White House national cyber director is leaving the administration
Cairncross will be replaced by Kirsten A. Davies.
Thoughts from the team here on what happens to our timeline regarding the pause?
r/CMMC • u/medicaustik • Nov 14 '25
Hello /r/CMMC -
As we wind down 2025, the CMMC ecosystem has seen several hundred organizations successfully passing their CMMC Level 2 C3PAO certification assessments! We love to see it!
This community and our discord community have always been about open sharing of information amongst fellow practitioners and straight up people who just need some help. We love seeing how everyone shares what's working for them and what's not.
Recently, we've seen a handful of threads start with people wanting to share their Certification experience and their lessons learned - this is fantastic. But, if you aren't on /r/CMMC frequently, you will miss these threads.
So, I want to create a mega-thread to collect these experiences in one spot where people can share their experiences and others can ask questions.
If you were planning to post a whole thread about your experience, I encourage you to instead post here. We aren't preventing anyone from posting a separate thread, but think it's best to keep most of those types of posts here for the reasons stated above.
Congrats to everyone who has passed so far! For those who are scheduled, my main advice: relax. If you found this community, there's a good chance you're taking this as seriously as you should, and that means you're probably going to pass.
Notes
You are welcome to name the names of the tools you used, the service providers that helped you, the consultants who guided you, the C3PAO that assessed you. All of that is fair game and generally encouraged.
Share as much about your environment as you comfortably can - people want to know what other environments look like. Remember though, OPSEC is your responsibility, not ours. Do not post identifying information if you are not authorized by your organization to do so.
If you struggled with a particular requirement, or had a debate with your assessor, tell us about it.
If you absolutely crushed a requirement or control family and the assessors just looked at you slack jawed with how great you were, TELL US ABOUT THAT.
FORMAT
Please share the following information in your comment:
Organization Size: Rough user & device count
Scope: Enterprise / Enclave - if Enclave, how many users/devices in the Enclave
Architecture: Full Cloud / On-Prem / Hybrid
Cloud Services: Microsoft 365 (GCC/GCCH) / AWS / Other CSP
C3PAO: Who did you work with (optional, you don't have to share this if you don't want)
Cert Status: Pass / Fail / Conditional / In-Progress
And then of course give us all the details you want to share :)
r/CMMC • u/DaGoodBoy • Jul 13 '26
Cairncross will be replaced by Kirsten A. Davies.
Thoughts from the team here on what happens to our timeline regarding the pause?
r/CMMC • u/PNW_CARDINAL • 6h ago
I enjoy reading infosec related news and also enjoy seeing how 800-171 requirements, even the "less important" ones, could make a difference in real life.
PE 3.10.6 could be used to mitigate modern threats:
"A Russian national is being held in custody after being arrested for allegedly spying on a US defense tech company in Palo Alto, shoulder-surfing employees, and dropping remote surveillance devices at their homes ; Court documents describe the company in question as a large technology and defense company with offices in Palo Alto ; The indictment alleges he was ordered to surveil employees' homes, take photographs of their screens while working remotely at coffee shops, and permit his handlers to remotely access his laptop for the purpose of capturing data from nearby devices owned by the company’s employees ; In some cases he was asked to leave a laptop outside one employee's apartment complex, all while allowing his handlers to remotely operate the device."
According to the Assessment Guide:
PE.L2-3.10.6 – ALTERNATIVE WORK SITES - Enforce safeguarding measures for CUI at alternate work sites.
1 pointer, can be POAM'd.
ASSESSMENT OBJECTIVES [NIST SP 800-171A] - Assessor must determine if:
[a] safeguarding measures for CUI are defined for alternate work sites;
[b] safeguarding measures defined in [a] are enforced for alternate work sites.
DISCUSSION - Alternate work sites may include government facilities or the private residences of employees. Organizations may define different security requirements for specific alternate work sites or types of sites depending on the work-related activities conducted at those sites.
FURTHER DISCUSSION - Many people work from home or travel as part of their job. Define and implement safeguards to account for protection of information beyond the enterprise perimeter. Safeguards may include physical protections, such as locked file drawers, as well as electronic protections such as encryption, audit logging, and proper access controls.
A customer wants to configure an AVD enclave environment.
Regulation states that if you only do keyboard video mouse redirection, it creates the segmentation allowing the VDI to be an enclave.
Then, the customer adds to the mix that they want to be able to do CAC authentication for some users from the AVD.
It feels like keeping them segmented to the enclave is still the most secure way to allow access to CUI but if we're doing redirection for a USB CAC reader than that puts us outside the regulatory exemption, correct?
Trying to do both the right thing and the compliance thing here and it doesn't feel like there is a good answer.
r/CMMC • u/Narrow-Raspberry-928 • 10h ago
We did our self affirmation and got a high 90 score and now our status shows as CMMC l2 conditional self assessment with an expiry in 180 days. With the Cmmc pause in place and self assessments still acceptable, would the system allow us to self affirmed when our current status expires even if all the POAM remediations are not in place. Please advise
r/CMMC • u/drussell024 • 1d ago
GHES is available on Azure gov. We want to use it for CUI code source control. It has a fips_mode setting, but GitHub doesn't document it and seems to claim there is no native FIPS support. When we enabled it, nothing changed and the appliance still accepted non-approved ciphers (meaning no validated module on the appliance).
3.13.11 requires FIPS-validated cryptography to protect CUI.
Our thought was to:
Our concern though is that the hop from the gateway to the appliance (inside the private network) will still use the appliance's (GHES) own encryption, which to our testing, is not FIPS-validated. It can accept FIPS approved ciphers, but we don't see that enforced by GHES.
Has anyone used GHES in a CMMC L2 environment? Is GitLab the real answer? Does this plan seem reasonable with proper documentation describing the above? We already hold a level 2 certification and want to do this properly.
r/CMMC • u/Travel69 • 1d ago
We are a CMMC level 2 certified shop, with on-prem Windows/Linux servers/clients and VDI. We also use GCC-H and AWS GovCloud. A second environment is totally air-gapped, and hosts a mixture of on-prem Windows/Linux servers/clients/VDI.
I'm looking for best in class monitoring/observability platform to provide visibility into our health/status of our environment and robust monitoring/alerting for both environments. Ideally we'd like the same platform for both the internet connected network and the air-gapped network. But I strongly suspect a SaaS offering will be more fully featured than a 'legacy' on-prem air-gapped solution so we likely will need two separate solutions.
For monitoring we need very configurable alerting, performance metrics, custsom dashboards, deep monitoring of Microsoft services (on-prem/GCC-H), robust web application monitoring, robust Linux services monitoring, VDI performance monitoring, network equipment, VPN devices, and hypervisor support.
Splunk is off totally the table for various reasons. For our SIEM we are migrating to Azure/Sentinel on the internet connected network. TBD on the air-gapped network. Any SaaS solutions must meet FedRAMP Moderate. Scale is in the ballpark of 2000-3000 endpoints/devices.
What solutions are people using that they are very happy with? Datadog, Dynatrace, Grafana Labs, Elastic, Azure Monitor, etc?
r/CMMC • u/TicketAmbitious6200 • 1d ago
r/CMMC • u/Repulsive-Milk-8694 • 2d ago
r/CMMC • u/Nilram8080 • 2d ago
Our team is feeling pretty hung up on asset categorization and inventory. It sounded simple at first and then rapidly became not simple. Are things like managed and unmanaged switches and wireless access points CUI assets or specialized assets? They can transmit CUI but they're not storing it and they can't implement all of the assessment objectives. From the Scoping Guide it looks like they would need Enduring Exceptions. It states "Specialized Assets and GFE may be Enduring Exceptions". It does not state it can apply to CUI Assets, though much of the guidance online suggest they should be CUI Assets. Similarly USB disk drives and internal disk drives cannot implement all controls themselves. Should a hard drive be documented in inventory when internal to a computer, or only when loose and containing CUI?
r/CMMC • u/cylemmulo • 2d ago
So, looking at scoping, we're pretty small like 20 people, and basically nobody has any interaction with any CUI, but we have one or two that are giving the requirement I think on the off chance they have to send us CUI, whatever.
We have looked into scoping and how small we'd want that, curious if there would be anything wrong, or if anyone is doing this. Like setup literally a single segregated PC. We already have preveil for email, so set that up there, setup a syslog, a separate network, no printer access, setup all the other lockdowns on the PC etc.
Would there be any inherent problems with this? I know we have to have all the other lockdowns for the building, training etc. Just looking for an option that will be lower cost and lower management overhead. I don't know if I'm missing something obvious or completely misreading how to do things.
r/CMMC • u/No_Designer_8897 • 3d ago
Anyone else pay for an assessment then the pause happened and you were with within your refund period so you asked?
We just did. We waited the 60 days, then some and the auditor gave a bunch of different options but wasn’t worth it.
We are confident is our setup and couldn’t imagine a false claims act. It’s possible if we were audited we may gave a finding but nothing negligent.
I just can’t find a good reason we should still pay an auditor to audit us. Beyond the actual cost of the audit, the time for us to go through the audit is a a lot of resources in terms of evidence and working with the auditors. I feel kind of bad, because the auditors are in a tough spot, but also feel like they are taking advantage a bit with the outrageous costs of audits.
I was notified this morning that my C3PAO submitted our assessment to eMASS. Anyone know if it should be immediately available in SPRS, or if there is some delay? We have a couple of business deals tied to CMMC, and the sales folks are asking questions.
Closely related, is there any role requirement in SPRS to be the affirming official besides being the cyber user?
r/CMMC • u/DFARSDidNothingWrong • 5d ago
In the last two weeks:
ILC Dover / Astrospace: $13,468,000 total
- Federal government: $10,650,000 (79.1%)
- Whistleblower: $2,350,000 (17.4%)
- Attorneys' fees and costs: $288,000 (2.1%)
- Additional whistleblower settlement: $180,000 (1.3%)
Settlement: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/defense-and-aerospace-contractors-ilc-dover-and-ilc-astrospace-agree-pay-13m-resolve
Johnson Controls: $5,298,750 total
- Federal government: $4,150,000 (78.3%)
- Whistleblowers: $850,000 (16.0%)
- Attorneys' fees and costs: $298,750 (5.6%)
Settlement: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/hvac-supplier-johnson-controls-inc-and-two-subsidiaries-agree-pay-5-million-settle
r/CMMC • u/legdayerrdayy • 6d ago
How exactly has the pause on third party assessments impacted the workforce? I want to get certified and I don't expect the arguably overpriced pay.
I'm just looking for a decent second income.
r/CMMC • u/Picasso1067 • 6d ago
Just curious if anyone in GCCH experienced issues.
r/CMMC • u/Intelligent_Gur6298 • 7d ago
Hi Everyone - I'm looking for guidance or your opinion if our IT director is being overly zealous in his requirement of CMMC Certification. Now that our company is Level 2 Certified by C3PAO assessment, he is expecting all of our vendors and contractors to have, at the least, Level 1 certification for access to any project that occurred after the NIST SP 800-171 release in 2017. Its all become a bit onerous.
r/CMMC • u/DevelopmentShoddy399 • 7d ago
Originally posted on Nov 12th, 2026 - Our defense contractor wants a FIPS 140-3 firewall for our 7 employees. I think these are what we're best off with, but I'm not sure.
COA 1: PA-440
COA 2: FortiGateRugged 60F
COA 3: ??? We almost went with SonicWall but decided against it. $3,217 to $6,460+ SonicWALL NSa 4700 or maybe WatchGuard T45-PoE? I'm thinking the PA-440 can't fail. Not sure though. Thoughts?
EDIT Nov 17th 2026:
I don't like any of these I suggested, and notably because the FortiGate I mentioned has 2gb of ram, it's not what I want. I have done lots of research here. The 60F has 2gb ram, but the 70F has 4gb. For the "you probably don't need one" responses - we need one. I need an on-site firewall and access point. I'll probably lock the firewall in a small server rack and use a PoE injector to minimize cost of a Fortigate switch + Forticare subscription for just a switch. The entire income of the organization is only the defense contract we have. All users handle CUI here.
I wanted a silent firewall for my office that is not End of Sale. I need one with onboard storage because our SIEM is still being set up. I want it to have 4gb of ram, at minimum, for longevity. I want a multi-year support package without spending an absurd amount. The only options I'm shopping from are on the FIPS 140-3 FortiOS 7.4 list here:
I'm gonna go with the FortiGate 71F. If you're buying this in November 2026, this is not a bad Fortinet option. We're still working on our SIEM, so in the mean time, the 71F has onboard storage, as opposed to the 70F. The 81F would be great, but it's too expensive. I kind of wanted an 81F-PoE, until I learned it made noise - also too expensive. No bueno. It's gonna sit next to us.
r/CMMC • u/polykyri • 7d ago
I am looking for a solution to get photos from an SD card or scans into the enclave. We use SharePoint and have VM's in an enclave. Would it bring a computer in scope to plug in an SD card or USB drive with the file to transfer it?
r/CMMC • u/steenbag • 8d ago
Hi all,
We're working through our SPRS score, and one of our sticking points is 3.7.3, "Ensure equipment removed for off-site maintenance is sanitized of any CUI."
We're a small company with several remote employees. Historically we've used FedEx to ship devices to employees for onboarding/offboarding, or service. It would seem to me that this is incompatible with the requirement, so how are you handling it?
Eg, if a remote worker's laptop has crashed, and isn't bootable, and needs to come in for service, there is no way to wipe the drive. It's also not feasible (or possible for macs) to ask the user to remove a drive prior to shipping - and this would also make the MSP's job of troubleshooting the boot problem impossible. For local users, it's easy enough to get a technician from the MSP to come on site, so really it's just the remote workers that are an issue.
Thanks for any advice!
r/CMMC • u/Sudo-Delicious • 9d ago
Something I always tell organizations preparing for CMMC Level 2 is to test their security controls before the assessor does.
Just because your policy says something is in place doesn’t mean it’s actually working. For example, if accounts are supposed to lock after a certain number of failed login attempts, have you tried it to see if it works?
Don’t assume everything is working just because it’s configured that way.
Take the time to test it, document what you find, and fix anything that isn’t working.
It’s not enough to say you have a control in place, you gotta prove it.
r/CMMC • u/xxxTek007 • 9d ago
Aloha!!
We're working on getting a cloud enclave up asap. I'm now under pressure to get a solution in place right away. But I'm also being told that our derived info (Which is smaller parts of an OEM drawing that we use to manufacture parts) is not to be in scope. All my training tells me that it should be in scope. But the caveat is that non of the drawings are marked as CUI. They have a control statement D on them which to me should be treated as CTI/CUI but would like clarification from the contracting officer.
Any advice???
r/CMMC • u/SignalPicklee • 10d ago
Our mock assessment found several practices we scored as fully implemented are only partial. They're on some systems, not all of the ones in scope, so our SPRS score is too high.
How do I correct it before a C3PAO assessment, and does fixing it now look bad?
r/CMMC • u/Plugging-Away • 9d ago
I’ve posted this in Discord’s Cooey COE and C3PAO Forum as well.
Context:
- 1 company with 3 locations and a CAGE code per site. None of the records has a HLO as each record does not have immediate owners--all three sites are the same company.
- I am conducting pre-assessment checks as Consultant to an OSC pursuing L2
BLUF: How does the OSC, the on-contract C3PAO, and I overcome the coming pain point that _there is no HLO_ yet eMASS requires an HLO and checks that data against SAM.gov before putting the assessment data into SPRS?
Background:
- I've searched an multiple places and come up empty (my search skills may need honing).
- FAR 52.204-17 Ownership or Control of Offeror is pretty clear the company with 3 locations and 3 codes does not have an HLO.....AND I think not really the point.
- Lots of discussions about HLOs when there is indeed an immediate owner. None that I can find that seem to fit the context above.
- All three CAGE codes in the assessment is no prob. semi-colon delimited list!
- I have read/heard any number of reports of data rejection errors when C3PAOs try submit the assessment form without an HLO.
- I don't see any discussion of HLO in the FAQ much less the context that started this query
- I searched Discord’s Cooey COE and C3PAO Forum
- I search reddit r/CMMC