r/BudgetAudiophile • u/smackdaddies I aim to misbehave • Feb 19 '25
Guide to Buying Used Speakers, Improved and Revised, a SmackDaddies Production
Thanks to everyone who commented. I have redone the list to be more helpful, adding links will be ongoing.
This post is designed for the person new to audiophile gear, even if it is budget. It is not meant so much for the long time experienced audiophile. Think of this as rule of thumb type assistance, not a perfect list.
Used is a great way to get budget audiophile gear, If…
- You are in an urban area or otherwise live where there is a robust market
- You know what you are looking at
- What you buy has not pooped in its pants.
With this in mind, these are some suggestions for you. As always, YMMV. I don't claim this is a perfect list, just a useful list, especially for new to audiophile person.
Where to find stuff. Facebook Marketplace is where I find most in my area, but it may be different for you. Local places to check out in addition include Craigslist, Offerup, Garage Sales, Estate Sales, Pawn Shops, and FreeGeek, if you have one. Online, but shipping required, includes Goodwill, Ebay, Reverb, HiFiShark, Mecari, USAudioMark, Audiogon. Used Audio Gear stores are a great place to shop, but often have only the best, and it has often been refurbished. They cost more but you can count on what you buy working.
What you should look for. Generally speaking, things that are less than 20 years old, preferably 10. Why? Because they have a much higher likelihood of not needing repair. Age is not kind to any electronics, speaker surrounds and paper cones. Anything over 40 years old will need repair to work at spec. Which is doable, if you have money, or skills and time.
Google is your friend. Do your own research first to get an idea on what specific speaker you are looking at.
Avoid White Van Speakers. If you google the name of the speaker and can't find the company, don’t buy it.
Speakers should feel heavy and solid for their size. If you knock on the side it should not sound hollow. Avoid Monkey Coffins.
Generally speaker only manufacturers are better than companies that make all sorts of electronics (not always true, but a general rule of thumb).
Speakers with four or more drivers from the 60’s and 70’s. There are some very high end modern speakers, but generally speaking, more drivers does not mean more better.
If the speaker has wires just feeding out of the back, do not buy them. They may make sound but not in any way, even budget, are audiophile.
Plastic Speakers are usually junk, unless they are Genelec, ILoud, JBL, Kali and a few others. Pretty much any plastic speaker at Goodwill is crap.
Micro Systems are almost always crap. No, not all of them. Likely all of the ones you will find used unless you go to a good used audio store.
Five way binding posts are not evidence of a good speaker, especially if it is an older speaker.
Things to look at all speakers to determine if they are crap (although most anything is repairable)
If the crossovers are just capacitors in line, say no unless you are buying garage speakers.
Are the surrounds of the woofers trashed (or missing)? Replacement is fairly easily done, and there are a ton of kits out there.
Has the ferrofluid dried up or leaked out? I have read you get 15-20 years before that happens. Replacement fluid is sold. Ken Kantor advice is probably gospel.
I have seen a number of tweeters blown in my life on speakers I was hoping to buy, especially 70's and earlier gear. I may have blown one or two myself. Sometimes very hard to find a replacement that matches the other. How can you tell? Harsh or brittle sound, missing details in high-pitched sounds like cymbals or vocals, distorted sound at high volumes.
Are any of the capacitors split or appear to have leaked in the past
Rips and Tears in the cone
Different speaker models in the pair of speakers (means one has been replaced, likely does not match the other)
Speaker Brands, with comments - The Good, The Bad, The Ugly
Even good brands made bad speakers. And vintage can just mean clapped out. However, below is a list of speaker brands that I would consider, or not, as discussed.
Acoustic Research (AR)
Adams
ADS
Advent
Akai - Mostly dreck. New ones are crappy, old ones look cool but generally not good either.
Altec Lansing. Some very interesting 1970's and earlier. Anything since 1980 or so is dreck
Andover Audio
Audioengine
Boston Acoustics
B&W
Canton
Cerwin Vega (party speakers)
Dali
Dayton Audio - Generally very entry level, and most are very cheap new. Ok for their price point, some like the B652 get real love
DCM
DefTech
Edifier
Elac (avoid the BS-41, personal opinion, hated my set)
Energy
Fischer - I have never heard a good one. Made a lot of all in one systems.
Genelec
ILoud
Harmon Kardon - The brand owns companies such as Revel and Infinity which make/made great speakers. I don't know anything badged Harmon or HK that is very good. The HK 50 Omni seems interesting at least
Infinity - Their Primus line is perhaps one of the best used buys available. Seriously. Better than most new.
Jamo C series are good. S series are entry level and less awesome. Your budget is your budget. Some think they are too bright. I loved my C103
JBL (not their tiny plastic speakers like the Control 1). Not a huge fan of the 80's Northridge speakers. Ended up putting mine in the garage. Lots of love for other JBL from fans. I am 0-2 with them.
JVC. Garage speakers. Not even budget audiophile. I would listen to a pair of SK 33, 44, or 55's from the 70's if I could find them. .
Kali
Kanto
KEF
Kenwood. Good electronics company, not a good speaker manufacturer. Perhaps ok for your garage.
Klipsch makes some all time great speakers. Again, their entry level like the R-41 are…not awesome. The budget speakers are often labeled "bright" or shrill. And their claims of high efficiency? Advertising fluff.
KLH made some very good speakers in days past…and later some very bad ones. Their newest are reportedly quite good. So...pre 1980 and post 2020 are good? YMMV
Marantz - Other than their Imperial line, not good. Info on the Imperial Line
Martin Logan
Micca - I love me some Micca's. Solid budget speakers. New they are cheap ($100 to $160) so used should be under 50 for sure. Less if they are the Micca MB42 non X versions
Mirage
Mission
Monitor Audio
Monoprice - Some decent inexpensive speakers. Nothing that would be call classic or great
MTX - cheap garage speakers. House brand of Crazy TV Lenny (Madison) and others. Yes, I did own them. They were fun for an 18 year old having house partys when the rest of the family was on vacation. Not that it ever happened
NHT
Ohm Walsh
Panasonic - No. No. And No again.
Philharmonic Audio
Philips. Pre 1990 Philips was a very innovative electronics company that did not make great speakers. After 1991 they became a great mountain of trash electronics company with terrible speakers.
Pioneer. If they say Andrew Jones on the back they are great cheap speakers, or they are good if they are the CS, HPM, or L series. Any of the vintage ones will need work unless someone already did it. The DJ series are ok powered speakers at their price point
Polk makes great speakers. Their T series are not great. Avoid them
PSB - Image speakers have a tendency towards bad tweeters, so pay attention if you are looking at them. PSB makes good speakers otherwise.
QAccoustic
Realistic (Tandy). A major part of electronics life pre 80's, with stores everywhere. Key to the DIY'r. Speakers made by Realistic could be quite good, until they cut quality to increase profits. Eventually they stopped manufacturing speakers and just rebadged things (Most of their 90's stuff was made by Pioneer) Optimus 10, Optimus-23, T-70 and T-300 are reportedly good speakers. The designer of those speakers has some comments in this AudioKarma Post
Revel. Yes please, may I have another.
RSL (Rogers Sound Lab). Direct to consumer company. Good.
Sansui. Perhaps their SP line in the 70's. They are real wood with a wood grill. Nothing else.
Sanyo. Even their 1970's speakers were bad. By the time they got to the 80's they were just terrible.
Sony. The Sony Sscs line up are ok budget speakers (although their current pricing is disgustingly high). Most Sony speakers not worth your time. If you can find an of their SS line such as the SS-M9ED are worth a listen. Mostly they were sold in Japan. If I found any AR1, GR1, or APM-6 I would give them a try.
SVS
Store Brands such as JCPenny, Sears, Montgomery Wards - mostly terrible dreck, at least the speakers.
Tannoy
Technics. Made a lot of terrible rack systems over the years. At best garage speakers. However, they became more of a high end speaker manufacturer in the 2010's. Recommended by others include The SB-F1 through F3, especially their Mk2 line. So, avoid the monkey coffins they have made, but if you see newer speakers listed above, worth an investigation.
Triangle
Wharfedale
Yamaha
What about Bose?
Not my cup of tea, but some people think they are great. Listen to them before you buy. There are a lot of bars running the 201's and they sound fine there.
What should I pay
Rule of thumb for me is 30% of their current new price. This of course is modified by if they are NIB or if they are vintage gear I really want. HiFiShark.com is your friend for determining prices asked, as is EBay, by search for the sold price (not asking) In the end, the fair price is what a willing seller and willing buyer agree to.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '25 edited Feb 19 '25
I don't find that to be the case. Rather there are a lot of places trying to cash in on the vintage audio boomlet from the vinyl resurgence. I often see mediocre gear sold at premium prices. Who knows if they have been refurbed or even had the contacts cleaned.
Also I don't agree with your assessment of Technics- they have made more than a handful of good models. I'd advise people to do their research on the particular model.
I couldn't personally recommend any Pioneer speakers that aren't HPM or CS-R specifically. HPM were designed by a guy who worked at JBL- and put a lot into drivers and electronics. CS-R was sort of their premium line before HPM. The rest of their speakers are just okay.
4
u/Fickle-Willingness80 Feb 19 '25
If you know what you’re looking at and there’s damage to drivers it way be an opportunity to repair and score a great deal on the purchase price. Just make sure you understand the depth of the damage and replacement repair costs. Inspect each driver (with signal) even if they look fine.
5
u/JeebusFright Feb 19 '25
Tannoy crying unloved in the corner...
2
u/ghrant Feb 19 '25
Add these notes for PSB, the “Image” (not “imagine”) series have weak tweeters. They are actually a good sounding speaker, if flipped enough of those now to know to avoid those without a thorough listen test.
2
u/ghrant Feb 19 '25
I applaud you for making this list. I’ve been thinking about doing the same but it felt “old man yells at clouds”.
I have over 50 years of experience in the audio field. I started with my father (audio buff way ahead of his time) in the 70’s, made a living from audio retail in the 80s and 90s and continue to freelance audio gear collect/flip to this day. My focus has been on how to get the best audio experience for the average person for the least amount of money. 5 or 6 figure audio systems, while cool and interesting, are not my cup of tea. I think most of your points are clear and helpful A couple thoughts;
… anyways. Good job, keep spreading the knowledge.
1
u/tupisac studio monitors guy Feb 20 '25
Great post.
Two small things - I'd add Adam to the brands and change iMicro to iLoud.
1
u/collectability Feb 20 '25
Can you add ADS to the list, please?