r/AskPhysics • • 2h ago

How big wingspan would a horse need to fly?

15 Upvotes

Reading "My uncle the magician" and Aslan gave the horse wings which made me ponder the question.


r/AskPhysics • • 2h ago

Is there a "skill tree" / dependency graph for learning physics (like one in the link here for math)?

3 Upvotes

I really like how it's laid out its topics on its start page. It's basically a visual prerequisite graph starting from basic set theory and branching all the way up to advanced/niche stuff like unbounded operators, with lectures attached to each node, and I saw a few videos and while they're not long enough IMO they do give a very good idea of the topics and order to learn.

Does anyone know of something similar for physics? Ideally, a visual roadmap or dependency chart that goes from intro mechanics all the way up to grad-level and specialized topics (QFT, GR, condensed matter, etc.), bonus points if it shows the math prereqs needed at each step.

I've already seen "Map of Physics" video, which is great, but I'm looking for something closer to an actual learning progression/curriculum tree rather than just a concept web.


r/AskPhysics • • 14m ago

HS Physics - I get upthrust, but.. what's that got to do with displaced fluid?

1 Upvotes

I understand upthrust/buoyant force, how an object sinks, remains stagnant at a certain depth or rises to float, and the pressure applied on the object by the fluid. Makes great sense. But... what does all of this have to do with the weight of displaced fluid?

Upthrust - the upward force applied on an object due to the pressure of the fluid below the object. Particles push upwards. They also push sideways on the object, but that cancels out. They also push downwards, because there is fluid above the object too. But the downward push and upward push are not cancelled out because the pressure at both depths are different - the bottom part of the object experiences more force (more "push") because of this increase in pressure.

This upward force, when it is greater than the downward push and the weight of the object combined, causes the object to rise. If the total downward force is stronger, it sinks.

Objects that are denser sink because the particles have less surface area on which to apply pressure, and so the upthrust is weaker, and is easily countered by the greater mass (which causes greater weight). Objects that are less (average) dense float because the mass (and weight) is spread out over more volume, so more particles have the opportunity to push upwards.

  1. particles above the object feel a downward force (towards the object) via gravity. Particles below the object must also feel gravity but this force is AWAY from the object, so why is the force stronger by particles below the object?
  2. I am happy with my explanation/understanding so far, because my exam is soon and I don't have time to go as deep as I would like. I know that there may be some inaccuracies or nuances I have missed, but my exam won't be testing that much (hopefully...). I would normally stop here and move to the next topic, but I don't understand where the weight of the displaced fluid comes into this. Archimedes' Principle is key to our syllabus, and that's the only part I still don't get. Every online source I have scoured over the past few days simply state "upthrust is equal to the weight of the displaced fluid," and if I look for a "why" to that, they explain what I have explained above. I can't understand how the above explanation and understanding of this topic has to do with the weight of the amount of water a ship moves???

And if a ship isn't fully submerged, it doesn't even move the same amount of water as a sunken ship... Because less than 1/4 of the ship is actually in the water. It just doesn't make sense!!


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

Why can't we make a spacecraft that flies like a plane until the air gets too thin to hold its weight, then switch to thrusters for the rest of the trip?

140 Upvotes

I'm not an expert, I'm just curious.


r/AskPhysics • • 21h ago

If you stretched a rope between objects in two galaxies drifting apart from cosmic expansion, what would happen?

30 Upvotes

Meow


r/AskPhysics • • 5h ago

Black hole, or rabbit hole ?

0 Upvotes

Hypothetically, if you gave a book - about black holes - a constant acceleration would it's increasing kinetic energy have an increasing gravitational field associated with it ?

And, if so, could that gravitational field become strong enough at some point to turn the book about black holes into a black hole ?


r/AskPhysics • • 8h ago

The theoretical interactions of a mathematically perfect Cone used as a projectile at hypersonic speeds (over Mach 5)

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AskPhysics • • 19h ago

Why (or how) can transparent liquids be seen?

6 Upvotes

For any transparent liquid (e.g, glycerol, ethyl ether, chloroform, tetrachlorocarbon or even water), it is possible for us to distinguish it from the atmospheric air by looking at their surface. Why?

I do find it intuitive that liquids reflect light differently from gases. But if we ensure both the given liquid and the surrounding air are completely transparent (no impurities), then why should we be able to identify the contact surface?

If inot the visible-light color (both are transparent), which optical property could our human eyes be perceiving?


r/AskPhysics • • 9h ago

Applying modulation techniques to gravitational waves

0 Upvotes

I had a shower thought: what happens if we apply the modulation techniques in signal communications we use to gravitational waves?

Now, I can see two reasons why it wouldn't work. Firstly is because it's power is several magnitudes weaker than EM. And second is because the receiver needed is "very expensive". Though it is outside my field to give my opinion.

So my other question is, is it theoretically viable assuming infinite allocations and resources, or just impossible to implement? Obviously, I doubt it is practical.


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

Walking perpendicular to a laser reflected by a far away mirror.

9 Upvotes

The following thought experiment:

I shine a laser pulse into the sky from a laser pointer. At a 1-lightseconds distance there is a large mirror which is oriented perfectly normal to the direction the laster pointer is pointed at. After 2 seconds, the reflected light should perfectly hit my laser pointer again (let's neglect diffraction).

Now I do it again and take a step to the side (perfectly parallel to that mirror plane) right after sending the pulse - the reflected light should now hit the ground where I just stood, rather than hit my laser pointer again.

I now send a continuous beam while walking a constant 1m/s parallel to the mirror plane. The reflected laser light should form a point on the ground that follows me at about 2m distance.

But all inertial reference frames are equivalent - in my reference frame I'm stationary, so the reflected laser light should end up back on my laser pointer (and whether or not the mirror is stationary in my reference frame shouldn't make a difference, since the motion is perfectly parallel to the mirror plane).

How is this resolved? Will I see the reflected laser light end up on my laser pointer while a person that stands still and does not walk with me at 1m/s sees the reflected light form a point on the ground that follows me with a 2m distance? That doesn't seem like it could be right. Or does motion of the mirror relative to the laser pointer - even if completely parallel to the mirror plane - affect how it reflects the beam? That doesn't seem plausible either.


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

Before science started going quantum what questions or problems or observations made scientists start realizing they might have to stop seeing things in a conventional sensible way or should I say in the classical way?

14 Upvotes

What were the specific experimental observations, contradictions, and unresolved problems in classical physics that led scientists to question its foundational assumptions and develop quantum mechanics? What are they things that made them go…ummm wth


r/AskPhysics • • 6h ago

If I move at (near) the speed of light away from an object that is moving away from me at (near) to the speed of light. Am I going at (near) 2X the speed of light? What with everything being relative and all.

0 Upvotes

What with everything being relative and all.


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

What is Quantum Spin and how does it create a magnetic field?

9 Upvotes

I do not understand this concept at all. Lol.


r/AskPhysics • • 19h ago

Drone flight in a rotating cylinder.

1 Upvotes

So I’m writing a work of fiction where a large group of people are living in an ONiel Cylinder (giant cylinder rotating in space to create artificial gravity). I’ve attached a picture for a sense of the size of the thing.

https://thumb.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/9/94/Spacecolony3edit.jpeg/330px-Spacecolony3edit.jpeg?utm_source=en.wikipedia.org&utm_campaign=parser&utm_content=thumbnail

My question: Can things like helicopters and large drones work well in this sort of giant habitat? I know gravity isn’t EXACTLY the same as earth’s, but it is close…would this effect the ability of drones to repulse, hover and fly?


r/AskPhysics • • 2d ago

Is it difficult to launch something into the Sun from Earth?

145 Upvotes

This is something I see people say on Reddit all the time, and it doesn't make sense to me. People say it's actually almost impossible to launch something from Earth and hit the sun.

People tell me that it's because the Earth has so much rotational energy that if you launch something from Earth, you have to counter-act all of that rotational energy to get it to the sun, and that's basically impossible. It would require all of the rocket fuel that's ever been produced in the history of man to launch an object into the sun.

And... why? Like, can't you just kind of "spiral something in" to the sun? People tell me, no. That's impossible. You can't calculate the necessary trajectory, even with a modern supercomputer. You would invariably miss the sun, then the sun would gravitationally slingshot the object out of the solar system.

That last part I don't know how to mathematically prove or disprove. Can somebody help me with that? I want to know, why is it so hard to calculate a trajectory that hits the sun? The sun is really big. Doesn't that help? The Voyager probes made fairly precise fly-by trajectories of planets, which are both smaller and farther away than the sun. It seems intuitively like, if you can hit Jupiter then you should be able to hit the sun.

And won't the sun's enormous gravity help you? Again, people on Reddit have told me, no that's a common misunderstanding. The sun's enormous gravity means it's super, super hard to hit the sun because the sun just slingshots everything that comes near it, but doesn't hit it absolutely precisely, out of the solar system. But that doesn't make sense. Because if I'm close to hitting the sun, won't its gravity kind of help by pulling a near-miss into the sun? Again, people tell me, you'd think it would, but that's not how the physics works. That doesn't make sense to me. I'm not exactly trying to disagree, but I don't understand why the math works out that way.

Is it really more difficult to hit the Sun than the Moon, Mars, or Jupiter?


r/AskPhysics • • 7h ago

Does anything after 3D not technically exist since they can be represented as 3D?

0 Upvotes

for exemple, in 1D, you can just go left and right,

with 2D you can go left, right, up and down,

And with 3D you can go left, right, up, down and in depth.

But if you tell me about 4D, well to me that can't exist because 3D is already sufficient for going anywhere.


r/AskPhysics • • 21h ago

Help me understand beat frequency

0 Upvotes

I am working through some lecture slides where we are learning about sound, particularly we are discussing beat frequency. She provided us with this example:

"When a tuning fork is sounded together with a 492 Hz tone, a beat frequency of 2 Hz is heard. Then a small piece of putty is struck to the tuning fork, and the tuning fork is again sounded along with the 492 Hz tone. The beat frequency decreases. What is the frequency of the tuning fork?

hint: The tuning fork is a harmonic oscillator, the frequency f of the fork decreases as its mass increases.

The correct answer is 494 Hz. If we only know that the beat frequency is 2 Hz, then the fork frequency could be 490 Hz or 494 Hz. But since the beet frequency decreases as the fork frequency decreases, we can choose between the two frequencies."

(yes, beat is spelled as beet in the lecture slide.)

I used the formula f beat = |f1 - f2| which gave me 490 Hz and 494 Hz. However, I assumed that 490 Hz would be the correct answer as the frequency moves down due to the weight as she stated, but I cannot wrap my head around why it is 494 Hz?

I do not know if I have spent too much time looking at this problem and just cannot see the answer right in front of my face, but this one is bugging me because it seems so easy.

What am I missing here? Also, any extra advice for sound problems would be very appreciated! Thank you!


r/AskPhysics • • 21h ago

Does a rapid change in pressure cause more damage to a membrane designed to withstand a certain pressure?

1 Upvotes

If I have a hypothetical membrane that can withstand 20 psi before sustaining damage and I hit it with 19.99... psi, would the membrane be any closer to breaking if I brought it up to that pressure in half a second vs over 10 seconds? Could a real membrane, assuming it can definitely withstand 20 psi be damaged by 19 psi because of other physics reasons?

I get that barotrauma exists and that speed of pressure change affects the human body in destructive ways. I don't understand if that damage is a side effect of the human body needing to adjust to differences in pressure or if the speed at which the pressure changes fundamentally affects the "force" being exerted. Since pressure is force per unit area, does does pressure*acceleration mean anything in the same way that F=ma means something?


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

Please give me some experiences about study physics

3 Upvotes

I've read some books on conceptual physics and found the subject interesting. At first, I thought it might not be too complicated.

However, when I opened my textbook to work through some exercises and problems in preparation for my midterm exam, I got stuck on a single question for over 30 minutes.

Even after asking others for help and getting some useful ideas, I still had to spend a lot of time trying to solve the problem on my own, only to keep making mistakes.

I don't want to think of myself as stupid. I genuinely want to enjoy learning physics and stay passionate about it. But right now, it honestly feels more like torture, and that's really discouraging.

How do you guys deal with this kind of frustration and stay motivated?


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

Columbia Philosophy of Physics

2 Upvotes

I have a BS in Physics, and a MA in Scientific Rhetoric. I'm intending to go into the field of technical writing and/or editing, but I came across Columbia University's Philosophy of Physics MA program and it sounds so fascinating. I loved studying physics, but I wasn't in the place to continue on to a MS right out of college, but knew I wanted to stay in the scientific community so tried to find other ways to be involved (ie. technical writing). I didn't struggle to understand the concepts in my classes, but I was definitely more interested in what my professors were saying than the math on the board.

I've heard that philosophy of physics is a field that does get some respect from physicists but I don't want to shoot myself in the foot and come across like a woo-woo physicist trying to make false and unnecessary conclusions (this could be my own bias). I doubt this would qualify me as someone who has an advanced degree in physics since it isn't pure physics, even if I do take quantum mechanics as part of the program.

I think I'm more interested in the implications and applications of certain theorems and conclusions, more so than one specific field, and the Phil. of Phy. program offers classes that seem directly focused on answering my questions about physics. I just want to keep learning.

Should I find some other way to be involved in the physics community, or go where I feel like is going to be the most fun (this master's program)?


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

Energy and directional deflection

1 Upvotes

Same as topic. Have any experiments measured whether a particle beam/particle develops a deflection/spin change etc as its energy increases, differing from the trajectory predicted?


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

How do I derive the relationship between the coefficients of superficial expansion and cubical expansion without the usage of the coefficient of linear expansion?

0 Upvotes

I'm in eleventh grade and my friend and i curiously and this to our teacher and he said that there is no way to do so and I took it up as a challenge, I took a few hours working on this but I couldn't draft a single theory as to how they might be related. Our grade hasn't been taught calculus either so all the sources on the internet were too complex. I need help!!!


r/AskPhysics • • 16h ago

How close are we to manipulating zero-point energy?

0 Upvotes

r/AskPhysics • • 22h ago

If sweating makes us cooler in dry weather, then why doesn’t condensation heat us up?

0 Upvotes

Also, when vegetables are steamed, is it cooking by condensation? If so, how is this possible?

Do humans feel hotter when water at room temperature condenses on us?