r/AttackOnRetards • u/tyatgrancetio • 7h ago
r/AttackOnRetards • u/LadylikeMusex • 10h ago
Leaks I wish Eren's mental state was explored/shown more once he became the founder
r/AttackOnRetards • u/BronzePaladin • 7h ago
Discussion/Question My problem with Eren's supposed stupidity.
One of the explanations that Eren did not attempt to change the future to his liking (to achieve full rumbling and protect the lives of all his friends including Hange) was because he was Idiot, next to grandfather's paradox, his love for his friends and his destructive desires.
I DISAGREE.
Before timeskip Eren showed multiple times that he is not the idiot, when not clouded by his anger , he killed two kidnappers of Mikasa by lulling them into false sense of security and using makeshift spear, he was able to see through false persona of Christa Lenz and he properly deducted that he was able to control use coordinate thanks to physical contact with Dina Fritz. After Timeskip he was many times suprised by events that he did not forsee with his clayvoirance, yet managed to deal with them. He located position of Warhamer's crystal and found the way to crack it. He saw through Pieck's bluff in chapter 116 and later he managed to convince Ymir to help him, by his emotional Speech. Yet, when gifted with immensely powerfull powers of Founder, whose limits are not specified, he allowed Hange to die, himself to be killed (and strip himself of seeing view of 100% of the outside world destroyed), left his friends in middle of postapocalyptic world, that was likely to fall into the war over limited resources and exposed Paradise to very likely retribution. All of that so Ymir could (maybe) lift the curse and make powers of titan dissappear, which was not guarented and he did not know, whether that would happen or not. The fact that his plan worked, was more due to luck than his effort, yet earlier we saw him being quite intelligent and capable of devising solid plans. Combined with his immmense willpower and determination (dude became 5 best soldier in 104th training corpe through sheer grith and literally maimed himself to infiltrate enemy city as cripple) this makes his choices in the last 8 chapters of the manga even more puzzling, especially he was granted vast and god-like powers of the founder. Fo example, he could, erase the memories of Jaegerists, so they would not oppose them in the port, lure alliance to him, erase their memories (like he did in ch 131), disarm them, finish the rumbling, return to Paradise, simulate going mad of the guilt, announce via Paths he is about to destroy the Paradise, allow alliance members free themselv, let Mikasa kill him, curse is (hopefully) lifted in the end. My point is with his vast powers, high willpower and solid inteligence Eren should come with better plan to achieve his 3 main goals: see the full outside world as the blank state devoid of human life, protect his friends, secure Paradise's future. The only reason, I can think why he did not do that was because, he was broken by knowledge that he killed his mother and and due to grandfather paradox was unable to change that , but he would not give up without the fight against the paradox. He would attempt to change the past that did not suit him and fight against it evein in vain. The problem is, we did not see him struggling against paradox and being broken by futility of his efforts, nor we did not see any other explanation why he procedeed with so risky and contrary to all of his goals plan. Equivalent of such sudden explanation would be compressing Reiner's backstory, that lasted few chapters in two pages.