r/BehavioralEconomics • • 9h ago

Media Does a membership fee make you spend more? Sunk cost fades after you pay, but a second effect may not (Costco as the case)

7 Upvotes

Two effects that often get mixed up, using Costco as the example:

  1. Sunk cost. The classic study is Arkes & Blumer (1985). Theatre-goers who’d paid full price for a season ticket went to more of the first five plays than people given a discount, but not the last five. The pull fades as the payment gets older (Gourville & Soman 1998 found the same with gym fees).
  2. Fee → “the prices must be good”. Lee & Norton (HBS working paper, 2007, unpublished, small samples) suggest that paying a fee on its own makes people assume the prices inside are better, and spend more. It isn’t sunk cost: in their studies the fee was paid at the same time as the shopping, not months before.

So a membership pulls two ways: one pull fades after the renewal, the other doesn’t. The scale is real: Costco’s fees add up to nearly two-thirds of its profit (10-K, fiscal 2026).

Two questions for people here:

  • Has anyone seen data on whether members spend less later in their membership year, as the sunk-cost fade would predict?
  • Does anyone know a published replication of the fee → better-prices result? I couldn’t find one.

I made an animated explainer of this, with all sources in the description: https://youtu.be/efui0ji_pSs