I am new to real woodworking but I have a fair amount of general knowledge/experience from working with my Dad. This is my first real project that I didn't really plan on becoming what it is now but sort of snowballed into this once I started to build a "simple" workshop type table.
I'm still working on finishing the top and eventually the shelves on the long upper + lower stretchers. Originally I had picked up some "scrap" maple panels from my local Rockler that had already been planed but ripping them on the edges to glue them up made them cup and bow in ways I wasn't comfortable moving forward with, so I got a sheet of 3/4" MDO from my local store to use as a top instead.
The frame itself here is all hand done. What turned this project from a miter-and-screw job into this was trying to get the frame square and coplanar, which lead to me getting a jointer. And then I wanted to try my hand at a mortise and tenon joint. At some point I decided my goal was to try and use no hardware, only glue and hand joints and that was sort of my driving force.
The rectangular frame itself I made from old growth 2x4s from demoing a room in my house. After milling them a bit, they were so pretty and straight I wanted to use them for something. I'm not fully sure what the exact names of each type of joint is called so forgive me if I get some wrong. For the frame, the ends are joined with a blind mortise and tenon. The legs are two 2x4s that were half-lapped on one end to create a U-joint that the frame sits in. Like I mentioned, this sort of snowballed as it went, so one issue I ran into was that even though the frame rails were jointed square with one face, I did not rip the opposite edge square or plane them (at the time I didn't have access to or think I needed a planer). So when I dropped the frame into the U joints, the legs did not sit square to the frame and I had to adjust them with my chisel and then lock them in place with the triangle blocks in the corners.
That was also probably my next major mistake? Attaching the legs to the frame before I cut the lap joints for the stretchers. It certainly made making sure the laps aligned correctly was easier since the legs were already set but it made cutting the laps way more difficult, especially the short ones, because I had to shift the entire frame around to get in position to cut them. I "cheated" on the leg laps and used my circ saw to remove stock to the right depth and then chiseled them flat on the legs.
For the stretcher laps I just used a tablesaw with the miter slide and then the same. This was where I learned another lesson specifically about chisels - make sure your chisel is FLAT and SHARP. I bought a Narex chisel for this project and maybe incorrectly assumed it would be both out of the box and when cutting the first several laps, was finding it incredibly hard to get it truly flat. It caused me to keep taking more and more stock trying to get it flat when the problem was that my chisel wasn't flat enough or sharp enough. Once I flattened the back and sharpened it, that problem went away and getting the laps flat was much easier.
Once I had cut all the laps in all the legs + stretchers, I dry fit everything together and checked to see the table frame was still square/coplanar. This is where I also realized a mistake I had made which was not dry fitting all the stretchers together when I marked the lap joints on the legs. The joint placement on the legs were fine but the markings I had made on the stretchers caused me to cut the shoulders a bit short to where they didn't meet the leg. I cut pieces to fit the gaps and glued them to the leg to correct this. I also went through with a feeler gauge across all the joints with light clamp pressure to see that I was close enough for things to be glued.
After checking everything probably 50 times to make sure I hadn't missed something, I finally worked up the courage to glue everything together. Clamped all the joints together and used a pipe clamp to make sure the shoulders stayed tight during the drying phase.
Everything glued up well, frame is rigid and square. I plan for this table to live outdoors but in a covered area so while all of this was going on, I applied Outdoor Oil from General Finishes to most of the pieces that were not going to be glued and then the rest after gluing took place, with extra attention to any exposed butt-ends like the feet.
If you see the blueprint style plan at the end, you may notice that for the top, I plan to have substrate 2x4s beneath the MDO top for extra support but also to accommodate stuff like dog holes. I plan to attach the MDO top via washer head screws through clearance holes in the substrate boards into pre-drilled holes under the tabletop after I paint the top. The substrate boards I just kept simple and screwed into the frame on each end. Obviously that breaks my "no hardware" rule but this project has gone on a lot longer than expected and I really need a table to work on, lol.
Full disclosure, it didn't start this way but I ended up using GPT pretty heavily to help me plan/design and then adjust as things came up and moved forward. It was extremely useful but even I, as an amateur, noticed that some of the info it gave me wasn't always correct as far as the best way forward in a situation. My guiding principles for the table was that it needed to survive the 4 seasons in a covered scenario without me needing to rebuild it after a year. I wanted it to be long lasting, sturdy, and stable enough that it "feels like it was grown out of the ground, like a tree". I also wanted space to store tools and it helped me figure all of that out and discuss tradeoffs.
So I think in conclusion, the general tips I would pass along to other new people I learned from this are:
- Be prepared to make mistakes and understand that 99.9% of them can just be fixed pretty simply
- An ounce of planning saves a pound of work
- Have the right tools - make sure things are sharp, have the right blade for the right cuts, etc.
- You can always take more away but it's way harder to put some back
- Understand the meaning of flat, coplanar, square, and level
I just wanted to share my work and maybe inspire someone thinking they can't into feeling like they can. The whole thing has been a huge learning experience for me on top of being fun. Happy to answer any questions if anyone has some!