r/Astronomy • • Mar 27 '20

Mod Post Read the rules sub before posting!

908 Upvotes

Hi all,

Friendly mod warning here. In r/Astronomy, somewhere around 70% of posts get removed. Yeah. That's a lot. All because people haven't bothered reading the rules or bothering to understand what words mean. So here, we're going to dive into them a bit further.

The most commonly violated rules are as follows:

Pictures

Our rule regarding pictures has three parts. If your post has been removed for violating our rules regarding pictures, we recommend considering the following, in the following order:

  1. All pictures/videos must be original content.

If you took the picture or did substantial processing of publicly available data, this counts. If not, it's going to be removed.

2) You must have the acquisition/processing information.

This needs to be somewhere easy for the mods to verify. This means it can either be in the post body or a top level comment. Responses to someone else's comment, in your link to your Instagram page, etc... do not count.

3) Images must be exceptional quality.

There are certain things that will immediately disqualify an image:

  • Poor or inconsistent focus
  • Chromatic aberration
  • Field rotation
  • Low signal-to-noise ratio
  • Images that don't fill the frame because you were shooting through an eyepiece

However, beyond that, we cannot give further clarification on what will or will not meet this criteria for several reasons:

  1. Technology is rapidly changing
  2. Our standards are based on what has been submitted recently (e.g, if we're getting a ton of moon pictures because it's a supermoon, the standards go up to prevent the sub from being spammed)
  3. Listing the criteria encourages people to try to game the system

So yes, this portion is inherently subjective and, at the end of the day, the mods are the ones that decide and the mods are under no obligation to explain this decision to you.

If you are informed that your post was removed because of image quality, arguing about the quality will not be successful. In particular, there are a few arguments that are false or otherwise trite which we simply won't tolerate. These include:

"You let that image that I think isn't as good stay up"

  • See above about how the standards are fluid.

"Pictures have to be NASA quality"

  • They don't.

"You have to have thousands of dollars of equipment"

  • You don't. Technique matters.

"This is a really good photo given my equipment"

  • The standard is "exceptional". Not "exceptional for my equipment".

"This isn't being friendly to beginner astrophotographers"

  • Correct. To keep the sub from being spammed by low quality and low effort posts, this sub has standards.

"My post was getting a lot of upvotes"

  • Upvotes are not an "I get to break the rules" card.

Using the above arguments will not wow mods into suddenly approving your image. It will result in a ban.

Trying to argue with the mods using bad arguments isn't going to fly.

Lastly, it should be noted that we do allow astro-art in this sub. Obviously, it won't have acquisition information, but the content must still be original and mods get the final say on whether on the quality (although we're generally fairly generous on this).

Questions

This rule basically means you need to do your own research before posting.

  • If we look at a post and immediately have to question whether or not you did a Google search, your post will get removed.
  • If you asked Chat GPT or any other LLM, your post will be removed (see our rule regarding sources).
  • If your post is asking for generic or basic information, your post will get removed.

  • If your post is using basic terms incorrectly because you haven't bothered to understand what the words you're using mean, your post will get removed.
  • If you're asking a question based on a basic misunderstanding of the science, your post will get removed.
  • If you're asking a complicated question with a specific answer but didn't give the necessary information to be able to answer the question because you haven't even figured out what the parameters necessary to approach the question are, your post will get removed.

To prevent your post from being removed, tell us specifically what you've tried. Just saying "I GoOgLeD iT" doesn't cut it.

  • What search terms did you use?
  • In what way do the results of your search fail to answer your question?
  • What did you understand from what you found and need further clarification on that you were unable to find?

Furthermore, when telling us what you've tried, we will be very unimpressed if you use sources that are prohibited under our source rule (social media memes, YouTube, AI, etc...).

As with the rules regarding pictures, the mods are the arbiters of how difficult questions are to answer. If you're not happy about that and want to complain that another question was allowed to stand, then we will invite you to post elsewhere with an immediate and permanent ban.

Object ID

We'd estimate that only 1-2% of all posts asking for help identifying an object actually follow our rules. Resources are available in the rule relating to this. If you haven't consulted the flow-chart and used the resources in the stickied comment, your post is getting removed. Seriously. Use Stellarium. It's free. It will very quickly tell you if that shiny thing is a planet which is probably the most common answer. The second most common answer is "Starlink". That's 95% of the ID posts right there that didn't need to be a post.

Do note that many of the phone apps in which you point your phone to the sky and it shows you what you are looing at are extremely poor at accurately determining where you're pointing. Furthermore, the scale is rarely correct. As such, this method is not considered a sufficient attempt at understanding on your part and you will need to apply some spatial reasoning to your attempt.

Pseudoscience

The mod team of r/astronomy has several mods with degrees in the field. We're very familiar with what is and is not pseudoscience in the field. And we take a hard line against pseudoscience. Promoting it is an immediate ban. Furthermore, we do not allow the entertaining of pseudoscience by trying to figure out how to "debate" it (even if you're trying to take the pro-science side). Trying to debate pseudoscience legitimizes it. As such, posts that entertain pseudoscience in any manner will be removed.

Outlandish Hypotheticals

This is a subset of the rule regarding pseudoscience and doesn't come up all that often, but when it does, it usually takes the form of "X does not work according to physics. How can I make it work?" or "If I ignore part of physics, how does physics work?"

Sometimes the first part of this isn't explicitly stated or even understood (in which case, see our rule regarding poorly researched posts) by the poster, but such questions are inherently nonsensical and will be removed.

Sources

ChatGPT and other LLMs are not reliable sources of information. Any use of them will be removed. This includes asking if they are correct or not.

Content

Due to the profusion of AI slop apps, we're no longer allowing apps at all. No, we don't care if you're wanting a "review". No we don't care if they're free. No we don't care if you put it in a website.

Bans

We almost never ban anyone for a first offense unless your post history makes it clear you're a spammer, troll, crackpot, etc... Rather, mods have tools in which to apply removal reasons which will send a message to the user letting them know which rule was violated. Because these rules, and in turn the messages, can cover a range of issues, you may need to actually consider which part of the rule your post violated. The mods are not here to read to you.

If you don't, and continue breaking the rules, we'll often respond with a temporary ban.

In many cases, we're happy to remove bans if you message the mods politely acknowledging the violation. But that almost never happens. Which brings us to the last thing we want to discuss.

Behavior

We've had a lot of people breaking rules and then getting rude when their posts are removed or they get bans (even temporary). That's a violation of our rules regarding behavior and is a quick way to get permabanned. To be clear: Breaking this rule anywhere on the sub will be a violation of the rules and dealt with accordingly, but breaking this rule when in full view of the mods by doing it in the mod-mail will 100% get you caught. So just don't do it.

Claiming the mods are "power tripping" or other insults when you violated the rules isn't going to help your case. It will get your muted for the maximum duration allowable and reported to the Reddit admins.

And no, your mis-interpretations of the rules, or saying it "was generating discussion" aren't going to help either.

While these are the most commonly violated rules, they are not the only rules. So make sure you read all of the rules.


r/Astronomy • • 5h ago Heartwarming

Astro Art (OC) [OC] Happy One Light Day, Voyager 1!

Post image
589 Upvotes

(This is a re-upload because I accidentally typed light year on the title, whoops-)


r/Astronomy • • 3h ago

Discussion: [Topic] Voyager 1 crossed one light-day from Earth today (18 Nov, 10:16 UTC). Here’s its whole 49-year trip as signal travel time, and why the line wiggles every year [OC]

Post image
123 Upvotes

I plotted both Voyagers' distance from Earth as one-way signal time, using NASA JPL Horizons positions every 2 days from launch to 4 November, with NASA's published crossing time for today.

The small yearly wiggle is Earth going around the Sun: for part of each year Earth is moving towards Voyager, so the gap closes slightly before growing again. NASA picked today because after this crossing Voyager 1 never comes back inside 24 light-hours, even at the low point of the wiggle.

Voyager 2 is at about 20 light-hours and won't reach one light-day until around 2035.

Happy to answer questions about the data or the method.


r/Astronomy • • 18h ago

Other: [News] NASA's Voyager 1 spacecraft to reach historic light-day milestone today

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

Earth's alien envoy is about to hit a history-making milestone for space exploration.

NASA's Voyager 1 spacecraft will be one light-day, or 25.9 billion kilometres, from Earth later today.

After almost 50 years in space, the spacecraft is the farthest human-made object from Earth.

NASA Voyager project scientist Linda Spilker said it was an "incredible milestone to celebrate".

"One light-day is not a time so much as a distance," Dr Spilker said.

At a distance of one light-day, Voyager 1 will be exactly 24 hours away from Earth at the speed of light.

"In other words, if you sent a radio signal from the Earth, it would take exactly 24 hours to reach Voyager 1," she said.

With the spacecraft living long past its retirement date and its systems starting to fail, it is a landmark many at NASA never thought it would reach.

Voyager changed our view of the Solar System

Voyager 1 and 2 were launched in 1977 to explore Jupiter and Saturn. Voyager 2 also flew by Uranus and Neptune.

The probes were then kept in operation to explore the outer reaches of the Solar System.

Both Voyagers were extremely high-tech in the 70s, built to withstand incredibly high levels of radiation.

But they were also limited by the technology of the time. Each probe relies on an eight-track tape player to record data.

Even with its old tech, the Voyager spacecraft provided a whole new view of the Solar System.

Planetary Society chief scientist Bruce Betts was inspired to become a scientist as a child after seeing images beamed back from the spacecraft.

"[The Voyager probes] weren't the first to Jupiter, but they were by far the best images we'd ever had," Dr Betts said.

"It made those places real in a lot of people's minds."

The mission was originally expected to last only a decade, but both spacecraft are 49 years into their far-flung trip to the outer edges of the Solar System.

Picture credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech

Read more: https://www.abc.net.au/news/science/2026-11-18/nasa-voyager-one-light-day-from-earth-milestone/107154162


r/Astronomy • • 3h ago

Astrophotography (OC) M1 - Crab Nebula

Post image
59 Upvotes

The expanding remains of a massive star that exploded in a supernova, originally witnessed by astronomers back in 1054 AD, sitting about 6,500 light-years away in the constellation Taurus.

Taken from Madrid city center with my Askar 71F without reducer - pretty impressed with the details in the filaments that I could pick up! Also, it's the most colorful target I've imaged so far :)
Astrobin here

Equipment and acquisition:
- Askar 71F (no reducer)
- Asi585MC Air
- Teseek 17
- SvBony + asi120mm guide camera
- ZWO EAF, ZWO EFW
- L-Ultimate filter: 70 x 300 sec
- Antlia ALP-T SII-OIII 3nm filter: 80 x 300 sec
- About 12.5 hours in total
- 30 flats, 30 darks, 30 bias

Processing (PI)
WBPP, SetiAstro AutoDBE, SPCC, blurX correct only, starX
On starless image: DBXtract, linear fit to OIII, setiastro perfect palette picker (SHO), then manual curves transformations with and without ACDNR mask, selective color correction, dark structure enhance, noiseX.
For stars: setiastro NB to RGB star stretch, pixelmath to recombine with starless


r/Astronomy • • 9h ago

Astrophotography (OC) Pacman Nebula

Post image
148 Upvotes

NGC 281

18h OIII

18h Halpha

IMX 533 mono, -15°

Newton 200/1200, EQ6R

Bortle 4.5, Romania

Pixinsight, Seti Astro, GraXpert, Photoshop


r/Astronomy • • 18h ago Bravo

Astrophotography (OC) The Milky Way arch over Lençóis Maranhenses, Brazil

Post image
477 Upvotes

In Lençóis Maranhenses, among endless dunes and lagoons, the Milky Way arch can be captured with 2 different orientations in the same night. This is the second one, later in the night.

Because of the Earth's rotation, the arch changes orientation during the night: the first one appears in the east at the start of the night, and the second one in the west a few hours later. It is something that in most parts of the Northern Hemisphere we cannot see.

Taken this past July during my visit to the area. I stacked more than usual to be able to get the arch so detailed, including hydrogen alpha and OIII, the red and blue nebulas. Also, using a low light technique near the foreground was a really special addition to get the shapes of the dunes.

The place is a wonder during the day, with endless lagoons, compositions and awesome skies. A week doesn't feel like enough, truly a place to come back to!

Equipment:

Sony a7IV astromodified

Sony 20mm f/1.8G

Benro Polaris

This is a real image taken by me, tracked, stacked, calibrated and blended, not generative AI involved (if you think it is, try generating it yourself)

https://www.instagram.com/igneis.nightscapes/


r/Astronomy • • 9h ago

Astrophotography (OC) Horsehead & Flame Nebula (Night Vision)

Thumbnail
gallery
52 Upvotes

• AstroShader iso 310 and 3 second exposures x 15.
• The Horsehead and Flame Nebulae
• The Pvs14 Gen 3 monocular night vision device with the following specifications:
• Photocathode Sensitivity: 2058 FOM: 2700
SNR: 37.5 EBI: .7 Halo: .7 Center resolution: 72
• Unfilmed/filmless Gated 18UM 11769 style is also mentioned.
• svbony sv48p 102mm With SVBONY SV188P Telescope Diagonal, 2" 90°Mirror Diagonal 99% Reflectivity
• Sky-Watcher 150i
• Tele Vue 55 mm eyepiece
• Sharpcap polar aligned and synscan pro one star alignment.
• Lightroom minor touches
• Baader H-alpha 2" Narrowband CMOS Optimized 6.5nm Filter


r/Astronomy • • 1d ago

Astrophotography (OC) My first astrophotography - The Andromeda galaxy

Post image
695 Upvotes

r/Astronomy • • 3h ago

Other: [News] A New Milestone for Life on Earth

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
8 Upvotes

r/Astronomy • • 22h ago

Astrophotography (OC) California Nebula - Fun side image for the month

Post image
152 Upvotes

This is kind of a throwaway image. I was short on imaging targets and just had to set something for an unexpected clear night. Typically I like to image really dim targets and put a lot of integration time into them. The California Nebula is not dim. Even with short narrowband images, it simply glows. This image is only 6.6 hours of total integration, half an hour of it is RGB stars. I only captured Ha/SII, didn't bother with OIII. I have imaged this with full SHO before, but you really need to oversample O3 before you can pick up anything.

Posting this here because it is pretty. This isnt the best astro photo you’ll see today, but it is pretty nonetheless. Looks like a campfire flame in the sky. Thanks for looking

For those interested in imaging this target: it is predominantly an HA target, like most nebula. But the S2 signal is really wrong. I imaged this about 40% HA, 60% S2 (mapped to yellow). The S2 is strong enough that I had to tone it down in processing, it’s mostly there to give some accent to the main HA signal. The best images include O3, but you need to seriously over sample that channel if you want to pick anything up.

  • Telescope: Apertura 75Q
  • Camera: QHY Minicam Mono
  • Total Integration: 6.6 hours

r/Astronomy • • 17h ago

Astrophotography (OC) Moon, Southern Highlands.

Post image
62 Upvotes

Sony a6300, Skywatcher 8" dobsonian.

1/500 shutter speed, 500 ISO.

10 image stack, cropped, processed in lightroom.


r/Astronomy • • 8h ago

Astro Art (OC) Commemorating today's milestone from Earth

8 Upvotes

Music by KLF; audio speech from the Golden Record; 3d model by Sidharth1; rendered in Blender and DaVinci Resolve


r/Astronomy • • 1d ago Bravo Heartwarming

Astrophotography (OC) Bubble nebula

Post image
592 Upvotes

Bubble nebula - reprocessed

230 x 5 min OIII

231 x 5 min Halpha

IMX 533 monochrome, -15°

Newton 200/1200, EQ6R

Romania, Bortle 4.5

Pixinsight, Seti Astro, GraXpert, Photoshop


r/Astronomy • • 23h ago

Astro Art (OC) [OC] A little comic I did in honour of Voyager 1’s big milestone coming up in less than 24 hours, where it will reach one light day's distance away from Earth.

Post image
82 Upvotes

r/Astronomy • • 22h ago

Astro Art (OC) Relativistically Beamed Quasar Jet

53 Upvotes

My take on a realistic supermassive black hole in an Active Galactic Nucleus (AGN).

The material in the jet is moving very close to the speed of light, here it is going at 95% lightspeed. At such speeds, special relativity leads to an effect called “Beaming” or ”Doppler Beaming” where the apparent motion of the super-fast gas causes the luminosity along its length to be brighter and perpendicular to its motion to be dimmer, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativistic_beaming for more.

How real is the video? The colours here are realistic, the disc is super hot (10\^6-10\^8K), so it is blue-white to the naked eye. The brightness is dimmed so we can see the central region, making the rest of the disc appear black. Each second of the video covers around 12 minutes in real time. I have also included relativistic redshifting and boosting in the accretion disc, but the variability and extreme temperatures makes this hard to see in practice. I have increased the density of the jet a bit so it’s easier to see. In real life these jets are very diffuse.

Special thanks to my colleague Dr. Michail Chabanov for consulting with me on how best to represent the jet.


r/Astronomy • • 1d ago

Astrophotography (OC) M33

Post image
106 Upvotes

I used a 150PDS, an iOptron GEM28 mount, and a Sony NEX-7 camera. The total exposure time was 17.5 minutes (the forecast promised a clear night, and I had planned for 1 hour and 40 minutes of data, but ended up with only 17.5)—consisting of 70 frames with 15-second exposures at ISO 1600. The location is a Bortle 7 zone. All processing was done in Siril. I didn't have enough time to fully bring out the nebula's spiral arms or to effectively reduce the noise.


r/Astronomy • • 18h ago

Astro Art (OC) Short video I made for Voyager 1’s Light Day

6 Upvotes

Camera work was done by hand; everything was rendered inside Unreal Engine 5.8.


r/Astronomy • • 1d ago

Other: [Topic] An Arabic manuscript astronomy scroll from Persia, dated Ramadan 1215/January-February 1801 sold at Bonham on Nov. 11 for substantially more than the presale high estimate. Reported by Rare Book Hub.

Post image
16 Upvotes

Lot 13 sold for £20,800 ($27,622); presale high estimate £12,000.

Bahreyni Amir 'Abd al-Hamid A manuscript in scroll form on astronomy, calendars and the astrolabe.

Arabic manuscript on paper (several sections joined together), in scroll form, illuminated headpiece, text in thuluth in black ink within cloudbands on an illuminated floral ground, several illuminated roundels representing the planets and their courses, one human figure representing a constellation, inner margins ruled in colours and gold, light blue borders
201 x 17 cm.

See more detailed photos at the original catalog link: https://www.bonhams.com/auction/32278/lot/13/a-manuscript-in-scroll-form-on-astronomy-calendars-and-the-astrolabe-copied-by-amir-abd-al-hamid-bahreyni-persia-dated-ramadan-1215january-february-1801/


r/Astronomy • • 1d ago

Astrophotography (OC) The MOA-II telescope, New Zealand’s largest optical telescope under the summer sky.

Post image
225 Upvotes

IG: @jshmcguigan

With a mirror diameter of 1.8-metres, the MOA-II telescope is New Zealand’s largest optical telescope. Its primary focus is on the MOA (microlensing observations in astrophysics) project, which hunts for gravitational lensing events which can help lead to the discovery of exoplanets!

Shot on Nikon Z6A + Nikkor 20mm F1.8
Sky: 60s F2.5 ISO4000
FG: 60s F1.8 ISO6400


r/Astronomy • • 1d ago

Discussion: [Topic] Let's send a little hello to Voyager from Earth on November 17

Post image
217 Upvotes

I saw this NASA initiative called Voyager: One Light Day, and I genuinely think it's one of the coolest things we could participate in.

For those who don't know, Voyager 1 and 2 have been travelling through space for decades, carrying the Golden Records (a collection of sounds, music, greetings and little pieces of humanity) . In a way, they're carrying a small part of Earth into the unknown.

On November 17, NASA is inviting us to step outside and shine our phone flashlights in Morse code, spelling out Voyager's call sign.

Now, before anyone points it out, Voyager can't actually see us. Its cameras were switched off decades ago to conserve power, and our phone lights obviously won't travel billions of miles through space. But that's not really the point, is it?

It's about sending a symbolic greeting to something humanity built and sent into the unknown. Something that's been travelling farther than almost anything we've ever made, carrying a message about who we are.

I don't know, there's just something incredibly beautiful about thousands of people looking up at the same sky and sending a little hello to a spacecraft that's been out there for longer than many of us have been alive.

Let's take a minute on the 17th and be part of it. ❤️

NASA link: https://science.nasa.gov/specials/apps/voyager-one-light-day/


r/Astronomy • • 23h ago

Astro Research A Stellar Sleeper Agent: Neutrino Detection Prospects of T Coronae Borealis

Thumbnail
aasnova.org
8 Upvotes

r/Astronomy • • 2d ago Heartwarming

Astrophotography (OC) Elephant’s Trunk Nebula

Post image
756 Upvotes

I think I am finally finished my obsession with this beautiful DSO.

It has been a labour of love from both the UK and Cyprus to get this image!

Equipment:

Astromodified Canon 700d
Skywatcher 72 ED DS Pro
Skywatcher AZ GTI in EQ Mode
Optolong L-Enhance Filter
ASI Air Mini
ZWO 120mm Guide Cam with 30mm Guide Scope

175 x 180 sec exposures taken over multiple nights with 20 darks taken each night to match. Using the L-Enhance filter.

120 x 180 sec exposures taken over multiple nights without filter. 20 darks taken each night to match.

20 Flats with and without filter
20 Bias with and without filter

Each night stacked separately then combined using APP.

Used my broadband subs as the luminance channel whilst stacking.

I started with a pretty heavy crop to isolate the trunk section.

BGE, deconvolution and de-noise in Graxpert.

Siril for SPCC.

Star removal using StarNet through Siril.

SHO Palette using VeraLux Alchemy.

GHS using human weighted luminance.

Curves adjustment using VeraLux Curves.

HDR Multiscale.

SCNR in Siril

Recombination of stars.

Slight saturation increase.

Thanks for looking!


r/Astronomy • • 1d ago

Other: [Topic] [PSA] This deserves feather and tar

6 Upvotes

(Ok I was going to post a screen cap of the ad with commentary, but got a rule warning so I took it off.)

Recently I was randomly pushed a gofundme ad about a project that is called "the tate mobile observatory" and if you are interested you can find them on Facebook and gofundme.

What immediately cought my eyes was the fact that the "Orion nebula" and "Andromeda galaxy" and the pleiades are so outlandishly wrong. The issue is not just that the posters are AI generated - I don't like these but whatever, they are everywhere. But my redline is that you should at least start with real images (or accurate illustrations) and simply have AI assemble them into a poster. If necessary, post-process it and replace the AI altered images back to the real one.

To be very clear - I am not calling for review bombing or harassing the organizers. Let's be better than that!

At the same time, I believe it is proper to call them out, and emphasize that anyone who cares so little about science accuracy does not deserve to self proclaim as advocate for science/STEM education and ask for money from the public.

And it is important to remind people that, sadly, such "projects" exist, and it is important to spread the words - please don't give money to them.