For most of my time analyzing the Hall of Fame, I have made peace with its induction process. It is imperfect, but each election cycle produces worthwhile debates. This year’s ballot nevertheless leaves me frustrated, not because these 27 players deserve less consideration, but because many of the strongest eligible players outside the Hall are not on it
I do not intend to imply that this ballot does not warrant serious consideration. However, it’s frustrating to rehash arguments about Torii Hunter, who has languished at the bottom of the BBWAA ballot for seven cycles, while other center fielders notably: Jim Edmonds, Kenny Lofton and Bernie Williams barely got a hearing. In fact, by JAWS (which is but one measure of Hall of Fame worthiness) here are the best eligible, living, and non-PED using, candidates outside the Hall of Fame by position:
Catcher: Buster Posey (14th)
First Base: Keith Hernandez (22nd)
Second Base: Bobby Grich (8th)
Third Base: Graig Nettles (12th)
Shortstop: Bert Campaneris (22nd)
Left Field: Lance Berkman (19th)
Center Field: Kenny Lofton (10th)
Right Field: Dwight Evans (17th)
Starting Pitcher: Rick Reuschel (32nd)
Reliever: Joe Nathan (8th)
The only player on that list receiving a hearing this cycle is Buster Posey, everyone else will not. In fact most of the players listed above have not had their cases heard in years, and the process for their cases to be heard is opaque and arduous. This ballot still has some interesting contrasts worth discussing. Here is the ballot announced this week:
Bobby Abreu, Jake Arrieta, Jay Bruce, Mark Buehrle, Asdrubal Cabrera, Starlin Castro, Wade Davis, Brett Gardner, Cole Hamels, Felix Hernandez, Torii Hunter, Jon Lester, Andrew Miller, Dustin Pedroia, Andy Pettitte, Buster Posey, Alex Rodriguez, Francisco Rodriguez, Jimmy Rollins, Pablo Sandoval, Ervin Santana, Kyle Seager, Joakin Soria, Chase Utley, Omar Vizquel, David Wright, Ryan Zimmerman
A Brief Rules Refresher
Before we discuss the ballot, here is a refresher on the rules. We are discussing the BBWAA ballot, which is the main way for players to earn induction to the Hall of Fame. Players must be retired for at least 5 years before they become eligible for the Hall of Fame and must have participated in at least 10 seasons. Eligible BBWAA members can vote for up to 10 players on their ballot. Any player who earns 75% of the vote earns induction, and a candidate must receive at least 5% of the vote to remain on the ballot. These numbers do not round up: if you get 74.99% of the vote you fall short. Players receive 10 chances on the BBWAA ballot before falling off. Players who fall off the ballot are eligible for induction via the Era Committees, the process I have been covering recently.
The Ballot
There are 27 players on this ballot including 13 returning candidates. Thirteen is the fewest returning candidates since the 2013 ballot (which, despite only returning 13 candidates, is arguably the most stacked ballot in recent memory). The 13 returning candidates, in descending order by vote total (and years on the ballot in parentheses), are:
Chase Utley, 59.1% (4th)
Andy Pettitte, 48.5% (9th)
Felix Hernandez, 46.1% (3rd)
Alex Rodriguez, 40.0% (6th)
Bobby Abreu, 30.8% (8th)
Jimmy Rollins, 25.4% (6th)
Cole Hamels, 23.8% (2nd)
Dustin Pedroia, 20.7% (3rd)
Mark Buehrle, 20.0% (7th)
Omar Vizquel, 18.4% (10th)
David Wright, 14.8% (4th)
Francisco Rodriguez, 11.8% (5th)
Torii Hunter, 8.7% (7th)
The new candidates, in alphabetical order:
Jake Arrieta
Jay Bruce
Asdrubal Cabrera
Starlin Castro
Wade Davis
Brett Gardner
Jon Lester
Andrew Miller
Buster Posey
Pablo Sandoval
Ervin Santana
Kyle Seager
Joakim Soria
Ryan Zimmerman
Here’s that 2013 ballot that I mentioned earlier, the last time we had 13 returning candidates on the ballot. This ballot is just in alphabetical order:
Sandy Alomar, Jeff Bagwell, Craig Biggio, Barry Bonds, Jeff Cirillo, Royce Clayton, Roger Clemens, Jeff Conine, Steve Finley, Julio Franco, Shawn Green, Roberto Hernandez, Ryan Klesko, Kenny Lofton, Edgar Martinez, Don Mattingly, Fred McGriff, Mark McGwire, Jose Mesa, Jack Morris, Dale Murphy, Rafael Palmeiro, Mike Piazza, Tim Raines, Reggie Sanders, Curt Schilling, Aaron Sele, Lee Smith, Sammy Sosa, Mike Stanton, Alan Trammell, Larry Walker, Todd Walker, David Wells, Rondell White, Bernie Williams, Woody Williams
OK. Which ballot feels bigger? Think about this for a second. The 2013 elected no candidates to the Hall of Fame that cycle, but look at the Hall of Famers who came off this ballot and that does not include Bonds, Clemens, McGwire, Palmeiro and Sosa. That ballot did not just have stars: it had some of the biggest names of the era. This ballot…feels thin, easily the weakest ballot I have ever seen. I revived my Ballot Strength chart from last year, which averages the number of candidates clearing four statistical thresholds: 50 JAWS, 100 on the Hall of Fame Monitor, 50 on Hall of Fame Standards, and 60 career bWAR. The 2000–2026 average was 10.1. Last year scored 6.5; this year scores 3.5, the lowest in the sample. These are index scores, not literal counts of players I would elect. Statistically: this ballot contains far fewer players who meet clear these statistical benchmarks than normal. You can view my full ballot strength document on Google Sheets.
Do not mistake me: there are some excellent candidates on this ballot, and several players I view as Hall of Famers. But if I were a candidate for the Hall of Fame: this is the ballot I would like to debut on, there is a lot of space on ballots this year.
Which leads me to why this ballot feels so stale. I look at the names on this ballot and ask if this is who the Hall of Fame really wants the BBWAA to discuss for over the next two months. The issue is not whether these players have fans or deserve consideration. It is whether the current system gives the strongest unelected candidates comparable opportunities to be evaluated.
Moving onto what I am watching this ballot, there are two basic questions that come up with every Hall of Fame cycle. Are there any new candidates who could earn induction, and will any returning candidates’ odds of induction improve (or decline)?
What to Watch: New Candidates
Starting with newcomers only one new candidate stands out in my eyes for future induction: Buster Posey. Posey ranks 14th in JAWS for catchers, and 10th in WAR7. Posey will continue a debate which continues to permeate across the electorate on whether peak or total career value matters more for Hall of Fame induction. By career standards Posey falls well short in many ways. The only BBWAA inducted catcher with fewer hits than Posey, for instance, is Roy Campanella whose career ended in tragedy when a car crash paralyzed him. Campanella also started his career in the Negro Leagues. Historically players with high peaks but short careers tend to fall short, although in recent years the electorate’s mood has changed. Last cycle the BBWAA inducted a player with fewer than 2,000 hits for the first time in decades (Andruw Jones). If Posey earns induction on the first ballot he would be only the second position player with fewer than 2,000 hits to earn induction that quickly (the other being Jackie Robinson). The last time the BBWAA inducted a position player with so few hits was 1975 when Ralph Kiner earned induction with only 1,451.
Other first time inductees will struggle to stick on the ballot, even in a weak year. The only other candidate I can imagine sticking past this cycle is Jon Lester. Jon Lester falls short in my eyes, but he will hit the ballot with 200 pitchers wins. In some ways his case is a strange version of Felix Hernandez’s (and Cole Hamels). All three pitched a similar number of innings with similar run prevention statistics. Lester’s lack of hardware will hurt him. He never won a Cy Young although he did come close in 2016. He only made five All-Star teams. But he also won three World Series and played a big role in the Cubs’ curse breaking win in 2016. His 1.77 World Series ERA is superb. While my initial reaction is Lester falls well short, I think his postseason success alone warrants a closer investigation.
What to Watch: Returning Candidates
I would place returning candidates to watch in four buckets:
Bucket 1: Chase Utley
Utley has the most support of any returning candidate at 59.1%. High enough it’s entirely plausible Utley can earn induction this year. In fact if he picks up as much support this cycle as he did last cycle (19 points): he would earn induction resoundingly.
Bucket 2: Starting Pitchers
Four starting pitchers return to the ballot with strong support: Felix Hernandez, Andy Pettitte, Cole Hamels & Mark Buehrle. Given how the BBWAA is ‘reimagining’ how they view starting pitchers it will be interesting to see how the electorate treats these four pitchers. I remain skeptical that the electorate can accommodate shorter modern pitching careers without lowering the historical standard. This ballot will provide another test. I anticipate all four to gain significant support. I do not think Pettitte or Hernandez can gain enough support to earn induction, but both are set up for potential induction in 2028.
Bucket 3: Peak Position Players
Here I mostly refer to David Wright and Dustin Pedroia. Both arguably posted Hall of Fame peaks but lack the counting stats we typically associate with Hall of Fame position players. Both continue to gain support over the years and, given how weak this ballot is: they could easily pick up significant support.
Bucket 4: Everyone Else
This bucket includes Bobby Abreu, Torii Hunter, Alex Rodriguez, Francisco Rodriguez, Jimmy Rollins and Omar Vizquel. The open ballot creates opportunities for gains, but these candidates face very different obstacles. Their results will help clarify which retain a plausible BBWAA path and which may ultimately depend on an Era Committee.
A thin ballot should create room for overlooked candidates to gain support. It should not change the standard for induction. I will evaluate these 27 players on their merits, but the strength of the ballot also makes it harder to ignore the candidates who are no longer allowed onto it.