r/AskProfessors • • 13d ago

META Reminder: this is r/AskPROFESSORS

111 Upvotes

Today, in posts I genuinely never thought I'd have to make:

Over the last week, I have removed multiple posts per day asking other students for advice. These posts will continue to be removed, and frequent fliers will start receiving temp bans.

Students, if you are a making post asking for advice from other students this is not the subreddit for you.

This subreddit is r/AskProfessors. If you want a professor perspective, you post here.

Post in r/college, or your institution's subreddit, or r/gradadmissions or wherever, if you want the perspective and advice from other students.


r/AskProfessors • • 2d ago

Becoming a Professor: Weekly Megathread

1 Upvotes

This is our weekly megathread for questions about becoming a professor.

You may be interested in our FAQ on the topic.

Otherwise, please keep all questions and discussion about becoming a professor in this dedicated thread.


r/AskProfessors • • 3h ago

Studying Tips Again applying to PhD

1 Upvotes

I left a PhD program with Masters. Now, applying again for PhD. I left last program because it was not good fit. How will the admission committee evaluate my application this time? Is it a red flag?

I applying some big school too.


r/AskProfessors • • 4h ago

General Advice STEM vs Humanities/Social Sciences Profs Openness to talk?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Thank you all for your efforts as academics and educators. Even if we don't express it as often as we should, we students do not let it go by unnoticed!

I am a first year social sciences student and I have noticed that each one of my professors is extremely accessible and willing to discuss topics past strictly course material, such as career prospects, personal research, and even some other personal stuff.

In contrast, I have heard from multiple friends in the STEM and even business programs at other universities that their professors are much less open and keep things strictly to course content. From what I have heard, they are also less accessible (e.g they don't have zoom office hours you can book with them outside of the scheduled in person hours).

Is there a real culture difference between how humanities/social science professors handle student relations in comparison to STEM, or am I falling for a sample size fallacy?


r/AskProfessors • • 19h ago

General Advice What to buy my PI?

3 Upvotes

I want to buy my PI a gift. Before you comment "this is not allowed" I just want to clarify I work at a medical school and he is not a teaching faculty. I was hired as an RA for a year and volunteered with him for another year part time. I will be leaving soon and have checked the institutions policy regarding gifts (to my understanding it is okay as long as you are not a student, which I am not). We are in the biological sciences. I want to buy him a gift for being a supportive mentor. He has this coffee cup warmer that he always uses and wanted to maybe buy him a better one? What other things would you as a professor love to receive?? He's not a very big eater either since he likes to stay fit and has a strict diet so any fruit baskets, snacks, etc. are out of the picture.


r/AskProfessors • • 1d ago

Grading Query I don’t know if I should bring an essay grade up at office hours

3 Upvotes

Please excuse my naivety. I am taking a social science class this semester that is split into a discussion component and lecture component. The lecture component is taught by the professor, and the discussion component is taught by a graduate student instructor. We were recently assigned to write an essay, which was to be graded by the graduate student instructor.

Before writing this essay, I had reached out for help twice—from both the professor and gsi. I asked the gsi directly for help for resources learning how to better do analysis over email, to which he responded saying that he wasn’t going to give me examples of past students’ essays, a complete non-sequitur from what I was asking. I responded correcting his assumption, and asked for help, and he ghosted me. and left my email on opened. So I went to my professor’s office hours for help instead.

He read over my essay, and said that he actually rather liked it and that it was actually really nice; he didn’t have any advice to give for what I’d written so we spent the rest of the time brainstorming how I could wrap up the last paragraph. I also asked him whether regrades on essays were possible because at this point I already had a hunch about how my gsi would grade my essay, based on small ways he’s treated me in discussion (e.g making fun of me for not speaking up louder—that was something the rest of the class laughed at and I was mortified by) as well as the fact that he never answered my email for help and accused me of something I wasn’t doing.

I got my essay grade back today and it was a 65. Met with the gsi to ask what went wrong, etc. and he basically said I didn’t do enough analysis, which is the very thing I had previously sought help for twice, and the thing he had ghosted me over when I tried getting help from him. No rubric was used; the gsis basically gave grades based on impressions. In our meeting he also said harsh things such as the interjection that I didn’t even do the essay—he said this about something I spent days laboring over—and adopted a dismissive attitude that said he could be doing so many other things with his time. I left more devastated by how he was ripping into my essay than by the grade.

The essay is weighted quite heavily in this course and I’ve calculated that I will need a 99.4% in the rest of the course to make up for it and get an A, which is impossible given that I’ve scored an average of 98% on the exams and I doubt I’ll be scoring a perfect score on our last exam, which is the hardest one.

Is this something worth going to office hours with my professor over? I’m scared he’d just say that he has no jurisdiction over the grading and I’ll have ruined a professional relationship with him since he is quite close to this particular gsi.


r/AskProfessors • • 14h ago

Academic Life Are anonymous constructive criticism surveys common?

0 Upvotes

I dislike it when professors ask for constructive criticism at the end of an exam. I’ve learned the hard way that I'm better off stroking a professor’s ego than offering any kind of genuine feedback without anonymity. Do colleges ever ask students for anonymous reviews of their classes / professors? I'm surprised that isn't a standard practice.


r/AskProfessors • • 1d ago

General Advice Final year project supervisor... uninterested?

0 Upvotes

I'm going into a bit of a panic and would love to hear from some professors.

I have an end of year project (data science), where I had to choose a dataset. The one I chose I got really excited about, because it had lots of information and it's a subject area I'm passionate about (outside my degree).

I've had to put 3 submissions for it so far (the recent one being the only one that is actually considered and graded for the future), basically my ideas and then a proposal and then some research. Well, I did research, and I think my dataset isn't any good, I'm now regretting my choice. But I've not really gotten feedback from my supervisor, she has gone along with it, and given me a few suggestions here and there about what I could do. Our calls on Teams have lasted maybe 10 minutes, while other students are meeting with their supervisor face-to-face.

Two of my friends with different supervisors have told me very, very different stories. One, has gotten feedback about changes she needs to make with her dataset (suggesting an additional one and what she should be considering), she has also been told what she needs to do reference wise, she has also been given an additional tool to use to work with on her thesis.

My other friend has had their supervisor contact an external source to get involved with an aspect of his project and the dataset he is using and also an API he can gather more information from.

I feel like I'm being left out in the cold. My dataset seems to be very flat by comparison, my questions I wanted to consider don't really seem achievable with what I am working with... and I think my supervisor doesn't really have much interest.

What should/could I do at this stage? I am fortunate that I am in the very, very early stages and haven't done much work at all, but my research phase (the most recent one) seems to have really showed me that my project is not a good idea at all. This has given me anxiety I haven't felt in a long long time, I have a constant knot in my chest.


r/AskProfessors • • 17h ago

Career Advice Can any one get a phd now?

0 Upvotes

I am talking about PhD in Engineering and CS....With chatgpt around, can any one get a phd. A phd is a thesis which does a deep dive on a topic (never done before) - basically its solving a problem....With AI brainstorming ideas, AI writing code, Doing simulations , writing papers, writing thesis...ITs as if any one can get a PhD. Am i missing something? I want to do a PhD to become a prof, but this whole thing is making me feel, it could get really competitive


r/AskProfessors • • 20h ago

Grading Query Is this grading/rubric fair?

0 Upvotes

I’m in a freshman english comp class, and I wrote a profile essay. I got points taken off for both “MLA Document Design” and “MLA Source Integration.” My teacher specifically mentioned that I needed more variation in my signal phrases. I feel like that applies to “MLA Source Integration.” Wouldn’t the document design apply to headings, page numbers, font, etc.? When I emailed her, she said that there were no problems with any of those aspects, just the signal phrases. That’s why I got points off in both categories.

To be more specific, I got a C for the document design. It says “The writer attempts to meet the requirements for MLA document design, but minor errors are present.” The error is apparently the signal phrases.

For source integration, I got a B. it says “Signal phrases are varied. The writer’s and the sources’ ideas are distinguishable from one another. The writer’s uses both summary and quotations based on rhetorical need.” I feel like this makes sense, and I agree that my essay fit more with this description than the A description.


r/AskProfessors • • 22h ago

Studying Tips APA paper writing

0 Upvotes

I recently started taking remote classes from an online college and we have weekly papers due that have to be in APA format. It’s been years since I have written papers for school , so I purchased the American Psychological Association 7th edition book to brush up, but I am much more of a visual learner. Are there any reputable sources where I can see papers in the correct format ? I did a google search but it there was alot of conflicting examples .

Additionally, AI was not a thing last time I was in school. I have read the college and course AI policy and I did not see anything about using AI to review a paper and make sure it is correctly formatted. Is this a thing that students normally do now just like they check for spelling and grammar errors?

I am not nervous about the course work or paper writing , but more about making sure I am using APA format correctly. Any tips and advice would be greatly appreciated.


r/AskProfessors • • 1d ago

America Naval Academy tenure track suit filed

12 Upvotes

I saw this article today regarding USNA tenure track faculty filing to sue the USNA for removing tenure-track positions. Thoughout my time in undergraduate & graduate school I’ve learned that tenure is treasured within the profession. Politics aside, my question to r/AskProfessors, do you think the tenure-track professors have a case against the Federal Government here?
——
A tenure-track faculty member at the U.S. Naval Academy filed an APA suit today in D. Md., seeking class status. The suit alleges the Navy broke its own rules by ending tenure review, even for faculty already slated to go up in Spring 2027, and asks the court to keep the process in place while the case proceeds.

This follows Hegseth's September announcement that the service academies would end civilian and tenured faculty. The Navy and the Academy haven't commented yet.

https://www.24sight.news/p/scoop-naval-academy-tenure-track


r/AskProfessors • • 1d ago

America Help a high school English teacher: what writing and research skills are your students lacking?

9 Upvotes

I teach high school English at a small private school. There’s only one other English teacher, and I teach students from 9-12. I started here four years ago, so the first set of kids who have been with me since they were freshman are now applying to colleges. I really hope that I’ve prepared them for what comes next, especially given how much the education landscape has shifted recently. While I still have them for six more months, what would you recommend I prioritize? What skill gaps are you seeing in your incoming freshmen?

Any insight is appreciated.


r/AskProfessors • • 1d ago

Professional Relationships My professor keeps addressing class-wide announcements directly to me

0 Upvotes

The first time it happened was before midterms. He posted a class announcement that started, “Dear ProfessionalLow…” and then went into our updated reading schedule.

I thought maybe he was toggling between the announcement draft and an email to me and got his wires crossed. I thought he’d edit the announcement as soon as he noticed, but apparently he never noticed—and he never sent me whatever email he was drafting!

Then, this week, he posted another announcement on our LMS that reads, “Hi ProfessionalLow, registration for 2027….”

None of my classmates have commented on this to me. I’m going to ask them today if they’re seeing it too…but I’m POSITIVE these are classwide announcements. My other profs all make them too, but never address a particular student.

He’s a great professor and I’m wondering if I should tell him so he can edit it. I don’t want to embarrass him, though. Is there any reason y’all can think of why a professor would do this on purpose? Is it wise to bring it to his attention or would that be weird?


r/AskProfessors • • 1d ago

Academic Advice Should I give up on Physics due to my low IQ

4 Upvotes

Hello, I am in my final year of a four year degree in physics, specifically a double major in experimental and theoretical physics. My grade average at the moment is a miserably low 2.2, which I am deeply ashamed of and have been trying to rectify over the past year.

Recently, now that I have been in my final year, I have realised how much of a moron I truly am. I'm struggling to understand and solve basic questions that my peers are able to do with flying colours. For example I am completely unable to even know how to attempt to solve most problems unless I have seen a worked example done by someone else or I can relate it to some notes I have taken that ar basically the same as the expected solution. I seem to have no ability to actually solve problems. It's almost as of my brain just, isn't there. No matter how hard I try, I just can't solve things on my own like everyone else.

It took me so long to truly understand how to properly solve PDE's via reparable variables compared to everyone else because I struggled with such simple concepts as fitting a guess solution to the given boundary conditions or because I struggled to apply fourier series to find the eigenvalues for the complete solution. I didn't even know that what I was looking for was the eigenvalues until someone explained it to me.

To put into perspective I have an IQ of around 85 (1 deviation below the mean) (yes i got it official tested during my autism diagnosis) so I am essentially sub human in terms of intelligence. I constantly feel like I have holes in my knowledge that would essentially require me to repeat my degree to patch up completely.

I thought after getting a high 2.1 in some of my harder classes such as QM2 (only up to degenerate perterbation theory and second quantisation) and analytical mechanics that I would finally have the know how and knowledge to be able to succeed, but that just isn't going to happen. I have already flunked two class tests on PDE's and Sturm Liouville type problems due to me simply not knowing how to go about solving them or applying any of the knowledge I have learned. Im hopeless and don't know what to do, and I feel like I've wasted my life for nothing.

My goal was always to go on and study a masters see where to go from there, either work in the energy sector on renewables or on something similar or even give working in academia a go. But those doors are essentially shut off forever for me due to my low IQ and inability to actually solve problems. I know that there have been no documented cases of someone with an IQ in the 80s ever achieving a degree in physics with a decent grade. I just feel like im doomed and don't know what to do.


r/AskProfessors • • 1d ago

Grading Query Lexical Variation

0 Upvotes

So as I go through college, I am developing my writing ability a lot. And I notice this in my writing through the different words I'm using. I'm reading academic literature, and I'm mirroring the argument structure, absorbing vocabulary and phrasing, etc. This shows up in my writing as lexical variations and odd phrasing because I'm expanding my writing. However, the level of college I'm at right now does not expect that from students. So, particularly, my question is for professors or other students. Do you know when your student is developing a more formal wirting style, or do you assume AI or cheating? I am very worried that my development in my writing and awkward phrases or words may get mistaken for AI. (PS: I am a humanities and social science student)

Thanks!!!


r/AskProfessors • • 1d ago

Academic Life Would it be weird to email prof about something unrelated to school?

1 Upvotes

So a couple months ago, I had this amazing professor. He told me a lot of things about himself and raised alot of unanswered questions. One of the things was an art piece he commissioned, I’ve wondered how it’s going but was too nervous to ask. I just thought about it again and I’m wondering if I should email him about it to see how it’s going and maybe see pictures of it?


r/AskProfessors • • 2d ago

Professional Relationships Should I follow up about letters of rec?

0 Upvotes

Hello! I have a question about emailing professors for letters of recommendation, especially after a mistake I made in the emails. I'm a Humanities undergrad and I want to apply to a Master's program at some point, probably a few years after I graduate.

However, I already have professors in mind who I'd want to ask for letters of rec. I took one of their classes in Spring last year and another last semester, and they're both professors I really liked. I told one of them I wanted to go to grad school, and they actually said that if I wanted to do a graduate program, I was ready. They even referred me to a university academic advisor who mentioned an on-campus research internship I could apply to, and I now currently intern there, so I thanked them for that. I tried to engage in their classes often and attended their office hours.

I emailed both of them this semester to ask if they were available to talk, and said I wanted to ask them more about grad school and ask for a recommendation letter (edit: I meant I would mainly be notifying them that I might ask them for one when I do apply, basically just asking if this would be okay with them if that makes sense). They both responded a few days later, but I made the mistake of not responding for two weeks after I sent the emails. That was my mistake, it was fully my responsibility and I regret it ofc.

I ended up sending follow up emails anyway, and they haven't responded in over a week, so I'm wondering if I should just stop/not send another follow up? I know they're probably busy with end of semester grading, and I don't want to email them to ask again for a favor they really don't have to do and aren't really getting paid for, especially after I messed up in not responding the first time I asked. I'm not quite sure what the etiquette is here, especially since the semester ends mid December so I'm not sure when/if to email again.

Besides, I feel like if I were in their position I wouldn't want to be asked a favor a second time just because the student made a mistake the first time they asked.


r/AskProfessors • • 2d ago

Professional Relationships Emailing former professor

0 Upvotes

Hello! I took a class with a professor last spring that generously offered to write me a letter of rec if I ever needed it. I thought that was great since I didn't feel like I did anything or went above and beyond to "earn" it, but nonetheless will be helpful when I apply to grad school. Their class was required for my major, and only teaches one other online section for a different class that I think I will be taking. It was an in person section where I was one of the only ones participating in class and it was not the type of class where office hours were necessary to understand content. It was not the type of class where attending office hours was crucial for success. I went maybe twice to talk about grad school and advice with that, but other than that not anything that would be building a good relationship i guess? I was thinking of sending an email when the semester ends with updates in my academic life, but I don't know if that's pointless. I want to maintain contact so that they don't forget me, but that just seems really transactional and I feel bad if that's the only reason I'm emailing is so that I don't lose that rec letter. Should I go through with it? Are these types of emails with this intention common amongst students? If it is generally okay, how do I even start the email?


r/AskProfessors • • 1d ago

Grading Query Automatic fail for Turnitin score above 35%?

0 Upvotes

My professor has an automatic fail for a Turnitin score above 35%. The paper will not be graded. Before I started using draft coach, I submitted a paper that came back as 45%. This included highlighted text such as my name, references, the required template and healthcare terminology. Now I spend all my time in this course rewriting my work to lower the Turnitin score. There are only so many ways to reword things. I don’t find this fair or useful so I’m asking a professor for their input or any suggestions to improve.


r/AskProfessors • • 3d ago

Academic Life International student with dissertation writing complete, but graduation is delayed for third semester. Advisor requested extra unfeasible experiment they don't have funds for. Insists I can't graduate and will not sign paperwork. Located at UT San Antonio. What can I do? They do this to all student

4 Upvotes

I am stuck here.


r/AskProfessors • • 3d ago

Professional Relationships My PhD supervisor gave me almost no research direction for 8 months. Now he's upset that I've made progress with my co-supervisor. Am I missing something?

14 Upvotes

I'm a first-year PhD student in engineering at a fairly well-known research university. My primary supervisor is a very established professor in his field, while my co-supervisor is a relatively young, tenure-track faculty member working in an adjacent mathematical/theoretical area.

I'm posting because I recently had a rather uncomfortable meeting with my primary supervisor, and I'm genuinely trying to understand whether I've mishandled the situation or whether there are some academic politics at play.

Some background:

For the first 7–8 months of my PhD, I struggled enormously to find a research direction. I repeatedly approached my primary supervisor asking what problems I could work on, or even what broad research directions he thought were promising.

His response was consistently along the lines of, "It's your PhD, you should come up with your own research problems."

I understand that a PhD requires intellectual independence, and I wasn't expecting someone to hand me a ready-made paper. But as someone just starting out in a research field, I was hoping for at least some guidance on open problems, promising directions, or where my interests might intersect with his.

Even when I explicitly asked for broader directions rather than specific problems, I was told to read papers and figure things out myself. On top of all this, there were no group meetings, people always worked on their own agenda and the professor selectively gave his one-on-one time to folk he believed were more productive.

Eventually, I became so frustrated and unproductive that I seriously considered quitting the program.

As something of a last attempt to make my PhD work, I approached another professor whose expertise aligned with my interests. I obtained my primary supervisor's permission to bring her on board as my formal co-supervisor.

This turned out to be an excellent decision academically. She started meeting with me regularly, discussing technical ideas, suggesting possible approaches, and helping me develop a research problem.

Over the following four months, we developed a substantial body of work that we now believe is approaching publication readiness.

Then came the uncomfortable meeting.

I recently presented this work to my primary supervisor to get his feedback.

His initial reaction was surprisingly negative and, frankly, quite angry.

One of the first things he asked was essentially, "What would my contribution be to this? This is already completed work. Why should I be a co-author?"

I responded that the research was being conducted in his laboratory using an experimental platform developed there, although I recognize that this alone doesn't necessarily justify authorship.

He then remarked that plenty of people want him as a co-author because he's a big name in the field.

That comment caught me off guard.

To clarify, I wasn't approaching him simply to get his name onto a paper. He's my primary PhD supervisor, and I wanted his scientific feedback and involvement. I also hadn't made any final assumptions about authorship.

He went on to say that I could continue working on these problems with my co-supervisor, but that I shouldn't really come to him with them because these weren't the research problems he was interested in.

This was particularly frustrating because I had spent months asking him what he was interested in working on without getting a concrete answer.

At one point, I directly asked him what kinds of scientific problems actually excited him.

Interestingly, the tone of the conversation changed considerably after that. He became calmer and finally started explaining some specific research directions that interested him. This was probably the most substantive guidance I'd received from him on research direction since joining.

He also began comparing my work against the broader state of the art, suggesting that while the methodology was interesting, its contribution to the field was relatively incremental.

I politely explained that I understood his field-level perspective, but this was also my first PhD paper, developed within a few months, and I wasn't claiming to have revolutionized the field.

He seemed to acknowledge that distinction and eventually clarified that the work was actually very good, particularly because my co-supervisor had brought a fresh perspective to the problem, and that it could become a strong publication.

What I'm struggling to understand:

I can't help feeling that part of his initial reaction came from the fact that another professor had become the main intellectual influence behind my research.

My co-supervisor is relatively junior, and the two professors haven't collaborated before. I wonder whether there's some uncertainty about their respective roles, or whether my primary supervisor feels excluded from the work.

I also feel there may be differences in the amount of attention and guidance different students receive in the lab, although I don't want to jump to conclusions about favoritism.

I respect my primary supervisor's scientific accomplishments and would love to benefit from his experience and perspective. But I also can't afford to spend my PhD waiting indefinitely for guidance.

I didn't go behind his back. I asked for permission before involving my co-supervisor, and I did so because I was desperate to make academic progress.

Now I feel caught in an awkward position where my co-supervisor has been genuinely helpful, but I worry that continuing to work closely with her might create tension with my primary supervisor.

I'd particularly appreciate perspectives from PhD students, postdocs, and faculty on a few questions:

  1. Is it normal for a primary supervisor to provide almost no research direction during the first year and expect a new student to identify everything independently?
  2. Was his reaction to the co-authorship question reasonable, or does it suggest that he felt excluded from the intellectual development of the project?
  3. How should I navigate a situation where my primary supervisor and co-supervisor have different research interests, particularly when the junior co-supervisor is providing most of the actual technical guidance?
  4. Would it be reasonable to continue developing the current publication with my co-supervisor while pursuing a separate, more experimentally focused direction with my primary supervisor?
  5. More generally, how do you manage the politics of having a famous, established PI as your primary supervisor when much of your day-to-day research mentorship comes from a younger faculty member?

I'm not looking to vilify my supervisor. I'm aware that I may be interpreting some aspects of the interaction incorrectly, and I would genuinely appreciate hearing alternative perspectives, especially from faculty who have been in similar situations.

I just want to do good research, publish meaningful work, and build a healthy working relationship with both supervisors without getting caught in academic politics.


r/AskProfessors • • 2d ago

Professional Relationships Should I mention previous publications in a cold email for an undergraduate research position?

0 Upvotes

I am leaning towards no because I don't want to come off as arrogant, but the professors I'm emailing receive hundreds of emails every day from undergrads asking the same question, so I'm curious if it would be a good idea to include that I have a couple previous publications in order to grab their attention. I've heard that many professors don't even open these cold emails, so I'm hoping to increase their chances of opening the email.


r/AskProfessors • • 2d ago

Academic Advice Is this an acceptable or ethical assignment to ask students to complete?

0 Upvotes

We have a project this term to write an OER textbook for “future students”, so…our professor. We are putting attributions on our work and just rewriting or copying entries from other OERs and it has been reiterated that this is for a future textbook, not a project contained to the class.

I do think this would be an interesting project except I have major issues with the instructions and how this class has been taught leading up to this project. It’s an upper level asynchronous course that I was looking forward doing research for. Instead I’m reading similar entry level chapters over and over across different free textbooks and then making my own version of the same chapter.

We watch Khan Academy and Crash Course videos and do discussion posts that are basically all close ended questions that make it difficult to actually have any type of discussion and meet word counts. They have been teaching this course for at least decade both in person and online and was providing lectures until recently so switching to an extremely low effort class and having us also create learning material for the next class feels like I just paid to do their job for them and gain nothing.

I reached out requesting if I could submit my work but be published and I have not received a response. E: I meant NOT be published

Other than submitting my SEI, do I have anything to actually complain about?


r/AskProfessors • • 3d ago

Academic Advice What is the minimum time I’ve known a prof for before asking for a LOR?

1 Upvotes

Basically I’m only starting school mid January 2027, but I have some applications which requires a lor from a prof due mid March. How likely are professors willing to write this LOR? I don’t need a very powerful LOR it just needs to be normal / decent. Thanks!