I tend to be a bit of a mixed bag politically, and on abortion in particular up until quite recently (yesterday to be precise) I used to hold a rather liberal view.
I am an atheist so wherein a Christian would argue that God bestows one with the soul at the moment of conception and one's whole moral worth in concentrated therein or that murder constitutes a transgression against the divine will by brighting about one's coming to the afterlife before the time ordained by God, the only source of moral value I could reconcile with my disbelief in God was conscious experience and not life itself as it merely describes a material state to which no ethical consideration can be reasonably attached.
The rest of the pro-abortion arguments have failed to impress me — her body her choice blanantly ignores the fact it is her child and his body she's murdering, she's not financially well off to raise the child implies death is preferable to poverty, etc.
As such I only objected to abortion after 16 weeks, the agreed term upon which the fetus's brain exhibits activity attributed to conscious phenomena.
What made me change my mind on the issue was the following hypothetical. Picture a man in a vegetative state. Now, as an additional provision to his already cruel predicament suppose he was born this way and no man nor woman has ever felt in any sense attached to his wakeless form. Therefore it cannot be argued that the man's life is owned to his former self or his relatives or anybody else with however tenuous ties to him. He is a perfect philosophical zombie unburdened by any extraneous moral concerns. Then, say the coming day by some unknown sort of medical miracle he would spring out of his hospital bed, wide awake, his mind live with thought and emotion of which you were informed by an enthused doctor. So you decide to murder him before it happens.
This strikes me as unquestionably monstrous despite of the man's states lack of conscious experience which goes strictly against the utmost foundation of my ethical framework previously expounded upon. And the only principle by which the wickedness of the act can be clearly demonstrated is his potential for sentient being.
Now, with this rather overdrawn preamble fully articulated in all its gratuitous detail to the question at hand.
As I can afford myself no luxury of deferring to God's judgement on that matter, at what point of one's biological development should one's later potential count and why? How can any precise stage of fetal formation qualify good grounds for moral consideration. It can be well argued that all organic matter under particular circumstances harbors a latent capacity to later on produce conscious experience and to avoid the absurdity of extending human rights to every living or dead thing regardless of its humanity it requires there be an additional standard all of whose possible versions appear to me untenable unless substantiated by an underlying metaphysical framework which I don't remember if I've mentioned it but I'm an atheist.
Is it one of these things which you have to accept not making sense in retribution for not believing in God or is there a kind of materialist solution I'm missing? I extend my gratitude to everyone bearing through my philosophical ramblings as well as an apology to the same object.