r/BestofRedditorUpdates • u/Direct-Caterpillar77 • 12h ago
NEW UPDATE My husband is in love with his student. I have no fucking idea what to do. (New 2 Year Update)
I am not The OOP, OOP is u/No-Faithlessness7067
My husband is in love with his student. I have no fucking idea what to do.
Thanks to u/Choice_Evidence1983 for finding the update
TRIGGER WARNING: infidelity, abuse of authority
Original Post Apr 18, 2024
My husband and I (both 35 rn) met in college. We fell in love and got married 8 years back. I gave birth to our daughter in 2020. My husband is a professor at this med school (he’s a doctor himself). My friend, Sarah, also works in the same college and she’s in the same department as my husband.
Few months back(in December), Sarah took me out for lunch and told me that she suspected something’s going on between my husband and this med student (25f). She claimed she’d seen both of them give ‘yearning looks’ to each other. She said that she’s known my husband for so long, and she’d never seen him talk to any other woman like this, that he’d been so aloof around women all these years, but it’s just different with this one girl.
In that moment, I had laughed at her face. I remember telling her that she’s jumping to conclusions based on these supposed ‘yearning looks’.
“That’s why I didn't tell you before", she had said,"I was confused too. It's not like he goes out of his way to talk to her but whenever they do talk, it’s like watching a slow burn romance movie. She looks at him like he’s Brad Pitt and he looks at her the way he used to look at you.” I remember the exact word’s because they stung. Internally I was breaking down, externally I just smiled and told her that she’s probably overthinking.
That night, I casually mentioned this my husband. I was laughing at the absurdity, and I expected him to join in. And deny the wild possibility that he’s in love with a student. But he didn’t. Instead he looked at me, all teary eyed, and said ‘I’m sorry’.
“ I can’t get her out of my mind. I’ve tried, trust me. I should’ve told you sooner. But I thought I could save our relationship, I really wanted to.”
I asked him if he’d cheated on me. He said no. He said he didn’t even talk to her, nor did they have any contact outside of college and that he completely understood how morally depraved it is to try and pursue a relationship with a student. She wrote him a letter about an year back, confessing her love for him and he had told her that even tho he was into her, nothing would come out of it. Aparently that was when the ‘yearning looks’ had started.
I honestly don’t remember how I reacted then. I think I just started packing and came to live with my parents along with my daughter. I’ve been living with my parents since then. Half of me wanted him to come and beg for forgiveness. But he never did. He comes by sometimes to spend time with our daughter but that’s it. He never talks about the elephant in the room nor do I bring it up.
I keep checking that girl’s social media. She’s insanely beautiful, almost doll like, and intelligent. I can’t help but think that someone like him should be with someone like her. He’s always been very good looking and I’m more of a plain Jane. She’s the Meredith to his Derek.
I don’t know what to do. What do I even tell people? I don’t even know who I am without him. Some part of me still wants him to come back.
Edit; I’ve decided to talk to him. I know I’ve been avoiding this since months but after reading all the responses, I feel it’s time I rip that bandaid out. I’m going over to our house. I’ll update on what happens.
TL;DR husband just admitted that he’s in love with this young woman who also his student. She loves him too.
RELEVANT COMMENTS
MossValley
So he didn't actually cheat? He has a crush,? If I'm understanding that right he hasn't betrayed you yet. Crushes sometimes happen that doesn't mean the relationship is over. Get therapy with him.
OOP
I mean, cheating for me isn’t just physical. He’s had crushes in the past and I’ve had crushes in the past but we’d always been upfront and then laughed about it.
This one feels like a betrayal because he was attracted to someone for more than an year, this someone gave him a freaking love letter, he told her that he’s attracted to her, and not once did he mention it to me. That’s a huge breach of trust for me and I don’t think I can look past it.
OOP Added more about her friend Sarah and what she observed
I know. He said he entirely stopped interacting with her after the letter incident. It does seem absurd but even my friend, Sarah corroborated this. She said he never went out of his way to talk to her before, and then almost entirely stopped talking. Given that Sarah and him are in the same department 24/7, and that she noticed something as small as them giving each other looks, I’m sure she would’ve noticed anything out of the ordinary. I’ve had access to his phone and his passwords throughout and he wasn’t texting or calling her either.
That’s why this feels weird lol.
Update Apr 20, 2024 (2 days later)
Link to previous post ; https://www.reddit.com/r/relationships/s/hw3M65WUVH
For those who don’t wanna read the boring details : In short, I have decided to go ahead with the divorce.
Long story: The day I made the post, I met up with Sarah for dinner. I thanked her for telling me about my husband and the student, and also for being such a good friend.
I asked her about my husband. She said there’s nothing unusual. He’s been a bit withdrawn and aloof with everyone lately but that’s about it.
Yesterday I went over to my house unannounced. He was there alone in his office. I told him I wanted to talk. He said he’ll explain everything.
So apparently this woman has had a crush on him since two years; her friends ‘ship’ her with him. She would stare at him during her rotations and would blush whenever he looked or talked to her. Back then, he didn’t think much of it. Many girls have had crushes on him and he always ignored it.
About 1.5 years back, they were in the same research group thing (I don’t know how this works but there were 5-6 people along with these two). Because of this, they had to spend some time together working, and it was then that he started noticing her. He went into detail about how he was impressed with her intelligence blah blah blah and her beauty blah blah blah. The moment he realised that he had a crush on her, he dropped out of the research thing. This was a year ago.
Few weeks later, she gave him the letter confessing that she has feelings for him. The first thing he told her after reading it was ‘you can get into trouble because of this’. She didn’t care. She wanted an answer. ‘Is it all in my head’ she had asked, to which he replied with ‘it’s not just in your head, but nothing can come out of it. I hope you understand.’
That was the last time they interacted. According to him, the ‘yearning looks’ Sarah described were more of ‘awkward eye contacts’ than anything else. He told me that even though he is still attracted to her, he has no intention of pursuing any sort of relationship with her regardless whether we stay together or not. He said he’s willing to change his job and go to therapy. I told him to give me sometime to think about it.
To sum up;
- This has been going on since three years. Not once did he mention anything to me.
2. The student and him spent a considerable amount of time last year working on the research.
3. He told her he liked her back lol.
4. He’s still very much attracted to her
And that’s why I’ve decided to go ahead with a divorce. I don’t think I can trust this man again. And a relationship without trust isn’t something I am interested in. I’ve told my parents about it. They’re not exactly on board but they’re still supportive. I’ve also contacted my lawyer about the same. It’s gonna be a long process, I believe.
That’s it. I believe this is my last update.
TL; DR ; he’s still attracted to her; I won’t ever trust him again. We’re getting a divorce.
RELEVANT COMMENTS
ChanceReason6617
I'ts a crush! He is not in love.
OOP
That doesn’t matter. He crossed a line he shouldn’t have by telling her he likes her.
_thisisnotanexit
Literally I can’t believe these comments. He’s gushing about her beauty and intelligence, he told her the feeling was mutual?! He could have easily denied it to her and then kept his distance but he liked the attention.
OOP
I mean, to be fair to him, he wasn’t exactly ‘gushing’ about her. I kept asking and he kept answering.
Deal breaker for me was him telling her the feeling is mutual.
~
allbutluk
Lmao these dumbass comments “you too hasty its a cruuuuush chill”
Like stfu the man literally said “I CANT GET HER OUT OF MY HEAD”
If he was commited to his wife he would have changed job PROACTIVELY not wait until now
He let it develop to a point he cant take his mind off of her and yall saying its no big deal, you guys obviously never had a real relationship
OOP
He said he didn’t change his job earlier because, quote ‘I’m a doctor and there are people counting on me. I couldn’t just walk out on them one day.’
Rn too he said he’s willing to change is job if ‘that’s what it takes to make you stay’.
I can’t get over my ex husband being in love with his student. It’s eating me up inside. July 21, 2024 (3 months later)
For context; my ex husband is a doctor and he was in love with his student for years. She was into him too and wrote him a love letter etc. When I confronted him, he told me it was a crush and that he put a stop to it as soon as he could, and that nothing physical ever happened, but the damage was done. You can read the posts on my account if you’re interested but that’s the gist. Nothing more there.
So I decided to take our daughter and permanently move to my parents house. We’re in the middle of separating now. A lot of people have told me to forgive him, and I’ve myself debated if I’m taking the correct step or not, but the trust is gone and I don’t think I want to be in a relationship with someone like him.
It’s taking a lot of strength to do this. I have lost all self esteem. Fact is that I was always insecure of how my ex was way above my league, about how I was lucky to have him, how people often said he could’ve done so much better. Over the years, my insecurities had disappeared. Now it’s all back. He’s attracted to someone so beautiful, so incredibly intelligent. And obviously she’s also into him. I keep looking at her social media all the time, obsessing over her. There was a Instagram story she uploaded where she was with my ex husband and few others, and it felt like someone stabbed me in the heart. He looked happy, and he’d never looked that happy in years.
I got tired of being pathetic and even complained to the hospital management about the inappropriate relationship between her and my ex. All I got in response was that they can’t take any steps without concrete proof. Now my sad ass wants to snitch about her to her parents. To get her in trouble. To make her suffer.
I know this is unhealthy. I’m in therapy but idk, I don’t think I’m healing. I hate that I have to be sad and heartbroken over that man and he doesn’t seem to care. He’s stopped coming to visit our daughter too. I wish he would’ve cared. I wish he would’ve fought for me. I wish he would’ve not tossed aside our decade long relationship for her. I hate this. I hate everything.
RELEVANT COMMENTS
MayorCharlesCoulon
If you wanted to go full petty, you could out them to her training program. Medical schools and teaching institutions frown on faculty/learner romantic relationships and consider it an abuse of power. Your husband likely had to formally evaluate her and she him, their affair (even emotional) would tip the fairness of those evals compared to the other students. I have seen married doctors fired for this kind of behavior.
Also, tell her parents. She sure as shit didn’t mind hurting you or your daughter, don’t roll over because of a misplaced sense of loyalty to your d-bag ex.
OOP
I did reach out to her training program. They basically told me that they can only take steps if I have any tangible proof. Which I don’t. I asked my friend Sarah who works in the same department as him to also complain but she’s not keen on the idea. Idk why.
Final comment from OOP
I feel like I’ve already wasted so many years on him. We met when we were 20. I thought I knew him so well but now it’s like I didn’t know him at all. I don’t understand what’s changed tbh. He’s a very good looking guy. All throughout our relationship, there have been many girls who had had crushes on him. He used to be so chill about all of it. Never made me feel insecure. Never lost his mind like this. Idk what’s happened honestly.
Does the ex FaceTime or contact the daughter
It’s a one hour flight. He does face time with her daily but he won’t do it if I’m in the room (so he does it when my mom/dad is looking after her). He’s not reached out about alone time; he’s only said he’s waiting for the court orders regarding the custody. He doesn’t wanna see me at all. We had a big fight after I reported him and that girl to her college and he said it’s not correct for our daughter to see us fighting like that again so he’s not gonna visit.
UPDATE : I found the love letter my husband’s student wrote him. Should I take it to the authorities? Aug 5, 2024
I posted about two weeks back. I had to back to my ex husband’s city as per my lawyer’s suggestion. My mom and sister are living temporarily with me and we have rented an apartment.
Yesterday I went over to my old house that I shared with my ex to get some of my stuff. I texted him about it and he made sure he wasn’t there when I arrived. I collected all my stuff. Then I decided to look through his study. Yes, I know it’s snooping and it’s wrong but whatever. We I don’t know what I expected to find there but, lo and behold, I found the letter the student wrote to him. It was callously thrown in between some of his work files. I took a picture of the letter and came back.
I did read the letter, and it was nauseating to say the least. She’d written how she knew it was wrong and that he was married blah blah but she felt she had a ‘connection’ with him and that she’d never forgive herself if she didn’t tell him how she feels. That’s the gist but it basically goes on for 2 pages. That stupid girl even made sure to sign the letter lol.
The letter confirms few things;
- My ex did NOT lie about there being no physical affair. Cause in the letter she was lamenting about the fact that she would love to jump his bones but the opportunity never presented.
- He did stop interacting with her abruptly cause she was sad about that too.
- He did lie to me about the letter. When I asked him all those months back, he told me he ‘got rid of the letter cause it was of no consequence’. He kept it in his study. A place where he only keeps the most important of his stuff. A place where even family pictures weren’t allowed cause they ‘can’t let him concentrate’. A place where even I wasn’t allowed when he was working.
Now that I have the letter, I have proof of the inappropriate conduct between a professor and a student. Last time I tried reporting, the authorities wanted proof. Now I have it. So I’m considering re-reporting the issue, with solid proof this time. I’m not gonna involve my friend Sarah in this cause she’s made it clear that she doesn’t want to be a part of this at all.
One part of me wants to report them and fuck them over but the other part just wants to let it go. Any advice on how to proceed?
Edit : I’m not gonna report them. It’s fine.
RELEVANT COMMENTS
Ready_Wolverine_7603
His action seems to be that he stopped interacting with her and I fail to see how that's illegal in any way shape or form.
You're acting petty and needlessly cruel and snooping through his study when he wasn't there was a break of his trust. Try to get the therapy you need to move on and leave it at that.
Of course it's not entirely impossible that he knows your character and has set up a camera in his study because he assumed that you would rifle through confidential documents given the chance, but in that case I'm sure you'll hear from his lawyer and then you can still present the letter you found, whatever good you think it will do you
OOP
A. I have never, in the 15 years of knowing him, have gone through his personal stuff. To comment on my character is uncalled for.
B. His trust? He fell in love with another woman and failed to mention it for three freaking years. He told her he was into her (because he owed her honesty for whatever reason according to him) but failed to mention this to his own wife. I’m sorry but I don’t give a flying fuck about his trust now.
~
more_weight
If anything, this letter exonerates your ex. He didn’t act on it.
OOP
And the girl? I wish I could show you the letter. The disrespect of going after a married guy. The audacity of writing things like she wishes our child was never born so he could leave me easily and wouldn’t have to be tied to me throughout life. That alone should’ve warranted more of a response from him. The fact that after reading all that bs, about our marriage and our kid, all he told her was ‘you can get into trouble for this’ is crazy.
What was in the letter
She wrote things like how she wished our child was never born to begin with, so that he could have an easy separation and wouldn’t have to be tied to me forever. I wish I could show you the letter. I’m not even typing half of it here. It was nauseating.
Redhaired103
Her shitty behavior is on her, your behavior is yours. If your ex can develop a crush on a barely-adult like this, he's not emotionally mature either.
Think of it this way, you're going to be free from someone who does not love you and probably going through a mid-life crisis. All the possibilities are in your future if you just close this chapter. Your focus needs to be on yourself, on your own healing and your own life.
OOP
Yeah I understand that. I’ve decided to let it go.
NEW UPDATE
Update 4 Nov 12, 2026 (2 years later)
It’s been over two years since my original posts, and I thought I’d come back with an update.
For anyone who doesn’t remember, my husband was a doctor and professor who developed feelings for one of his medical students. He admitted that the attraction was mutual, although he maintained that nothing physical had happened between them. I eventually decided to divorce him.
Our divorce was finalized towards the end of last year.
I’ve moved to my parents’ city, and our daughter now spends holidays with her father. My ex-husband and I don’t communicate much beyond what’s necessary for our daughter.
I’m generally doing well. I’ve been focusing on myself, rebuilding my life, and trying to move forward.
As for my ex-husband and his student, they’re together now.
Yup. Properly together.
She has graduated from his medical college and has apparently taken some time off before pursuing higher studies. I don’t know the exact timeline of their relationship, but from what I understand, they got together after she graduated. I don’t know what sort of ethical rules are being broken here and frankly, i do not care.
Sarah, my friend who works in the same department as him, has told me a few things too. Apparently, he’s constantly on his phone texting her, and she sometimes drops by to see him.
He’s also become a very happy, smiley person, which is interesting because I remember spending the entirety of our relationship with a man whose default expression was somewhere between grumpy and mildly inconvenienced.
Apparently, everyone is always gushing about how he managed to land such a beautiful woman. I imagine that’s doing wonders for his ego.
From everything I’ve heard, he seems happier than he ever was with me.
I’m not going to pretend that doesn’t sting a little.
But the most difficult part of this whole situation has actually been our daughter.
When she visits her father during the holidays, his girlfriend is there too. And apparently, she’s absolutely wonderful to my daughter.
My daughter comes home excitedly telling me about their trips and vacations, how nice this woman is, how she helps her with makeup, buys her pretty dresses, and does all sorts of things with her.
Sometimes I genuinely feel like my daughter adores her more than she adores me.
I know that’s probably irrational. I know children get excited about people who spoil them, especially when they’re on holiday. But knowing that intellectually doesn’t necessarily make it any easier to hear.
And yes, I remember what this woman wrote in that letter I found. She wished my daughter had never been born because it would have made things easier between her and my husband.
Well, I suppose she doesn’t regret my daughter being born quite so much now that she gets to play house with her father. Funny how that works.
But seriously, I’m glad she’s treating my daughter well. As much as I dislike the circumstances, I would never want someone to be unkind to my child.
I don’t want to poison my daughter’s relationship with her father or his girlfriend. She’s too young to understand the circumstances surrounding our divorce, and I have no intention of making her carry any of that.
So when she comes home excitedly telling me about her holidays, I listen. I smile. I ask her questions. I let her be happy.
And sometimes, privately, it hurts more than I’d like to admit.
I suppose another strange part of all this is seeing how happy my ex-husband apparently is.
For years, I knew him as a rather grumpy, serious man. Now I’m hearing about someone who’s constantly smiling, texting his girlfriend, and generally acting like a lovestruck teenager. It’s difficult not to wonder why I never got that version of him.
I don’t regret divorcing him. I genuinely don’t. I couldn’t have continued in a marriage where I felt that my husband was in love with someone else.
I’m doing well. There are just moments when the whole thing still feels incredibly unfair.
Anyway, that’s where things stand. He’s happy, she’s happy, and I’m trying to build a life that makes me happy too.
I hope everyone who was kind to me during that awful period is doing well. I really appreciated the support back then.
**TL;DR:** Divorced my husband last year. He’s now dating his former student, and they seem very happy together. She treats our daughter wonderfully, which is both reassuring and painful given our history. I’m doing well and don’t regret leaving, but some things still hurt.
THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP
DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7