r/Catholicism • • 14h ago

Priest wants all second graders to kneel during first Communion

3 Upvotes

Hi there I just attended a parent meeting for my child’s first Holy Communion, and we were told the priest is requiring all the children to kneel and receive on the tongue. Is this normal? I have never kneeled and when I made my first Communion we did not kneel (yr 2000).

Edit:

This is in the United States. Chicago suburbs. At mass I typically only see maybe 2-4 people kneel out of a full parish so that is why I ask asking since this is definitely not something that I’m familiar with.


r/Catholicism • • 7h ago

Priest is making me doubt baptizing my children

1 Upvotes

Cradle Catholic, born and raised in the Church, 12 years in Catholic school, married in the Church. Husband is non-practicing, and I haven’t practiced in years.

My children are older, born during covid, when lockdowns were happening and gatherings discouraged. So on the cusp of the cut-off age. Life happened fast, I wasn’t really observing my faith over the years.

I just recently started walking back into my faith, still navigating what that looks like for me, let alone what I want that to look like for our children.

We met with the priest, who began to make me doubt again. Baptism would be important to me. My husband is agnostic/secular humanist, though was brought up Catholic as a child.

The priest questioned why I wanted them baptized now, after all these years. Why I JUST now joined a parish and started going to church. I haven’t brought my children yet, as I am navigating how I will approach it appropriately since this will be new to them. And I am still re-entering my walk. He said I have to go full throttle, or else the baptism does not work.

I studied anthropology, so that had really put religion into a different perspective for me, and I am navigating my beliefs.

I was never taught to make it part of my personality, which has been a culture shock to me entering the church again. There seems to be a blind all-or-nothing approach now, which I understand is part of having faith: to dive in headfirst into what you do not know. Once again, different from what I was taught growing up in school.

He made it seem like baptizing our children is pointless at this point, and that if my goal is to raise morally good people, I can do that without baptism.
That all that matters is that someone loves God, and does everything in His name. Which… yes. I understand that.

But what turned me away was seeing so many people using His name to excuse or forgive intentional immoral behavior, as self-righteousness, or a grift. That loving God and doing things in His name does not automatically mean you are a good and moral person.

He criticized me not consistently going to Mass since joining the Parish. I cannot help that I often work on weekends (typically triples that start as early as 4 am and end as late as 10 pm) because I cannot afford childcare. So yes, my walk back into faith is a slow one.

Anyways, I want to baptize my children, but to possibly be shamed and criticized in front of my family like I was in my meeting… does not come from a place of love in my opinion from the priest.


r/Catholicism • • 5h ago

U.S. Catholic bishops approve national day of prayer for racial justice

Thumbnail
ewtnnews.com
34 Upvotes

r/Catholicism • • 16h ago

Question about teachings changing

0 Upvotes

Emotionally charged topic, please be kind***

I am currently in OCIA (so please forgive me if I term things incorrectly, I am still learning) and recently we discussed a couple of things that have changed over the years in Catholicism. One example being that it was once believed that if you were cremated, you could not be “resurrected” at the end of time because you wouldn’t have a body to return to, but now the understanding is that cremation is okay so long as the entirety of the ashes remain in one vessel and the vessel is kept in consecrated ground.

My question is, can’t many other “worldly” things be rationalized by this similar ideology? Like one area that I’ve been pondering a lot is IVF, and how if we have the technology to prevent children from being born with diseases, how would this not be a good thing? To prevent this kind of suffering? If God allowed the technology of IVF to be created, how is this not a good thing? Could it just be that the church has not “caught up”? I know IVF is a VERY charged concept, and I understand the argument that freezing embryos indefinitely or letting them expire is bad so that’s a separate discussion because that COULD theoretically be avoided (donation, using all the embryos). So I’m not understanding exactly how this might not just be something where the church hasn’t “caught up”.

Please be kind in the comments, I am still learning and this is a genuine question.

ETA: thank you for your perspectives!! It seems maybe I misunderstood the explanation on why cremation was once not permissible but now is.
Some people mentioned that just because a technology exists doesn’t mean it’s inherently good (like weapons for example). And that helps my understanding a bit.

I still struggle to understand the entirety of why IVF is inherently bad. I understand the argument that freezing and destruction of embryos is bad, so I don’t need further explanation there. The part I’m still struggling to understand is that while it’s technically circumventing gods will, I feel like similar arguments can and have been made of many other things that are inherently good such as medicine or vaccines. I just think it can become a slippery slope, and so I have a hard time fully grasping the delineation of where the sin actually starts. If anyone could help give some perspective on that particular aspect (how things like medicine or cancer treatment are okay but IVF for something like disease prevention is not, especially if the testing is done on non-fertilized eggs and therefore conception has not occurred) I would really appreciate it!!


r/Catholicism • • 10h ago

Why Divine Office is not mandatory for lay people?

0 Upvotes

Sometimes I feel like the Church isn't strict enough by not mandating prayers like the Divine Office. For example Muslim are required to pray 5 times a day. I feel like we will be closer to God if we pray every day. Also, this will help lukewarm faithful become more serious about their faith. Overall, I feel like being a Christian is easy because you can call yourself a Christian but be lukewarm. It feels like there are no consequences ; is this part of what Christ wanted, or am I missing something about the Church/Christ's teaching?


r/Catholicism • • 7h ago

I am non-practicing Catholic and my boyfriend (atheist) was cursed - Help!

0 Upvotes

Hello, please read, and approach with grace. I need help. I am a baby, non-practicing, Catholic, concerned about a curse against my boyfriend, affecting my son and I by proxy.

I dont know if I just need prayers, advice, or a reminder. I just need you good faithful people to see us and send us love and light.

For some context, I converted to Catholicism in 2022 (because of my very Catholic ex) when I was 18. I was devout for a couple of years and stopped practicing after ex and I broke up.

Fast forward, I am now 22 with a 7 month old baby. My boyfriend and I have been together for a year - he is not the dad.

We met after he divorced his ex-wife. The catalyst to their breakup was that she wanted to start trying for kids and he wasn’t ready to settle down. To keep it short, he hardly ever says anything negative about her. They had a lovely marriage. Just not life-long compatible. Total polar opposites. Amazing people, both of them.

Now… a year ago when him and I got together, he very casually mentioned that she was a witch. I was extremely intrigued because despite not practicing my faith, I absolutely do not mess with that. He says she intentionally cursed him some years ago after a fight. Although he says he doesn’t believe in any higher power or God, it’s something he brings up, jokingly, when things aren’t going well. He is always happy, healthy, life-of-the-party, no financial stress, no issues with mental health; Living the good life.

Now that we’ve gone public with our relationship via an Instagram story post from him, he has mentioned “Maybe [ex-wife] cursed me again”, several times this week. Yet he doesn’t believe in anything… He is from China, and through and through, denounces any higher power existing. I am trying to get through to him in any scientific or logical way I can, to at the very least, get him into a church for a blessing. Seemingly out of nowhere, he is sick, very stressed, and financially struggling for the first time ever, and lost in life.

I contacted a church office and my God mother for advice. My God Mother very specifically told me not to try to protect him because I will take on the negativity. Whether I am at risk or not, I want to protect us. She advised that because I am not practicing, I am not seriously, spiritually equipped to take this on, for him. My prayers should be directed towards my baby and I.

He speculates that she cursed him again. It’s not a serious claim to him. But from day 1 of finding out she very intentionally practices witch craft and believes in Astrology, I have never felt “safe” from whatever negativity she sends him, by proxy. ESPECIALLY because I have a baby and he didn’t give her one. Her and I both agreed we didn’t want drama, have been cordial, and maintained that each other is very kind, despite never meeting. She’s even in a new relationship as well.

I have always believed in manifestation in the psychological way. If you tell yourself you’ll achieve something, you will find a way to get there. In the same way, if you constantly worry and doubt, that negativity will fester and manifest. So I am trying to approach him with this logic to protect us all.

Last thing, this has inspired me a bit more to go through with baptizing my son- which would also mean going to confession and receiving communion. I know it will protect us, but I also know I won’t stop doing the sinful things I do. So I’ve always put it off.

My faith is a mustard seed, but I am damn serious about that mustard seed.


r/Catholicism • • 21h ago

I genuinely don’t understand heaven and hell and original sin

2 Upvotes

First why would God, allow original sin? If he’s omnipresent and omnipotent, he’d know Adam and Eve are committing something they’re not suppose to and would stop them because of how detrimental it would be. And why create hell? I’d say most people don’t necessarily willingly reject God, for someone it can just be very hard to believe in the Bible and a Deity. Who the hell would willing reject an eternal paradise with a benevolent, loving God? I hope this makes sense.


r/Catholicism • • 9h ago

Sex before marriage

39 Upvotes

I am a female college student currently in OCIA and plan to receive baptism, confirmation, and first holy communion in April. I love Catholicism and everything I've been learning and I do feel that I have been growing closer to God and developing a stronger understanding of things. I try my best to be a good person and have a good heart- which I do feel like is most important to the faith.

However, Ive been struggling lately because I have a boyfriend and we have sex. I know premarital sex is extremely looked down upon and I completely understand why because even though I have every intention to be with this man forever and get married eventually and he wants that to, I know God wants me to abstain in order to protect my heart and body because we cant know for certain what will happen down the line (at least thats my understanding).

I feel guilty because I don't think I'll stop having sex. There is a lot more to our relationship than sex of course and recently we have been going to mass together and both growing in our faith, but also we both love being intimate with each other. I think sexual compatibility and intimacy is important to a relationship but I also feel like its poor judgement to be engaging with something I know the church is against especially since im soon to recieve the sacrements and become 'legally' catholic. Has anyone had similar qualms? If I am a good person with a good heart is this really that important?


r/Catholicism • • 16h ago

I’m not superstitious, but my rosaries keep defying the laws of physics

18 Upvotes

I'm not superstitious at all, but I'm genuinely baffled by how my rosaries keep seemingly defying the laws of physics.

For some context, when I started university about three years ago, I found a rosary at my grandma's old place after she moved away. I started carrying it with me everywhere and had kept it ever since, usually tucked deep inside my pocket, underneath my wallet and keys, so it wouldn't fall out.

Well, about two months ago, I somehow managed to lose it while studying. To this day, I have absolutely no idea how. I searched everywhere, but it was just gone. I chalked it up to it somehow falling out of my pocket without me noticing, even though I distinctly remember not taking my wallet out that day.

Anyhow, after hearing about the loss of my previous rosary, a family member kindly got me a new one (bless her heart), and I continued praying with it as usual.

Fast forward to today. I distinctly remember praying the rosary when I woke up this morning. Afterward, I either put it in my pocket or left it on my desk. I haven't left the house today, nor have I even changed my clothes since waking up.

And yet, it's somehow VANISHED.

I've checked my bed, under the mattress, inside the pillowcases, every pocket, every corner, and practically every square inch of the flat. Nothing. Absolutely nothing.

I'm genuinely baffled as to where it could possibly have gone. It's not even that I'm attributing anything supernatural to this. I just cannot wrap my head around how I've managed to lose two rosaries in the span of 2 months when I previously carried one around for 3 years without ever losing it.

Oh, and as a bonus, I also somehow managed to accidentally break the crucifix off yet another rosary chain. At this point, I genuinely don't know what to make of my apparent inability to keep a rosary intact or in my possession.

I've already tried asking St. Anthony to intercede for me, so you don't have to suggest that in the comments.

I know ths is a pretty loweffort post that has very little to do with Catholicism or Christianity itself, but I just wanted to share because I'm genuinely amazed (and mildly frustrated) by the whole thing. How on earth did I manage to lose two rosaries in two months after three perfectly uneventful years? Also I know that rosary is just object, and prayer is the important thing, still amazes me though.

Last ditch effort is going to be retrieving the trash I went out with at like 3am and check that. Yes I am willing to stoop so low out of curiosity.


r/Catholicism • • 18h ago

Where can I find the list that indicates what leads to excommunication?

6 Upvotes

I recently learned that abortion results in excommunication, and I became curious about what other actions lead to excommunication, so that I might avoid them.


r/Catholicism • • 9h ago

I have lots of questions.

0 Upvotes

So, I was raised catholic and stopped believing at like 12 years old. I have recently started coming back, but I have some questions. If God really loves all of us, why would he send anyone to be tortured forever? Isn't renouncing Satan just giving him what he wants? How can Satan be pure evil if he was God's favorite? And if we all came from two humans, aren't we all products of incest(I don't mean anything bad by this)?


r/Catholicism • • 3h ago

how did padre pio teleport did he say how he did this

0 Upvotes

r/Catholicism • • 11h ago

My future/Becoming a priest

4 Upvotes

Im 15 (male) and have no idea what to do with my life. That the idea of becoming a priest came to my mind. Is it a good idea to become a priest and how and what would i need to do? Im deeply grateful to those who help me.


r/Catholicism • • 23h ago

Why not Orthodoxy?

10 Upvotes

For context, I've been catholic all my life and am not planning to convert, but I'm curious.

To all who chose Catholicism: what made you pick Catholicism over Orthodoxy?


r/Catholicism • • 21h ago

Faith as a way of life, not just the creation of promotion of propositions

8 Upvotes

While studying theology deepens our understanding of the Christian faith, treating it purely as an intellectual exercise risks fostering pride and reducing God’s mystery to rigid, human-made systems. We must  resist contentious, ego-driven debates in favor of charitable dialogue. We must engage our faith in ways which transcend an over-intellectualization of the faith.  We must follow God with our whole being, and not just our minds:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/theology-as-a-way-of-life-not-mere-propositions/


r/Catholicism • • 11h ago

Did my priest imply that I can have sex with my girlfriend and still receive Holy Communion?

121 Upvotes

Hello everyone. Today I finally went to confession after 17 years. I cried out of sorrow for having carried 17 years' worth of sins of all kinds, but also out of emotion and joy at finally returning to the Church.

One of my sins is that I've been in a relationship for four years. We live together, and we've had sexual relations outside of marriage. We also have a baby who is almost one year old. I told the priest that recently I've been abstaining from sexual relations until we can get married. I asked him if I could receive Holy Communion.

He told me that the Church previously did not allow this, but that Pope Francis changed things, and that nowadays I can receive Holy Communion even in this irregular relationship situation. He said I should simply focus on being a good, faithful partner and, above all, a good father.

Honestly, this has left me a little confused.


r/Catholicism • • 6h ago

There’s a teaching I can’t really get myself to agree with, but it’s a mandatory one.

35 Upvotes

I was taught that it’s catholic law (or whatever the correct term is) to not cohabitate until marriage. I understand the rational behind premarital relations and pornography, and I do also understand the argument about proximity to sin / opening the opportunity for lust. That said, I cannot fathom marrying a partner before having lived with them. As someone who has dated before and after moving in, it is a night and day difference, and cohabitating has illustrated some serious compatibility issues that I never could have known before. How is this a reasonable expectation given the sanctity of marriage and prohibition of divorce?


r/Catholicism • • 16h ago

Afraid of being in a delusion again, here is what happened to me as a believer in the Catholic faith

0 Upvotes

sorry for the typos Im a little bit in a panic

2 men rung my doorbell and they claimed the be a messenger from God, they blasphemed the Catholic Church and they spooked me into worshipping another man, and also considering a woman as a God.

I got into a delusion and the delusion I was taught was that the Catholic Church caused the holocaust and they tried making me feel guilty and that I need to blaspheme the Catholic Church to break free and join their group.

After the delusion faded, I realized what I have done and I wondered if I lost my salvation or the Holy Spirit, I'm embarrassed to tell the Priest what happened, and the person from that group that rang my doorbell ended up scaring me into a baptism saying if I don't do it I will end up destroyed spiritually.

I had no strong root in my faith, and this is what happened to me, I was surprised but yes I felt a deep conviction and warning to not listen to them, but I ignored the voice which I believed to be God telling me to stop, and this is what happened to me.

I came back to my senses, should I let the Priest know what happened, am i beyond hope? I don't think I permanently lost my salvation I was being stupid and got easily deceived. Next time I will try to listen to what God tells me, and I believe he warned me before to stop and I didn't listen now, I will listen.


r/Catholicism • • 2h ago

If God offered you guaranteed heaven at the cost of your free will, would you refuse Him just to preserve your freedom to refuse Him?

1 Upvotes

r/Catholicism • • 7h ago

Not completing confessional penance?

1 Upvotes

I was wondering if you haven’t completed your penance after confession, and go back to confession again another time, was your last confession not valid?


r/Catholicism • • 9h ago

Faith Comes from Hearing: Lights and Shadows of the Vatican’s "Venite ad Me"

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/Catholicism • • 11h ago

Can you help me out with my grace prayer I’m writing for Thanksgiving?

1 Upvotes

I’m having trouble with it. Especially with wrapping it up. Here’s what I have so far:

“We thank you so much for the blessing of this gathering of loved ones, and for the blessing of this Thanksgiving feast that was prepared by the loving hands of Aunt Amy and cousin Rachel.

And please Lord, send our love to Uncle Jim, and cousin Steven, and all of our loved ones who are in Heaven. All of whom are forever loved and forever missed.

Amen.”

(Uncle Jim and Steven passed this year, which is why I’m singling out their names.)


r/Catholicism • • 22h ago

Exploring Catholism

0 Upvotes

Hello,

I am interested in the Catholic Church. I grew up and athiest and became Episcopalian in my mid twenties. After a couple of years of this, I became LDS. I recently left the LDS Church for reasons I wish not to discuss. I'm interested in maybe attending a mass next Sunday and wondered if there is anything I need to know before going.


r/Catholicism • • 11h ago

A prayer to Mary

2 Upvotes

Lately, I’ve been saddened by the news. First I heard about the pastor who was smashing statues of the Virgin Mary and, worse still, encouraging children to do so, as well. There have also been several stories of late of sacrilege and I just wanted to make something for Mary. I am not an artist, but I like to write, so I wrote for her a prayer. Here it is in case anyone might like to pray along.

A Prayer to Our Mother Mary
O, Blessed Virgin, who by God’s grace we may be so fortunate to call Our Mother Mary, how I wish I could pick for you the most beautiful rose from heaven’s garden. Even then, how it would pale in comparison!How beautiful you must be, for those who have been so lucky to see you with their own eyes all say it. But I know you in my heart, and that is more than enough. I know the beauty of your motherly warmth. When I pray the Rosary, I know you are there, ever guiding us to your Son. How your heart must ache that your Most Holy Son should give His earthly life, and still some refuse His mercy. Pray for us, Mother Mary, that all hearts may soften to His call, and may more be brought to the foot of His cross through your ever-patient and loving intercession.
Amen


r/Catholicism • • 3h ago

Protestant myth of excommunicated people being able to be killed with immunity

3 Upvotes

One of my protestant friends told me today that there was a period in history when a person who was excommunicated from the Catholic Church could be (and usually would be) killed by anyone without consequence because they were considered to already be dead inside. I want to figure out where this idea came from so I can address it. Please comment with any leads or explain what he is referencing. ​I didn't want to ask him directly at the time because he has in good faith brought me a lot of myths about the Catholic Church, and I didn't want to just dismiss this idea out of hand without really understanding if there is some truth to it. Thanks!