r/BEFire • • 7h ago

Brokers Elderly renter with €700K: 100% stock ETF? And prepare for wealth transfer to children

1 Upvotes

TLDR: Help for elderly lady in Flanders with 700K cash after house sale, needs ~1K/month on top of pension, 2 kids. Plan: invest 600-700K in one accumulating world ETF (IMIE/SPYI) via MeDirect (free) or Bolero, lump sum or 50K/month, then years later move to Bolero in her own name and gift to 2 kids either full ownership (0% or 3% if registered to kill 5-year risk) or bare ownership with usufruct (notary + split account). Question: crazy to go 100% stocks at her age, and does anyone know a cheap broker that actually allows gifts to another person and usufruct splits?

Hi all,
This is not for myself but trying to help an elderly person who has:

  • realised that the investments she has with the bank are not gaining her much
  • Just sold her house (now renting an apartment) so an additional significant amount of cash
  • A pension but needs to use about €1000 of her capital per month for her expenses. (In a normal year that could easily be covered by yearly gains on her capital rather than the capital itself, even when discounting for inflation).
  • 2 kids, who like her are based in Flanders.
  • started to think about transferring to the next generation but not ready to do that now

The reason the investments with the bank are not gaining her much is that the bank is adding a lot of costs, and the mostly defensive nature of the investments. I can perfectly understand why a bank would recommend an elderly woman to invest defensively, but if you have €700K and need about €1000 of it per month, then I would argue her investment horizon is not HER lifetime, but rather about preserving the wealth for the next generation in which case 100% stocks via ETFs would seem like a good approach. And even if they would crash 50% there would still be enough left for her monthly needs.

Now the approach I would recommend for the investment part of the approach is the following:

  • invest the full 700K (or 600K if she wants 100K on the side for piece of mind)
  • in IMIE/SPYI to keep it simple, great spread with a single ETF. Though maybe a bit heavy on US and technology/AI stocks.
  • A distributing ETF would be logical as a source of income, but given how they are taxed in Belgium I believe accumulating ETFs like IMIE/SPYI remain the better choice and then she simply has to sell some ETFs every now and then.
  • Either invest it all in one go (time in the market beats timing the market) or eg 50K per month (so spread at list a little bit the risk, while not being 'out of the martket' for too long).
  • Belgian broker to keep it simple for her (TOB, capital gains tax...).
  • Either invest in Medirect (belgian, €0 commission), or in Bolero (costlier but the only one I could find that allows for the future wealth transfer based on what I could research).

Wealth transfer some years into the future:

  • Inheritance tax would likely reach the top 27% bracket, so a gift before she departs would seem the better choice.
  • If she chose Medirect, then open a Bolero account in her name, transfer the ETFs from Medirect to Bolero (Medirect charges €50 and Bolero reimbursed €20 so costs €30 net).
  • Then transfer from her Bolero account to 2 bolero accounts (one for each child).
  • Either full ownership, Bolero charges €0, state also charges €0 if she only gifts via pacte adjoint, or 3% if she registers via MyMinfin to avoid the need to stay alive 5 years.
  • Or bare ownership, where she'd keep the usufruct. Income wise this is pointless as IMIE/SPYI is accumulating so no dividends, but it would give her more control to ensure the stocks are not sold to go on expensive cruises 😄 Would require a notarial deed, then opening of the split account where the capital account is in the kids name and the income account in her name.
  • Possibly the Bolero step could be skipped and all can be done with Medirect but this is unclear: "Effectentransfer: Aanvragen waarbij er een wijziging zou zijn van uiteindelijke begunstigde, zoals bij een successie of een schenking, worden per geval beoordeeld."
  • keep her income for monthly expenses safe in both gift scenarios: for full ownership this has to be a fixed charge in the gift papers, for example the kids must pay her 1.000 euro per month, indexed each year, enforceable even after the gift, because you cannot keep usufruct in a simple bank gift (would need to research that more). For bare ownership with usufruct a minimum of 2 to 3% per year, plus a welfare clause that the kids top up if she needs care.

What do you think?

  • She doesn't need a lot per month from that capital (€1000/month), should she put €100K aside or invest the full €700K?
  • Am I crazy to recommend an elderly lady to invest in 100% stock ETF?
  • She is aware of the alternative to invest (some) of the capital in real estate but is also aware of the hassle of managing real estate. Splitting the wealth between real estate and liquid assets does have an important benefit in terms of inheritance tax as the tax brackets are applied separately.
  • Do you know of other cheap brokers that allow transferring stocks to a different person and allow a split of bare ownership/usufruct?