r/AutodeskInventor • u/TBBT-Joel • 13h ago
Tutorial Using AI for Inventor CAD work Analysis. Conclusion: It can handle production jobs. Results inside.
I run a small manufacturing company. Among other things we make aftermarket components for legacy industrial equipment. Think proprietary fittings, collets, clamps and other wear components
Parts can have a 20-40 year service life and we come in when the OEM's stop supporting their equipment or gives the go away price. We now have over 30 years of accumulate drawings across thousands of sku's and a couple different cad programs. We also make semi-custom pieces like a collet with a different bore diameter that is made to order.
Recently I started analyzing Claude 5.5 Opus (and Fable) for automating some of the CAD processes.
Problem 1: Drawing packages. For semi custom collets I need a parametric part file, drawing> STL/STEP, DXF for EDM tool path >> updated I properties with part numbering schema. By hand I can do this in about 5 minutes and 15-30 minutes if I have to modify the original CAD file to make a template file for the part family. It's also easy to forget one of the steps like opening iproperties or sheet template to update a part name.
- Result: I used Claude 5.5 to Spit out the complete drawing package and build macros to automate the process and minimize token cost. Since it's driven from a template and there's no discretion it works 10/10 times and knocks out a package in ~ 2-5 minutes with 1 prompt which is: "Make part [family part name] with X.XXX" bore diameter and output drawing package to new sub folder
- Cost: <$5 in token costs to build the scripts and automation tools and run a half dozen custom jobs
Problem 2: Customers want McMaster-Carr style product dimension drawings and step/STL files for fit checks. Can't use engineering drawing as that would give away all manufacturing data. Problem is there was several hundred variants, some different enough that trying to write a script or do a template cut and paste wouldn't work. I set up one template as a "gold example" and let it run. It produced 100 drawings, and in the same work flow organized 480 sku's and their drawing package and put all their legacy data into one standard folder structure.
- Result: Organized 480 drawings across 30 years of legacy data, provided standard PDM folder structure and did librarian work around rev control. Of the 100 drawings produced about 80% were useable as is. Total time was about 30 min of effort to make standard and follow up on prompts. Estimated human completion for these tasks was bout 16 hours
- Cost: used 700K Tokens in Claude 5.5 Opus ~$10
Problem 3: Machine shop suddenly wanted a model based definition of a helical worm drive gear after a deacde of going off the gear spec on a paper drawing. Drawing showed straight teeth as you don't generally model catalog worm drive gears using a COTS Hob. We argued they said no. so we made the drawing. This was the most complex, I had a drawing that showed all correct geometry but with straight cut teeth. I'm attaching before and after as this is a generic COTS gear profile with a custom spline and nothing is really that proprietary.
- Results: Model 1 shot the entire CAD file and drawing in about 10 minutes. It caught some minor non critical mistakes on the original drawing. It replaced one fillet with a radius in the first attempt and fixed it on prompt 2. Fit checked a 3d printed model and it worked. Human estimate would have been 1-2 hours (I'm not the world's best mechanical designer and had never tried to model helical worm drive gears before).
- Caveat: The feature tree was made in a way no human would do it. Instead of sweeping a single tooth profile on a helical path (then circular pattern) it created ~20 planes over 0.5", wrote a python script to calculate the gear profile on each plane and then lofted between a sketch on all 20 planes. I wouldn't consider this model parametric without having it rerun the python script to calculate the helical profile.
- Cost: 230K tokens =<$3. There's no way I could have paid myself or an engineer to do it at similar cost.
Tools used:
Claude 5.5 opus, Google drive, no custom connectors. Claude built calculators and scripts in Python or macros as needed and ran it's own validation checks. I kept Inventor 2027 open and asked in claude code with a google drive pointed towards the relevant files and background information.
Conclusion:
- Claude Opus can make production drawings and assets that work for CNC shop tolerances (+-0.001")
- It worked well with a given template, paper drawing or example STL file
- These parts are all mathmatically verifiable i.e change a bore to X.XXX" or "make the 14.5 degree helical teeth profile using this COTS Hob and parametric hub profile as starting point". I think open questions like "make a better hinge" or "make me a motor mount" would probably not do as well. I did not ask it to make complex assemblies, these are all single part files.
- Using the MCP and script based tools talking to Inventor it still struggles with dimensioning, lines overlap, lack readability
- We have no integrated claude into our normal work flow. Any rebuttal of "well I could do it faster by hand" didn't hold up to real life data and even if it was possible. Doing 400 repetitive drawing changes woudln't be rewarding design work.
- Claude can recreate and displace PDM type tools. It was able to organize enforce best practices, find latest revisions, review drawings for missing information and other work that a traditional CAD librarian would use. We inherited decades of bad practices, changes in part naming convention, paper drawings with no Cad file, duplicates etc etc. It organized everything in minutes with few mistakes that a human needed to review
- It will succesfully recreate CAD formats. We swapped Solidworks to Inventor from Step files/PDF 2D drawings. I think the biggest advantage will be able to get out of vendor locked profiles. I assume soon we'll see open source tools to downgrade CAD versions, Swap from vendor to vendor and some will not need a license without running afoul of any law or reverse engineering the CAD software. I think the days of having a simple 1 sketch drawing from 2027 not being able to open in 20XX will be over soon, which was obviously always an anti consumer practice to force you to buy the latest version.
This post was written by hand. I'm not selling anything or promoting my company just wanted to give an actual writeup for my review. My take away is that CAD tasks are where software engineering was 1-2 years ago "this is cool but it can't take my job". I have a feeling it will only get better from here until it can do most CAD related tasks that are well defined and verifiable and knock out much busy work and upkeep work.