So, do I have a crush? Maybe, maybe not. For context, I’m 19F, in my third year of uni, and the person this post is about is a guy friend of mine (21M). He's not a super close friend, but a friend nonetheless.
We’re in the same year (I’m 19 because I started and finished school early, and he’s 21 because he transferred here after spending his first year at a different uni). We’ve known each other for two years now and are in the same friend group, where he’s the only guy.
Honestly, I think I might have liked him a tiny bit right from the start when I was 17. Back then, experience-wise, I was basically a kid. I’d never really had friends before, had no idea how to navigate social interactions, and was a total mess. It wasn't a full-blown crush, just this constant awareness of whenever he was in the room. I don't think I was even capable of having a real crush back then because I didn't know who I was yet, whereas I’ve grown and developed so much as a person over these past two years.
He has shared a some of his sad crush stories. He always used to mention how, for some reason, he only ever liked girls older than him. Just putting that out there for context, not sure how relevant it is.
Anyway, it took us a few months at the beginning to get past the awkwardness. Even though we were in the same friend group, whenever we were left alone together, I felt super awkward because I never knew what to talk about. That awkwardness completely faded by the end of our first year, though, and now we’re just normal friends. Actually, I think I started noticing something weird about my own feelings around the end of last semester, or maybe even earlier than that.
Sorry, I need to add one more piece of backstory here. At the end of our first year, he had a situationship. It was so obvious that our whole friend group noticed he acted like a total idiot around that girl. At the time, I didn't really get why, but watching him act so foolishly around her really got on my nerves (looking back now, I think I might have been a little jealous? I'm not entirely sure). Anyway, that situationship didn't work out.
Fast forward a bit to the start of our second year (first semester), and this idiot ends up losing his virginity to another girl (there were other very foolish things he did too, which I won't get into) who turned out to be completely unhinged and even threatened suicide or something. The reason this detail matters is because it confuses me: if I actually liked him, shouldn't I have felt something when that happened? Because I didn't feel anything at all (though, to be fair, I wasn't thinking about liking him back then either).
But second semester of our 2nd year I had this weird feeling, how do I explain it? Like when you're around someone and you just feel like there's something in the air, almost like I was developing a crush on him.
Anyway, fast-forwarding to the present: over the summer, when we weren't really in touch, I found myself thinking about him constantly. And as soon as our third year started, I realized how suddenly these feelings hit me, and they're intense. For some reason, I started crushing on him hard. Still, I don't think he likes me back, I honestly just can't tell.
I’m honestly exhausted by all of this. I even checked myself against the typical signs of having a crush, and I literally do every single thing a girl with a crush does. I get so frustrated with myself. When I’m home, I convince myself that I don't actually have a crush on him and that I can handle it, but the moment I see him again, all of that goes right out the window.
Just today, we were walking home together when he spotted that same situationship girl, literally ran over to say hi to her, and I was just standing back watching it happen with my heart hurting. The worst part is, he actually told that girl once that he sees our friend group (since we’re all girls) like kids, meaning he probably just looks at me like a little sister. Thinking about him is getting in the way of everything in my life.
We don't even match or make sense together, yet whenever he’s around, I can’t bring myself to think anything bad about him. Before, I used to think the things he did were stupid and that he acted like an idiot, but now I catch myself justifying everything and making excuses for him.
On top of that, I can't tell anyone about this. I can't tell my female friends because it's just not the right time, and since we're all in the same friend group, they would act so obvious around him that he’d figure out what's going on immediately. I really don't know what to do. Sometimes he acts in ways that make me wonder if there's even a tiny chance he likes me back, while other times I feel the exact opposite, like he has zero interest in me whatsoever, and then I read a Reddit comment listing the signs a guy likes you, and he doesn't show a single one of them. My heart still hurts from today. I really didn't want to cry, so I wrote this post instead, and honestly, getting it out made me feel a little better. Has anyone else been through this? How do I get over a crush when we're in the same friend group? Should I? WHAT DO I DO???