r/CompetitiveEDH • • 12d ago

Vote for Staple Community vote for the best cEDH card ever - a clarification post!

0 Upvotes

We're launching a bracketed competition to find out which cEDH staple is the best staple! The staples are not for any particular deck or in any particular order. They're just 64 famous, good, iconic and overall best cards across the meta!

The results will always be in this post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/CompetitiveEDH/comments/1xpspfd/whats_the_best_cedh_staple/

The brackets will run 1 per week for a total of 21 weeks. On the first 16 weeks we have the first round followed by 4 weeks for the winners of those rounds. Finally on the 21st week it will be the GRAND FINALE where we will find out which card the sub thinks is the best card! See above results link for the full "pod" breakdown!

Here are all the cards in this competition:

Cards: . . .
Mystic Remora Sol Ring Tainted Pact Shifting Woodland
Vampiric Tutor Lotus Petal Underworld Breach Fetch Lands
Demonic Tutor Mox Diamond Crop Rotation Dual Lands
Birds of Paradise Noxious Revival Orcish Bowmasters Gaea's Cradle
Rhystic Study Opposition Agent Borne Upon a Wind Otawara, Soaring City
Esper Sentinel Intuition Demonic Consultation Boseiju, Who Endures
Force of Will Lion's Eye Diamond Chain of Vapor Gemstone Caverns
Fierce Guardianship Entomb Faerie Mastermind Ancient Tomb
Silence Mirrormade Necropotence Minamo, School at Water's Edge
Pact of Negation Yawgmoth's Will Grand Abolisher City of Traitors
Deflecting Swat Gleaming Splendor Jeska's Will Dryad Arbor
Dark Ritual Food Chain Thassa's Oracle Cavern of Souls
Simian Spirit Guide Survival of the Fittest Brain Freeze Emergence Zone
Elvish Spirit Guide The One Ring Ad Nauseam Talon Gates of Madara
Smothering Tithe Collector Ouphe Badgermole Cub Urza's Saga
Gamble Animate Dead Wheel of Fortune Cephalid Coliseum

Without further ado: enjoy voting for the best card!


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 4d ago

Vote for Staple Which is best? Gemstone Caverns vs Fierce Guardianship vs Gamble vs Smothering Tithe

0 Upvotes

Which is best? Gemstone Caverns vs Fierce Guardianship vs Gamble vs Smothering Tithe

  1. Gemstone Caverns
  2. Fierce Guardianship
  3. Gamble
  4. Smothering Tithe

Open in the Reddit app to vote.


This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 4h ago

General Discussion / Question Lieutenant Commander Data - a new way to mono blue

11 Upvotes

[[Lieutenant Commander Data]] is being played in a friends Kinnan list as a draw engine and watching it put it work made me wonder about its viability as a commander

I put together a list that leans into being a sloppy list and aims to close out the game with loops to recast spells and generate mana to draw out our deck, brain freeze our opponents and hit them with a faerie mastermind or win off of a thassa’s

Played a few games with it tonight and it felt very good, I almost always had cards in hand and an answer to my opponents boards. I think this deck probably suffers with having to stall out the game as long as possible and having a hard time finding its win conditions.

Data [Cedh]


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 14h ago

Help, I am new to cEDH! I really want this deck to work in CEDH but I dont think its fast enough

31 Upvotes

For some background I'm building a Tiamat CEDH deck. It was my first constructed deck that I wanted to build into cedh after many variations. Recently at Magic Con Atlanta I went to a CEDH tournament and went 0-5. I've play tested my deck many time and know the lines and it can consistently win by turn 4-5 at the latest. In the tournament I saw people mulligen down to 4 and win turn 2 or even turn 1. I was wondering how I can make my deck that quick if possible.

https://archidekt.com/decks/28510090/tiamat_irl

This is the deck list. Ill take any help I can get, but I will understand if this is just a thing I can't do because its not "meta".


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 5h ago

Deck Fine Tuning NBC Kinnan

5 Upvotes

Hello, I have just changed a few cards in my NBC Kinnan list in an attempt to make my mulligans a bit better. I wanted more interaction and an extra way to win the game out of nowhere (provided I have some mana). I added the Intuition pile of Colossal Skyturtle, Shifting Woodland and Basalt Monolith, a few more counterspells and ways to get more draw engines going like Pia Aether Aestic and The Unagi. That said, I cut some “traditionally” good kinnan cards such as Seedborn Muse, Phyrexian Metamorph, Simic Signet, and a few other things that helped the deck go “faster”. The issue I found myself running into is that I run into far more midrangey turn 4 kinds of decks than I do turbo decks and very often I find myself in huge counter wars over win conditions. I won locals a few times with the old list, but when I would lose i found it’s often because someone was out grinding me in value or because I didn’t have enough on the stack interaction. I wanted my flips to be more relevant (hence cutting Wandering Archaic and adding Unagi) and I wanted to be able to keep eyes off of me until I am able to execute a combo after stopping a win attempt of some else’s. If I could get some feedback on my NBC Kinnan list, I’d appreciate it. I’ve worked on this list a lot lately and I even had Ian Flannery give me some coaching sessions on this list.

https://moxfield.com/decks/eN5kbBtU0EuDp85vqbD1sA


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 1h ago

General Discussion / Question Muad’Dib, Prophet Foretold; Good for any strategy NOT storm or (strictly) landfall?

• Upvotes

Muad’Dib, Prophet Foretold; Good for any strategy NOT storm or (strictly) landfall?

Really wanted to build this deck but I’m not a huge storm/spell slinger type of player, and although landfall is nice, I’d like to know if anyone has some viable ideas that isn’t storm or (strictly) landfall. Thanks!


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 15h ago

General Discussion / Question Rog/Reyhan Discord + Rog/Rey Food chain lists

8 Upvotes

Looking to see if there is a Rog/Reyhan discord and if anyone has built one using food chain and the new Khan


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 1d ago

General Discussion / Question Is geist of saint thalia viable as a commander?

57 Upvotes

The main thing is that it wins with top. From a quick look, it seemed that there were around 11 good tutors for top and it doesn't really matter if it goes to battlefield or hand because of the reduction from geist. in addition, thalia lets you play mox amber, and blue isn't the worst mono color out there as you can still interact. Has anyone made a deck with geist of saint thalia?


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 1d ago

General Discussion / Question Narset still playable?

10 Upvotes

Narset used to be quite dominant in the cedh meta, but now I’ve noticed a lot of people are off of her. What are your opinions? I’m currently building a list, and I’m considering putting her in, but I fear I might be better suited with a different stax piece?

[[Narset, Parter of Veils]]


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 20h ago

Help, I am new to cEDH! Now i realise how bad my last deck was...

4 Upvotes

reviewed kefka list from my previous post:

https://moxfield.com/decks/QVnF_LiDOk2zBiRru9a_GA

idk if its any good but i fixed some of the most important issues. Advice is welcomed but please dont be as mean as last time - ive got no clue how to make a proper deck so i just want some help.

btw its only the second revision of my first deck so i havent been able to test much.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 1d ago

Help, I am new to cEDH! Nervous to start playing cEDH

26 Upvotes

I have really been getting into a ton of cEDH content lately and have put together some decks but I feel nervous to go actually play. Nobody in my normal playgroup cares about it so I’d be playing with randoms at my lgs.

Has anyone else had this problem and if so how did you deal with it?


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 1d ago

Deck Fine Tuning Muad'Dib deck brew

24 Upvotes

Here is my brew for Muad'Dib. I enjoy fringe decks and understand the meta quite well, but I wanted opinions.

For reference I play the following decks:

Kinnan

Dog Thras

Sisay

Gwenom

Ral

Rog Si

Tymna Malcolm

Lumra

Rocco

Rog Ishai

The lines in this deck include:

Ashaya/Quirion ranger for arbitrarily large amounts of landfall triggers to cycle through the library. The same is true for the Oboro line, with the main win conditions being breach/brain freeze and thassas. There is also the a win line using Qurion ranger to untap a creature protected by Legolas's quick Reflexes to wipe thr board and use finale as a finisher.

I've included cheap cantrips and creature rituals to stack the graveyard as fast as possible to enable delirium and empower sensei's, although I've opted to not add a cost reducer for sensei's (yet).

Let me know what you think please. ❤️

https://archidekt.com/decks/28348944/muaddib_cedh_brew


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 1d ago

Deck Fine Tuning Selesnya Hulk

19 Upvotes

With the release of Ezri Dax I figured out a purely selesnya hulk deck.
The line is first hulk Preston the Vanisher and Ezri Dax you will have a Preston trigger for Two Ezri both of which will enter as hulk then one will die to the legend rule. With that trigger you will grab Karmic Guide and Starved Rusalka, with Preston triggers on each. You will return hulk and whatever other creature you want. You then have three hulks you can sacrifice grabbing Radiant Solar, Glaring Fleshraker, or Whiteplume Adventurer as your finisher and Felidar Guardian.
I chose Halana/Yoshimaru as the commanders primarily for Halana’s ability to start a hulk line without having a sac outlet in play which are harder to come by in Selesnya. As it is Selesnya, I don’t expect it to be the best, but I intend to test it out and see how it performs.
https://moxfield.com/decks/GolkJevgTkSd_4fqWxc5vQ


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 1d ago

Deck Fine Tuning First real tourney help

4 Upvotes

I am going to the Midwest classic this Saturday. I am hoping for some final edge sanding with my two top decks. I am committed to Derevi, but some other help is appreciated.

Derevi is a Derevi creature like. I am trying to make infinite mana 6 ways to Sunday. Either by using Emiel and cradle or Chromatic orrery. There are some fun lines by cloning Derevi and letting the OG die to the legend rule only to bring her back for 4 with chromatic orrery and float one mana constantly. My win cons are faerie mastermind, walking ballista or gleaming splendor for the easy button. I am also more than game to just go to combat.

With Kefka I tried to do more of a control build. I like to play the game a bit slower and use the discard effect to eat away at my opponents hands. I am playing for midrange hell and know it. Then hopefully when resources are low, go for Thoracle or a breach line. I like to pressure life totals a bit with treasure makers and take advantage of Talion/Sheoldred

https://moxfield.com/decks/mlNHHw2Ftky-EzQ-gidUew

https://moxfield.com/decks/4J7soc0mDUiJpQvibdWF4A


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 14h ago

General Discussion / Question Need an Ad Naus combo for Yuriko.

0 Upvotes

As you may know I have been building a budget deck around Yuriko that can be played casually in a cedh pod! It was $50 but decided I needed more interaction. So it’s officially a little of $100 budget!

I want to run Ad nauseum in Yuriko, but world love to know some combos! Any suggestions?


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 2d ago

General Discussion / Question A month or so later

62 Upvotes

What about that Blue Samut? Did you face it often ? Was it the game warper that some claimed, or was it just another sorta silence effect?

I didn't face it in the few games I played but tbh I didn't have much playtime due to life and stuff.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 1d ago

Deck Fine Tuning Cutting is the bane of my existence

0 Upvotes

I have made a [[Magik, Illyana Rasputin]] cEDH deck, I know the commander is fringe at best, but I am loyal to the character so i am going to make her work.

https://moxfield.com/decks/Se2dI27-KUq4A7YoevVMmQ

I'm looking for advice for cuts, because what I have in the sideboard is actually still in the main list. I am also considering counter building my local meta, which is alot of Gaea's cradle's with Expedition Map/Strip Mine.

Any help would be amazing, Thanks in advance.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 2d ago

Community Content cEDH gameplay in Japan, special guest Jordan Quinn from CriticalEDH

40 Upvotes

Hi guys

We're a group of friends from Japan, and we want to share the EDH scene here in Japan, this time we recorded a game with Jordan Quinn from CriticalEDH!

Hope you enjoy it!

https://youtu.be/14r_i_gsSwg

Check our channel, also we have an interview!


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 2d ago

Spoilers! Card Discussion [NAU] Calmwater Mentor

54 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on the new Calmwater Mentor?

2ww for a 3/2 Seal Monk

When it enters search for up to 2 creatures with Power 2 or less.

Its esentialy two imperial recruters in one Card. I know it can Set Up a win by finding Cloud of fairys and flickering hound. Play hound then Cloud, triggering hound and finding Mentor to find shreaking drake and anything. Drake can be played for u flickering cloud and bouncing it selfe netting one mana.

Some other combinations to find would be

esper + delni

Dual caster mage + spellseaker

Pia + squee

What other 2 Card combinations could be assembled with this card?


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 2d ago

Community Content Ricochet Trap! Underrated from MonoR to uFarm!

11 Upvotes

This week we bring a card to the podcast that has been in and out of low and high color lists for years- Ricochet Trap!

Most notably seeing success in Sky’s tournament-topping uFarm list, Ricochet Trap provides an awesome way for you to protect your own wins, without needing to interact first when you need to stop others.

While you may think this competes with other misdirection type effects- most lists playing this card are on ALL of those effects. Dswat, Redirect lightning, and Misdirection in blue!

The question is not whether or not you need to cut the card for one of the cards listed above- but if you want to cut a different piece for another one of these powerful effects.

https://youtu.be/NKxFW5oqqjE?is=Ye2PQ-Em4ZdBWScU


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 2d ago

Spoilers! Card Discussion [NAU] Calmwater Mentor

21 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on the new Calmwater Mentor?

2ww for a 3/2 Seal Monk

When it enters search for up to 2 creatures with Power 2 or less.

Its esentialy two imperial recruters in one Card. I know it can Set Up a win by finding Cloud of fairys and flickering hound. Play hound then Cloud, triggering hound and finding Mentor to find shreaking drake and anything. Drake can be played for u flickering cloud and bouncing it selfe netting one mana.

Some other combinations to find would be

esper + delni

Dual caster mage + spellseaker

Pia + squee

What other 2 Card combinations could be assembled with this card?


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 2d ago

Help, I am new to cEDH! Beginner friendly deck?

9 Upvotes

Hey so I’ve been curious about cedh I’ve experimented with Zirda and Clue farm before I didn’t like them that much. And I tried rog/thras also didn’t like it does anyone have any recommendations on what to try that’s beginner friendly?

Edit:I also tried kinnan and I didn’t like it. I didn’t like Zirda because I didn’t just like how the monolith dependence. I didn’t like clue farm because of the 4 colors and Kinnan because it just didn’t click with me. In casual I love landfall.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 2d ago

Help, I am new to cEDH! My first cedh deck (kefka court mage)

4 Upvotes

Ive just started cedh and i have made a deck from the ground up. Let me know if there is anything wrong with this deck but from what ive played, it seems to work pretty well.

also, i swear theres nowhere to play cedh regularly in the uk. has anyone else had this problem or is it just me because i have barely any mtg friends?

deck list: https://moxfield.com/decks/zggyYZcAKEm1DO_lCqsRHA


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 3d ago

General Discussion / Question The One Ring vs Black Market Connections

40 Upvotes

Discuss please:

The recent Hashaton 8-0 deck

Did not use The One Ring and ran Black market Connections.

I found this interesting. What are thoughts on this?


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 3d ago

Tournaments & Meta Crystal Advice

8 Upvotes

I am needing some advice for my Crystal list. I am not sure if there is something I am overlooking or missing but I played in my first tournament this weekend and my performance was not what I had hoped. I ended up not making the top 16 and closing the day with just 1 point. In pretty much every game I was very close to winning but could never get there. It may just be because this was my first tournament and need to get games under my belt but I could use any advice. Here is my list.

https://moxfield.com/decks/t9ShAd2NFXiejYiT6WKLoA