r/Bitcoin • • 12h ago

Daily Discussion, November 18, 2026

20 Upvotes

Please utilize this sticky thread for all general Bitcoin discussions! If you see posts on the front page or /r/Bitcoin/new which are better suited for this daily discussion thread, please help out by directing the OP to this thread instead. Thank you!

If you don't get an answer to your question, you can try phrasing it differently or commenting again tomorrow.

Please check the previous discussion thread for unanswered questions.


r/Bitcoin • • 13m ago

My Crypto Alphabet Adventure - CB

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I wrote My Crypto Alphabet Adventure, a short alphabet book that explains basic cryptocurrency terms in a kid-friendly language.
One letter = one simple concept. Colorful, easy to read, and designed to make the topic less intimidating.
You can find it here if you’re interested: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0F8W1P9ZW
Would love to hear what you think!


r/Bitcoin • • 24m ago

Have I missed the bottom…

0 Upvotes

Where is everyone who thought I was crazy for asking now ?


r/Bitcoin • • 42m ago

Introducing Bitcoin Date Night: 100 cards, only 21 are about bitcoin, to help you truly understand who you hodl

Thumbnail
bitcoindatenight.com
0 Upvotes

r/Bitcoin • • 46m ago

Cory Klippsten: inflation isn't just a symptom, it's the root issue, and the inability to save and the financing of wars sit downstream of it

0 Upvotes

Inflation gets blamed on politics, or on corporations charging too much. Cory Klippsten argues that studying Bitcoin changes that diagnosis: inflation is itself the root issue, with the inability to save and the financing of wars downstream of it.

He connects that change in perspective with needing less daily news and with questioning how history gets written and taught.

His most personal point is about the future. He thinks getting into Bitcoin gives you a much better chance of becoming a definite optimist. For him, that outlook means sleeping better, pursuing lasting relationships, investing for his kids and trying to live long.


r/Bitcoin • • 1h ago

Core Lightning (CLN) v26.12rc1 tagged!

0 Upvotes

Changelog

[26.12rc1] - 2026-11-16: "CODENAME"

Added

  • JSON-RPC: 'listforwards' and the 'forward_event' notification have a new 'failure_reason' field with the root cause of a local forward failure ('insufficient_outgoing_liquidity', 'too_many_htlcs', 'max_htlc_value_in_flight') ([#9419])
  • JSON-RPC: askrene layers now contain "impressions" representing the effects of successful payments we made through channels. ([#9150])
  • lightningd: watchman module registers getwatchmanheight, chaininfo, watch_found, watch_revert, block_processed and revert_block_processed RPCs for bwatch plugin integration. ([#9202])
  • askrene: getroutes: maxhops, a parameter to limit the length of the paths in the solutions (already in v26.06.10). ([#9627])
  • tools: lightning-hsmtool can recover HTLC outputs after channel state loss. ([#9730])
  • nix: development shells now include shellcheck. ([#9677])
  • nix: development shells now stop startup_regtest.sh daemons when the shell exits. ([#9677])
  • nix: development shells now include eatmydata for contrib/startup_regtest.sh. ([#9677])
  • nix: development shells now include uv for Python dependency and command execution. ([#9677])

Changed

  • JSON-RPC: getroutes can now return PAY_INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS (215) and PAY_DESTINATION_INSUFFICIENT_CAPACITY (220) error codes. ([#9150])
  • cln-rpc: No longer parse messages from nodes older than v26.06, because fields marked required in the schema and added up to v26.06 are now required in the Rust types, e.g. openchannel hook channel_type and onion message first_path_key. Option<T> is now T. ([#9678])
  • cln-rpc and cln-grpc: getlog and listpeers no longer return the SKIPPED log type or num_skipped, listpeers adds the BROKEN log level, splicein and spliceout no longer return tx, and listpeerchannels next_fee_step is removed. ([#9537])
  • cln-rpc: funderupdate and listnodes lease fields, and listpeerchannels max_accepted_htlcs, our_to_self_delay and their_to_self_delay are u16. ([#9537])
  • cln-rpc: cancelrecurringinvoice recurrence_start and recurrence_counter are u32, listclosedchannels last_commitment_txid is a txid string, and listnetworkevents id is a pubkey. ([#9537])
  • cln-rpc: payment timestamps are u32 in sendpay, sendonion, waitsendpay, listpays, listsendpays, delpay, injectpaymentonion, sendpay_success and sendpay_failure. ([#9537])
  • cln-rpc and cln-grpc: forward_event adds created_index, in_htlc_id, preimage and updated_index, and listfunds adds csv_lock and spendable_at. ([#9537])
  • cln-rpc: hook types follow the corrected schemas: htlc_accepted cltv_expiry_relative is signed, openchannel to_self_delay and max_accepted_htlcs are u16, openchannel2 and rbf_channel responses accept channel lease fields, and rpc_command return.result is an object or an array. ([#9537])
  • Update libwally to v1.6.1 ([#9698], [#9741])

Deprecated

Note: You should always set allow-deprecated-apis=false to test for changes.

  • JSON-RPC: 'invokerune' and 'destroyrune' (use 'createrune' and 'blacklistrune') ([#9606])
  • Config: option xpay-handle-pay, pay is deprecated and will be replaced by xpay in v27.03, hence xpay-handle-pay is not needed anymore. The configuration option will no longer be shown in listconfigs. ([#9254])
  • cln-grpc only: deprecate amount fields for onchain methods, use *_sat fields instead. Old msat fields still work, but must be whole satoshis. Affected messages: AddpsbtoutputRequest, WithdrawRequest, FundpsbtRequest, UtxopsbtRequest, FundchannelRequest, FundchannelStartRequest, MultifundchannelDestinations, OpenchannelBumpRequest, and OpenchannelInitRequest ([#9678])

Removed

  • JSON-RPC: wait no longer returns the details object for invoices, forwards and sendpays; use the subsystem-specific object instead. ([#9650])
  • Plugins: coin_movement notification tags, txid, utxo_txid and vout fields (use primary_tag, extra_tags, spending_txid and utxo). ([#9650])
  • Plugins: channel_state_changed notification omits short_channel_id when the channel is unconfirmed, instead of null. ([#9650])
  • Plugins: notifications no longer include the legacy payload object or flat unwrapped fields; use the object named after the method instead. ([#9650])

Fixed

  • JSON-RPC: addpsbtoutput and addpsbtinput no longer crash when given a v2 PSBT that does not allow modification. ([#9698])
  • waitsendpay reports the remote failure for sendonion payments that failed before the call, instead of "Payment failure reason unknown" ([#9623])
  • sendpay: immediate success when replaying a completed self payment. ([#9517])
  • JSON-RPC: waitsendpay error data now includes raw_message even when the payment already failed before the command was called. ([#9342])
  • JSON-RPC: waitsendpay for an earlier groupid now reports that attempt's failure, not the failure of a later retry. ([#9734])
  • JSON-RPC: plugin start now accepts plugin options as an options array of keyword=value strings, as documented in the plugin schema. ([#9391])
  • JSON-RPC: graceful notifications now update when a pending HTLC changes state. ([#9305])
  • Reader of BOLT 12 payer_proof now accepts the writer-rule-mandated 239 -> 1000000000 marker jump. ([#9429])
  • channeld: reject HTLC amounts exceeding the BOLT 1 maximum to avoid signed balance underflow and abort. ([#9610])
  • Protocol: forwarding an HTLC that would exceed the outgoing channel's 'max_htlc_value_in_flight_msat' now fails with 'temporary_channel_failure' instead of 'required_node_feature_missing' ([#9419])
  • dual-fund/splice: fail the interactive channel negotiation if the sum of the outputs exceed 21M BTC (satisfy BOLT-02 cap of 21M BTC per output) ([#9493])
  • Protocol: a peer reconnecting to a channel where we lost state now reliably force-closes it, instead of our error racing their channeld exiting. ([#9563])
  • channeld: no longer retransmits channel_ready on reconnect after a splice has locked. ([#9256])
  • splicing: fixed crash when splicing a channel which hasn't been announced yet. ([#8557])
  • channeld: reject tx_init_rbf if the peer already sent splice_locked, as BOLT #2 requires. ([#9571])
  • connectd: the WebSocket port now accepts handshakes from clients that send lowercase HTTP header names, such as Node.js's built-in WebSocket. ([#9308])
  • lightningd: guard for arithmetic operation overflow on onion message request for forward a payment through a blinded path ([#9411])
  • Offers: we set a 10 minute expiry when we create invoices for offers in other currencies. ([#9150])
  • log: don't crash when truncating large log messages ([#9331])
  • wallet: Addressed a performance regression during blockchain scans ([#9340])
  • connectd: on macOS and other systems with dual-stack IPv6 default, wildcard '--addr=:<port>' now correctly binds both IPv4 and IPv6. ([#9148])
  • askrene-getroutes: Account for fees in the flow amount when computing probability costs. ([#9723])
  • xpay no longer retries every channel through a node that keeps returning unknown_next_peer. ([#9592])
  • renepay could fail with "minflow couldn't find a feasible flow" while HTLCs were still in flight. ([#9568])
  • renepay: fix a memory leak of routes that were still in flight when the payment completed. ([#9504])
  • plugins/recover: fix missing comma in nodes_for_gossip array. ([#9631])
  • Plugins: bkpr-listbalances no longer exits, taking lightningd down with it, when an account's debits exceed its credits; the inconsistency is logged and that account is reported as 0msat. ([#9488])
  • lsps-plugin: lsps-lsps2-invoice no longer creates an invoice that stays valid past the opening fee params' valid_until. ([#9657])
  • Plugins: sendpay_failure notifications and waitsendpay errors now report status failed (with completed_at and updated_index), not pending. ([#9731])
  • cln-plugin: a plugin no longer panics when it logs after its log writer task has exited (e.g., during shutdown); the message is written to stderr instead. ([#9732])
  • lsps-plugin: lsps-jitchannel no longer selects fee parameters whose min_payment_size_msat is above max_payment_size_msat, which no payment can satisfy. ([#9620])
  • lsps-plugin: the LSPS2 service now rejects lsps2.buy with a payment_size_msat outside the offered min_payment_size_msat/max_payment_size_msat. ([#9620])
  • lsps-plugin: the LSPS2 client now copies opening_fee_params verbatim (including valid_until), and the service sends valid_until in the LSPS0 datetime format. ([#9620])
  • lsps-plugin: a short channel id with an out-of-range component is now rejected instead of being parsed as a different channel. ([#9620])
  • lsps-plugin: an LSPS2 promise must be printable ASCII without JSON escapes, so its 512-byte limit is measured on the encoded string as bLIP-52 requires. ([#9620])
  • cln-rpc: ShortChannelId parsing now rejects out-of-range elements instead of silently corrupting the id. ([#9709])
  • cln-rpc and cln-grpc: connect responses and connect notifications with an unresolved address no longer fail to parse. ([#9537])
  • rust: Amounts that overflow fail, don't silently ignore in release builds ([#9423])
  • pyln-client: Millisatoshi(0).to_approx_str() no longer raises a ValueError. ([#9695])
  • pyln-client: GossmapNode.alias no longer includes the NUL padding from the node_announcement. ([#9689])
  • pyln-client: Gossmap no longer fails to load the gossip store when a node announces an alias that is not valid UTF-8. ([#9689])
  • pyln-proto: ShortChannelId.from_str now raises ValueError for malformed or out-of-range ids. ([#9709])
  • lightning-hsmtool: getsecret does not show mnemonic after typing passphrase ([#8951])
  • Report the cause when locking secret memory fails, instead of aborting with no diagnostic. ([#9438])
  • build: on macOS, Homebrew's headers and libraries are only used when Homebrew is installed, and no longer leak into nix build. ([#9677])
  • nix: nix develop now configures and builds correctly on macOS without injecting Homebrew paths into the Nix toolchain. ([#9677])
  • macos: builds with lowdown succeed, as we no longer attempt to spawn a nested sandbox ([#9423])
  • nix-builds: correctly set PYTHON in case where uv is not present ([#9423])
  • nix: the flake build (nix build) no longer fails because ./configure cannot detect Python. ([#9203])
  • Fixed spurious bitcoind startup failures by retrying bitcoin-cli -rpcwait checks when RPC briefly fails. ([#9240])

EXPERIMENTAL

  • wallet: Add bwatch-driven wallet transaction and UTXO tracking behind --experimental-bwatch. ([#9298])
  • Protocol: implement option_simple_close (BOLT2) for simpler one-shot mutual close fee negotiation. Enable with --experimental-simple-close. ([#9104])

r/Bitcoin • • 1h ago

Buying on the way down

3 Upvotes

Anybody else think buying on the way down lately has been the way to go? I held off DCA’ing on the last rise to $80k and figured I’d wait. I had already bought in as much as I was comfortable with when it was around $62k last time. So now I’ve just resumed buying with what I had saved during the last increase. Better lucky than good? 😬


r/Bitcoin • • 1h ago

How do you actually learn about Bitcoin?

0 Upvotes

Buying Bitcoin takes a few minutes. Understanding it can take years.

Books, podcasts, talks, conferences, the whitepaper or simply using it, like setting up your own wallet or running a node, are all great ways to learn.

We're working on an idea in this space and would love to hear from you first: how do you usually learn about Bitcoin, and what would you think of an option that makes learning more creative and playful?


r/Bitcoin • • 1h ago

That’s it, now I’m losing hope.

40 Upvotes

I imagine this is what you went through during the previous bear markets, wondering whether to sell at a loss, thinking you’d made the worst investment of your life. That’s exactly where I am right now.


r/Bitcoin • • 2h ago

Coldcard, Binance, Chaos… and Bitcoin Shrugs [Clip]

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Bitcoin • • 3h ago

Historical consecutive red weekly candles for bitcoin

12 Upvotes

Bitcoin has experienced several consecutive red weekly candle streaks throughout its history, but streaks of 5+ weeks are relatively rare.

Since 2017:

3+ weeks are Relatively common

4+ weeks has 8 occurrences reported

5+ weeks has Approximately 3 historical occurrences

6+ weeks has 2–3 occurrences

9 weeks has 1 occurrence (record)

Currently we are at week 7...you do and think what you want with this.


r/Bitcoin • • 4h ago

The cycle remains intact

Post image
252 Upvotes

Credit to @sserrano44 on X.


r/Bitcoin • • 7h ago

Shaking out the weak hands... Bear markets are designed to terrify. Stay away from Leverage trading.

Post image
93 Upvotes

r/Bitcoin • • 7h ago

Taking a lone out against Bitcoin

0 Upvotes

I'm looking to buy a second home but most of my semi liquid money is invested in Bitcoin that I REALLY don't want to sell. I've heard you can get a cheap loan using BTC as collateral but have no idea how to get started or more importantly avoid scam companies while doing so. Can anyone point me in the right direction? It's so low now that I think it's a good time to start the process and avoid a liquidation type of situation. I SHOULD be bringing in a lot of disposable income and staying with parents while renting out my first home. I really want to get out of here but refuse to rent. It doesn't make financial sense to kick the renters out and move back to my house. I could also use that as some of the collateral too.


r/Bitcoin • • 8h ago

Wake me up

Post image
991 Upvotes

r/Bitcoin • • 8h ago

How often do you upgrade your hardware wallet?

0 Upvotes

I've been using my trusty Trezor One for quite a while now, and it's still doing exactly what it's supposed to do. No complaints about reliability or functionality.

However, with Black Friday coming up, I'm starting to wonder whether it's worth taking advantage of potential discounts and upgrading to a newer hardware wallet.

I'm curious about how others approach this:

  • How often do you upgrade your hardware wallet?
  • Do you upgrade proactively to benefit from newer security features, or do you simply stick with your device until there's a compelling reason to replace it?
  • Is the Trezor One still perfectly adequate from a security perspective, or are there meaningful advantages to newer models?
  • If you were upgrading today, which hardware wallet would you choose and why?

I'm not necessarily looking for the latest and greatest gadget. I just want to make sure I'm not overlooking meaningful security improvements while holding onto an older device.

With Black Friday around the corner, there might be some interesting deals worth considering.

Curious to hear your experiences, especially from long-term hardware wallet users!


r/Bitcoin • • 9h ago

I tracked how many bitcoins are actually lost. Only 230 BTC are provably gone, but 3.6M haven't moved in 10+ years

2 Upvotes

People often quote "3–4 million BTC are lost." I wanted to see what can actually be measured on-chain, so I built a daily ledger that keeps the provable part apart from the merely dormant.

What it shows (data to Nov 17, 2026):

- Only about 230 BTC are provably destroyed: the genesis reward (50), two coinbases overwritten by duplicate transactions in 2010 (100), rewards miners never claimed (~29) and value sent to OP_RETURN (~51).
- 3.60M BTC (17.9% of supply) haven't moved in 10+ years; 2.22M in 15+ years.
- About 1.10M BTC sit in blocks matching the Patoshi mining pattern, widely attributed to Satoshi. Unmoved isn't the same as lost.
- Old coins still wake up: 53,563 BTC older than 10 years moved in the past 12 months, including 80,015 BTC on a single day (July 4, 2025).

I also put the well-known estimates (Chainalysis 2017 and 2024, Coin Metrics 2019) next to a same-day on-chain measure. Most of the disagreement comes from counting different things, not from different data.

The page deliberately gives no single "lost" number, because a coin that hasn't moved may still be held. Data is open (CC BY 4.0). Happy to hear corrections.

https://bitcoinyears.com/lost-bitcoin/


r/Bitcoin • • 10h ago Bravo

A student asks: If you’re never selling your Bitcoin, what’s the point of stacking it?

74 Upvotes

The point isn’t to never spend. It’s to stop spending on things you don’t need, so you can afford the ones that matter. Nobody values money for the paper, the gold bar or the data on a computer. We value what it can get us.


r/Bitcoin • • 10h ago

only 1% of active traders are profitable in long run

0 Upvotes

quite staggering actually, I always thought it would be low, but in range 5-10%. These number come from data analysis of all active traders on taiwan stock exchange, over long period.

So, apart that only 1/100 of active traders make it, rest majority of active traders with losses have psychical discomfort or outright ruined life from it. In another research, I saw number that only about 5% of population is resilient enough psychically to be able trade without ruining own life (bad sleep, health problems, emotional instability...).

But if you think that only losses makes problems, it's quite opposite, also huge gains more often than not ruins one's life - people start feeling overconfident and lose it all, or develop gambling addiction. It is quite frank hard to make huge gains and walk from trading I think, don't have personal experience in this :)

This comes in line with popular "meme" (but it's true), that best performing stock portfolios are ones, where owner lost access or died or got into comma for 5-10 years, simply because he could not make mistakes if he would actively trade.


r/Bitcoin • • 13h ago

With all these cyber attacks and only going to get more sophisticated why AI

0 Upvotes

I'm considering ditching keeping my coins in online platforms and moving to a physical wallet.

I have been hesitant up till now because I felt like I was more likely to fuck that up vs keeping them in a big sophisticated platform like coinbase, but now I'm not so sure.

I'm not confident they will be prepared for what's to come. And if last week was an indication, it's only the beginning of more service disruptions and worse.

What's the conventional wisdom of this group say? Are people leaving big online platforms and getting a physical wallet for piece of mind.


r/Bitcoin • • 15h ago

Spotted in Middletown DE.

Post image
55 Upvotes

r/Bitcoin • • 15h ago

Thoroughly impressed.

161 Upvotes

It’s amazing that through all this turmoil, Jensen huang banging spies, pterodactyls in the sky’s, jellyfish spaceships, 2.2 trillion wiped out of markets.. and BTC is holding strong at 64,000. Just take a minute to really think about that. We all know bitcoin is a risk asset so should be dumped heavily during times like this. But I can’t help but to shed a small tear of joy, almost like a proud father watching his kid ride a bike for the first time at the fact that BTC is holding strong. Is it not?! I mean 5 years ago this was a top. Now it’s a crazy support level. Talk about zooming out. If the world is still standing in 5 years and Armageddon hasn’t unleashed its fury it will be interesting to see where Bitcoin is chugging along at. Truly a remarkable piece of technology, that even I after studying it for many years, still truly don’t know the depth or grasp of what this is and what it could become.

Quick Fun Fact: the Last bitcoin to be mined will be in 2140! Like just wrap your head around that one. We’ll all be bones and dust by then. But Bitcoin will still be mining coins every 10 minutes until then. Imagine what 100,000 satoshis will look like in that year?! Would it even be money ? Or what? Fascinating haha


r/Bitcoin • • 16h ago

GTA 6

0 Upvotes

Is it possible that the launch of GTA 6 could help Bitcoin recover from its recent decline?


r/Bitcoin • • 17h ago

What could we be doing differently?

2 Upvotes

I will start this with a bit about me.

I got into Bitcoin when my sister-in-law asked me to cash out her Bitcoin ($500 worth). I had heard of Bitcoin prior to this but had never given it more time than it took to say the word Bitcoin. She had been given the Bitcoin by her now ex-partner, who had done so to try and encourage her to look into Bitcoin. Looking back, I always wondered how he didn't work, travelled a lot and seemed to be very very happy. Now I know.

Anyway, like the good brother-in-law that I am, I dedicated some time to understanding how the heck I could cash this out for her. Through that process, I began to learn about Bitcoin, and my life has changed. I bought my first sats in 2022.

I truly believe in Bitcoin in the sense that our financial system is garbage: money debasement, inflation, real wages not keeping up with inflation, blah blah blah. And that Bitcoin is honest money. Will we ever be on a Bitcoin standard? I hope so, and I will keep fighting for it, but I don't think the future is predetermined, and sometimes the bad guys (FIAT) do win. Maybe most times?

Okay, so now the reason for my post.

I am constantly amazed by how very few people seem to have an issue with our financial system and/or don't seem to understand the issue. I mean, I was one of these people prior to trying to cash out that Bitcoin for my sister-in-law.

I truly believe that if more people understood the issue, if more people understood how they are being robbed, the floodgates would open for Bitcoin, and perhaps we might just be able to correct our financial system. I mean, look at the world right now. There seems to be a revolution happening in every corner of the world. By revolution, I mean people being unhappy with something and making that heard.

We all seem to be so incredibly divided. But do you know what we all have in common? Garbage FIAT, money debasement, inflation, real wages not keeping up with inflation, blah blah blah.

As a Bitcoin community, is there not something more we could be doing to educate, dare I say it, enlighten people to this madness and hope? Yes, we have the YouTube videos, yes, we can talk to people around us. But is that the best we can do?

I suppose I just feel like the issue with FIAT is a shared problem for everyone. Something we can all get behind regardless of political views, race or gender.

What could we be doing differently to shine the light for others?