I know this is going to be unpopular, but I genuinely believe we gave Terry that massive contract extension based more on emotion than actual football decisions.
Think back to the 2025 offseason. Every single social media post from the Commanders was flooded with “PAY TERRY” comments, usually with thousands of likes. The entire fanbase was practically demanding the front office give him whatever he wanted.
And I get it. Terry was the definition of loyalty. He stuck with this franchise through some absolutely miserable years, never complained, and finally got to experience success with Jayden Daniels in 2024. He deserved to get paid.
But deserving a payday and being worth a $90+ million extension are two different things.
Look at the numbers:
2024: 1,096 yards, 13 TDs, 17 games
2025: 582 yards, 3 TDs, 10 games
2026: 230 yards, 1 TD, 5 games
That’s 812 yards and 4 touchdowns in 15 games since signing his extension. Now he’s dealing with a serious knee injury, and his durability going forward is a legitimate concern.
I’m not blaming Terry for getting hurt. Injuries happen, and nobody could have predicted exactly how things would play out. But we handed a massive extension to a receiver approaching 30, coming off his best touchdown season, without really considering whether we’d be getting that same production throughout the contract.
I love Terry and everything he’s done for Washington. But at some point, we have to separate our attachment to players from what’s actually best for the franchise.
The front office’s job isn’t to make the fanbase happy. It’s to build a winning football team.
Looking back, I think we let loyalty and the excitement of the 2024 season cloud what should have been a business decision. Im curious how many people still believe that extension was the right move.