I've been building **MoveLens**, a free game review site, and I'd like feedback from people who know engines.
**Try it:** https://sanjaymarathi-movelens.hf.space (no account, no ads, no daily limit)
Paste a PGN or import a game by Chess.com or Lichess username. Stockfish 19 analyses every position and each move gets one of 11 labels, with a coach comment, the better move as an arrow, an eval graph and accuracy for both players. You can also play your own moves on the board at any point and get an instant verdict, retry a mistake to find the better move, or show the top 3 engine lines.
**How the labels work**
- Every score is turned into a winning chance: `win% = 50 + 50 * (2 / (1 + e^(-0.00368 * cp)) - 1)`. A move's quality is the winning chance it gives away compared with the engine's best move.
- Excellent: loses under 2%. Good: under 5%. Inaccuracy: 5–10%. Mistake: 10–20%. Blunder: 20% or more.
- **Great:** the best move, and every alternative is at least 10% worse (the second MultiPV line is enough to check this).
- **Brilliant:** the best move, leaving 2+ pawns of material to be taken, when you weren't already winning and aren't worse afterwards.
- **Miss:** your opponent just erred and your move gives back 10% or more.
- Book moves come from 3,800 named openings, and accuracy uses the published Lichess formula.
**Depths:** Fast (the default) is depth 12 with at most 0.15 s per position, so a typical game is reviewed in about 10–15 seconds on the free server. Deep is depth 20 with at most 1.5 s per position.
No site publishes its exact thresholds, so I'd especially like opinions on the Brilliant and Great rules, and on games where you think a label is clearly wrong.
It's open source (MIT): https://github.com/SanjayMarathi/MoveLens