r/AutoCAD • • 3h ago

XREF vs adding a layer(s) to original

6 Upvotes

When an architect provides a DWG floor plan to another designer, such as an HVAC or plumbing designer, what’s the standard practice for adding ductwork or piping layouts?

Is it better to work directly in the architect’s DWG using separate mechanical layers, or create a new DWG and attach the architectural floor plan as an XREF?

For context, the HVAC designer has their own plan sheet template with a title block, legend, and viewport for the duct layout. The architect’s DWG contains only the floor plan, with no paper-space layout or plan sheet.

The designer may also begin offering plumbing drafting in the future, so I’m wondering whether each discipline should have its own DWG, with the architectural floor plan referenced into each, or whether everything can be managed using separate layers in a single drawing.

I’m trying to establish a clean, professional, and repeatable drafting workflow. I’d appreciate hearing how others handle this, particularly when coordinating drawings and exchanging DWGs with architects.