r/Comcast • u/EternalBeast • 9h ago
Experience Xfinity Mobile is charging me $1,375 for their own IMEI mistake. Here’s the full timeline, almost 4 months in.
Posting this as a warning, and in case anyone has been through the same thing. Long post, but I want the whole picture out there.
Background: I joined Xfinity Mobile in late May. In July I ordered a Galaxy S26 Ultra. Their warehouse recorded the wrong IMEI for it on my account, and that one error has caused everything below.
Summer: the original mix-up
Jul 31: My line wouldn’t work with the new phone because the IMEI on my account didn’t match the device. I spent 5+ hours in chat that day.
Jul 31 to Aug 1: Another 5 hours in chat overnight, plus a phone call. Agents confirmed the wrong IMEI was on file, but nobody could fix it.
Aug 1: I went to a local Xfinity store. Staff said they couldn’t fix it and sent me back to support. Support then said I’d have to return the phone and reorder, and promised a prepaid label and a price match. None of that came. A temporary eSIM they sent also failed.
By this point, six support tickets had been opened and every one closed with just “Your request is closed.”
Aug 2: I filed a BBB complaint.
Aug 4 to 5: Their executive resolutions team got my line working on the phone’s second IMEI. They confirmed in writing that the IMEI on file was wrong and said they’d update their billing and inventory systems once a pending order closed.
Aug 6: I returned the device tied to that pending order. The rep said she’d monitor it and follow up.
Aug 11: I followed up. I never heard back, and the IMEI was never corrected.
Fall: the early upgrade
Early Oct: I did an early upgrade to a new iPhone. The deal: send back the S26 Ultra in good condition within 21 days and they waive its remaining balance, about $1,375.
Oct 6: The new iPhone arrived. I mailed the S26 Ultra using their prepaid trade-in label.
Oct 10: USPS tracking shows their trade-in vendor received it.
Oct 21: Trade-in rejected for “serial number mismatch,” because the account still had the wrong IMEI from their summer mistake. The app said the phone was “heading back to you” and that I’d be charged the full balance. The return tracking link opened a page saying the tracking number couldn’t be found. I emailed the executive resolutions rep. No reply.
Trying to fix it
Oct 24: 2+ hours in chat. A ticket to correct the IMEI was opened and then denied and closed about 12 minutes later, with no reason given. Since the trade-in couldn’t be fixed, I asked to return the new iPhone instead. The agent confirmed I was eligible and said a return label had been emailed. It never arrived. I emailed the escalation rep again. No reply.
Oct 26: Another chat. This agent said my 14-day return window had passed, even though I only found out about the rejection on Oct 21. My dispute was added to the ticket, with an update promised in 24 to 48 hours. I emailed the escalation rep a third time. No reply.
Oct 30: I called the escalation rep’s direct line and left a voicemail. No callback.
Nov 7 to 9: Daily automated texts saying my ticket was “taking longer than expected.”
Nov 11: Automated text: “We couldn’t approve this request, and we have closed the ticket.” No explanation.
Today, Nov 18
My bill estimate jumped to about $1,467, which is my normal bill plus a one-time charge of about $1,375 for the S26 Ultra.
The S26 Ultra showed up at my door, 39 days after their vendor received it. Nothing had been fixed.
In chat, support told me the “only way” to resolve this is to go to a store and have them physically check the IMEI, then wait 7 days for a correction ticket. That’s the same store step that went nowhere in August, when the store told me only support could fix it.
When I pushed back, the agent offered me a “free” Apple Watch as compensation. It would add a new line at $10 a month.
Where things stand:
I followed every step of their process on time and have screenshots, tracking and written emails for all of it
Two tickets this fall denied with no explanation, plus six closed over the summer
No return label, no reply from their escalation team, and a $1,375 charge for a mistake they admitted in writing in August
I’ve updated my BBB complaint, I’m filing with the FCC, and I’m going to a store this week as instructed
Lesson for anyone doing an early upgrade or trade-in with Xfinity Mobile: before you send anything, check that the IMEI on your account matches the phone you’re sending (Settings, then About phone), and screenshot every chat.
Has anyone gotten a trade-in rejection like this reversed? What finally worked?


