I'm hoping someone might have advice on how to handle this unusual situation involving the SFMTA and Bureau of Delinquent Revenue (BoDR), stemming from my license plate being stolen.
Apologies because this is super long, but I want to convey just how unsettling this ordeal has been. I'm truly at a loss for how to handle it.
Initial Incident
1/24/24: I was pulled over on 101 NB in San Bruno by three special unit vehicles. Quite the scene. Their lights started flashing and I was instructed to pull over. Before I could even put my car in park, officers ordered me over the speaker to turn off the car, put my hands out the window, and informed me I was under arrest for a stolen vehicle. Since I purchased the car from a used dealership just one month earlier and I thought I'd unknowingly bought a stolen car!
In my rearview mirror, I could see officers with weapons drawn (pointed at the ground). Following their instructions, I opened my door from the outside, stepped out, put my hands behind my head, walked backward toward them, and was handcuffed and placed in one of their vehicles.
They asked if it was my car (yes), whether anyone else was inside (no), and my license plate number. I started with "7..." before an officer interrupted saying the plate on the car started with a 9. Meanwhile, other officers still with weapons drawn, were shouting toward my car for anyone inside to make themself known.
A few minutes later, an officer searching my car explained that the VIN didn't match the stolen vehicle they were looking for. Someone had swapped my license plate with one from a stolen car. Phew!
They let me out of their vehicle, removed the handcuffs, filed a police report for my stolen plate, and advised me on getting replacements. Once everything was cleared up, the officers were very kind and apologetic. One even reassured me everything would be OK, as I was visibly shaking from the being in shock and overwhelmed.
Following Week
1/25/24: The next day, I walked to my car to head to the DMV and found an SFMTA citation for having no plates. Fine. I'd get replacements and add the citation to my to-do list.
At the DMV, I presented my temporary registration and purchase contract. I then learn the dealership had never submitted my registration paperwork. The DMV informed me I'd have been in serious trouble without my purchase contract.
Greeeeaaaat. Back to the dealership I go! Unfortunately, it was three hours away because I'd purchased the car while visiting family over the holidays. I found a safe place to park until I could make the trip.
1/30/24: SFPD called to inform me my stolen plate had been recovered on another vehicle and provided the police report number.
2/1/24: Completed the dealership visit and second DMV trip, then began resolving the SFMTA citation, as well as some Bay Bridge toll violations.
So far I easily spent 10+ hours resolving this initial incident. Things settled.
Second Incident
7/2/24: I walked to my car to drive to work. It was gone. Yup, my car had been completely stolen this time.
To keep this part short, resolving everything with my insurance company took six weeks.
For the next two months, I relied on buses and trains to commute to my job down the Peninsula. Public transit cost twice as much as I'd previously spent on gas each month, and my commute took roughly twice as long.
In September 2024, while awaiting my insurance payout and purchasing another car, I moved into an apartment with a garage.
By this point, I'd spent 30+ hours dealing with these incidents and incurred substantial expenses, including:
- $10 SFMTA processing fee to waive the original citation
- $18 notary fee for insurance
- $400/month for garage parking moving forward
- Significant therapy expenses related to being mistakingly arrested
- $2,500 out of pocket because my replacement car cost more than the insurance payout
A Year Later
1/23/25: I receive a letter from BoDR dated 12/24/24, stating I have 30 days to resolve an unpaid SFMTA citation before it goes to collections. The letter was definitely NOT mailed when dated, which I can't help but think was intentional.
I'm confused because I never received a second SFMTA citation. Turns out, the car my stolen plate was recovered on received a street-cleaning ticket on 1/25/24. The citation went to the dealership because the car was still registered to them at the time. Nobody notified me.
I frantically call and email BoDR, explaining the situation and providing all three police reports. Their representative tells me I need to resolve it directly with SFMTA.
3/5/25: After six weeks of repeatedly contacting SFMTA, the citation is finally dismissed. Honestly, it probably only happened because I'd matched with an SFMTA employee on Hinge and begged him for help three days before the dismissal. I felt terrible asking and offered to take him out for a meal. He never responded...fair.
I finally think this chapter is over. At this point, I've lost track of how many hours I've spent dealing with everything.
Now
11/13/26: Nope! Truly Friday the 13th! Another BoDR letter arrives, this time regarding TWO additional outstanding SFMTA citations from 1/30/25 (the day my stolen plate was recovered). Of course, the letter is dated 10/6/26.
I've called and emailed both BoDR and SFMTA, providing comprehensive documentation from 2024 and 2025. Although it's only been a few days, I'm losing my mind. The emotional distress of reliving the initial incident has been overwhelming. Last night, I even had a nightmare about police lights flashing behind me. And the thought of dealing with collections has me spiraling.
So SF, does anyone have advice? Is there someone else I can contact or a way to get this resolved efficiently? I'm truly at a loss and would appreciate any guidance. Thank you so much in advance.