the problem with "which of these two policies is better?" is that chatgpt has read thousands of policies. when yours doesn't mention something, it fills in the usual answer and you can't tell which parts came from your document and which came from its memory. that's how you end up assuming water damage or a waiting period is covered when the policy never said so.
this chain fixes that by building the checklist before it reads anything, making it quote the line for every answer, and writing "not stated" when the line isn't there. works for health, home, car, travel, pet, whatever. also works for phone plans or job offers if you change the wording.
first upload both documents (PDF or pasted text) with a message like "two policies, A and B. don't summarize yet". then run these in order:
Step 1, the checklist:
I'm comparing {{insurance type}} policies. My situation: {{situation}}. Before reading the documents, list the 10 things that decide what I'd actually get paid in a claim for someone like me, like the deductible, coverage limits, exclusions, waiting periods, how claims are paid, and what can change at renewal. Put them in a table with empty columns for Policy A and Policy B.
Step 2, policy A:
Fill the Policy A column using only what document A says. For every cell, quote the exact sentence it comes from and where it is in the document. If the document doesn't say, write "not stated". Don't use what policies like this usually include.
Step 3, policy B:
Do the same for Policy B, with the same rules. Quote the sentence for every cell, or write "not stated".
Step 4, the claims test:
Make up 3 realistic claims for my situation, one small, one large, one in a gray area. Walk each one through both policies using only the quoted lines and say what each one would pay. Where the answer depends on a "not stated" cell, say so instead of guessing.
Step 5, the questions:
List every "not stated" cell and every gray area as a question I can email each insurer. Word each one so the answer has to be yes, no, or a number. Then tell me which policy looks better for my situation based only on what's written, and what would flip that answer.
why it works:
- step 1 builds the checklist before it sees the documents, so the marketing summary at the top of each policy doesn't decide what gets compared
- "quote the exact sentence" means you can check every cell yourself in 10 seconds
- "not stated" is the important bit. the gaps are where the bad surprises are, and step 5 turns them into a written answer from the insurer instead of a guess
don't treat the result as advice, treat it as homework done for you. the insurer's written answer is what counts.
i build AI Toolbox, a browser extension for ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Grok. you can save these 5 as a chain: type .. in the chat box, pick it, fill in {{insurance type}} and {{situation}} once, and the steps send one after another, each waiting for the reply. the free plan includes 2 chains.