Hi all,
I've compiled together an email for observations across all 6 papers.
The same has been reviewed by frontier AI model Fable 5.2.
All observations are grounded in ICAI's study material.
Those who had appeared for the CA finals in this attempt, please share the observations for your respective papers/groups.
I hope this reaches in the right hands at the ICAI's proper committee.
I've already emailed them. Please substitute your details in the below draft.
You may alter the email based on your papers. Or, you may discard any observation that you disagree with.
----------
To: examfeedback@icai.in
Subject: Observations on question papers - CA Final Examination, November 2026 - Roll No. [ROLL NUMBER]
To
The Additional Secretary (Exams)
The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
ICAI Bhawan, Indraprastha Marg, New Delhi 110 002
Respected Sir/Madam,
Sub: Observations on the question papers of the Final Examination held in November 2026
With reference to the announcement of the Examination Department dated 2nd November 2026 inviting observations on the question papers, I submit my observations below, paper-wise. My details are:
Name: [FULL NAME AS PER ADMIT CARD]
Registration number: [REGISTRATION NUMBER]
Roll number: [ROLL NUMBER]
Email-id: [REGISTERED EMAIL]
Mobile number: [MOBILE NUMBER]
There are 13 observations across the six papers. Each one states the question, the issue, the authority relied upon (the Study Material of the Board of Studies wherever possible) and the request. Page references are to the Study Material applicable for the November 2026 examination.
PAPER 1: FINANCIAL REPORTING
Observation 1
Paper 1: Financial Reporting, Part I, MCQ No. 2 (2 marks). The question states that NG Ltd. acquired all the shares of "a foreign entity SG Inc." for €18 million, when "the fair value of the net assets of the foreign entity" was €12 million. It then states: "The functional currency of the entity is US$." Within the question, the word "entity" otherwise refers only to SG Inc. If SG Inc.'s functional currency is the euro, goodwill of €6 million is translated at the closing rate as required by paragraph 47 of Ind AS 21 (Study Material, Paper 1, Module 3, Chapter 7, Unit 2, paragraph 2.9, page 7.120), giving US$3 million, option (D). If SG Inc.'s functional currency is the US dollar, goodwill is measured in US dollars at the acquisition-date rate, giving US$4 million, option (B), with no retranslation. Both readings are available on the wording. I request that options (B) and (D) both be accepted.
Observation 2
Paper 1: Financial Reporting, Question No. 6(c)(iv) (one of four sub-parts carrying 4 marks in all). The case describes a breach of a material covenant of a long-term loan before the end of the reporting period, waived by the lender after the reporting date but before approval, and asks whether this is an adjusting or non-adjusting event. No reporting period is stated. Under the carve-out in Ind AS 10 (Study Material, Paper 1, Module 1, Chapter 4, pages 4.65 and 4.79) the waiver is an adjusting event. Notification G.S.R. 549(E) dated 13 August 2025 omits that carve-out for annual reporting periods beginning on or after 1 April 2026. The November 2026 Revision Test Paper (pages 8-9) sets out both positions, and the November 2026 Mock Test Paper (Series I), Paper 1, Question 6(b), stated the period expressly. I request that either conclusion receive full credit where the candidate states or applies the reporting period.
PAPER 2: ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
Observation 3
Paper 2: Advanced Financial Management, Case Scenario VI, MCQ 23 (1 mark). The question asks for "the effective cost per USD in INR, including the option premium" under the currency option hedge but does not name a spot-rate outcome. The case data give two outcomes, ₹86/USD (40%) and ₹94/USD (60%). MCQ 20 of the same case describes ₹87.20/USD as the effective cost including the premium where the option lapses at ₹86, and ₹91.20/USD where it is exercised at ₹94. Options (A) ₹87.20 and (B) ₹91.20 therefore each match the paper's own usage for one outcome. The Study Material (Chapter 10, Test Your Knowledge Q39, pages 10.68 and 10.96) evaluates an option hedge outcome by outcome and weights the results by probability, which gives ₹89.60/USD here; that figure is not among the options. I request that both (A) and (B) be accepted as correct.
Observation 4
Paper 2: Advanced Financial Management, Question 4(b) (5 marks), Economic Value Added of B Limited. The balance sheet shows Long-term Debt @ 12% of ₹90 lakh and, under current liabilities, Short-term Borrowings of ₹40 lakh; the question does not state how the short-term borrowings are to be treated. The Study Material (Chapter 13, para 6.3, page 13.24) defines invested capital in one paragraph both as total assets less non-interest-bearing current liabilities, which retains the borrowings (₹315 lakh after the ₹5 lakh provision adjustment), and as equity plus long-term debt, which excludes them (₹275 lakh). In Illustration 5 the two definitions coincide; here they give EVA of ₹12.69 lakh and ₹16.25 lakh respectively. The interest expense of ₹10 lakh, which is lower than 12% on the long-term debt alone, does not resolve the point. I request that both treatments be accepted, with full step marks where applied consistently.
PAPER 3: ADVANCED AUDITING, ASSURANCE AND PROFESSIONAL ETHICS
Observation 5
Paper 3: Advanced Auditing, Assurance and Professional Ethics, Question 4(b) (5 marks), engagement (ii): CA P represents OZ Infrastructure Ltd. in a tax appeal for 5% of the tax saved if the appeal succeeds. The question does not state whether OZ Infrastructure Ltd. is CA P's audit client, and the conclusion turns on that fact. The Study Material (Chapter 19, page 19.76) cites "the successful outcome of an appeal in revenue proceedings" as a prohibited contingency, while Regulation 192(h), as reproduced there, permits contingent fees for non-assurance services to non-audit clients, and the answer to Test Your Knowledge Q29 (pages 19.185-19.186) holds a member not guilty for a fee of 10% of tax demand reduced in a Tribunal appeal for a non-audit client. I request that either conclusion be accepted where the candidate reasons from Clause (10) and Regulation 192 on a stated assumption about the client relationship.
Observation 6
Paper 3: Advanced Auditing, Assurance and Professional Ethics, Question 4(c) (2 + 2 marks). The question describes a "special purpose cash flow statement, projecting the cash available for debt servicing over the next 24 months", required by a bank to appraise a term loan, and asks for the course of action "as per the applicable SA" and a restriction paragraph. The Study Material treats projected cash flow statements required by banks from intending borrowers as prospective financial information examined under SAE 3400 (Chapter 11, pages 11.3 and 11.6), under which an opinion on whether the projected results will be achieved cannot be expressed. SA 805 is framed for historical financial information (Chapter 8, page 8.10), and Clause (3) of Part I of the Second Schedule bars vouching for the accuracy of a forecast. I request that answers based on SAE 3400, alone or read with SA 800/805, receive full credit in both sub-parts.
Observation 7
Paper 3: Advanced Auditing, Assurance and Professional Ethics, Question 6(b) (5 marks), NPA case II: "Classified as NPA for 1.5 years; the sale agreement is cash basis and 'without recourse'." The Study Material (Chapter 14, Unit 1, page 14.38) requires an NPA to have remained NPA for at least two years before sale, and states that excess provision shall not be reversed. Clause 88 of the RBI Master Direction (Transfer of Loan Exposures) Directions, 2021 repealed the RBI guidelines on purchase/sale of non-performing assets, and those Directions were consolidated in the RBI (Commercial Banks - Transfer and Distribution of Credit Risk) Directions, 2025 dated 28 November 2025. Neither sets a minimum NPA age for transferring stressed loans, and both permit reversal of excess provision. Under the law applicable to FY 2025-26, case II can be sold. I request that both conclusions on case II, and either treatment of excess provision in part (ii), be accepted.
PAPER 4: DIRECT TAX LAWS AND INTERNATIONAL TAXATION
Observation 8
Paper 4: Direct Tax Laws and International Taxation, Case Scenario IV, MCQ No. 20 (2 marks). The income of the REIT chargeable at the maximum marginal rate under section 115UA(2) is ₹ 1,21,00,000, and options (A) ₹ 47,19,000 and (D) ₹ 51,72,024 apply 39% and 42.744% respectively. Section 2(29C) defines the maximum marginal rate by reference to the highest slab of an individual "as specified in Finance Act of the relevant year" (Study Material, Module 1, Chapter 1, page 1.33). Paragraph A of Part III of the First Schedule to the Finance Act, 2025, on which the material for this examination is based, prescribes surcharge of 37% above ₹ 5 crore, giving 42.744%. The provisos to section 2 of that Act limit surcharge to 25% for income chargeable under section 115BAC(1A), giving 39%. The Study Material does not state which rate is the maximum marginal rate for A.Y. 2026-27. I request that options (A) and (D) both be accepted.
PAPER 5: INDIRECT TAX LAWS
Observation 9
Paper 5 (Indirect Tax Laws), Question 1, 14 marks. The paper requires answers on GST law effective up to 30.04.2026. Item (iii) gives Hotel ARCUS's March 2026 room rates, the highest ₹6,500 per day after a 20% off-season discount; item (iv) and Additional Information (a) concern its ARIES restaurant, including supplies through an electronic commerce operator. Their treatment depends on whether ARCUS is "specified premises". ICAI Study Material, Paper 5 (Module 1, Chapter 2, page 2.37; Module 2, Chapter 12) defines this by declared tariff above ₹7,500, which the undiscounted ₹8,125 exceeds. Notification No. 05/2025-Central Tax (Rate) dated 16.01.2025, effective 01.04.2025, omitted "declared tariff" and uses the value of supply of any unit above ₹7,500 in the preceding financial year, or a declaration. The question gives neither. I request that answers treating ARCUS as not specified premises, with consequential computation, also be accepted.
Observation 10
Paper 5 (Indirect Tax Laws), Question 2(a), 5 marks. The question gives financial year 2024-25 turnover for the Bengaluru, Hyderabad and Kolkata branches, states that a Chennai branch started in April 2025, gives April-June 2025 turnover for all four branches, and asks how common input service credit of ₹12,00,000 for June 2025 and ₹4,00,000 for July 2025 is distributed. Under rule 39(1)(e) and the Explanation to rule 39 of the CGST Rules, 2017 (ICAI Study Material, Paper 5, Module 2, Chapter 7, page 7.109), where any recipient had no turnover in the preceding financial year, the relevant period is the last quarter, previous to the month of distribution, for which all recipients' turnover is available. For June 2025 no such quarter exists, and the preceding year excludes Chennai. I request that June 2025 distributions on either 2024-25 turnover of the three branches or April-June 2025 turnover of all four, with the basis stated, be accepted.
PAPER 6: INTEGRATED BUSINESS SOLUTIONS
Observation 11
Paper 6, Integrated Business Solutions, November 2026, Case Study 1, Question 1.7(b) (Question 1.7: 5 marks). The case states that the EPCG Authorisation was obtained on 1st April, 2024, with an Average Export Obligation of ₹3 crore per annum, and gives the exports as aggregates "Upto 31st March, 2026 (During last 3 years)". Only two financial years of the export obligation period had elapsed by 31st March, 2026, exports made before the Authorisation cannot count towards it, and the figures are not given year by year, although the Paper 5 Study Material (Chapter 8, Foreign Trade Policy) requires the Average Export Obligation to be fulfilled every financial year and counts only exports over and above it. Deducting the Average Export Obligation for two years gives 72.92% of the specific obligation of ₹9.60 crore, with the half-period running to 31st March, 2027; deducting it for three years gives 41.67%. I request that either reading, consistently applied, be accepted.
Observation 12
Paper 6, Integrated Business Solutions, November 2026, Case Study 3, Question 3.5 (2 marks). Statement (v) reads that where the job worker is not registered, the principal may supply the waste and scrap from the job worker's premises "only if such premises have been declared as an additional place of business of the principal". CBIC Circular No. 38/12/2018-GST dated 26.03.2018, paragraph 9.4(ii), states that supply from the job worker's premises is available to the principal only if he declares those premises as his additional place of business or if the job worker is registered, and paragraph 9.4(iii) applies these principles mutatis mutandis to waste and scrap under section 143(5). The Paper 5 Study Material (Chapter 16, Job Work) carries the same clarification. Statement (v) is therefore correct, as are statements (i), (ii) and (iv). No option lists all four, and options (B) and (D) each contain only correct statements. I request that both (B) and (D) be accepted.
Observation 13
Paper 6, Integrated Business Solutions, November 2026, Case Study 4, Question 4.2 (2 marks). The case states that the dividend just paid is 25% of EPS of ₹32, the risk-free rate 6%, the market return 13.5% and beta 1.2, and that the dividend will grow at 12% "over the next two years", while the next sentences refer to growth of 10% "beyond the initial three-year period". Applying the two-stage dividend discount model in the Paper 2 Study Material (Chapter 5, Security Valuation), with a cost of equity of 15% and PV factors to three decimals, the intrinsic value is ₹182.29 for a two-year high-growth period and ₹185.48 for three years. Neither value is among the options (₹110.83, ₹167.13, ₹141.60, ₹130.12). Option (B) results only if the terminal value is computed on the year-2 dividend without the 10% growth step. I request that the question be treated as having no correct option and that marks be awarded to all candidates.
I request that these observations be placed before the examiners concerned and considered while finalising the marking scheme.
Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,
[FULL NAME]
Registration number: [REGISTRATION NUMBER]
Roll number: [ROLL NUMBER]