r/Breadit • • 2h ago

Weekly /r/Breadit Questions thread

1 Upvotes

Please use this thread to ask whatever questions have come up while baking!

Beginner baking friends, please check out the sidebar resources to help get started, like FAQs and External Links

Please be clear and concise in your question, and don't be afraid to add pictures and video links to help illustrate the problem you're facing.

Since this thread is likely to fill up quickly, consider sorting the comments by "new" (instead of "best" or "top") to see the newest posts.

For a subreddit devoted to this type of discussion during the rest of the week, please check out r/ArtisanBread or r/Sourdough.


r/Breadit • • 3h ago

Khorasan Scald Sourdough

224 Upvotes

Khorasan Scald Sourdough 🤩

Took 100g of Fresh Milled Khorosan Wheat and Made a Scald with 200g of Water.

Incorporated this and 30g of honey into my base country loaf formula modified to tolerate the higher hydration.

Buttery flavor profile, super tender and soft crumb.

Top 5 Sourdough loaves I’ve made 🤩

{Recipe}

100g Starter
150g Water (72F if using stand mixer)
335g Bread Flour (King Arthur)
10g Salt

+

Scald

100g Khorosan Whole Grain Flour
200g Boiling Water
30g Honey

Instruction šŸ‘‡

Mix your starter night before along with your scald.

Pour boiling water over your whole grain Khorosan flour and honey and mix until a thick porridge and allow to cool.

On the Next Day add your starter, scald and water to a bowl and mix.

Next add your dry ingredients of bread flour and salt to the bowl of your stand mixer and mix on low for 3-4 minutes to incorporate and then kick into 2nd/3rd speed and allow dough to develop until it passes window test and is clearing the bowl. This took me about 12-13 minutes total. If dough seems really loose add some flour in until it comes together better.

Target dough temp of ~80F.

Perform 2-3 sets of folds on the dough every 30 minutes. Add more if the dough is slack.

Total bulk fermentation time of ~4.5 hours at 80F.

Lightly preshape the dough.

Rest 10 minutes and do final shaping and place into proofing vessel.

Proof at room temp for 1-2 hours or until dough has filled the basket and passes poke test.

Place uncovered into fridge for 12-24 hours to finish cold fermentation.

Preheat oven and Dutch Oven at 450F for 20-30 minutes.

Place parchment paper down onto Dutch oven and and turn out your loaf and do one vertical score down the middle to help with oven spring and controlled expansion.

Bake for 20 minutes covered, and 20-25 minutes uncovered to develop the crust. This loaf benefits from a darker crust so push it a bit.

Let cool for a few hours and enjoy!


r/Breadit • • 15h ago

Insanely Fluffy Pretzels with Tangzhong 🄨

Thumbnail
gallery
924 Upvotes

I’m recipe-testing as I consider opening a milk bread home bakery, and had to share this creation! OMG these are the softest, fluffiest pretzels ever, thanks to the tangzhong, but still maintain the chewy shell that all good pretzels must have.

I didn’t add too much tangzhong as I still wanted a dense, yet cloud-like, texture, and I think this hits the mark.

This isn’t the most well-written recipe, but the proportions for 6 large pretzels are:

- 195g Warm water
- 7g Instant yeast
- 75g brown sugar (I’d add less next time)
- 405g bread flour
- 50g cooked and cooled tangzhong (cook flour and water in a 1:5 ratio until thick)
- 2 tsp kosher salt
- 52g butter

And I used a diluted lye mixture of 35g lye : 940g water

Instructions:

  1. Use spiral mixer to mix together first 4 ingredients for 7 min
  2. Add in TZ and mix for another 2 min
  3. Sprinkle in salt and mix for another 4 min
  4. Add in chopped up pieces of butter and mix for another 6-8 min, or until you reach windowpane
  5. Rise for another hour
  6. Divide into 6 balls and let rest for 15-20min
  7. Shake into pretzel shape and let rise for 1.5-2 hours (my kitchen is quite cold)
  8. Refrigerate for 20-30 min to firm up
  9. Dip each pretzel in diluted lye solution for a few seconds each
  10. Bake at 420F for 15 min

if you’re using lye, you must do your own research because it can do some damage. I wore eye protection, gloves, and a face mask when I followed step 9. Even then, it got on my fingers and I spent like 20 min rinsing my hands. Be careful! Worth it though.


r/Breadit • • 5h ago Heartwarming

Japanese Milk Bread

Thumbnail
gallery
67 Upvotes

I decided to make this soft and fluffy shokupan. To me the challenge is in the shaping.
Here is the recipe: https://butterjoykitchen.com/shokupan-recipe/


r/Breadit • • 50m ago

Roasted homemade butternut squash soup and home made bread šŸž šŸ˜‹

Thumbnail gallery
14 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 5h ago

Homemade Bread hedgehog’s for granddaughteršŸ˜‚

Thumbnail gallery
33 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 3h ago

Wednesday morning loaf

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

72% hydration with a ratio of 7:1.5:1.5 of bread, whole wheat, and rye flours. The loaf cold proofed overnight.


r/Breadit • • 2h ago

First focaccia

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 7h ago

Detroit Style - Pie #3

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

#3. Flour: 90% KA bread / 10% semolina; hydration: 80%; salt: 2.4%; IDY: 1.0%; cold ferment: ~65 h; final pan proof: ~2.5 h; pan oil: ~18 g canola; bake: 450°F convection in countertop Ninja, 21 min; pulled by color.

Compared with #2: hydration 75 → 80%; semolina 15 → 10%; yeast 0.79 → 1.0%; cold ferment 24 → 65 h. I just did this stuff because I thought it'd help. Way more open & honeycombed crumb; deeper caramelization and a more blistered, textured underside. Audibly crunchy crust! Decent frico - still lots of work to do.


r/Breadit • • 12h ago

Is it truly cheaper to make our own bread??

84 Upvotes

I live alone and have been making my own bread for the past 2-3 weeks in an effort to save money.

I live in Canada

Before then, I bought the the literal cheapest white loaf for 3$ and it had like 24-26 slices (720 grams). It lasted me 2 weeks or so. (1.5$/week average or 6$/month)

I’ve been using a small ish recipe and it tends to deliver for about 350-380 grams of bread (final product. To lower the bill even more I make my bread in an air fryer for about 35-40 minutes at 385 (0.5kwh or about 0.04$ with everything considered)

I’ve invested into an enameled cast iron before hand (that I regret since I bought a huge 7 quart pot for 100$ even though it’s a deal it’s not practical at all. In in search actually for a after Christmas deal of a 5 quart.

Here’s the recipe break down with direct cost of product per recipe for me. The estimated costs was made with all the regular pricing near me (cheapest option)

- 250g unbleached white flour ; 0.4$
- 235g water ; 0.00$
- 1tsp salt ; 0.01$
- 1tsp sugar ; 0.006$

- 1tsp instant bread active dry yeast ; 0.03$
OR
- 1tsp traditional active dry yeast ; 0.2$

Since my pot is so huge for the amount of bread, I have to throw in 2 ice cube to make sure there’s enough hydration.

Final price of my loaf is at the cheapest; 0,576$ or 0.746$ if there is no sale to cut the price further (can happen, whereas the cheapest loaf is never ever at a deal)

I make about 1 loaf every 3-4 days, let’s say 2 a week.
Scenario 1 for 2 weeks : cheapest ; 2.304$
Scenario for 2 weeks : higher quality yeast ; 2.984$
Monthly scenario 1; 4.608$ or 4.61$ (1,39$ saving)
Monthly scenario 2; 5.968$ or 5.97$ (3Ā¢ savings…)

Looking very quickly, the bi-weekly/monthly pricing it doesn’t look that economical to do at home our own bread.

Let’s say I decide to exclude sugar/salt from the equation, it’s not much different. About 0.016$ less.

Also, I’ve been buying the cheapest flour (about 0.14$/100grams) in my area.

I’ve even done the calculation again only taking into account the flour, yeast and electricity only; it’s 0.47$/loaf or 3.76$ a month. (2.24$ in saving or -37%).

At first I was surprised and a bit disappointed tbh at the low saving even after playing the numbers. Then a friend told me to look at the cost of the bulk item and and count the cost per grocery run for bread.
Flour 7$ for 5kg (20loaf)
Yeast 2.99$ for 450gr or 4.5$ for 113gr (90loaf or 22 loaf)
Salt 1.79$ for 1kg (a wash)
Sugar 2,79$ for 2kg (400loaf, let’s call it a wash atp)
Totalling 14.57$ or deduced at 10$

If I take into account that the loaf at the store is 3$ minimum (the barebones!). Buying more than 3 loafs(1 1/2 month of bread for me)will outpace the price in bulk and me doing it. Looking at it that way ; after deducting the sugar and salt because they are clearly a wash with my daily use; after I bake 6 loaf , it’s like all the loafs after are « freeĀ Ā»! (About 14 loafs free or 1 3/4 of a month) Feels better to be honest.

Also, the loaf at the store is never at a deal (it being the cheapest), yet I’ve seen flour and other ingredients of bread making in deals. Quite spaced out but I’m willing to wait and bulk buy when the time comes. I’ll do on my own a price update when I bulk buy the deals. TBH from what i gathered of all my shenanigans; the flour price and the yeast is truly the biggest factor.


r/Breadit • • 7h ago

Roman pizza recipelearned in Rome (two separate tries)

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

Hi, have learned the dough recipe while on a trip to Rome. However when I tried to reproduce it in Singapore, the dough seems a lot stickier to handle, and I suspect it's due to the humidity issue. Planning to reduce hydration, but would like to seek some second opinion before I proceed. Thanks!


r/Breadit • • 21h ago

Second Run at Japanese Milk Bread (Getting Better)

Thumbnail
gallery
303 Upvotes

As someone that refuses to stop trying to make things better, I have it a second try from yesterday!


r/Breadit • • 13h ago

Finally made some good looking baguette

Post image
52 Upvotes

75% hydration with a poolish. My girlfriend said I looked like a kid in the candy store lmao. Also yes I need a wider baking steel/stone. Reposting because the original didn't have a photo whoops.


r/Breadit • • 18h ago

Couple of sourdoughs

Thumbnail
gallery
122 Upvotes

For experiment I added 100 gr of discard sourdough!

650 gr of white flour

300 gr of wholegrain

100 gr of discard

200 gr of levrain (mother)

650 water


r/Breadit • • 1h ago

Broccoli Cheddar Sourdough Foccacia

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Had this idea to do broccoli inclusions since broccoli cheddar is such a great combo. Came out delicious!

BROCOLLI BREAD.

86g starter

530g flour

415g water

13g salt

96g broccoli

Machine mixed 8 minutes speed 2, 2 bowl folds 2 coil folds. Proofed 12 hours 73F and baked about 30 minutes 425 with spray bottle steaming. I baked this before I had my coffee and mistakenly put it on the top rack so probably its 25 minutes at 425 if correctly placed.


r/Breadit • • 6h ago

Cast Iron Pan Pizza

Post image
8 Upvotes

My second time with this recipe. It’s a thick, insanely airy and buttery dough. I left the dough in the fridge overnight, but I guess I can leave it up to three. Going to try that next time to see a flavor difference.


r/Breadit • • 5h ago

Any tips for someone making bread for the first time?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I don't know why, but lately I've had such a strong craving for homemade bread, and my TikTok has started flooding me with pictures of homemade bread.

I'm crazy about a German bread I saw, and this focaccia too. But they seem difficult to make for the first time. Should I try another recipe?

If you could recommend a recipe, please let me know. I don't like bread that's soft on the outside. I prefer bread that's crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.


r/Breadit • • 8h ago

The American

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Super enriched dough.

I took 3 dough parts, flattened them, spread on smooth peanut butter, did a bookfold, added hazelnut chocolate, then rolled it into the tin. I did that whole fold-and-roll sequence 3 times in a row, and this is what we created.

I just want to say, this was delicious. If you toast this with some jam spread afterwards, the combo is superb.

I made this alongside a few other bakes, but out of everything I made, this was my favorite. It gave my dough the exact test I needed—heavy fillings supported by structure and engineering.

I hope you guys like it. Also, I am British. Peanut butter & chocolate is one of my favorite things ever. It’s homage, guys, I promise.


r/Breadit • • 2h ago

Homemade Bread this morning

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 1d ago

A vintage bun divider

1.8k Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 5h ago

Homemade Lievito madre Shokupan

4 Upvotes

Ive converted my levain into lievito madre by feeding at 50% hydration twice a day for 4 weeks


r/Breadit • • 5h ago

Brioche bunn with sour cherry filling

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 17h ago

I am tasked with making the rolls this year for thanksgiving. I also live 3 hours away. So I'm hoping to make them Wednesday night and the warm them Thursday. Any tried and true recipe suggestions are 100% welcome.

24 Upvotes

r/Breadit • • 3m ago

Mushroom Soup and Sourdough Croutons

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Mushroom soup with cream cheese, butter, heavy whipping cream, mushrooms (pureed), seasonings and celery/carrit mix, in a mishroom stock.

Sourdough discard mixed with butter and italian herbs drenched over stale sourdough 1/4 loaf cubes and cooked in air fryer.