r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Material-Buy3266 • 18h ago
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Boring_Pool1800 • 23m ago
What If? Could everyone aboard the Titanic have survived if the passengers and crew were replaced with modern-day people who cooperated completely?
Imagine that five minutes after the Titanic struck the iceberg, everyone aboard was instantly replaced by a person from 2026 of the same age and gender.
The ship, weather, available materials, and rescue timeline remain exactly the same. No modern equipment is introduced.
The difference is that everyone immediately understands the ship is sinking and agrees to work together toward one goal: saving as many lives as physically possible.
They could maximize lifeboat capacity, dismantle furniture and wooden structures to build makeshift rafts, use mattresses or other buoyant materials, and organize the evacuation however they see fit.
With approximately 2 hours and 35 minutes remaining before the ship sinks, could they realistically save all 2,200 people?
If not, how close could they get?
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Dense_Primary629 • 56m ago
What if motion isn't travel at all, but retuning? A speculative take on the Hartman effect
This is a speculative idea, not established physics — I'm sharing it to test the logic, not to present it as settled science.
In my book I argue for a different picture of motion, which I call the Law of Motion as Phase Retuning. Instead of picturing an object crossing empty space from A to B, picture it like a radio dial turning: the signal fades out of one station and fades into the next. Nothing travels between the stations. The object simply retunes its coupling, smoothly, from one place to another.
Quantum tunneling fits this picture neatly. A particle facing a barrier it 'shouldn't' cross is like hitting a radio's preset button: it jumps straight to the next station and skips the forbidden band entirely. That would explain the Hartman effect — the measured tunneling delay saturates instead of growing with barrier width — because the particle never actually spends time 'inside' the barrier the way a crossing picture suggests.
If motion is retuning, a few questions follow. First, what is acceleration, physically — a change in how fast the retuning happens? Second, does tunneling violate causality, or does it only violate our picture of space? And third, if nothing crosses the gap, why does motion still look so smooth and continuous to us?
I'm the author of 'Zero-Metric Phase Theory' by Tim Tian, available on Google Play Books.
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/SuperKillerFrog • 1d ago
General Discussion How to verbally present my poster at a conference?
Hi,
I'm here to ask something not scientific, but i need some people with experience to answer. So I'm sorry if it goes against the rules, I'll delete it promptly if so. I was just so confused about the number of scientific subs, that this one just seemed the most approachable.
I am going to a conference next week and I'll have a poster there. I'll be my first experience like that, so i may be overthinking it. It is basically a competition for college students, but i can attend with the poster even when I'm just in the 3rd year of high school. It's not really a big deal, i just want to learn it right.
So, I'm supposed to present my poster to the judges in 3 minutes. I know it's such a short time. So, below, in the comments, there's my (translated, so it can have weird sentences) verbal presentation. I wont post the poster itself, but i guess you can imagine it. Ill just point my finger to the pictures.
Thanks everyone!
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/babyskele • 1d ago
Teaching Tasked with Developing a STEAM Program for My City
Hello! I have recently been granted the exciting opportunity of being able to build a STEAM program from the ground up to make it more accessible to kids in my area and get them more excited about the world around them. Many activities I find are cool, but I really want to focus on explaining everyday phenomena through STEAM subjects. Biology is easier for me as a molecular biology graduate, but I really want to make sure I'm doing as much as possible.
Age groups: 6 - 12 years old (will be separated)
Budget: Variable as there is no baseline yet
A really hard area for me has been mathematics! Any help is appreciated!
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Aggravating_Duck6108 • 1d ago
General Discussion Would Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer spur a new evolutionary path?
Completely silly question I can't stop seriously considering.
In the famous tale of Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer Rudolph is born with a mutation that causes his nose to glow. By the end of the story, Rudolph has found that the mutation is beneficial (allowing him to navigate in foggy or snowy conditions other North Pole reindeer cannot) and he also finds a mate. If Rudolph were to pass his red-nosed-ness on to any of his offspring, would it's beneficial nature spur evolution towards red-nosed-ness being more common among North Pole reindeer?
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Present-Carpenter203 • 2d ago
General Discussion What happens to old internal cells?
What happens to old cells that die within the body? I know old and dead skin cells just kind of, fall off, in time; but what about cells within the body? Are they just used as fuel for the next generation of cells or do they die and become waste that the body has to process?
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Same-Leadership7144 • 1d ago
What If? Very VERY odd question, so bare with me
I am not a man of science, never was never is and probably never will be, what I am however is a writer, and I come to you men and women of science to discuss possible answers for the conundrum I've found myself in. So, I'm currently writing this fictional novel with fictional races; There's people made of paper, rock, ink, and chalk. Only issue is I can't quite figure out their insides since well they're not human but I want their anatomy to be the closest thing to human anatomy but not quite, so say they'd have the same organs as humans but like made out of paper and stuff. I've been trying to think of substitutes for these things but since I don't know how the human body works so I figured I'd ask you guys for help though I don't even know if this counts as science anymore. Also should they all have the same insides or should they be diffrent? LMK ur thoughts (if this doesnt get wiped off the face of the sub)
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Latte_Schwartz44 • 2d ago
What If? Does anything interesting happen to the ability of using Venusian transits of the Sun to do maths of the Solar System when the Sun stops being on the main sequence?
Obviously I mean this before the Sun can destroy Venus.
I imagine that the transits would be vastly more common than today where pairs follow a century of no transit, but given the Sun's outer edge becomes more tenuous at that point, I don't know if anything useful would happen.
Earth itself would be way hotter at this time too so lets just assume we're on the Moon and put the telescope there instead.
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Mohamadhayssam • 2d ago
Quantitative ¹⁹F NMR with an internal standard for adsorption experiments
Title: Quantitative ¹⁹F NMR with an internal standard for adsorption experiments
Hi everyone, I’m using ¹⁹F NMR to measure PFAS concentrations before and after adsorption.
If I take 1 mL of my sample and add a known amount of an internal standard, can I calculate the sample concentration directly from the integration ratio, accounting for the number of fluorine atoms and dilution?
For example, if my starting solution is nominally 1,000 ppm, can I use the internal standard to determine its actual concentration instead of assuming it is exactly 1,000 ppm? Would I need a separate calibration curve?
What should I check to make sure the quantification is reliable?
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/FunctionOk65 • 2d ago
Why were scientists in the past able to make groundbreaking discoveries with limited resources, while modern scientists, despite having advanced technology and endless resources, seem to struggle to achieve equally revolutionary breakthroughs?
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/IlyasAlim0629 • 2d ago
If electrons are negatively charged and atomic nuclei are positively charged, why don't electrons fall into the nucleus?
We know that opposite electric charges attract each other. So why doesn't the electron simply collapse into the positively charged nucleus?
What keeps atoms stable? Is it quantum mechanics, the uncertainty principle, or something else?
I've always found this fascinating and would love to hear different explanations!
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/No-Interview-2173 • 2d ago
The Twin Experiment
I’ve always been fascinated by the idea of conducting a particular experiment.
Imagine taking two identical twins who are born at exactly the same time and raising them under precisely the same conditions. How many years or even decades would it take before noticeable differences began to appear between them?
Let’s say two boys are born, and from the very beginning of their lives, they consume exactly the same number of calories, take the same number of steps, go to sleep and wake up at exactly the same times, and follow identical daily routines. In other words, not a single action performed by one differs from the actions performed by the other.
Now, here’s the question: Would they eventually become completely identical?
If they got into a fight, who would win? Who would perform better on a mathematics test? If they competed in arm wrestling, who would come out on top? Who would be able to run longer on a treadmill?
Would their physical characteristics, abilities, and intelligence remain exactly the same? And at what point, if ever, would a significant gap begin to emerge between them in a particular area?
That’s just one part of the experiment I have in mind. There’s a second question as well.
What if one of the twins performed exactly one push-up every morning?
In other words, they both wake up at the same time. The first twin does one push-up, while the second simply stands still without moving. After that, they continue their day as usual, doing exactly the same things as each other.
How long would it take — months, years, or even decades — for a noticeable difference to develop between them? Would their bodies eventually become significantly different?
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/i_like_xenos • 3d ago
Teaching If I wanted to create machines, what field would I need to study in?
Edit: Thank you to everyone who has provided me with amazing advice! I'll definitely look into these options as well as attempt to figure out which jobs would work out best with these interests. I've really enjoyed reading all the advice and its been very helpful ❤️
So I love science but I'm not very good at understanding it. Recently though I've been flooded with videos about the guy who made his own laser gun and thought; "Wow, I really want to do that."
Ever since I was a kid I wanted to be an inventor or innovator of some sort but I was never sure what I wanted to create. I wrote plenty growing up as well and the characters I always fell back on were the same figures I watch and adore to this day — people who invent and innovate. I want to create and improve upon things that already exist, especially things that rely on computer tech in some capacity. Then again maybe what I want to do is simply too broad to pin down. I want the same versatility someone like Nile Red has, where he can just do whatever comes to his mind just because he feels like it but with more... technology stuff? I suppose? Its hard to explain. I like the idea of creating things with a function. Maybe it would be considered mechanics? Or robotics?
I don't even know where to start with studying but I want to at least try. Perhaps starting with computer stuff would be smart, given the electrical components seem to be used in pretty much any technology, but what then?
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Netherwarrior6 • 4d ago
What If? What would be the opposite of the Heat Death of the Universe?
So, the way I understand it, one theory for the end of the universe is that through Entropy, everything will eventually dissipate into a state where everything is the same, and the system is at maximum chaos, and no energy remains to transfer into a higher state. This would leave the universe essentially frozen with no energy transfer happening ever again.
My question is, theoretically, what would the opposite of the heat death of the universe be, where instead everything becoming slowly more chaotic until it all evens out, everything becomes more and more ordered until what? What would a system of perfect order potentially be like? Would it just be similar to maximum entropy, or would it be different? What might it potentially look/be like.
This question has been on my mind for a few days, and I can't find any topics discussing it anywhere, probably because it's likely impossible, but I am really curious.
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/RoutineBodybuilder49 • 4d ago
Seeking Advice: How Can I Become a University Lecturer in Biological Sciences?
Hi everyone!
My dream is to become a university lecturer in the biological sciences. I'm currently exploring my higher education options and trying to understand the right academic pathway to achieve this goal.
I'd genuinely appreciate advice from lecturers, researchers, or anyone with experience in academia. I'd love to hear about your academic journeys, recommendations, and any advice you wish someone had given you when you started.
Thank you!
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/ldmarchesi • 3d ago
What would happen to the ecosystem of a planet if nothing dies?
I'm writing a science fiction book where for in lore reasons nothing on the planet dies. What would the implications be?
How would that affect the atmosphere and the ecosystem?
Composition, temperature, etc...
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/claymel • 4d ago
General Discussion What are the best steps to mastering “space stuff”? (sorry)
I want to learn all there is to learn about the universe, space, and everything both beyond and within, but I have no idea where to start. I have no idea what there is to learn after I start, as I don’t know what anything is called/what all exists, and I don’t even know how to create a proper title for this post. Nevertheless, my goal is to get myself as close as possible to the “truth” of everything—our life, our worlds, the whole world, the hows, the whys, etc.—before I die (obviously we’ll never know the “truth,” I’m just saying I want to get as close to that level of knowledge as humanly possible and I’m planning on spending the rest of my recreational life doing it)
What starting/prereq concepts and learnings paths (ex: calc -> differential —> discrete) do you recommend for a most bulletproof foundation, and when (if ever) will I be able to go independent with my studies? Any advice? Any other answers to questions I didn’t think to ask but should’ve? I know I could throw this same prompt into some bot and get a decent answer, but I’d prefer to not and I figured the answers from here would be more comprehensive. Thank you.
Also interested in chem and life and so on within our atmosphere
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Mean-Criticism1529 • 4d ago
General Discussion How do astronomers determine whether a star is older than the galaxy it belongs to?
Something i find interesting about astronomy is that stars and galaxies don't necessarily form at the same time. but how accurately can we determine the age of an individual star especially one that is billions of years old?
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/glowshroom12 • 5d ago
General Discussion How far could you hit a baseball if you made a machine that swung a baseball bat?
I guess you’d need two machines. One that can launch a baseball as fast as possible and one that can swing a baseball bat with as much force as possible. you might also need a sturdy bat, it could shatter if it swung hard enough.
would air resistance stop it at some point, how fast, high or far could such a thing launch a ball
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/True_Blue_Mew • 5d ago
General Discussion if dark matter cannot interact with electromagnetic waves then could there be "Anti-electromagnetic" waves that cannot interact with normal matter
if dark matter cannot interact with electromagnetic waves then could there be "Anti-electromagnetic" waves that cannot interact with normal matter, if it could exist how could humans detect whatsoever
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Next-View5892 • 4d ago
What would occur if a third dimensional being entered a 4th dimensional space?
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/AffectionateSalad952 • 6d ago
What If? SPECULATION: Why is the current assumption about black holes is that it results in a Singularity?
The moment that gravity gets high enough for an object, it will start to bend light and therefore we cannot see further into it. Everything from here on out must be inferred or deduced using math since we can no longer observe what is inside. Matter takes up space and has size, and it can only be squeezed so tightly together. The fundamental interactions are what stop matter from directly touching. So my hypothesis is this: gravity becomes so strong for an object in space that it overcomes the three other fundamental interactions of matter, and forces matter to compact as close as the other fundamental interactions allow. This also leads me to assume that the moment these fundamental forces are overcome, particles stop behaving as they typically would since forces like the weak force have been overcome. The law of conservation of energy would be conserved because these forces still exist inside the pool of energy inescapable from the black hole, but they would have no interactions because gravity is overpowering them. What math and or proof do we have to prove this wrong? What math and or proof do we have to prove the singularity theory wrong?
r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/a1boom • 6d ago
Continuing Education could I major in environ. engineering and minor in astrophysics?
I’m a junior in high school and I definitely know I want to get into environmental engineering but astrophysics appeals to me as well. I really value interdisciplinary work and these are very different.
I think it could be very valuable to have both of these behind my belt.
If this is something worth pursuing, what university even offers this?
Side note: I’m just asking degree wise. I won’t work in astrophysics but I want the minor nevertheless. I love calculus and physics but want to be involved in the creation of new technologies on earth and I think I could apply astrophysics knowledge into real life
Please let me know your thoughts. Be as real as possible but also consider all possibilities. Thanks!