Hear me out. Sure, we're supposed to be as primitive as possible in the BW. However, every decent tree branch that makes a decent hang has already been sawed by 100 ropes. Mostly they are either dead or gone. Sometimes I've struggled 45 minutes or more with a manky, inadequate bear piñata. In recent years I've given up on hangs altogether, and go with ursacks + smelly proof bags + blue barrels (which the North American Bear Center tells us dramatically reduced bear encounters, blue barrels being smelly proof but not bear resistant).
EDIT: The blue barrels I use are ONLY for a handy container to keep my ursacks dry and easily portaged. I am not advocating using blue barrels alone. It is well documented by North American Bear Center in Ely that they do reduce bear encounters, by containing smells, but they don't meet the rules alone. I use them as a second line of defense after my ursacks and smelly bags.
In addition to a fire circle, what if the Park services placed a high cable between prominent trees, for the purpose of throwing over your bear hang rope? Many other parks have started to do this. Other parks provide actual bear lockers. Maybe lockers are a bridge too far for the BW. But cables would be inobtrusive, and likely reduce bear problems more than the current requirements that many groups slack off on one way or another. They try to make a proper bear hang with the best of intentions and by the time they are done, it's about 11 feet off the ground hanging next to a perfect ladder tree.
What's your opinion on the idea of permanent bear hang cables?
EDIT: One post estimated the cost of outfitting all 2000 BW campsites at a million bucks. He's not far wrong, which is a key argument against the idea, along with burdensome labor. I'd argue for picking 50 most-used sites closest to popular entry points, or sites that repeatedly get problem bears for whatever reason. I'm sure a reasoned study by the forest service would be required for such a radical change. I, for one, think it might be worth the cost if it reduces the number of bears that must be euthanized.
None of this would ever happen without us advocating for it. Would it be worth it in your opinion?