r/BudgetAudiophile • I aim to misbehave • Apr 24 '22

Beginner BudgetAudiophile Guide to Subwoofers - yes, another SmackDaddies Production

Subwoofers. They are great. And sometimes they suck for reasons we cant figure out. So lets chat.

Budget Subwoofers come in three tiers - the under $150, the $150 to $400, and the $400 to $600. And yes, they get better in each tier. Even the cheap ones can improve your system, but they have limitations.

General Advice

Spending more money equals a better sub. No way around it. Your budget is your budget, but if you can get to the over $400 level, they are impressively better.

Placement matters - a lot. MartinLogan has a great subwoofer setup video. Stop now, watch this video. Have you watched it yet? Go do it. Even if you have been using a sub a long time, you will learn something. Well set up subwoofers should integrate with your main speakers - you should not hear the sub separately from the speakers. Weird, I know, but there it is.

If you want some amusement, watch Zeos do the sub crawl.

If you live in an apartment (or with roommates), no, you cannot isolate your sub from disturbing them when you rock out. Ain't going to happen. Best advice is to talk with your neighbors first. Try to find times that won't disturb them (much). Bring them pie. Help shovel their car out. Don't be a jerk. SVS has advice that may help. If you want to feel the boom (but not piss off the neighbors), try a bass shaker.

  • Bass Shaker info from HorizonsEdge What is a Bass Shaker? Bass Shakers, or tactile transducers, are basically a speaker that only operates at extremely low frequencies. It's physically screwed into a chair, sofa or virtual reality cockpit, and sends a low frequency vibration through the furniture, shaking its occupant with precision.
  • Why use them? If you live in an apartment this is a viable alternative to adding a subwoofer so as to not alienate your neighbors. Energy will not transfer from your furniture. You may want something between hardwood floors in some instances.
  • How do I connect them? Typical configuration is a subwoofer amplifier connected via LFE (or high level inputs if it is an option) driving a shaker screwed into your furniture. The amp is then wired to the shakers with speaker wire.

Fun Facts They are often found in high end gaming chairs and theaters to enhance the experience.

Sometimes two cheaper subs are better then one slightly more expensive sub. You will fill the room with low frequencies better with more subwoofers. Science

Don't try to reuse subs from a HTIB or Logitech system. They truly suck. They are not ever going to sound good.

Sometimes you cant set it up "right". WAF, room use, whatever. I have a flat sub buried under my steel "tanker" desk, because that is where I can fit in my home office. It is not the "right" location. It still can add value, just not as much as with proper set up. Do what you can.

How do I connect them up?

It depends on the sub, but there will be one, or both of the two options on your sub.

First – High level inputs (speaker wire). The concept here is you run speaker wire from the Amp to the Sub on the inputs, and from the Sub to your speakers from the Outputs. There are other ways to accomplish this, but this is the basic concept.

Second – Low level inputs (LFE). Sometimes there will be one connection, sometimes two. Sub frequency is basically mono, so one connection is fine. Read your sub manual for instructions if your receiver has one output and the sub has two inputs.

Under $150 Subs. Most of these subs will be low power (100 w or less) with smaller drivers (6", 8" or 10"). They will not have awesome construction and they will use drivers that are...cheap. There is no $150 subwoofer that will produce good quality sound at reference levels, nor produce Movie theater bass. They are not designed to. They are, as Erin at Erin's Audio Corner calls them, mid-bass units. They are going to do ok at 40-50 Hz to 80 Hz. Which is great for music. Most music that we listen to, just doesn't get below 40 Hz. Yes, some, very little, does. If you are into house music/dubstep, you will want lower. For those of us listening to Rock, Jazz, folk, most alternate, pop - you will have very little if anything that low. So great, right?

No, not so much. Again, they don't produce under that level at all. Second, turning them up to 11 makes them a crappy bloated mess. Likely you are never going to be able to turn them up to over 1/3 volume. Which is still ok, because they will fill in what most bookshelf speakers just don't reproduce well - most stand mounts crap out at 80Hz, sometimes as low as 60 Hz. So even the most hated of subwoofers, the Polk SW10, can help. (I own one, paid $25 for it used, which is about what it is worth new). Now some cheap subwoofers are better than others. Again, Erin at Erin's Audio Corner has some nice comparison videos on budget subs.

TL:DR for under $150? Keep the power down, try to place them as well as you can, don't expect miracles. But used correctly, it can make a positive difference in music listening enjoyment, and even help some with movies.

$150 to $400 Subs. Subs at this level are usually getting bigger. Bigger drivers - 12", even 15". Bigger amps - mo powa. Better design. Better quality drivers and amps. They will generally be able to get to lower notes, but not that much lower (35 Hz). Are they going to reproduce lower sound levels? Yes. Are they big. Hell yes. Are they equal to over $400 subs? Hell no. General same rules apply - they are going to start sounding bad when you turn the power up, say past 50% (or lower) .

$400 to $600 Subs. This is the sweet spot for budget subs, especially for music. Spending more money will buy better subs, especially if you need that movie theater bass, but for music - it's all you need to spend. Subs will have better electronics, better design, better drivers. You can turn them up and they won't be a bloated mess. You still need to set them up correctly, but they are just better. Most subwoofer manufacturers produce good subs in this range.

Over $600 subs. Yup, they are good. I don't think you need to spend that much on a budget to get a very good sub. You be you.

General Subwoofer Buying Advice

Spend over $400 if you can. Or buy a more expensive sub used. Just be sure it works. A lot of used subs suffer from bad amplifiers - they get driven to hard and then fail.

Ported or Sealed Box. Everyone has an opinion. I am agnostic on the issue. Ported subs will generally get to a lower HZ, people say sealed is better for music. Whatever. I have a ported Martin Logan sub and I think it sings. YMMV.

Universal beginner advice - Don't over think it. Buy what you can afford, do your best with set up, it will be better than not having one

Wirecutter maintains some great statistics and reviews.

Various YouTube folks like Erin's Audio Corner, Joe N Tell, Zeos

HomeTheater Buying Guide on reddit. Lots of reviews. Generally speaking, if it is good for home theater, it will likely be good for music.

What about Amazon Reviews? … They are idiots. Never believe Amazon reviews when it comes to speakers/subwoofers.

That's it - another Smackdaddies production. It's worth what you paid for it.

24 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

9

u/joentell I review stuff on YouTube Apr 24 '22

👏 Very good summary here and I agree with everything said. I would add that if someone had to decide between 2 x$250 subs that could only go down to 30hz vs 1 x $500 sub that could get down to 20hz, I would recommend the single $500 sub. The two subs give smoother bass, but they will never hit 20hz with authority. The single better sub will. Also, you can save up to eventually get a second $500 sub. With the two $250 subs, you'll have to try to sell them which might be hassle than it's worth.

On the flip side, if someone were to ask me whether they should get one $1000 sub vs 2 x $500 subs, I would go for the two $500 ones just because they will at least get down to 20hz. Even the Monolith THX 10 I previously reviewed gets down to 16hz in-room. The SVS PB1000 Pro does also. The prices have gone up on subs lately, so check the current prices.

4

u/polypeptide147 Bookshelf speakers don't go on a bookshelf Apr 24 '22

I had a Dayton SUB1200 and upgraded to a SVS SB1000. The difference is night and day. One of the best upgrades I've made to my system.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '22

So mortified I got a Polk SW10 before discovering this subreddit. However, it’s night/day when you listened to music as long as I have without having any sub.

1

u/smackdaddies I aim to misbehave Apr 25 '22

It is a bad subwoofer in so many ways, but even it can be set up to be a useful addition. I still use mine

1

u/TheJakell Apr 25 '22

This seems like the place to ask since I just can't decide and pull a trigger on a sub. I'm looking to pair with Elac Debut B5.2s for HT and music. It's relatively small room, 8' x 12' I think. Ideally, I'd like to expand to a 5.1.2 setup so any money saved on the sub would go towards other speakers.

The options:

Emotiva SE8 - $330

SVS SB1000 (not pro) - $480

Rythmik L12 - $629

The budget can stretch to the Rythmiks, but like I said could end up putting the money else where in the system

1

u/smackdaddies I aim to misbehave Apr 25 '22

I think you would be happy with any of them. I would prob go SVS

1

u/HorizonsEdge [X1500H, HTD L2 L/R/C , Polk R50,RSL12s+Shakers] Apr 24 '22

I would suggest that you add a section about bass shakers. For those like myself who can not use a sub bc apartment attaching shakers to my couch has been a fantastic alternative.

1

u/smackdaddies I aim to misbehave Apr 24 '22

I really know nothing about them

1

u/movie50music50 Apr 25 '22

A decent sub you can hear and feel. Bass shakers are a huge step down in that you can only feel them. They add nothing to music and, without a good sub, very little to movie watching. Why should he bother? He already posted some great info.

0

u/blauerschnee Apr 24 '22

RemindMe! 2 days