r/BatmanBeyond • u/Lysandermia • 2h ago
A philosophical question: Is the Joker in Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker actually the Joker?
I understand that the Batman Beyond-era Joker isn't some heavy-duty AI coupled with computer vision and robotics. He literally emerges from a chip containing his own DNA. However, DNA isn't synonymous with consciousness, nor does retaining someone's memories necessarily mean you've recreated their consciousness.
So is this genuinely the Joker, some kind of clone, or Tim assuming his physical traits and then descending into some form of psychosis or dissociative identity disorder? I lean towards the latter (increasingly so as I've got older). Back when I was a kid, I just saw him as a Star Wars-style clone.
Would be interested to find out how you guys interpret this incarnation of the Joker...