curious what sorts of evidence-based policies exist for helping men and boys here.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

With the average U.S. senator approaching 64 years old and the average House member nearly 58, is our aging Congress equipped to understand and effectively regulate artificial intelligence (AI), cybersecurity, and increasingly complex technology?

6 Upvotes

Given the recent National Security Agency (NSA) classified network outage, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) nationwide ground stop, and reported banking disruptions, all within the past week, do our elected representatives possess the technical knowledge necessary to oversee these systems, distinguish cyberattacks from technical failures, and develop legislation addressing the rapidly evolving risks of AI?

https://wpde.com/news/nation-world/nsas-national-security-agency-classified-internal-network-is-down-sources-say-no-evidence-cyberattack-communications

https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/online-outages-hit-banks-including-195009081.html?fr=sycsrp_catchall

https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/caused-national-ground-stop-know-030533886.html?fr=sycsrp_catchall

Edit:

Republicans eliminated funding for the Office of Technology Assessment in 1995, but Democrats had multiple opportunities to restore it and never succeeded. The Democratic House even proposed $6 million to reopen it in 2019, but the funding was removed from the final legislation.

With artificial intelligence, cybersecurity, and critical infrastructure becoming increasingly complex, why has restoring independent technical expertise in Congress remained such a low priority?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Idea: Dems first bill is entitled “The Trump’s Best Ideas” bill. What would you include?

5 Upvotes

So there are some things that Donald Trump has proposed that are actually not bad ideas. I

wonder if Democrats could put together a bill that takes those best ideas.

Like capping credit card interest rates at 10% vanning private equity for owning homes.

He is super vain and not terribly bright. I think he might go for it and it might actually grace the wheels on getting done the stuff we really care about.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

What are the chances of the next court being a Liberal majority?

5 Upvotes

Thought?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has announced a plan to disband the NYPD's riot control unit, and will establish a civilian team to respond to protests instead. What are your thoughts on this?

63 Upvotes

Link to article on it:

As of now the plan appears to ultimately be for a group of non-police civilians ie social workers to be the first responders on the scene for mass demonstrations and protests. They will be unarmed and will seek to verbally de-escalate hostile situations among the crowds. If violence breaks out or continues and these civilian groups assess physical intervention is needed, then they will call the police who will come in but be barred from using pepper spray, noise horns, have guns on the scene and more.

The initiative fulfills a campaign promise Mamdani made, and goes to the heart of progressive demands for policing to be re-imagined as an institution following the George Floyd protests in 2020.


r/AskALiberal • • 8h ago

Has Mangioni done anything to improve the outlook for better healthcare in the US or has he wasted his life?

0 Upvotes

Thoughts?


r/AskALiberal • • 8h ago

Why is it not considered racist for White people to be against dating particular races, but is "internalized racism" if minorities aren't interested in their own race?

0 Upvotes

IMO both can be racism.

The "people like to date their same culture" excuse doesn't really hold up, since it's already racist to assume someone who's of a different race must have particular cultural views, upbringing etc. For all you know, someone of a different race has more in common with you in terms of values, upbringing and interests than someone of your own race (if you spend time on online interest communities, you quickly find that people befriend and have lots in common with those of other races, because online colour can't be seen).

Seeing another race as a monolith, or having higher requirements for them to prove themselves (see online dating stats, which mean minorities have to work harder by focusing on proving themselves offline) is racism, just as rejecting minority job applications based on their name being foreign (as shown happens, in many resumé studies, even through the gap largely closes if a minority gets to the interview stage as they're then able to compensate for their perceived "foreignnes") is racist.


r/AskALiberal • • 23h ago

What policies can we support to grow cities in red states?

0 Upvotes

Urban areas are strongly correlated with voting for Democrats and supporting liberal policies. Many of the states that have flipped blue the last several years, such as Virginia, Georgia, and Colorado have done so largely because of the growth of their urban areas like NOVA, Atlanta, and Colorado. If we could encourage the growth of cities like Des Moines IA, Jackson MS, or Anchorage AK, its possible we could turn those states into reliable blue states.

What policies could we encourage, at any level of governance, to help grow these cities and make sure they turn theur states blue?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

What would you want Congress to ask about the Iran war before voting on more funding?

3 Upvotes

When the new Congress takes office in January, I'd like to see a public hearing on what the administration is doing to end the war with Iran. On November 16, Pakistan's foreign minister said he was waiting for a U.S. response to Iran's latest proposals. The next day, Reuters reported that Bahrain said it had intercepted Iranian drones while Qatar and Oman were still pursuing diplomacy.

I'd start by asking what Washington wants from a deal and what it's willing to offer. I'd also ask what another month of the blockade would accomplish and how officials weigh its effects on Iranian families and the risks to civilian crews in the Strait of Hormuz. Those answers would give lawmakers something specific to weigh if the White House asks for more money.

What would you ask first at that hearing, and how would the answer affect your support for more funding?


r/AskALiberal • • 16h ago

At what point should the President and Congress put their foot down with the Supreme Court?

0 Upvotes

Eliminating the Electoral College seems to be popular with the majority of Americans, and it seems like the Supreme Court will probably do its best to dictate that things like NaPoVoInterCo won’t pass.

Ultimately the question is, at what point are you ok with the President and Congress simply deciding the ignore the Supreme Court? This is entirely doable, as the Supreme Court lacks any share in the states monopoly on violence, as well as the power of the purse. The Supreme Court can make whatever rulings they want, but they have no power to enforce them. This is likely intentional, as whatever the flaws of the founding fathers, it’s unlikely that they wanted to trust the fate of their nation totally into the hands of seven men in robes. It seems far more likely that the Supreme Court was meant to serve as more of an advisory body.

In light of this, it seems that there’s a limit to the absurdity that the Supreme Court can engage in, a point at which the President and Congress can safely and ethically prioritize the will of the American people over this clique of nine individuals.

So, what is it? At what point are you supportive of the President and Congress simply telling the Supreme Court to go fuck itself and operating in spite of it?

NaPoVoInterCo feels like it could be a breaking point. It probably won’t be, but it’s a role of the dice, and the populists only have to win once to functionally eliminate the entire institution.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

What did Schumer do or not do that specifically hurt Americans?

11 Upvotes

Schumer seems to have become the most hated guy in the Democratic party overnight. How? What did he do that specifically harmed Americans?

I can't say I understand it, but there's tons about politics I don't know and I could be missing something important. And to be clear, I mostly agree with Van Hollen over Schumer, and can name multiple policy disagreements with Schumer, including one very big foreign policy disagreement lol.

But in the category of "what was his record for America", I simply am not sure what this guy did so wrong to be so maligned?


r/AskALiberal • • 18h ago

Do you think we’re gonna survive the next 2 years?

0 Upvotes

The level of catastrophic incidents happening keep ramping up by the week, and the administration seems almost entirely uninterested in dealing with any of it.

I feel like the house has caught fire, and it’s spreading fast and the only person in the house to put it out is a 5 year old.

How optimistic are you about us making it 2 years to the point an actual responsible government can hypothetically take control?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

How do you think Fetterman will vote if he jumps ship?

13 Upvotes

People defend Fetterman saying he votes 90% with the Democrats. Do you think that will persist if he jumps to the GOP in protest of Van Hollen becoming majority leader?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

If the electoral college was abolished what states would candidates travel to?

19 Upvotes

Every state ? Big states ?


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Red state residents: Who are the GOP "maverick" lawmakers in your state legislature?

3 Upvotes

In deep-red states or states with Republican supermajorities, most bills pass along party lines, but there are almost always a few GOP lawmakers who break ranks.

  • Who is the Republican lawmaker in your state that leadership can’t always count on?
  • What is a recent bill or issue where they voted against their party, and why did they do it?

Interested to hear about specific state-level representatives, their districts, and the local dynamics driving their votes.


r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

Florida passed Amendment 3 to slash property taxes. What are your thoughts on its policy trade-offs, economic effects, and revenue replacements?

2 Upvotes

Florida voters passed Amendment 3, expanding the non-school homestead exemption up to $250,000 by 2028 and capping annual non-homestead assessment increases at 5%.

While it protects school funding and provides direct tax relief to primary homeowners facing high housing costs, and is only projected to cut over $11 billion annually from municipal budgets, I had these questions for the community:

  • What are your general thoughts on using property tax exemptions to address cost-of-living concerns?
  • Because property taxes are generally stable and inelastic, does shifting local revenue toward user fees or sales surtaxes make local tax systems too volatile or regressive?

r/AskALiberal • • 1d ago

How have being a LGBT person influenced on your political views?

3 Upvotes

I'm bisexual and I think it makes me naturally s liberal person and against conservatism in society, regardless of the economical model or . country.


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

Does the Democratic Party's 5-6 person majority in the Senate will reduce the "Rotating Villain" problem?

8 Upvotes

Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema were the main villains to any left leaning legislation for quite a while. And it's become pretty synonymous with the Democratic Party.

We need 51 votes to get legislation passed and there are 49 Republicans against it, but secretly there are 7-10 Democrats against it and they choose 2-3 of them to publicly vote against the measure to take the heat.

It's a pretty standard move, used by both sides, but with this big of a majority do you think it's less likely to happen I'm the next 2 years?

We saw it "allegedly" happen in the House with the Hegseth impeachment. With 10 dem senators not being present during the vote.


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

If you had a choice to push ONE policy or vote, what would you push?

7 Upvotes

Democrats are going to have a lot of opportunities to achieve something. Just wondering what everyone's number one priority would be if they had the ability to push it.


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

What do you think about 5 EU countries setting up a deportation center in *Rwanda*

4 Upvotes

Clarification: at the time of writing the exact county has not been officially named, but the BBC has a lot of evidence that it will in fact be Rwanda.

BBC Article

5 EU countries (Germany, Greece, Denmark, Austria, and The Netherlands) are moving forward with setting up deportation centers in a 3rd country to send migrants to.

The claim is that it's only for people who have completely exhausted their legal rights to stay in the named countries, but human rights advocates claim that they will deport people well before then to a country with a shaky human rights record.

Is this something you agree with? Is this meaningfully different from US deportation policies? Is this a Canary in the coal mine for EU policies towards migrants going forward?

Before anyone blames this solely or put the majority of the blame on the US please look up Sykes-Picot and The Berlin Conference .


r/AskALiberal • • 2d ago

What counts as "the establishment" to you?

5 Upvotes

Often when following politics, I hear candidates, pundits, and ordinary people discuss or criticize "the establishment". For example, someone will mention that (insert candidate) is the establishment's pick. Additionally, some elected leaders get pegged with the "establishment" label while others get to evade it, even those who have worked in DC for years. Technically aren't all elected leaders part of the establishment? The way the term gets used feels vague.

What do you think?