Hi, looking for some advice or thoughts from others.
Recently we brought a new cat into the house. We don’t have a lot of info about him; we were told he is great with other cats, is between 6-12 months old and wasn’t fixed.
We got him fixed on 10/21. Not sure if this matters, but we don’t believe he sprayed anywhere. Our 4 resident cats are all also male cats, all fixed the minute we were able to do it, and we’ve never had an issue introducing any of them to each other before. Ages for them are 10yo, 6.5yo, and 3 yo. The two 3yos have not taken to new cat at all. One of them is absolutely petrified of new cat; he started peeing all over the house and potentially spraying (he is fixed but it looks like there was spray somehow? If that’s even possible), the second he saw new cat his tail puffed up and he ran and hid and he wouldn’t hang out downstairs with us. I’m wondering if he was using a litter box and new cat rushed at him? The other one was maybe just trying to set boundaries but we can’t be sure. Sometimes he would scream like he was being hurt but we never saw new cat attacking him but they could eat near each other with no issue and it wasn’t happening all the time. New cat would kind of rush at them but it never looked like a true attack.
We know we fucked up by letting him out after a couple weeks, but like I said, it’s never been an issue! We had previous cats who have since passed away and they never had issues either.
We’ve now re-separated new cat into our bedroom area and the resident cats have the rest of the house. We just did this on Sunday. We’ve started trying to follow the Jackson Galaxy approach of introductions with keeping them separate and feeding and playing with new cat and 3yos on each side of the door. It seems fine, even terrified cat will play and eat when new cat is meowing on the other side instead of running away. The other 3yo did hiss and growl at the door at the door a little too. We were thinking of doing scent swapping this weekend and locking the 3s in the room and letting new cat roam the house. Is that too early? Should we lock the other two in the room with the 3s? They do not seem to have an issue with him, they just sort of ignore each other. All resident cats have returned to totally normal behavior after the separation.
I am very worried about terrified cat peeing in the room or setting back any progress we may have made.
I’ve been reading all through all the posts about it but a lot of them seem to be more about introducing a young kitten.
If new cat is supposedly great with other cats (and seems okay with 2 of the residents) and we know that ours have never issues, could it be as “easy” as letting the hormones leave new cat’s body after getting fixed? We still plan to follow to Jackson method and give it time but hearing new cat cry at the door when we’re home, even if one of us is up there with him, is making me so upset. I feel terrible.
I will take any advice I can get. I know it hasn’t been that long but I’m kind of spiraling over it all
ETA: besides the 10ya having a thyroid issue, which he has meds for, they all have a clean bill of health from the vet and are up to date on shots