I will continue to update this post as reviews come in.
Rotten Tomatoes: Fresh
Critics Consensus: N/A
| Critics | Score | Number of Reviews | Average of Rated Reviews |
|---|
| All Critics | 89% | 73 | 7.70/10 |
| Top Critics | 86% | 22 | |
Metacritic: 75 (23 Reviews)
Sample Reviews:
Monica Castillo, AV Club B - While the stage on which Scott gives one of his best performances isnât perfect, heâs still acting for every seat in the house, more than earning his round of applause.
Nick Schager, The Daily Beast - Scott is magnetically moving in this wrenching drama, no matter its frequent, frustrating desire to abridge his performance with an endless procession of montages.
Peter Travers, The Travers Take 3.5/4 - In this emotional powerhouse, Andrew Scott gives the performance of the year as actor Ian Charleson, who died giving the performance of his life as Hamlet. Note to the Academy: start engraving Scottâs name on next yearâs Best Actor Oscar.
Kevin Maher, The Times (UK) 5/5 - Our protagonist has a rich off-stage life... which furnishes the histrionics with an aching heart.
Nick Howells, London Evening Standard 5/5 - This is a performance of a lifetime; and one the Academy voters would need a collective bout of insanity to ignore.
David Jenkins, Little White Lies - Itâs by no means a bad film â itâs stuffed to the gills with memorable barbs, and it certainly means well.
Tim Robey, Daily Telegraph (UK) 4/5 - Andrew Scott pours his soul into Elsinore, with stunning conviction, and will rightly win awards for his performance. If it was his compatriot Jessie Buckleyâs turn last year for Hamnet, itâs his now.
Linda Marric, HeyUGuys 4/5 - Elsinore is a heartfelt tribute to an actor who kept doing what he loved when everything around him said to stop. It can be heavy-handed, but its sincerity is never in doubt.
Ed Gonzalez, Slant Magazine 2/4 - Ian Charlesonâs need to play Hamlet is never unpacked for us, even if Andrew Scott makes you feel it in your gut the way Ian does.
Donald Clarke, Irish Times 4/5 - Scott grasps the importance of conveying the actorâs motivation as a need rather than a desire. Again and again, the play makes bitter commentary on his situation. "I wasted time, and now doth time waste me," Hamlet says.
Sam Adams, Slate - Some may regard the rush of images and Stefan Gregory's swelling score as heavy-handed, but the sequence opens the floodgates as intended and brings us to the moment when Hamlet realizes that the uncertainty he feared above all has been pierced.
Johnny Oleksinski, New York Post 3.5/4 - Scott handles all of this with hidden-camera naturalism, helped out by Stone, who, while embracing a simplicity of style, also doesnât just plant a camera and let his lead park and bark, as is typical of British biopics.
Brian Tallerico, RogerEbert.com - Ultimately, Scott is so moving here that people will forgive how often the film works against what heâs doing, but they might not forget.
Ty Burr, Ty Burr's Watch List (Substack) 3.5/4 - Gives Scott a huge range of emotions to work with.
Alison Willmore, New York Magazine/Vulture - Elsinore neither damns nor absolves Ian for his refusal to follow suit, instead allowing the character to twist in his own doubts and regrets.
Benjamin Lee, Guardian 4/5 - Thereâs no artifice to Scottâs deeply felt performance despite being an actor playing an actor playing a character, he makes it all feel as real and as raw as it can be.
Kristy Puchko, Mashable - Elsinore is a religious experience.
Kyle Smith, Wall Street Journal - The movie, directed by Simon Stone, covers much-trodden territory and would have been more effective without the superabundant use of a âYou must cry nowâ score in the final act.
Steve Pond, TheWrap - Does "Elsinore" get melodramatic along the way? Sure, but only in the sense that Shakespeare gets melodramatic -- which is to say, gloriously so.
David Rooney, The Hollywood Reporter - Scottâs searing dual performance makes Simon Stoneâs film an emotional powerhouse even if it doesnât avoid inspirational clichĂ©. But itâs a vivid picture of London at the height of the AIDS crisis and a stirring gesture of gratitude to art.
Owen Gleiberman, Variety - Elsinore is in many ways styled as an art-house crowd-pleaser, and on that score it faces steeper odds than a film like this one might have a few decades ago. But Andrew Scott makes it an indelible journey.
Ryan Lattanzio, IndieWire C - Scott throws himself valiantly into the role of Charleson with the urgency and commitment of any of his best work, but the problem isnât his: Itâs that the movie surrounding him dulls the greatness of his performance with its conventional storytelling.
SYNOPSIS:
The deeply emotional and inspirational true story of Ian Charleson, a gifted actor whose greatest challenge becomes his greatest triumph. Facing his own mortality with unflinching honesty, wit, and grace, Charleson delivers a courageous performance that becomes a source of healing and inspiration for those around him.
CAST:
- Andrew Scott as Ian Charleson
- Olivia Colman as Margaret Johnson
- Billie Piper as Patsy Pollock
- Johnny Flynn as Richard Eyre
- Luke Thompson as Georgie
- David Dawson as Derek Jarman
- Matthew Beard as Sean Mathias
- Joe Locke as Nicholas
- Monica Dolan as Linda Tolhurst
- Georgie Glen as Jean
- Sadie Soverall as Alice
- Adeel Akhtar as Shahid
- Dickie Beau as Sister Belladonna
- Kadiff Kirwan as Sister Frigidity of the Nocturnal Emission
- Juliet Stevenson as Sylvia Syms
- Peter Mullan as Jack
DIRECTED BY: Simon Stone
SCREENPLAY BY: Stephen Beresford
BASED ON AN IDEA BY: Ethan Silverman
PRODUCED BY: Andrea Occhipinti, Gabrielle Tana, Pete Shilaimon, Mickey Liddell, Stefano Massenzi, Carolyn Marks Blackwood, Andrew Scott
EXECUTIVE PRODUCERS: Anna Marsh, Ron Halpern, Joe Naftalin, Sudie Smyth, Michael Glassman, Joseph Yakob, Natalia Shilaimon, Stephen Beresford, Ethan Silverman, Pierre du Plessis
CO-PRODUCERS: Claudia Cimmino, Meg Clark
DIRECTOR OF PHOTOGRAPHY: Mike Eley
PRODUCTION DESIGNER: Helen Scott
EDITED BY: Valerio Bonelli
COSTUME DESIGNER: Mel Page
MAKE-UP & HAIR DESIGNER: Nadia Stacey
MUSIC BY: Stefan Gregory
CASTING BY: Jessica Ronane
RUNTIME: 111 Minutes
RELEASE DATE: November 20, 2026 (Limited) / December 11, 2026 (Wide)