r/Carnatic • u/Gokuxlr8 • 6h ago
DISCUSSION Opinion of Carnatic Enthusiasts
Hi all!
I have learnt carnatic music for roughly 10 years (coerced into such classes by my mom) and I haven't really understood how people become professional critics and genuinely enjoy kutcheris (concerts) that go on for hours with the vocals having more to do with alaps and Kalpana swarams than substance .
Interestingly (or conversely), I have found movie songs with a carnatic touch to be more palatable than authentic, rustic keerthanais.
While I genuinely enjoy some carnatic ragas like Hindolam, Thodi and Bhairavi (with their keerthanais), many other ragas are more pleasing when they're used in movie songs, at least to me. (Imagine converting the most boring vannila flavoured mayamalavagowlai into something like poova eduthu oru maalai by the maestro ilayaraja).
I also love Gaana songs, but that's probably shunned here .
Have you faced something similar and grown out of this phase? (I'm 30 yo btw).
Thanks š