Simulation: https://daltonlens.org/colorblindness-simulator
A few days ago, I saw a post from u/EagleEye1991 on this subreddit about Ishihara plates people with even mild red-green color vision deficiencies have trouble reading. Since I have no color vision deficiency, I was able to read all the plates with little difficulty.
Out of curiosity, I decided to run this image through the Machado 2009 model (which actually has a theory for modeling anomalous trichromacy based on shifted cone sensitivity curves rather than just naïve interpolation) for both protan and deuteran color vision deficiencies.
Unsurprisingly, at a severity of 1 (full dichromacy), all of the numbers were invisible. I then tried a severity of 0.5 (which I thought was “moderate”) for both protan and deuteran simulations. On the Machado 2009 model, for both protan and deuteran simulations at a severity of 0.5, it was noticeably harder to make out all the numbers (especially the 6), but I could still see them. Even at a severity of 0.7 (which I thought was “strong”), I could still make out the 5, 7, 16, and 73. (Though, needless to say, it was way harder than the original image.)
Nonetheless, many people who have quite mild red-green color vision deficiencies cannot make out these numbers at all. Does this mean that Machado is not an accurate simulation for anomalous trichromacy, or does this mean that low severities (those below 0.5, for instance) rarely occur?