Penny Lane, a well-known antique store in downtown Bellingham, was recently the site of a what was allegedly a profiling incident involving a Mexican American family and the store's white business owners, Lyndsey Berglund and her family*.
Josephine Sidwell is a 70-year-old mother of four and grandmother of 12. She is a lifelong farm worker and survivor, closely associated with recovery circles in the Bellingham community. On the day Lyndsey Berglund, owner of Penny Lane, targeted her—rudely asking, "Are you going to pay for those?" while gesturing toward Josephine's brand-new pair of Nike Air Force 1s—Josephine was en route to a treatment facility she had waited months to enter. One of the last items she wanted to purchase for her journey, with her tightly budgeted SSI check, was a harmonica to play as she and her late father once did.
After this incident, because her mother was so distraught, Hanah Warthan—Josephine's daughter and a counselor at Recovery Café—went to Penny Lane to demand an apology and address the offensive behavior. Lyndsey Berglund refused to apologize, insisting she was simply being vigilant and that Josephine was caught on surveillance cameras. Hanah presented a receipt from the Nike store where the shoes were purchased the previous week, along with the box and bag. Josephine's daughter repeatedly asked for an apology, but neither Lyndsey nor her brother who was present, offered one.
Later, Lyndsey posted an "apology to the public" on Penny Lane's social media pages. When Recovery Café staff, on behalf of Josephine's family, visited Penny Lane to offer an olive branch and suggest a meeting at the Whatcom Dispute & Resolution Center, store ownership refused.
On Sunday, Cascadia Daily News published a guest commentary by Lyndsey Berglund, in which she repeated the same narrative: that she was the victim of shoplifting. "Unlike large corporations," Lyndsey writes, "most local businesses don't have enormous financial reserves or shareholders to fall back on. When our expenses increase, we can't simply absorb them forever." From reduced staffing hours to increased surveillance, she frames these issues and more as community problems requiring empathy "on both sides."
"There is a difference between profiling someone because of who they are and observing someone's behavior because a business is trying to protect itself. That distinction deserves a thoughtful conversation rather than immediate condemnation from either side," Lyndsey writes. Only problem is, Lyndsey was not the victim of shoplifting that day. At least not by Josephine Sidwell. Furthermore, Lyndsey has shown no interest in having a conversation with those she harmed, she appears interested only in gaining public favor.
A sincere apology goes a long way, Lyndsey. 'How to offer a genuine apology’ might not be taught in MBA programs, but anyone entering journalism should learn that correction notes are essential for building trust. And that can only be good for business, right?
*The Whatcom County Property Report Card lists the Penny Lane property at an assessed value of $863,788, owned by Richard and Debra Berglund—presumably Lyndsey's parents.