r/BaseBuildingGames • u/loulo88 • 6h ago
Self Promo/Dev Post Design question: should buildings slowly wear down and need upkeep, or stay permanent once built?
Hi all, I'm on the small team making Forgebound, a medieval survival city builder (Early Access is planned for 2028, so this is still very much on the drawing board).
We keep going back and forth on building upkeep. Two directions:
- Upkeep: walls, houses and workshops slowly wear down and need wood, stone and a worker's time to stay in shape. Expanding also means committing to maintain it, so a sprawling base has a real cost.
- Permanent: once built, it stays built unless a raid or a fire damages it. Your attention goes to growth and threats instead of chores.
Upkeep can make expansion a real decision, but in some games it turns into busywork you click through on autopilot. Permanent buildings feel good, but they can make the late game feel solved.
Which base builders handled this well for you, and which made it a chore? Is there a middle ground you liked, like only certain buildings decaying, or wear only kicking in after damage?
Disclosure: I'm part of the dev team. Steam page if you're curious: https://store.steampowered.com/app/3691400/?utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=community&utm_content=ext-basebuildinggames-1118