TL;DR
I'm not sure whether my situation fits the usual breakup or relationship framework because we agreed to a non-exclusive casual relationship rather than being official partners.
For the first few months, things worked well. Eventually, however, I realised I couldn't handle the non-exclusive arrangement emotionally. At the time, I knew very little about attachment styles or relationship dynamics, so I responded in the only ways I knew: adapting, negotiating, and trying to adjust my needs to fit the arrangement.
She was willing to support me through that process, but she didn't want to change the nature of our relationship.
The confusing part was that what we shared didn't feel particularly casual to me. We spent nights together, had physical and emotional intimacy, listened to each other's problems, spent time together, and supported one another. We both participated willingly in those things.
After some time, she began feeling overwhelmed and wanted more distance. I tried to accommodate that too, until eventually she decided to end the casual relationship altogether.
I struggled quite badly afterward. I wasn't functioning particularly well, while she seemed to move forward much faster and appeared to be exploring other connections.
I repeatedly tried to understand where I stood. Sometimes she would become quiet when I asked for clarity, but eventually we'd interact again. She would still share things about her life when we met in person, sometimes initiate spending time together, and accept my care. This kept me confused about what our connection actually meant.
Looking back, I also realise that I wasn't particularly interested in the physical intimacy anymore. I genuinely cared about her as a person and wanted the best for her. I also wanted her to remain in my life as a friend, although I can admit now that I still had hope for something more and was afraid to acknowledge it.
Eventually, after a period of distancing myself and changing my behaviour, I approached her and asked whether she would be comfortable with us rebuilding a friendship without the sexual aspect.
Her answer was no. She felt things had become too complicated and emotionally attached, and didn't believe a friendship would come naturally after feelings had developed. She also didn't feel capable of finding out whether it could work.
That hurt more than I expected. Not simply because she rejected the idea, but because during the period of distancing we'd still spent time together and interacted in ways I understood as friendship. I realised we might have had very different understandings of what our connection meant.
She made it clear that she preferred keeping things cordial and respectful rather than trying to rebuild a friendship. I respected her answer, even though I personally disagree with the idea that friendship cannot exist after feelings have developed.
I'm now trying a low-contact approach. We still share a social environment, so complete no-contact isn't realistic, and honestly, I don't particularly want it either. I remain civil and friendly, but I've stopped initiating unnecessary conversations and checking social media because I noticed that doing so had become almost like a slot machine for my emotions.
Something else that's confusing me is that she's recently become noticeably friendlier during our occasional interactions. I don't want to assume this means she wants to reconnect. It could simply be ordinary friendliness. But I notice that it can bring back hope and confusion.
The positive thing is that I'm sleeping and eating properly again. I'm trying to focus on my career, health, and life outside this situation. However, I still think about her frequently and miss her.
I suspect I have some anxious attachment tendencies because consistency, communication, and mutual effort are important for me to feel secure. She seems to prefer considerably more independence and distance, although I don't want to diagnose either of us based on one relationship.
My questions are:
- Is it normal to feel as though I've progressed through several stages of healing, only to find myself returning to the same emotional stage repeatedly?
- Can this happen when complete no-contact isn't possible because we still share a social environment?
- How do I distinguish genuine progress from simply suppressing my feelings or distracting myself?
- How should I interpret friendly interactions from someone who has explicitly said they don't want to rebuild a close friendship?
- For anyone who has experienced something similar, what actually helped you move forward without having to treat the other person like a stranger?
I'm not trying to get her back or find a way to change her mind. I just want to understand why this process feels so repetitive and how to move forward while remaining a normal, friendly person around someone I once cared about deeply.
Sorry for the long post. I wanted to provide enough context rather than oversimplify what happened.