r/BoardgameDesign • • 3h ago

Ideas & Inspiration How do you make projectiles satisfying?

3 Upvotes

I've been stumped. I have these ideas for a military-style game, but I'm struggling with how to make the troops shoot at each other in a satisfying way. Simply pointing at someone and saying, "You got shot," is really boring. So, how can someone make physical, analog pieces shoot at each other in a way that feels engaging and satisfying?

as an example a soldier can shott 2 tiles in fron of him , just saing it got shoot seems realy boring , any ideas?


r/BoardgameDesign • • 23h ago

Playtesting & Demos Second playtest of Ultimatum!

Post image
22 Upvotes

I ran my second major playtest of Ultimatum, my board game I'm making! 

It was a lot of fun but the biggest issue is that it took far too long - the game finished after 5 hours, and it is possible for the game to go even longer than that, which is no good. My goal is a 2-3 hour long game, maybe up to 4 if it can really really justify it. 

I'm hoping (and iterating on design will reveal!) that the reason for the length of the game is the information, and the way it's presented. My players often weren't sure exactly what their cards did, and needed to ask me how things worked frequently, so I need to remake the player board and cards so that it's much more obvious how everything works. 

The rest of the time was spent arguing, negotiating, pleading with, and threatening each other - and that's the whole point of the game, so I don't mind that! 

Any ideas on how to speed things up, questions about the game, or anything else at all would be very welcome. 


r/BoardgameDesign • • 13h ago

Design Critique Alright poke holes in this idea of a Mutually Assured Destruction game

0 Upvotes

Big red button in the middle of the table. Anyone can press it on their turn if they want to. If you press it you launch nukes and kill everyone. Game over.

So how do you win? Build a space ship. Get to the moon. THEN press the button and kill everyone else. Easy right? No. You have to manage everyone's personalities tactfully enough to keep them playing the game while you steadily win the space race.

The rules so far:

-Each player starts with drawing 5 cards from the deck.

-First player is democratically elected

-On your turn the player draws a card and may use as many cards as they wish.

-trading and threatening the other players is always encouraged.

-if you have 4 spaceship parts on your turn you may fly to the moon and press the button.

Mechanics (please help me think this through more)

Big ol deck of cards with 4 types:

Money - buy stuff from the store to benefit yourself

Influence - allow you to do stuff to other players

Misc - rare cards that are much more powerful including spaceship parts

News - rare cards that affect the whole table

What can the stock market do for you

- influence (2 money for 1 influence)

- space ship parts (4 money for 1 part)

- draw another card from the deck (1 money for a draw) (can only do once a turn so the player doesn't burn through the deck)

What can a politician do for you

- 2 influence let's you steal a card from another player

- 1 influence let's you look at a card from another player

What random bullshit exists in misc

- spaceship parts

- spy- look at 2 cards from your opponent (can be the same or different players)

- The means of production - draw 2 cards

- government bonds- worth 2 money +an additional money for each bond you possess (1 bond = 2 money, 2 bonds = 5 money, 3 bonds = 8, ect.)

- blitzkrieg- steal 2 cards of your choice from another player

- enigma machine - when a player tries to look at your cards or steal from you play this card to prevent them.

- satellite states- pick 3 players. Each gives you a card of their choice

What's black and white and red all over...

-->When an event card is drawn, that player must reveal it to the whole table. This does not end their turn.

- water gate- all players vote for a player who is "the most scandalous" that player must discard 2 cards of their choosing (bribes and negotiations are allowed prior to voting)

- peace prize- all players vote for a player who is "the most peaceful" that player may draw 2 cards of their choosing (bribes and negotiations are allowed prior to voting)

- great depression- all players discard all their money (bonds do not count)

- baby boom - all players draw 2 extra cards

- Gorbachev's wall - all players trade 2 cards with the player to their right

- nuclear dismantling - all players must discard any spys, blitzkriegs, and satellite states

-alien tech (only 1 in deck)- each player gets a spaceship part

I don't really know if the idea at its core can work, but I think it could be a fun exercise in understanding M.A.D. and playing politics. Another idea is to make nukes an actual card, and no player can press the button unless they have one, thus increasing the need to lie and bully other players.

Lmk what you think.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Ideas & Inspiration AMA: 55 year old, dad of 2, full time worker, with first board game in pre-launch on crowdfunding. Here to help as much as my limited knowledge will allow.

29 Upvotes

Hey all.

First up, I think this is my second post ever. I lurk and read (generally the front page) as I lay in bed.
The reason I decided to make to huuuuuuge leap to a 2nd post was, basically, to see if I could offer any help to other board game designers.

I'm by no means any kind of expert or established pro, but the fact I started with just an idea for a game and had no bloody notion of where to start, who to contact or how to get it produced, means I may be able to offer some insight into the - at times - scary, overwhelming, journey from a place of complete ignorance to having a game set to launch.

My game is big in scope (minis, loads of components, etc.; think Scythe/Nemesis/Jaws of the Lion level of production), so I'll try to also answer any questions regarding creation, prototypes, manufacture, pricing, etc. of such games. Man, the amount of times I wish I'd created a little trick-taker or the like, but I simply couldn't think of one... no, no, I had to think of a big bloody epic beast of a thing, didn't I?

I will answer every question posted and be as transparent and informative as I can (withstanding divulging confidential client/artist/manufacturer information) but I may not be super quick doing so as I estimate the ratio of replies to naps to be 3 to 1.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 19h ago

Rules & Rulebook Hunter x Hunter Passionate Project

Thumbnail greedisland-masterofthebook.edgeone.dev
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I recently rewatched my childhood favourite anime Hunter x Hunter and got inspired to create a board game version of Greed Island!

I'm not planning to have it published and this is just a passionate project of mine. I spent the past two months working on the draft of the rulebook and am planning to start making the cards soon for playtesting.

Just want to share my rulebook and get some feedback on it (especially from Hunter x Hunter fans!). I just like the anime a lot and want to create a fun game for fans to enjoy. I'm planning to share the rulebook and print and play cards after playtesting (given it feels fun and engaging).

Any feedback would be great, thanks!


r/BoardgameDesign • • 23h ago

Game Mechanics How much strategy is too much for a funny party game?

2 Upvotes

Hey, all! New here and new to this world (I primarily work as a screenwriter)!

So-- me and my good buddy have been developing a few games over the past years, and one of the things we’ve been going back and forth on is how much actual strategy belongs in a party game.

Our first game is called Secret Santa.

The basic idea is that players combine funny characters and personalities, and then everyone competes to give that person the funniest (or most awful) gift.

But we didn’t want it to just be about the best joke. We wanted players to have agency and other ways to score points. So we added a mechanic where you can also score if people choose your gift. And ways to try to double your points for round or even change out new cards.

Anyway, I’m curious how other designers approach this.

At what point in a party game does strategy get in the way of just having fun,

Would love to hear your thoughts.

Thnx!

Dave


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Rules & Rulebook Morphiblock Rulebook – Revised Version After Your Feedback. Would Love Your Thoughts!

Post image
4 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I recently introduced Morphiblock, a 3D spatial logic game I've developed myself. I was looking for people who enjoy abstract strategy games and have the interest and time to carefully read through the rulebook.

You provided some really valuable feedback, including constructive criticism, editorial suggestions, and other comments on how to improve and refine the text.

After several rounds of revisions, I've now completed an updated version of the rulebook.

Whether you've already read the previous version or are reading it for the first time, I would be very grateful if you could take the time to read the revised version and share your thoughts and opinions.

Thank you all in advance!

https://www.morphiblock.com/MORPHIBLOCK_RULEBOOK_16_PAGES_2026.pdf


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Production & Manufacturing Website for print cards for custom game with double side?

2 Upvotes

Good morning. I would like to create a board game. Aside from the various plastic components, need only to build 5–6 plastic spaceships, each capable of holding up to 5 small plastic cubes (which I should be able to handle easily with a 3D printer), I was wondering how to go about printing double-sided cards. I currently use the software NanDeck for the cards, but I am open to switching if necessary.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 23h ago

Publishing & Publishers First-time board game publishers: how did you approach international distribution and legal requirements?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m based in Europe and working towards launching my own small board game publishing business. I’d like to reach some of the larger European markets and potentially sell outside Europe as well. I’d love to hear from other independent publishers about how they approached those first steps, particularly international distribution.

I have a strong background in international logistics, so I’m comfortable with that side of things. What I’m less familiar with is the legal and administrative side of selling games in different countries: how to identify the requirements that apply and make sure everything is in place before putting a game on sale.

How did you decide which countries to sell in initially? How did you find out what you needed to do to sell legally in each market? Did you involve a lawyer or a compliance consultant? If so, at what stage?


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Design Critique Transplantica Characters

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Here are my artists latest iterations of the patient cards!

I'm very happy with them. The vibe is just how I want it to be, invoking that retro Food Chain Magnate vibe I strive for with some googie elements.

Some obvious issues I'm aware of - the font for the numbers is too unclear and the numbers themselves are too small. Also, the lung might need another lung to be more clear.

Do you have any other critique or thoughts? Which are your favourites? How is the contrast between colours? Is the quality adequate for an indie production?

I might need to change the tint of green and blue, maybe red, to make it more distinct in low and warm lighting. Sorry for the glares!


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Playtesting & Demos Battle Pikmin! A Pikmin re-theme I made for Battle Sheep!

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

The original board game is called Battle Sheep:

https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/54137/battle-sheep

Basically you send out your Pikmin to try to conquer (occupy) as many spaces as possible. Whoever has the most visible Pikmin on the board at the end of the game wins!

I also made a variant/version with special tiles on the board such as the Pikmin Flower (8), if you move a stack of at least 8 Pikmin onto the tile, you gain a bonus Pikmin on your stack, Treasure (10), you gain 1 bonus point at the end of the game (like an additional Pikmin on the field), and Nectar, movingo onto this tile makes your stack stop at that tile. All extra tiles are placed randomly and not edge spaces.

Let me know what you think, it was a lot of fun to make and play with my friends!

You can check out my other re-themes here:

[One Piece Legendary](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/10p0q0j/i\\_made\\_a\\_one\\_piece\\_version\\_of\\_marvel\\_legendary/)

[Pax Westeros \(Game of Thrones Pax Pamir 2nd Edition\)](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1fmseex/i\\_made\\_pax\\_westeros\\_game\\_of\\_thrones\\_retheme\\_of/)

[Runeterra Reforged \(League of Legends Tyrants of the Underdark\)](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1eew974/i\\_made\\_a\\_league\\_of\\_legends\\_themed\\_tyrants\\_of\\_the/)

[Pokemon Ark Nova](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1hdby4p/i\\_made\\_a\\_pokemon\\_retheme\\_of\\_ark\\_nova/)

[Pokemon Splendor & Pokemon Splendor Duel](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1mn9h3i/i\\_made\\_pokemon\\_splendor\\_again\\_updated\\_the\\_cards/)

[NBA Innovation](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1nua3z1/with\\_the\\_nba\\_preseason\\_coming\\_in\\_a\\_few\\_days\\_i/)

[Zelda Forbidden Island/Forbidden Desert/Forbidden Jungle](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1nnjeaa/i\\_made\\_a\\_legend\\_of\\_zelda\\_retheme\\_of\\_forbidden/)

[Spy x Family Agent Avenue](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1qh1sfq/i\\_made\\_a\\_spy\\_x\\_family\\_retheme\\_of\\_agent\\_avenue/)

[Lord of the Rings Clank Catacombs](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1qndolc/i\\_rethemed\\_clank\\_catacombs\\_into\\_lord\\_of\\_the\\_rings/)

[Disney Legends of the Void](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1r02rba/i_rethemed_legends_of_void_into_a_disney_themed/)

[Genshin Impact Knarr]
https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1s7n8ey/i_made_a_genshin_impact_retheme_of_knarr/

[Pokemon Harmonies]https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1s8kib9/i_made_a_pokemon_retheme_of_harmonies/

[Avatar the Last Airbender Duel for Cardia]https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1sdvycf/i_made_an_avatar_the_last_airbender_retheme_of/

[One Piece Smash Up]
https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1v3hv70/made_a_custom_one_piece_smash_up_faction_as_a/

[Toy Story Battle] https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1wg0585/i_rethemed_toy_battle_into_toy_story_battle_and/


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

General Question First-time board game publishers: how did you approach international distribution and legal requirements?

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m based in Europe and working towards launching my own small board game publishing business. I’d like to reach some of the larger European markets and potentially sell outside Europe as well. I’d love to hear from other independent publishers about how they approached those first steps, particularly international distribution.

I have a strong background in international logistics, so I’m comfortable with that side of things. What I’m less familiar with is the legal and administrative side of selling games in different countries: how to identify the requirements that apply and make sure everything is in place before putting a game on sale.

How did you decide which countries to sell in initially? How did you find out what you needed to do to sell legally in each market? Did you involve a lawyer or a compliance consultant? If so, at what stage?


r/BoardgameDesign • • 2d ago Bravo

Ideas & Inspiration Need placeholder art for your game prototypes? Here are 150 illustrations you can use for free!

Post image
71 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

Over the last few years, this community has given me invaluable feedback and help while developing my own card game, Kravestorm. So I thought it was time to give something back...

I've put together a collection of 150 illustrations I've drawn along the way. Most of them are from my actual game (Core Set), while others were scrapped during development (earlier experiments).

I wanted to make these available to anyone who needs placeholder artwork while developing their own games. I've figured since these illustrations already exist, they might as well be useful to other developers too.

You can use these illustrations for free in non-commercial prototypes, playtests and development previews. You can download them individually as PNG files (no watermarks, no accounts required, no paywalls).

I've called this side project KOAL (Kravestorm Open Art Library), and it's already live and free to use.

I hope some of you might find this helpful!


r/BoardgameDesign • • 1d ago

Game Mechanics How do you stop players from "intentionally busting" in a push-your-luck game?

0 Upvotes

I'm balancing a 54-card push-your-luck game (Familiar Fugitives)where using creature abilities adds Exposure tokens to your hideout. At 6+ Exposure, you bust ("get Raided"): you lose 1 creature and take -2 VP.

We are debating how many Exposure tokens should be cleared after you bust:

  • Option A (Full Reset): Busting clears all your Exposure back to 0. (Problem: A player in the lead with an empty hideout can intentionally bust just to wipe 7+ Exposure tokens for free instead of spending actions to clear them.)
  • Option B (Partial Decay): Busting only removes 2 Exposure tokens. (Problem: A player at 7 Exposure drops to 5 and risks getting trapped in a death spiral next round.)

How do you stop players from weaponizing the "bust" as a free board-wipe without putting trailing players in a death spiral?


r/BoardgameDesign • • 2d ago

General Question At what point do you abandon a prototype or idea?

11 Upvotes

I've managed to make meaningful progress on my most recent idea. The first solid iteration of the gameplay and mechanics is done and I have started testing with friends and making adjustments based on that in preparation for trying to find some initial outside testers.

I've been through about 4-5 game ideas before getting to this point, with some progressing to actual gameplay testing while others were set aside just after the initial brainstorming and design phase. I know abandoning game ideas and prototypes is a very common thing for a designer to do, so I just wanted to hear from some people in this community about what their general rule of thumb is for abandoning an idea or prototype.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 3d ago

Design Critique Lianenobst – An abstract strategy game built around the Hilbert curve. Looking for design feedback!

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'd like to share an abstract strategy game I've been developing called Lianenobst (roughly "Vine Fruit").

The central idea is quite simple: What happens if you build a strategy game around a space-filling curve instead of a conventional grid?

The board consists of 64 squares connected by a single winding vine, following the geometry of a Hilbert curve.

This creates two different kinds of proximity: two pieces can be physically adjacent on the board while being far apart along the vine, or they can move along the vine in directions that are difficult to anticipate from the grid alone.

The game combines several movement mechanics:

  • Pieces can move or jump along the vine.
  • Friendly pieces can help each other jump across the grid.
  • Opposing pieces can be captured based on their geometric proximity and whether they are connected by the vine.
  • Each player has a piece of fruit that can be carried, passed between friendly pieces, or captured by the opponent.

The goal is to capture your opponent's fruit while protecting your own.

What interests me most is how these simple rules interact with the unusual geometry of the board. The vine creates unexpected routes, tactical opportunities, and situations where geometric distance and movement distance tell very different stories.

I've developed a playable HTML prototype with some help from AI. It works directly in a browser, either against the computer or with two players sitting opposite each other, using a single smartphone as the board.

Play Lianenobst here: https://www.orges-leka.de/lianenobst.html

Watch a short Minimax vs. Minimax gameplay: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/tYMPnxvCYeQ

I'd particularly appreciate feedback from a game design perspective:

  • Does the unusual board geometry create interesting strategic decisions?
  • Are the movement and capture mechanics intuitive once you've played a few turns?
  • Does the game feel like it has potential for deeper, long-term planning?

I'm currently refining the rules and exploring whether this could eventually become a physical board game.

Thanks for taking a look! I'd be happy to hear your thoughts, including critical feedback. **Edit**: Based on the feedback, I created a new version: "Lianenobst Flitz" with orang utans and small apes: small apes can run along the free vine as they see fit and they can not help the (big) orang utans with a helping hand to jump across the vine, otherwise everything stays the same: Here a screenshot:

Lianenobst Flitz

The game feels more dynamic with these new changes. Thanks for your honest feedback!


r/BoardgameDesign • • 2d ago

Ideas & Inspiration Feedback wanted

1 Upvotes

Looking for feedback on my game idea. Any and all feedback is appreciated (in the very, veyr early stages of fleshing it out. Picture the idea of Quacks of Quedlinburg meeting the bargaining of Zoo Vadis or Chinatown, but with cuddly animals who live in a post-apocalyptic environment. In Salvaged, players roll their unique dice from their own bag directly into their player boards and count all of the dice rolled at the table to determine the dynamic “Scarcity Track” of the game (the more common the rolls are, the cheaper they are, while rare rolls are expensive). The draft is replaced by the 90 second period of trading dice, money (Scrap), and cards between players, after which you pay these resources to purchase valuable Outpost cards with mixed costs (like “2 Scrap + 1 Copper Die”) and improve your dice set, all within the bounds of inventory limitations from the player board.

There's custom dice, dice bag building, and I wanted to really try and nail some ressource scarcity.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 3d ago

General Question I would like to illustrate playing cards and game boards.

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/BoardgameDesign • • 4d ago

Playtesting & Demos My DIY board game Pizza

Thumbnail
gallery
39 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Eventually, I got the itch to design my own compact, family-friendly game with simple rules and minimal components—something easy to bring out for a small group when getting a big party together isn't an option.

The Concept & Mechanics

I spent about a week brainstorming. A card game didn't quite click, so I started focusing on the board shape instead. I couldn't get a circular board out of my head, and once I combined it with a hexagonal grid, the early sketches looked suspiciously like a Russian pelmeni (ravioli) mold. Round board meant round tokens, and visually, the whole thing quickly evolved into a pizza.

From there, the mechanics came together by mashing up two classics:

• Reversi: For the tactile satisfaction of flipping tokens on the board.

• Dominoes: I wanted both sides of every token to carry meaningful values. Balancing those dual-sided values led to a matching and scoring logic that feels very close to Dominoes.

Prototyping & Rejection

Within a week of tinkering with paper cutouts, a surprisingly deep abstract gameplay loop emerged. I built a glued cardboard prototype with a custom box and tested it with friends—everyone loved how snappy it felt. Encouraged by their feedback, I made a few wooden plywood versions and managed to squeeze the entire rulebook onto a single A4 sheet (folded either as an accordion or a mini-booklet).

I pitched the game to a few publishers, got polite passes (the pizza theme on a pure abstract wasn't quite what they were looking for), and decided to just make the ultimate DIY copy for myself.

What do you all think about non-traditional packaging like bags, tins, or fabric sleeves instead of standard cardboard boxes? Also, if anyone has questions about balancing dual-sided tokens, I’d love to chat in the comments!

In fact, you can try this game online right now at pizzaboardgame.com

You don’t need to register to play against the bot, but if you want to track your statistics and earn achievements, a very simple registration process is required—no email address needed. Good luck!


r/BoardgameDesign • • 3d ago

Design Critique Game Design Tutorials

2 Upvotes

Started a YouTube channel to teach folks how game design works using short videos. Each video will explain the basics of a single topic and include links for further reading in the description.
I asked for feedback about half a year ago, and it would be nice to get an update on what could be improved.

One important note: I'm more interested in feedback on how to improve the content.

If you have a suggestion on how to make it easier to find, I'm all ears. But I'm not really trying to create a business with YouTube; all of this is with a focus on making design more accessible to folks wanting to learn.

Link to the channel content:
https://www.youtube.com/@GearedDice/shorts


r/BoardgameDesign • • 3d ago

Ideas & Inspiration Jugamos juntos: un protocolo para co-diseñar juegos de mesa sin destruir el juego ni la amistad

6 Upvotes

Ok, comienzo aclarando que muchos años atrás intenté desarrollar un juego de mesa en conjunto y las cosas no salieron como imaginaba. Hoy, 20 años después entiendo cuales fueron muchos de los errores cometidos en aquellos días y me doy cuenta de que incluso 20 años después algunos de esos errores persisten asíque se me ocurrió organizar un poco mis pensamientos, un poco para mejorar la comunicación en mi grupo de amigos y otro poco para compartir todo esto con otras personas que tal vez puedan encontrar utilidad en estas palabras.

Muchos de los proyectos de diseño de mesa que mueren no mueren por el juego. Mueren por el protocolo: la ausencia de reglas explícitas sobre cómo se decide, cómo se critica, quién es dueño de qué y cómo se sale. Diseñamos todo el sistema del juego y no diseñamos el sistema de colaboración, que es el que decide si el juego llega a existir. Esto es un intento de protocolo, extraído de un caso real. Tomen lo que sirva, critiquen lo que no, y agreguen lo que les falte.

1. Todo argumento de inercia está fuera del debate

En cualquier mesa de diseño conviven dos modos de discutir. Uno produce conocimiento: "esta mecánica produce X en los jugadores porque Y". El otro administra inercia, y viene en dos disfrazas opuestos:

  • "Todos los juegos lo hacen así" — el argumento del conformismo. Que un estándar exista es información, no argumento. La versión legítima es la convertida en hipótesis: "los juegos estándar hacen X porque mitiga el problema Y; en nuestro diseño Y aparece cuando Z; propongo verificarlo en la mesa."
  • "Eso es imposible / demasiado difícil" — el argumento del escepticismo sin contenido. "Imposible" no es una objeción técnica; no predice nada y no se puede testear.

La regla unificadora: toda objeción debe ser convertible en predicción concreta. "Esto va a fallar porque los jugadores harán X en la fase Y". Si la objeción no puede formularse como predicción, no participa del debate. Y esto es simétrico: tampoco "me gusta" ni "tengo un feeling" ni "no veo el fundamento" ganan por defecto. Las intuiciones valen, pero entran como hipótesis débiles, no como decisiones.

2. El prototipo decide; las personas ejecutan

La mayoría de los conflictos de co-diseño son disputas de autoridad disfrazadas de disputas técnicas. Si el desacuerdo se resuelve por debate, gana quien insiste más, habla más fuerte o argumenta más elegante — y ninguno de esos tres tiene correlación con si la mecánica funciona.

El circuito que propongo: si hay desacuerdo y ninguno convence al otro, la pregunta no es "quién tiene razón" sino "¿qué prueba distinguiría tu versión de la mía?" Se pacta un plazo (por ejemplo: la versión discutida entra al prototipo durante tres playtests), se registran observaciones, se decide sobre el registro. El desacuerdo se desplaza del plano del ego al plano empírico. Nadie gana por volumen; la mesa tiene la última palabra, para ambos.

Corolario: llevá un log de decisiones. Cada decisión relevante queda escrita con fecha, propuesta, objeciones y resultado del test. Dos funciones: impide reflotar infinitamente ideas ya descartadas por playtesting (el registro responde por vos, no tu paciencia), y registra autoría nominal de cada idea — lo que sorprendentemente reduce los conflictos de propiedad antes de que existan.

3. Nada se decide en la misma sesión en que se propuso

La reactividad emocional es el aliado silencioso de las malas decisiones: las ideas defendidas en caliente se defienden como extensiones del yo, y criticarlas equivale a atacar a la persona. Tres reglas operativas baratas:

  • La pausa no es derrota. Cualquiera puede decretar 24 horas de pausa cuando la discusión escala de tono. El tema va agendado, no enterrado.
  • La crítica va contra el prototipo, nunca contra la persona. Formato fijo: "la mecánica X produce Y en los jugadores", no "tu idea es mala".
  • Cierre ritual. Tres minutos al final de cada sesión: qué se decidió, qué quedó en prueba, qué queda pendiente. Los desacuerdos abiertos se escriben como "hipótesis en prueba", no como "ideas rechazadas". El papel no tiene tono de voz.

Y la regla de frontera: cuando termina la sesión, termina el tema. Ningún desacuerdo de diseño se continúa por mensaje a medianoche. Todo lo que no se dijo en la sesión va a la próxima agenda.

4. Dominios de propiedad, no jerarquías

Si un integrante del equipo es genuinamente más experimentado, la paridad total es una ficción que produce fricción perpetua. Pero "el más experimentado decide todo" es una invitación al resentimiento. La salida intermedia: división por dominios con veto pleno adentro de cada uno. Uno puede tener la autoridad sobre arquitectura de sistemas; el otro, sobre testing, componentes, temática o producción, según lo que realmente domine. La autoridad de cada uno se legitima en su territorio, no en el del otro.

Detalle: el dominio del socio menos experimentado en creación suele estar en evaluación. Quien jugó sesenta juegos no sabe necesariamente crear, pero es el mejor sensor del equipo para comparar ("¿qué juego resolvió este problema y por qué funcionó o falló ahí?"), leer experiencia de jugador y detectar curvas de aprendizaje rotas. El conocimiento enciclopédico puesto a trabajar como análisis comparativo deja de ser argumento de autoridad y se vuelve método.

5. La confianza no se otorga: se estructura

Con un socio de confianza total, un apretón de manos alcanza. Pero la confianza total es rara, y pedir confianza indefinida es la forma más rápida de descubrir cuánta había. Antes de diseñar nada, pacten por escrito, aunque sean amigos — especialmente si son amigos:

  • Titularidad del IP y qué es del proyecto común y qué queda fuera.
  • Exclusividad del proyecto: nada de lo que se diseña juntos se desarrolla en paralelo por fuera, ni a la sombra, ni "mi versión". Los iceboxes (ideas estacionadas) tienen autor nominal y regla de no-desarrollo-solitario.
  • Participación económica proporcional a la contribución real, acordada cuando todavía no hay dinero en juego.
  • Salida digna pre-acordada: definan en frío en qué momento se reconoce que el esquema no funciona, y que ese reconocimiento no es juicio sobre la amistad ni sobre las capacidades de nadie.

El punto más contra-intuitivo: poner reglas no es desconfiar, es proteger la relación de la tentación que conocemos que existe — incluyendo la propia**.** En mi experiencia personal intenté 3 veces crear negocios con amigos y lamentablemente no funcionó ninguno porque no tuvimos la madurez suficiente para separar instancias; amistad es amistad y no es negocio pero negocio no es amistad, es responsabilidad para/conmigo, para/con vos y para/con el proyecto (suele ser mas difícil establecer límites y exigencias con amigos que con extraños). Los acuerdos escritos en frío son lo único que se interpone entre un desacuerdo futuro y las 2 AM del resentimiento acumulado. Y paradójicamente, saber que existe una salida limpia y sin drama es lo que más sostiene los proyectos: el miedo a que "dejar el proyecto rompa la amistad" es lo que hace que la gente siga años en esquemas que no funcionan, destruyendo ambas cosas de a poco.

6. La pregunta final

Antes de invitar a alguien a co-diseñar, hacete una sola pregunta: si esa persona aceptara siempre tu criterio sin fricción, ¿igual querrías este proyecto con ella? Si la respuesta es sí, el proyecto vale y el protocolo es previsión. Si la respuesta es no, hay algo pendiente debajo — y ningún protocolo de diseño resuelve un conflicto que no se admitió.

IMPORTANTE: Adueñate de este texto, modificalo, incorporale tus propias experiencias y hagamos entre todos algo que ayude a cualquier iniciante a mejorar sus cartas.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 4d ago

Playtesting & Demos A "Con Noob's" experience and thoughts of Protospiel Madison

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Warning: I'm a naturally verbose mofo, so this is gonna be long. Also perhaps a little stream-of-consciousness-y. It is what it is.

As I told multiple people in person, I'll reiterate here for the wider world. I did not know Protospiel Madison existed until two days before it was scheduled to start. Knowing how I only discovered Protospiel Chicago weeks after it had ended and was bummed I couldn't attend, I was eager to make up for that lost opportunity. Had I known further in advance for either, I'd've made plans to be there the full weekend.

Irri-dis-un-regardless, I realized I could move some things around and make that three-ish hour drive on Friday morning at least.

I'd never attended any Protospiels before (duh). I had heard of them as a concept, but I thought they were only a thing that happened in Europe. Clearly I was wrong. Still, I didn't know what to expect going in.

After reading up on what they expect of their attendees and whatnot, I had a better idea - sort of. I know it was going to be tiny; I was used to the tens of thousands of bodies that Gen Con attracts, so I had to temper my expectations to around 200 folks. That part stayed true. It was frankly refreshing to be in such a cozy space with so few people.

Apparently the Saturday crowd is larger than the Friday one (that tracks for all conventions), so even that 200 count is bound to be higher than it really was. Maybe 100-150 people? Anyway.

I also learned they expect for people that show up with prototypes to also play other people's games. That's totally fair. In fact, I really liked how they gamified that aspect of participation with Mad Bingo (picture 2).

Play other people's games, provide feedback, then have the designer fill in an appropriate box on your bingo card. Hit a bingo and win a prize off their table of games and stuff. Brilliant!

One quick aside: Even though I did hit a bingo, I was unable to claim a prize because when I went to hand in the card, the folks at the desk were out to lunch. On top of that, it was getting late (just before 8pm at this time), and I knew I had an hours-long drive ahead of me, so I didn't have time to wait for them to get back. I had to get back home. :(

We now return you to your regularly scheduled broadcast.

Notably, the other thing I found novel and fun was the "Con Noob" ribbon they give out to people attending for the first time. That was cool and unexpected. :)

So I grabbed an open spot and set up my current prototype, Duelrift. It's a light 1v1 card battler where luck meets strategy. Aimed at the beer & pretzels crowd, setup is fast and games take 5-10 minutes to play.

It wasn't long before I had some people sit down for a session or two. A couple hours later I was looking at about a half page of very useful feedback from a variety of people. It was about this time when I figured I should probably also pay it back so I walked around the tables and found a few open spots so I had a go at a few of them.

This next bit might seem like an unrelated tangent, but stick with me here. I promise I'm going somewhere with it.

I went an art college.

One of the first and most consistent lessons they taught us was that, as artists of any stripe - whether that be illustrator, graphic designer, layout, painter, doesn't matter - it is quite literally impossible to improve our craft if we are unable to take criticism.

Skill and talent must be nurtured in order to get better at the things we are doing. The path to nurturing them is by learning from what others see in our work that we might be blind to. Truly learning how to take critique without taking it personally is an art form in and of itself, one that I believe I'm great at. But I worked to be great at it, I didn't start out that way.

It took years of countless moments of realizing and learning that, yeah, making these changes this person suggested does in fact make the work as a whole so much stronger.

It's that mentality that is required to present an unfinished work of art (our games in this case) to a stranger, have them go, hmm, I don't think this part is good but have you considered this? Then actually trying that and realizing that, yeah, that works so much better.

That is the feeling with which I left Protospiel Madison yesterday evening.

I have an entire page of notes that I'm excited to try and incorporate into Duelrift that I truly believe will make it go from just a good game to a great one!

Overall, the games I played ran the gamut in complexity and prototype-ness, from almost ready for publishing to "this is the first time I'm playing it publicly with strangers," which was all very much to be expected, but all without fail were universally fun.

Yo, if you see your spot on that bingo card, big shout out to all of you! <3

I may not remember your names, but our games are precious to us all, I know. And I hope my feedback for your games were as valuable as the input I received on mine, 'cuz I value mine dearly.

Oh! One final thing. See pic 3.

The two copies of Duelrift I had brought with me was my first test print through The Game Crafter. I was told to tell you TCG guys that I am very impressed with the quality! Just one tiny complaint I had was that the top lid of the box likes to get loose very quickly.

When I brought this up to one of the people I had sat down with, they said apparently it looked like the inner flaps need to be reversed. They currently curve to the back of the box (as shown in the picture), so the cover flap has nowhere to cling to in order to stay closed.

Something to consider fixing for the template? I dunno.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 4d ago

Production & Manufacturing Help needed - where are we going wrong with this production?

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

Hi all. We have been working very hard to finally produce our first ever game. We made 10 boxes for our launch and when we put them side by side on the table we were proud, don't get me wrong, but we also just looked at each other and shook our heads. Sadly, they are just nowhere near good enough for the standards we'd set. The close up photos are the best box and board we have made and as you can see, it's not right (especially the box). I've been a crafter for as long as I can remember (amateur granted) and my partner has worked in design of various forms professionally for many years (albeit board game design/production is new to us) plus we're both perfectionists, so standards are high.

It would be frustrating enough if we had just made these 10, but as you can see from the photos, this is far from our first attempt. We have gone all round the houses, buying new tools and equipment, researching different methods, making tweaks (hence why some look similar), over and over, round in circles.

We make everything by hand and in terms of machines we have a:

XTool S1 20w.

Brother ScanNCut

Epson ET-8550.

Is this just the nature of making things in a home studio? (Read: second bedroom). Making things by hand? Is this the best we can manage? We have learned so much in the last few months having never done this before so perhaps we are missing something? I was looking at the box Skyteam comes in the other day and that seems slightly different to what I've tried in terms of how the art work is attached but I'm just not sure anymore.

Any advice would be appreciated, because as it stands we don't feel like we can release this version of the game. Don't get me wrong I'm not saying it's bad and I don't want anyone thinking I'm fishing for compliments because we genuinely don't think the box in particular is good enough. Plus, that and the board take so much longer to make than when we (eventually) remade it in wood with a leather cover. However, it would be good to be able to make boards and boxes from greyboard etc as appropriate moving forward without the involvement of a more industrial set up and to a standard where they are actually more viable than a wooden counterpart.

Any advice is appreciated.


r/BoardgameDesign • • 3d ago

Playtesting & Demos Design Collab

0 Upvotes

I am looking for an artist to collaborate with on a board game I am designing. I would say I am 90% with the game itself and am looking to move forward publishing the game. Please let me know if you are interested.